This article uses panel data from the Survey of Income and Program Participation (SIPP) and the European Community Household Panel (ECHP) for a comparative analysis of workers' post-unemployment earnings trajectories in the United States and 12 Western European countries. Across the study sample of industrialized countries, results of difference-in-difference propensity score matching show post-unemployment earnings losses to be largely permanent and particularly significant for high-wage and older workers as well as for women. The analyses also show that negative effects of unemployment on workers' subsequent earnings are mitigated through either generous unemployment benefit systems or strict labor market regulation. These effects stem partly from favorable behavioral responses that prevent downward occupational and industrial mobility and partly from changes in the overall structure of labor markets favoring the transferability of worker skills between jobs. These positive effects materialize despite the fact that labor market policies tend to successfully protect the core work force from experiencing a job loss in the first place.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AcemogluDaron2001. Good Jobs versus Bad JobsJournal of Labor Economics19: 1–21.
2.
AddisonJohn T.BlackburnMcKinley L.2000. The effects of unemployment insurance on postunemployment earningsLabour Economics7: 21–53.
3.
AlbækKarstenVan AudenrodeMarcBrowningMartin2002. Employment Protection and the Consequences for Displaced Workers. Pp. 471–511 in Losing Work, Moving On: International Perspectives on Worker Displacement, edited by KuhnPeter. Kalamazoo, MI: W.E. Upjohn Institute.
4.
ArulampalamWiji2001. Is Unemployment Really Scarring? Effects of Unemployment Experiences on Wages. Economic Journal111: F585-F604.
5.
AshenfelterOrley C.1978. Estimating the Effect of Training Programs on Earnings.Review of Economics and Statistics6: 47–57.
6.
BeckerGary S.1993. Human Capital. A Theoretical and Empirical Analysis with Special Reference to education. 3d edition. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
7.
BenderStefanDustmannChristianMargolisDavidMeghirCostas2002. Worker Displacement in France and Germany. Pp. 375–470 in Losing Work, Moving On: International Perspectives on Worker Displacement, edited by KuhnPeter. Kalamazoo, MI: W.E. Upjohn Institute.
8.
BerkovitchElazar.1990: A Stigma Theory of Unemployment Duration. Pp. 20–55 in Advances in the Theory and Measurement of Unemployment, edited by WeissYoramFishelsonGideon. London: Macmillan.
9.
BertolaGiuseppe1999. Microeconomic Perspectives on Aggregate Labour Markets. Pp. 2986–3028 in Handbook of Labor Economics, Volume 3C, edited by AshenfelterOrleyCardDavid. Amsterdam: Elsevier.
10.
BertolaGiuseppeRogersonRichard1997. Institutions and Labor ReallocationEuropean Economic Review41: 1147–171.
11.
BorlandJeffGreggPaulKnightGenevieveWadsworthJonathan2002. They Get Knocked Down. Do They Get Up Again?
Pp. 301–73 in Losing Work, Moving On: International Perspectives on Worker Displacement, edited by KuhnPeter. Kalamazoo, MI: W.E. Upjohn Institute.
12.
BrandJennie E.2003. Enduring Effects of Job Displacement on Career OutcomesMadison, WI: mimeo.
13.
BudigMichelle J.EnglandPaula2001. The Wage Penalty for MotherhoodAmerican Sociological Review66: 204–25.
14.
BurdaMichael C.MertensAntje2001. Estimating Wage Losses of Displaced Workers in GermanyLabour Economics8: 15–41.
15.
BurdettKenneth1979. Unemployment Benefits as a Search Subsidy: A Theoretical AnalysisEconomic Inquiry17: 333–43.
16.
CanzianiPatriziaPetrongoloBarbara (2001). Firing costs and stigma: A theoretical analysis and evidence from microdata. European Economic Review45: 1877–906.
17.
CardDavidLemieuxT.Riddell.W. C.2004. Unions and wage inequalityJournal of Labor Research25: 519–62.
18.
CarringtonWilliam J.1993. Wage Losses for Displaced Workers. Is It Really the Firm That Matters?Journal of Human Resources28: 435–62.
19.
CouchKenneth A.2001. Earnings Losses and Unemployment of Displaced Workers in GermanyIndustrial and Labor Relations Review54: 559–72.
20.
DavisSteven J.HaltiwangerJohn C.SchuhScott1996. Job Creation and DestructionCambridge: MIT Press.
21.
DiPreteThomas A.1981. Unemployment over the Life Cycle: Racial Differences and the Effect of Changing Economic ConditionsAmerican Journal of Sociology87: 286–307.
22.
DiPreteThomas A.1993. Industrial Restructuring and the Mobility Response of American Workers in the 1980sAmerican Sociological Review58: 74–96.
23.
DiPreteThomas A.2002. Life Course Risks, Mobility Regimes, and Mobility Consequences: A Comparison of Sweden, Germany, and the United StatesAmerican Journal of Sociology108: 267–309.
24.
DiPreteThomas A.de GraafPaul M.LuijkxRuudTåhlinMichaelBlossfeldHans-Peter1997. Collectivist versus Individualist Mobility Regimes? Structural Change and Job Mobility in Four CountriesAmerican Journal of Sociology103: 318–58.
25.
DiPreteThomas A.EirichGregory M.2006. Cumulative Advantage as a Mechanism for Inequality: A Review of Theoretical and Empirical DevelopmentsAnnual Review of Sociology32: 271–97.
26.
DiPreteThomas A.McManusPatricia A.1996. Institutions, Technical Change, and Diverging Life Chances: Earnings Mobility in the United States and Germany. American Journal of Sociology102: 34–79.
27.
DiPreteThomas A.McManusPatricia A.2000. Family Change, Employment Transitions, and the Welfare State: Household Income Dynamics in the United States and West GermanyAmerican Sociological Review65: 343–70.
Esping-AndersenG⊘sta.1990. The Three Worlds of Welfare CapitalismCambridge: Polity Press.
30.
Esping-AndersenG⊘sta.1999. Social Foundations of Postindustrial EconomiesOxford: Oxford University Press.
31.
Esping-AndersenG⊘sta.2000. Who Is Harmed by Labour Market Regulations?
Pp. 66–98 in Why deregulate labour markets? edited by Esping-AndersenG⊘staReginiMario. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
32.
Estevez-AbeMargaritaIversenTorbenSoskiceDavid2001. Social Protection and the Formation of Skills: A Reinterpretation of the Welfare State. Pp. 145–183 in Varieties of Capitalism: The Institutional Foundations of Comparative Advantage, edited by HallPeter A.SoskiceDavid. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
33.
Eurostat.2003. ECHP UDB Manual. European Community Household Panel Longitudinal Users' Database. Waves 1 to 8. Survey Years 1994 to 2001. DOC. PAN 168/2003-12. Luxembourg: Eurostat.
34.
FallickBruce C.1993. The Industrial Mobility of Displaced Workers. Journal of Labor Economics11: 302–23.
35.
FarberHenry S.1993. The Incidence and Costs of Job Loss: 1982–1991. Brookings Papers on Economic Activity. Microeconomics, pp. 73–132 (with discussion).
36.
FarberHenry S.1997. The Changing Face of Job Loss in the United States, 1981–1995. Brookings Papers on Economic Activity. Microeconomics, pp. 55–142 (with discussion).
37.
GallieDuncanPaugamSerge (eds.).2000. Welfare Regimes and the Experience of Unemployment in EuropeOxford: Oxford University Press.
38.
GanglMarkus2004a. Welfare States and the Scar Effects of Unemployment: A Comparative Analysis of the United States and West GermanyAmerican Journal of Sociology109: 1319–64.
39.
GanglMarkus2004b. Labor Market Structure and Reemployment Rates: Unemployment Dynamics in West Germany and the United StatesResearch in Social Stratification and Mobility20: 185–224.
40.
GanglMarkus2004c. Institutions and the Structure of Labour Market Matching in the United States and West GermanyEuropean Sociological Review20: 171–87.
41.
GanglMarkus2005. Income Inequality, Permanent Incomes, and Income Dynamics: Comparing Europe to the United StatesWork and Occupations32: 140–62.
42.
GibbonsRobertKatzLawrence F.1991. Layoffs and LemonsJournal of Labor Economics9: 351–80.
43.
GoodinRobert E.HeadeyBruceMuffelsRuudDirvenHenk-Jan.1999. The Real Worlds of Welfare CapitalismCambridge: Cambridge University Press.
44.
GottschalkPeterSmeedingTimothy M.1997. Cross-National Comparisons of Earnings and Income InequalityJournal of Economic Literature35: 633–87.
45.
GregoryMaryJukesRobert2001. Unemployment and Subsequent Earnings: Estimating Scarring among British Men 1984–1994. Economic Journal111: F607-F625.
46.
HalabyCharles N.1988. Action and Information in the Job Mobility Process: The Search DecisionAmerican Sociological Review53: 9–25.
47.
HallPeter A.SoskiceDavid (eds.).2001. Varieties of Capitalism: The Institutional Foundations of Comparative AdvantageOxford: Oxford University Press.
48.
HeckmanJames J.IchimuraHidehikoToddPetra E..1997: Matching as an Econometric Evaluation Estimator: Evidence from Evaluating a Job Training Programme. Review of Economic Studies64: 605–54.
49.
HeckmanJames J.IchimuraHidehikoToddPetra E..1998. Matching as an Econometric Evaluation EstimatorReview of Economic Studies65: 261–94.
50.
HolmlundBertil1998. Unemployment Insurance in Theory and PracticeScandinavian Journal of Economics100: 113–41.
51.
ImbensGuido W.2004. Nonparametric estimation of average treatment effects under exogeneity: A ReviewReview of Economics and Statistics86: 4–29.
52.
JacobsonLouisLaLondeRobertSullivanDaniel1993. Earnings Losses of Displaced WorkersAmerican Economic Review83: 685–709.
53.
KletzerLori G.1989. Returns to Seniority after Permanent Job LossAmerican Economic Review79: 536–43.
54.
KletzerLori G.1998. Job Displacement. Journal of Economic Perspectives12 (1): 115–36.
55.
KletzerLori G.FairlieRobert W.2003. The long-term costs of job displacement for young adult workersIndustrial and Labor Relations Review56: 682–98.
56.
KorpiTomas2001. Good Friends in Bad Times? Social Networks and Job Search among the Unemployed in SwedenActa Sociologica44: 157–70.
57.
KorpiWalter2001. Contentious Institutions: An Augmented Rational-Action Analysis of the Origins and Path Dependency of Welfare State Institutions in Western CountriesRationality and Society13: 235–83.
58.
KorpiWalterPalmeJoakim2003. New Politics and Class Politics in the Context of Austerity and Globalization: Welfare State Regress in 18 Countries, 1975–1995American Political Science Review97: 425–46.
59.
KuhnPeter2002 (ed.). Losing Work, Moving On: International Perspectives on Worker Displacement. Kalamazoo, MI: W.E. Upjohn Institute.
60.
KuhnPeterSweetmanArthur1998. Wage Loss Following Displacement: The Role of Union CoverageIndustrial and Labor Relations Review51: 384–400.
61.
KuhnPeterSweetmanArthur1999. Vulnerable Seniors: Unions, Tenure, and Wages Following Permanent Job LossJournal of Labor Economics17: 671–93.
62.
LayteRichardLevinHenrikHendrickxJohnBisonIvano2000. Unemployment and Cumulative Disadvantage in the Labour Market. Pp. 153–174 in Welfare Regimes and the Experience of Unemployment in Europe, edited by GallieDuncanPaugamSerge. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
63.
MeyerBruce D.2002. Unemployment and Workers' Compensation Programmes: Rationale, Design, Labour Supply, and Income SupportFiscal Studies23: 1–49.
64.
MortensenDale T.1986. Job Search and Labor Market Analysis. Pp. 849–919 in Handbook of Labor Economics, Volume II, edited by AshenfelterOrleyLayardRichard. Amsterdam: Elsevier.
65.
MortensenDale T.1990. A Structural Model of Unemployment Insurance Benefit Effects on the Incidence and Duration of Unemployment. Pp. 57–81 in Advances in the Theory and Measurement of Unemployment, edited by WeissYoramFishelsonGideon. London: Macmillan.
66.
MouwTed2003. Social Capital and Finding a Job: Do Contacts Matter?American Sociological Review68: 868–98.
67.
NealDerek1995. Industry-Specific Human Capital: Evidence from Displaced WorkersJournal of Labor Economics13: 653–77.
68.
Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD).1999. Employment Protection and Labour Market Performance. OECD Employment Outlook pp. 49–132.
69.
Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD).2004. Employment Protection Regulation and Labour Market Performance. OECD Employment Outlook pp. 73–144.
70.
PetrongoloBarbaraPissaridesChristopher A.2001. Looking into the Black Box: A Survey of the Matching FunctionJournal of Economic Literature39: 390–431.
71.
RosenbaumPaul R.2002. Observational Studies. 2d edition. New York: Springer.
72.
RosenfeldRachel A.1992. Job Mobility and Career ProcessesAnnual Review of Sociology18: 39–61.
73.
RuhmChristopher J.1991. Are Workers Permanently Scarred by Job Displacement?American Economic Review81: 319–24.
74.
SchervishPaul G.1983. The Structural Determinants of Unemployment: Vulnerability and Power in Market RelationsNew York: Academic Press.
75.
S⊘rensenAage B.2000. Toward a Sounder Basis for Class AnalysisAmerican Journal of Sociology105: 1523–558.
76.
StevensAnn H.1997. Persistent Effects of Job Displacement: The Importance of Multiple Job LossesJournal of Labor Economics15: 165–88.
77.
ThomasJonathan M.1996. An Empirical Model of Sectoral Movements by Unemployed WorkersJournal of Labor Economics14: 126–53.
78.
TopelRobert H.1991. Specific Capital, Mobility, and Wages: Wages Rise with Job SeniorityJournal of Political Economy99: 145–76.
79.
U.S. Census Bureau.2001. Survey of Income and Program Participation. User's Guide. 3d edition. Washington, D.C.: U.S. Census Bureau.
80.
VishwanathTara1989. Job Search, Stigma Effect, and Escape Rate from UnemploymentJournal of Labour Economics7: 487–502.
81.
WeedenKim A.2002. Why Do Some Occupations Pay More than Others? Social Closure and Earnings Inequality in the United StatesAmerican Journal of Sociology108: 55–101.
82.
WinshipChristopherSobelMichael E.2004. Causal Inference in Sociological Studies. Pp. 481–503 in Handbook of Data Analysis, edited by HardyMelissaBrymanAlan. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
