In this article, we consider how the economic return to a college education varies across members of the U.S. population. Based on principles of comparative advantage, scholars commonly presume that positive selection is at work, that is, individuals who are most likely to select into college also benefit most from college. Net of observed economic and noneconomic factors influencing college attendance, we conjecture that individuals who are least likely to obtain a college education benefit the most from college. We call this theory the negative selection hypothesis. To adjudicate between the two hypotheses, we study the effects of completing college on earnings by propensity score strata using an innovative hierarchical linear model with data from the National Longitudinal Survey of Youth 1979 and the Wisconsin Longitudinal Study. For both cohorts, for both men and women, and for every observed stage of the life course, we find evidence suggesting negative selection. Results from auxiliary analyses lend further support to the negative selection hypothesis.
AltonjiJoseph G.DunnThomas A.1996. “The Effects of Family Characteristics on the Return to Education.” The Review of Economics and Statistics78:692–70.
2.
AngristJoshua D.ImbensGuido W.RubinDonald B.1996. “Identification of Causal Effect Using Instrumental Variables.” Journal of the American Statistical Association91:444–55.
3.
AngristJoshua D.KruegerAlan B.1999. “Empirical Strategies in Labor Economics.” Pp. 1277–1366 in Handbook of Labor Economics, Vol. 3A, edited by AshenfelterO.CardD.Amsterdam: Elsevier.
4.
ArmerJ. Michael. 1964. Community and School Environments and College Plans of Public High School Seniors. PhD dissertation, University of Wisconsin, Madison, WI.
5.
AshenfelterOrleyKruegerAlan B.1994. “Estimates of the Economic Return to Schooling from a New Sample of Twins.” American Economic Review84:1157–73.
6.
AshenfelterOrleyRouseCecilia. 1998. “Income, Schooling, and Ability: Evidence from a New Sample of Identical Twins.” Quarterly Journal of Economics113:253–84.
7.
AverettSusan L.BurtonMark L.1996. “College Attendance and the College Wage Premium: Differences by Gender.” Economics of Education Review15:37–49.
8.
BarrowLisaRouseCecilia E.2005. “Do Returns to Schooling Differ by Race and Ethnicity?” American Economic Review95:83–87.
9.
BeattieIrene. 2002. “Are all Adolescent Econometricians Created Equal? Racial, Class, and Gender Differences in College Enrollment.” Sociology of Education75:19–43.
10.
BeckerGary S.1964. Human Capital: A Theoretical and Empirical Analysis, with Special Reference to Education. New York: Columbia University Press.
11.
BeckerGary S.1991. A Treatise on the Family. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
12.
BeckerSaschaIchinoAndrea. 2002. “Estimation of Average Treatment Effects Based on Propensity Scores.” Stata Journal2:358–77.
13.
BianchiSuzanne. 1995. “Changing Economic Roles of Women and Men.” Pp. 107–54 in State of the Union: America in the 1990s; Volume One: Economic Trends, edited by FarleyR.New York: Russell Sage Foundation.
14.
BjorklundAndersMoffittRobert. 1987. “The Estimation of Wage Gains and Welfare Gains in Self-Selection Models.” Review of Economics and Statistics69:42–49.
15.
BlakeJudith. 1981. “Family Size and the Quality of Children.” Demography18:421–42.
16.
BlauPeterDuncanOtis Dudley. 1967. The American Occupational Structure. New York: John Wiley & Sons.
17.
BoudonRaymond. 1974. Education, Opportunity and Social Inequality. New York: John Wiley & Sons.
18.
BourdieuPierre. 1977. “Cultural Reproduction and Social Reproduction.” Pp. 487–510 in Power and Ideology in Education, edited by KarabelJ.HalseyA.H.New York: Oxford University Press.
19.
BowlesSamuelGintisHerbert. 1976. Schooling in Capitalist America: Educational Reform and the Contradictions of Economic Life. New York: Basic Books.
20.
BrandJennie E.HalabyCharles N.2006. “Regression and Matching Estimates of the Effects of Elite College Attendance on Educational and Career Achievement.” Social Science Research35:749–70.
21.
BrandJennie E.XieYu. 2007. “Who Benefits Most From College? Evidence for Negative Selection in Heterogeneous Economic Returns to Higher Education.” California Center for Population Research, University of California-Los AngelesCCPR 033-07.
22.
BreenRichardGoldthorpeJohn H.1997. “Explaining Educational Differentials: Towards a Formal Rational Action Theory.” Rationality and Society9:275–305.
23.
BrewerDominicEideEricEhrenbergRonald. 1999. “Does it Pay to Attend an Elite Private College? Cross-Cohort Evidence on the Effects of College Type on Earnings.” Journal of Human Resources34:104–123.
24.
BrykAnthonyLeeValerieHollandPeter. 1993. Catholic Schools and the Common Good. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
25.
CameronStephen V.HeckmanJames J.2001. “The Dynamics of Educational Attainment for Black, Hispanic, and White Males.” Journal of Political Economy109:455–99.
26.
CardDavid. 1995. “Using Geographic Variation in College Proximity to Estimate the Return to Schooling.” Pp. 201–222 in Aspects of Labour Market Behavior: Essays in Honour of John Vanderkamp, edited by ChristofidesL.GrantE. KennethSwidinskyR.Toronto, Canada: University of Toronto Press.
27.
CardDavid. 1999. “The Causal Effect of Education on Earnings.” Pp. 1801–63 in Handbook of Labor Economics, Vol. 3A, edited by AshenfelterO.CardD.Amsterdam: Elsevier.
28.
CardDavid. 2001. “Estimating the Return to Schooling: Progress on Some Persistent Econometric Problems.” Econometrica69:1127–60.
29.
CarneiroPedroHansenKarstenHeckmanJames J.2003. “Estimating Distributions of Treatment Effects with an Application to the Returns to Schooling and Measurement of the Effects of Uncertainty on College Choice.” International Economic Review44:361–422.
30.
CarneiroPedroHeckmanJames J.2002. “The Evidence on Credit Constraints in Post-Secondary Schooling.” Economic Journal112:705–34.
31.
CarneiroPedroHeckmanJames J.VytlacilEdward. 2001. “Estimating the Return to Education When it Varies Among Individuals.” Department of Economics, University College London. Unpublished manuscript.
32.
CarneiroPedroHeckmanJames J.VytlacilEdward. 2007. “Estimating Marginal and Average Returns to Education.” Department of Economics, University College London. Unpublished manuscript.
33.
CawleyJohnConneelyKarenHeckmanJamesVytlacilEdward. 1997. “Cognitive Ability, Wages, and Meritocracy.” Pp. 179–92 in Intelligence, Genes, and Success: Scientists Respond to the Bell Curve, edited by DevlinB.FeinbergS. E.ResnickD.RoederK.New York: Springer.
34.
ColemanJames A.1988. “Social Capital and the Creation of Human Capital.” American Journal of Sociology94:S95–S120.
35.
DaleStacy B.KruegerAlan B.2002. “Estimating the Payoff to Attending a More Selective College: An Application of Selection on Observables and Unobservables.” Quarterly Journal of Economics117:1491–1527.
36.
DiMaggioPaul. 1982. “Cultural Capital and School Success: The Impact of Status Culture Participation on the Grades of U.S. High School Students.” American Sociological Review47:189–201.
37.
DiPreteThomas A.EngelhardtHenriette. 2004. “Estimating Causal Effects with Matching Methods in the Presence and Absence of Bias Cancellation.” Sociological Methods and Research32:501–528.
38.
FarleyReynolds. 1996. The New American Reality: Who We Are, How We Got Here, Where We Are Going. New York: Russell Sage Foundation.
39.
FischerClaude S.HoutMichael. 2006. Century of Difference: How America Changed in the Last One Hundred Years. New York: Russell Sage Foundation.
40.
GoldthorpeJohnJacksonMichelle. 2008. “Education-Based Meritocracy: The Barriers to its Realization.” Pp. 93–117 in Social Class: How Does it Work? edited by LareauA.ConleyD.New York: Russell Sage Foundation.
41.
GrilichesZvi. 1977. “Estimating the Returns to Schooling: Some Econometric Problems.” Econometrica45:1–22.
42.
GrubbW. Norton. 1993. “The Varied Economic Returns to Post-Secondary Education: New Evidence from the Class of 1972.” The Journal of Human Resources28:365–82.
43.
HauserRobert M.1973. “Socioeconomic Background and Differential Returns to Education.” Pp. 129–45 in Does College Matter? Some Evidence on the Impacts of Higher Education, edited by SolomonL. C.TaubmanP.J.New York: Academic Press.
44.
HauserRobert M.2004. “Progress in Schooling.” Pp. 271–318 in Social Inequality, edited by NeckermanK.New York: Russell Sage Foundation.
45.
HauserRobert M.DaymountThomas N.1977. “Schooling, Ability, and Earnings: Cross-Sectional Findings 8 to 14 Years after High School Graduation.” Sociology of Education50:182–206.
46.
HauserRobert M.TsaiShu-LingSewellWilliam H.1983. “A Model of Stratification with Response Error in Social and Psychological Variables.” Sociology of Education56:20–46.
47.
HeckmanJames J.1978. “Dummy Endogenous Variables in a Simultaneous Equation System.” Econometrica46:931–59.
48.
HeckmanJames J.2005. “The Scientific Model of Causality.” Sociological Methodology35:1–98.
HeckmanJames J.HonoréBo E.1990. “The Empirical Content of the Roy Model.” Econometrica58:1121–49.
51.
HeckmanJames J.TobiasJustin L.VytlacilEdward. 2001. “Four Parameters of Interest in the Evaluation of Social Programs.” Southern Economic Journal68:210–223.
52.
HeckmanJamesUrzuaSergioVytlacilEdward. 2006. “Understanding Instrumental Variables in Models with Essential Heterogeneity.” The Review of Economics and Statistics88:389–432.
53.
HillC. RussellStaffordFrank P.1974. “Allocation of Time to Preschool Children and Educational Opportunity.” Journal of Human Resources9:323–41.
54.
HofferThomasGreeleyAndrewColemanJames. 1985. “Achievement Growth in Public and Catholic Schools.” Sociology of Education58:74–97.
55.
HollandPaul W.1986. “Statistics and Causal Inference” (with discussion). Journal of American Statistical Association81:945–70.
56.
HoutMichael. 1984. “Status, Autonomy, and Training in Occupational Mobility.” American Journal of Sociology89:379–409.
57.
HoutMichael. 1988. “More Universalism, Less Structural Mobility: The American Occupational Structure in the 1980s.” American Journal of Sociology93:1358–1400.
58.
HoutMichaelDiPreteThomas A.2006. “What We Have Learned: RC28’s Contributions to Knowledge about Social Stratification.” Research in Social Stratification and Mobility24:1–20.
59.
ImbensGuido W.AngristJoshua. 1994. “Identification and Estimation of Local Average Treatment Effects.” Econometrica62:467–76.
60.
JannBenBrandJennie E.XieYu. 2008. –hte– Stata module to perform heterogeneous treatment effect analysis, available from (http://ideas.repec.org/).
61.
JencksChristopherSmithMarshallAclandHenryBaneMary JoCohenDavidGintisHerbertHeynsBarbaraMichelsonStephan. 1972. Inequality: A Reassessment of the Effect of Family and Schooling in America. New York: Basic Books.
62.
KaneThomasRouseCecilia. 1995. “Labor-Market Returns to Two- and Four-Year College.” American Economic Review85:600–14.
63.
KaoGraceThompsonJennifer S.2003. “Racial and Ethnic Stratification in Educational Achievement and Attainment.” Annual Review of Sociology29:417–42.
64.
LareauAnnette. 2003. Unequal Childhoods. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
65.
LucasSamuel. 2001. “Effectively Maintained Inequality: Education Transitions, Track Mobility, and Social Background Effects.” American Journal of Sociology106:1642–90.
66.
MacLeodJay. 1989. Ain’t No Makin’ It: Aspirations and Attainment in a Low-Income Neighborhood. Boulder, CO: Westview Press.
67.
ManskiCharles F.1990. “Adolescent Econometricians: How Do Youth Infer the Returns to Schooling?” Pp.43–60 in Studies of Supply and Demand in Higher Education, edited by ClotfetterC. T.RothschildM.Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
68.
ManskiCharles F.1995. Identification Problems in the Social Sciences. Boston, MA: Harvard University Press.
69.
ManskiCharles F.WiseDavid A.1983. College Choice in America. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
70.
MareRobert D.1981. “Change and Stability in Educational Stratification.” American Sociological Review46:72–87.
71.
McLanahanSaraSandefurGary. 1994. Growing up with a Single Parent: What Hurts, What Helps. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
72.
MincerJacob. 1974. Schooling, Experience, and Earnings. New York: Columbia University Press.
73.
MincerJacobPolachekSolomon. 1974. “Family Investments in Human Capital: Earnings of Women.” Journal of Political Economy82:S76–S108.
74.
MorganStephen. 2001. “Counterfactuals, Causal Effect Heterogeneity, and the Catholic School Effect on Learning.” Sociology of Education74:341–74.
75.
MorganStephen. 2005. On the Edge of Commitment: Educational Attainment and Race in the United States. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.
76.
MorganStephen L.ToddJennifer J.2008. “A Diagnostic Routine for the Detection of Consequential Heterogeneity of Causal Effects.” Sociological Methodology38:231–81.
77.
MorganStephenWinshipChristopher. 2007. Counterfactuals and Causal Inference: Methods and Principles for Social Research. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
78.
NeymanJ.1923. “On the Application of Probability Theory to Agricultural Experiments: Essay on Principles, Section 9.” Statistical Science5:465–80.
79.
OlneckMichael. 1979. “The Effects of Education.” Pp.159–60 in Who Gets Ahead? edited by JencksC.New York: Basic Books.
80.
OrfieldGaryEatonS. E.JonesE. R.1996. Dismantling Desegregation: The Quiet Reversal of Brown v. Board of Education. New York: New Press.
81.
PernaLaura. 2005. “The Benefits of Higher Education: Sex, Racial/Ethnic, and Socioeconomic Group Differences.” Review of Higher Education29:23–52.
82.
RafteryAdrianHoutMichael. 1993. “Maximally Maintained Inequality: Expansion, Reform, and Opportunity in Irish Education, 1921–75.” Sociology of Education66:41–62.
83.
RosenbaumJames. 2001. Beyond College for All. New York: Russell Sage Foundation Press.
84.
RosenbaumPaul R.RubinDonald B.1983. “The Central Role of the Propensity Score in Observational Studies for Causal Effects.” Biometrika70:41–55.
85.
RosenbaumPaul R.RubinDonald B.1984. “Reducing Bias in Observational Studies Using Subclassification on the Propensity Score.” Journal of the American Statistical Association79:516–24.
86.
RouseCecilia. 2004. “Low-Income Students and College Attendance: An Exploration of Income Expectations.” Social Science Quarterly85:1299–1317.
87.
RoyAndrew D.1951. “Some Thoughts on the Distribution of Earnings.” Oxford Economic Paper3:135–46.
88.
RubinDonald B.1974. “Estimating Causal Effects of Treatments in Randomized and Nonrandomized Studies.” Journal of Educational Psychology66:688–701.
89.
RubinDonald B.1997. “Estimating Causal Effects from Large Data Sets Using Propensity Scores.” Annals of Internal Medicine127:757–63.
90.
SewellWilliamHallerArchibald O.OhlendorfG. W.1970. “Educational and Early Occupational Status Attainment Process: Replication and Revision.” American Sociological Review35:1014–1027.
91.
SewellWilliam H.HallerArchibald O.PortesAlejandro. 1969. “The Educational and Early Occupational Attainment Process.” American Sociological Review34:82–92.
92.
SewellWilliam H.HauserRobert M.1975. Education, Occupation, and Earnings: Achievement in the Early Career. New York: Academic Press.
93.
SheridanJennifer. 2001. Occupational Attainment across the Life Course: Sources of Stability and Change in Three Occupational Characteristics. PhD Dissertation, Department of Sociology, University of Wisconsin, Madison, WI.
94.
SmithHerbert L.PowellBrian. 1990. “Great Expectations: Variations in Income Expectations among College Seniors.” Sociology of Education63:194–207.
95.
SobelMichael E.2000. “Causal Inference in the Social Sciences.” Journal of the American Statistical Association95:647–51.
96.
ThomasScott. 2003. “Longer-Term Economic Effects of College Selectivity and Control.” Research in Higher Education44:263–99.
97.
ThomasScottZhangLiang. 2005. “Post-baccalaureate Wage Growth within Four Years of Graduation: The Effects of College Quality and College Major.” Research in Higher Education46:437–59.
98.
TrainKenneth. 2003. Discrete Choice Methods with Simulation. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
99.
TsaiShu-LingXieYu. 2008. “Changes in Earnings Returns to Higher Education in Taiwan since the 1990s.” Population Review47:1–20.
100.
U.S. Census Bureau. 2007. “Earnings Gap Highlighted by Census Bureau Data on Educational Attainment.” U.S. Census Bureau News, March15, Press Release.
101.
WelchFinis. 1973. “Black-White Differences in Returns to Schooling.” American Economic Review63:893–907.
102.
WillisRobert J.RosenSherwin. 1979. “Education and Self-Selection.” Journal of Political Economy87:S7–36.
103.
WinshipChristopherMorganStephen L.1999. “The Estimation of Causal Effects from Observational Data.” Annual Review of Sociology25:659–707.
104.
XieYu. 2007. “Otis Dudley Duncan’s Legacy: The Demographic Approach to Quantitative Reasoning in Social Science.” Research in Social Stratification and Mobility25:141–56.
105.
XieYuShaumanKimberlee A.1998. “Sex Differences in Research Productivity Revisited: New Evidence about an Old Puzzle.” American Sociological Review63:847–70.
106.
XieYuWuXiaogang. 2005. “Market Premium, Social Process, and Statisticism.” American Sociological Review70:865–70.
107.
ZhangLiang. 2005. Does Quality Matter? Benefits of Attending a High-Cost, Prestigious College. New York: Routledge.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
