Nearly 8 million children of employed parents are in nonrelative child care, but little is known about safety risks. Drawing on the literature reporting mistakes in organizations and medical errors, the authors analyze fatalities in U.S. child care. Types of child care vary greatly in organizational features, from formally organized centers to informal care offered in providers' or children's homes. This allows analysis of how the social organization of care affects risks. A unique national dataset is used to provide a lower bound on fatalities and to analyze fatality rates across types of care. Data come from three sources: (1) a systematic national media search for 1985-2003, (2) legal records of civil and criminal court cases involving fatalities and serious injuries in child care, and (3) ethnographic data from state records in seven states. Overall child care is quite safe, but there are striking differences in fatality rates across types of care. Center care is significantly safer than care offered in private homes and offers particular protection against fatalities from violence. Detailed narratives of how fatalities occur suggest that the organization of work is a crucial factor in risk differences.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AhnHey Jun.2005. “Child Care Teachers' Strategies in Children's Socialization of Emotion.”Early Child Development and Care175: 49–61.
2.
AlkonAbbeyGenevroJanice L.KaiserPamela J.TschannJeanne M.ChesneyMargaretBoyceW. Thomas1994. “Injuries in Child-Care Centers: Rates, Severity, and Etiology.”Supplement to Pediatrics94: 1043–6.
3.
BanksVeronica.2003. “Comparison of Fatality and Non-fatality Victims in the NCANDS 2000 Case Level Data.”The NDACAN [National Data Archive on Child Abuse and Neglect] Updata14: 1, 3, 6.
4.
BillingsCharles.1998. Incident Reporting Systems in Medicine and Experience with the Aviation Safety Reporting System. Report from a NPSF Workshop on Assembling the Scientific Basis for Progress on Patient Safety. Chicago, IL: American Medical Association. Retrieved June 5, 2005 (http://www.npsf.org/exec/billings.html).
5.
BlauDavid M.2002. The Child Care Problem: An Economic Analysis. New York: Russell Sage Foundation.
6.
BlauDavid M.2003. “Do Child Care Regulations Affect the Child Care and Labor Markets?”Journal of Policy Analysis and Management22: 443–65.
7.
BlauDavidCurrieJanet2004. “Preschool, Day Care, and Afterschool Care: Who's Minding the Kids?” Working Paper No. 10670. Cambridge, MA: National Bureau of Economic Research.
8.
BoskCharles L.2005. “Continuity and Change in the Study of Medical Error: The Culture of Safety on the Shop Floor.” Occasional Paper, School of Social Science. Princeton, NJ: Institute for Advanced Study. Retrieved June 15, 2005 (http://www.sss.ias.edu/publications/papers/paper20.pdf).
9.
BrennerRuth A.OverpeckMary D.TrumbleAnn C.DerSimonianRebeccaBerendesHeinz1999. “Deaths Attributable to Injuries in Infants, United States, 1983-1991.”Pediatrics103: 968–74.
10.
BrissP. M.SacksJ.AddisD. G.KresnowJ.-J.O'NeilJ.1994. “A Nationwide Study of the Risk of Injury Associated with Day Care Attendance.”Pediatrics93: 364–8.
11.
BurchinalMargaret R.NelsonLauren2000. “Family Selection and Child Care Experiences: Implications for Studies of Child Outcomes.”Early Childhood Research Quarterly15: 385–411.
12.
BurtonAliceWhitebookMarcyYoungMarciBellmDanWayneClaudia2002. Estimating the Size and Components of the U.S. Child Care Workforce and Caregiving Population. Washington, DC: Center for the Child Care Workforce.
13.
ButterfieldPerry M.2002. “Child Care is Rich in Routines.”Zero to Three22: 29–32.
14.
CohenLawrence E.FelsonMarcus1979. “Social Change and Crime Rate Trends: A Routine Activity Approach.”American Sociological Review44: 588–609.
15.
ConkeyDonWalkerChris2001. “State Suspends Provider's Day-Care License.”The Patriot Ledger. May 1, p. 1.
16.
Consumer Product Safety Commission.1999. Safety Hazards in Child Care Settings. Washington, DC: U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission.
17.
CookRichard I.WoodsDavid D.MillerCharlotte1998. A Tale of Two Stories: Contrasting Views of Patient Safety. National Health Care Safety Council of the National Patient Safety Foundation. Chicago, IL: American Medical Association.
18.
CroweHelen P.Philip SanfordZeskind.1992. “Psychophysiological and Perceptual Responses to Infant Cries Varying in Pitch: Comparison of Adults with Low and High Scores on the Child Abuse Potential Inventory.”Child Abuse and Neglect16: 19–29.
19.
CurbowBarbaraSprattKaiUngarettiAntoinetteMcDonnellKarenBrecklerSteven2000. “Development of the Child Care Worker Job Stress Inventory.”Early Childhood Research Quarterly15: 515–36.
20.
CurrieJanetHotzV. Joseph2001. “Accidents Will Happen? Unintentional Injury, Maternal Employment, and Child Care Policy.” Working Paper 8090, National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, MA.
21.
DismukesKeyYoungGrantRobert SumwaltBattelle.1998. “Cockpit Interruptions and Distractions: Effective Management Requires a Careful Balancing Act.” Aviation Safety Reporting System. Directline10: 4–8.
22.
Divine-HawkinsPatricia.1981. Family Day Care in the United States: National Day Care Home Study. Final Report. Executive Summary. Washington, DC: Administration for Children, Youth and Families, U.S. Department of Human Services.
23.
EstesAndrea.2001. “Infant's Return Home Offers Family Hope for the Battle Ahead.”The Boston Globe. South Weekly Section. July 15, p. 1.
24.
FeldmanK. W.BethelR.ShugermanR. P.GrossmanD. C.GradyM. S.EllenbogenR. G.2001. “The Cause of Infant and Toddler Subdural Hemorrhage: A Prospective Study.”Pediatrics108: 636–46.
25.
FinkelhorDavidOrmrodRichard2001. “Crimes against Children by Babysitters.”Juvenile Justice Bulletin (September). Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Justice.
26.
GibbonFitzHeatherM.2002. “Child Care across Sectors: A Comparison of the Work of Child Care in Three Settings.” Pp. 145–58 in Child Care and Inequality: Rethinking Carework for Children and Youth, edited by CancianFrancesca M.KurzDemieLondonAndrew S.ReviereRebeccaTuominenMary C.. New York: Routledge.
27.
FullerBruceKaganSharon LynnLoebSusannaYueh-WenChang.2004. “Child Care Quality: Centers and Home Settings That Serve Poor Families.”Early Childhood Research Quarterly19: 505–27.
28.
GoodSusan E.ParrishGibson R.IngRoy T.1994. “Children's Deaths at Day-Care Facilities.”Supplement to Pediatrics94: 1039–41.
29.
GormleyWilliamJr.1999. “Regulating Child Care Quality.”The Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science563: 116–29.
30.
HamreBridgetPiantaRobert C.2004. “Self-Reported Depression in Nonfamilial Caregivers: Prevalence and Associations with Caregiver Behavior in Child-Care Settings.”Early Childhood Research Quarterly19: 297–318.
31.
HelburnSuzanne W.BergmannBarbara R.2002. America's Child Care Problem: The Way Out. New York: Palgrave (division of St. Martin's Press).
32.
HelburnSuzanne W.HowesCarollee1996. “Child Care Cost and Quality.”The Future of Children6: 62–82.
33.
HughesEverett C.1971. “Mistakes at Work.” Pp. 316–25 in The Sociological Eye: Selected Papers, edited by HughesEverett C.. Chicago, IL: Aldine-Atherton.
34.
JacobsJane.2004. Dark Age Ahead. New York: Random House.
35.
JennyCaroleHymelKent P.RitzenAleneReinertSteven E.HayThomas C.1999. “Analysis of Missed Cases of Abusive Head Trauma.”The Journal of the American Medical Association281: 621–6.
36.
KahnemanDanielKruegerAlan B.SchkadeDavid A.SchwarzNorbertStoneArthur A.2004. “A Survey Method for Characterizing Daily Life Experience: The Day Reconstruction Method.”Science306: 1776–80.
37.
KanterRosabeth Moss.1972. “The Organization Child: Experience Management in a Nursery School.”Sociology of Education45: 186–211.
38.
KohnL. T.CorriganJ. M.DonaldsonM. S., eds.1999. To Err is Human: Building a Safer Health System. Washington, DC: National Academy Press.
39.
KohnMelvin L.1989. Class and Conformity. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
40.
KontosSusanStremmelAndrew J.1988. “Caregivers'Perceptions of Working Conditions in a Child Care Environment.”Early Childhood Research Quarterly3: 77–90.
41.
KoppelRossPetlayJoshua P.CohenAbigailAbaluckBrianRussell LocalioA.KimmelStephen E.StromBrian I.2005. “Role of Computerized Physician Order Entry Systems in Facilitating Medical Errors.”The Journal of the American Medical Association293: 1197–203.
42.
KotchJ. B.HusseyJ. M.CarterA.2003. “Evaluation of North Carolina Child Care Safety Regulations.”Injury Prevention9: 220–5.
43.
KriegerNora Jane.2001. The Experience of Being a Director in an Early Care and Education Center. Ph.D. dissertation, Department of Teaching and Learning, New York University, New York, NY.
44.
LareauAnnette.2003. Unequal Childhoods. Berkeley: University of California Press.
45.
LeapeL. L.2000. “Institute of Medicine Medical Error Figures Are Not Exaggerated.”The Journal of the American Medical Association284: 95–7.
46.
LeapeL. L.BerwickD. M.2005. “Five Years After 'To Err is Human': What Have We Learned?”The Journal of the American Medical Association293: 2384–90.
47.
ListmanDavid A.BechtelKirsten2003. “Accidental and Abusive Head Injury in Young Children.”Pediatrics15: 299–303.
48.
LoewensteinGeorge.2004. “Out of Control: Visceral Influences on Behavior.” Pp. 689–723 in Advances in Behavioral Economics, edited by CamererColin F.LoewensteinGeorgeRabinMatthew. New York: Russell Sage Foundation.
49.
MargolinLeslie.1990a. “Child Abuse by Babysitters: An Ecological-Interactional Interpretation.”Journal of Family Violence5: 95–105.
50.
MargolinLeslie.1990b. “When Vocabularies of Motive Fail: The Example of Fatal Child Abuse.”Qualitative Sociology13: 373–385.
51.
MarshallNancy L.CrepsCindy L.BursteinNancy R.CahillKevin E.RobesonWendy WagnerYangSue Y.SchimmentiJenniferGlantzFrederic B.2003. Family Child Care Today. Wellesley, MA: Wellesley Centers for Women and Abt Associates.
52.
McDonaldClement J.WeinerMichaelHuiSiu L.2000. “Deaths Due to Medical Errors Are Exaggerated in Institute of Medicine Report.”The Journal of the American Medical Association284: 93–5.
53.
MillDavinaRomano-WhiteDonna1999. “Correlates of Affectionate and Angry Behavior in Child Care Educators of Preschool-aged Children.”Early Childhood Research Quarterly14: 155–78.
54.
MocanH. Naci.2001. “Can Consumers Detect Lemons? Information Asymmetry in the Market for Child Care.” Working Paper 8291, National Bureau of Economic Research. Cambridge, MA. Monks, Matthew. 2004. “Shaking Incident Detailed.” Martinsville Bulletin. Feb. 4, p. 1.
55.
MoonRachel Y.BiliterWendy M.CroskellSarah E.2001. “Examination of State Regulations Regarding Infants and Sleep in Licensed Child Care Centers and Family Child Care Settings.”Pediatrics107: 1029–36.
56.
MoonRachel Y.PatelKantilal M.SarahJ.McDermottShaefer.2000. “Sudden Infant Death Syndrome in Child Care Settings.”Pediatrics106: 295–300.
NelsonMargaret K.1991. Negotiated Care: The Experience of Family Day Care Providers. Philadelphia, PA: Temple University Press.
59.
NICHD Early Child Care Research Network.1996. “Characteristics of Infant Care: Factors Contributing to Positive Caregiving.”Early Childhood Research Quarterly11: 269–306.
60.
NICHD Early Child Care Research Network.2000. “Characteristics and Quality of Child Care for Toddlers and Preschoolers.”Applied Developmental Science4: 116–35.
61.
NICHD Early Child Care Research Network.2003. “Child Care and Common Communicable Illnesses in Children Aged 37 to 54 Months.”Archives of Pediatrics and Adolescent Medicine157: 196–200.
62.
NICHD Early Child Care Research Network.2004. “Type of Child Care and Children's Development at 54 Months.”Early Childhood Research Quarterly19: 203–30.
63.
PerrowCharles.1984. Normal Accidents. New York: Basic Books.
64.
PhillipsDeborah A.HowesCarolleeWhitebookMarcy1991. “Child Care as an Adult Work Environment.”Journal of Social Issues47: 49–70.
65.
PhillipsDeborah A.VoranMiriamKiskerEllenHowesCarolleeWhitebookMarcy1994. “Child Care for Children in Poverty: Opportunity or Inequality?”Child Development65: 472–92.
66.
PizziLaura T.GoldfarbNeil I.NashDavid B.2001. “Promoting a Culture of Safety.” Chapter 40 in Making Health Care Safer: A Critical Analysis of Patient Safety Practices. Evidence Report/Technology Assessment: Number 43. AHRQ Publication No. 01-E058, July 2001. Rockville, MD: Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality. Retrieved June 5, 2005 (http://www.ahrq.gov/clinic/ptsafety/).
67.
ReasonJames.2000. “Human Error: Models and Management.”British Medical Journal320: 768–70.
68.
ReijneveletMarcel F.van der WalBrugmanEmilyRemyA.SingHiraVerloove-VanhorickS. Pauline2004. “Infant Crying and Abuse.”The Lancet364: 1340–2.
69.
RichardsonFranci.2001. “Prosecutor: Caregiver Contradicted Herself on Baby Injury.”Boston Herald. May 3, p. 2.
70.
RindfussRonald R.Kelly RaleyR.KathleenMullan Harris.2000. “The Quality and Comparability of Child Care Data in U.S. Surveys.”Social Science Research29: 356–81.
71.
SalujaGitanjaliEarlyDiane M.CliffordRichard M.2002. “Demographic Characteristics of Early Childhood Teachers and Structural Elements of Early Care and Education in the United States.”Early Childhood Research and Practice 4, no. 1. Retrieved June 6, 2005 (http://ecrp.uiuc.edu/).
72.
SeperJerry.2001. “U.S. Panel Overturns Deportation: Haitian Nanny Served Two Years for Fatally Beating Baby.”Washington Post. August 22, p. Al.
73.
SnookScott A.2002. Friendly Fire: The Accidental Shootdown of U.S. Black Hawks Over Northern Iraq. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
74.
StaffordZenah P.NagleG.RiceT.2005. Addressing Social-Emotional Development and Infant Mental Health in Early Childhood Systems. Building State Early Childhood Comprehensive Systems Series, No. 12. Los Angeles, CA: National Center for Infant and Early Childhood Health Policy.
75.
StroberMyra H.SuzanneGerlach-DownieYeagerKenneth E.1995. “Child Care Centers as Workplaces.”Feminist Economics1: 93–119.
76.
SutcliffeK. M.LewtonE.RosenthalM. M.2004. “Communication Failures: An Insidious Contributor to Medical Mishaps.”Academic Medicine79: 186–94.
77.
ThackerS. B.AddisD. G.GoodmanR. A.HollowayB.SpencerH. C.1992. “Infectious Diseases and Injuries in Child Day Care: Opportunities for Healthier Children.”The Journal of the American Medical Association268: 1720–6.
78.
TiceDianne M.BratslavskyEllenBaumeisterRoy F.2001. “Emotional Distress Regulation Takes Precedence over Impulse Control: If You Feel Bad, Do It!”Journal of Personality and Social Psychology80: 53–67.
79.
UttalLynet.2002. Making Care Work. New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press.
80.
VaughanDiane.1996. The Challenger Launch Decision. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
81.
VaughanDiane.1999. “The Dark Side of Organizations: Mistakes, Misconduct, and Disaster.”Annual Review of Sociology25: 271–305.
82.
Von KampenTodd.2002. “Sitter Gets Prison in Death of Infant.”Omaha World-Herald. December 17, p. 1B.
83.
WaldfogelJane.2001. “International Policies toward Parental Leave and Child Care.”Future of Children11: 98–111.
84.
WeickKarl E.1987. “Organizational Culture as a Source of High Reliability.”California Management Review29: 112–27.
85.
WeickKarl E.1990. “The Vulnerable System: An Analysis of the Tenerife Air Disaster.”Journal of Management16: 571–93.
86.
WeickKarl E.SutcliffeK. M.ObstfeldD.1999. “Organizing for High Reliability: Processes of Collective Mindfulness.”Research on Organizational Behavior21: 23–81.
87.
WhitebookMarcyPhillipsDeborahBellmDanCrowellNancyAlmarazMirellaJoonYoung Jo.2004. Two Years in Early Care and Education. Center for the Study of Child Care Employment. Berkeley: University of California.
88.
WoodJacqueline.2003. “Child Deaths and Injuries in Regulated Care: What Can We Learn and Put into Action?” Presented at the Annual Licensing Seminar of the National Association for Regulatory Administrators, September, Portland, ME.
89.
WrigleyJulia.1995. Other People's Children. New York: Basic Books.
