This article assesses the influence of the legacy of lynching on homicide levels within the contemporary South. Drawing upon literature relating to the brutalizing effects of capital punishment and “self-help” in the absence of access to formal law, this study hypothesizes that a measure of the frequency of lynching in the past will exhibit positive effects on contemporary homicide levels for the overall population and for race-specific populations (white and black offending). The results of negative binomial regression analyses of counties and county-clusters in the South are generally consistent with expectations. The measure of lynching exhibits consistently positive effects on overall homicide levels and levels of black offending in models with controls for other theoretically relevant covariates. For whites, the effect of lynching emerges for a particular type of homicide: interracial homicides that evolve out of interpersonal conflicts. At a general level, our findings underscore the relevance of the historical context for understanding variation in contemporary levels of homicide.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AllisonPaul D.2002. Missing Data. Quantitative Applications in the Social Sciences, vol. 136. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
2.
AndersonElijah1997. “Violence and the Inner-City Street Code.” Pp. 1–30 in Violence and Childhood in the Inner City, edited by McCordJoan. New York: Cambridge University Press.
3.
AndersonElijah1999. Code of the Street: Decency, Violence, and the Moral Life of the Inner City.New York: Norton.
4.
AnselinLucFloraxRaymond J. G. M.ReySergio J.2004. Advances in Spatial Econometrics: Methodology, Tools and Applications. Berlin: Springer.
5.
BaileyWilliam C.1984. “Poverty, Inequality, and City Homicide Rates: Some Not So Unexpected Findings.”Criminology22: 531–50.
6.
BaileyWilliam C.1990. “Murder, Capital Punishment, and Television: Execution Publicity and Homicide Rates.”American Sociological Review55: 628–33.
7.
BaileyWilliam C.1998. “Deterrence, Brutalization, and the Death Penalty: Another Examination of Oklahoma's Return to Capital Punishment.”Criminology36: 711–33.
8.
BaileyTrevor C.GatrellAnthony C.1995. Interactive Spatial Data Analysis.2d ed.Essex, England: Longman.
9.
BallerRobert D.AnselinLucMessnerSteven F.DeaneGlennHawkinsDarnell F.2001. “Structural Covariates of U.S. County Homicide Rates: Incorporating Spatial Effects.”Criminology39: 561–90.
10.
BallerRobert D.MessnerSteven F.AnselinLucDeaneGlenn2002. “The Interchangeability of Homicide Data Sources: A Spatial Analytical Perspective.”Homicide Studies6: 211–27.
11.
BanduraAlbert1973. Aggression: A Social Learning Analysis.Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall.
12.
BanduraAlbert1983. “Psychological Mechanisms of Aggression.” Pp. 1–40 in Aggression: Theoretical and Empirical Reviews, vol. 1, edited by GeenRussell G.DonnersteinEdward I.. San Diego, CA: Academic Press.
13.
BeckE. M.TolnayStewart E.1997. “When Race Didn't Matter: Black and White Mob Violence Against Their Own Color.” Pp. 132–54 in Under Sentence of Death: Lynching in the South, edited by Fitzhugh BrundageW.. Chapel Hill, NC: University of North Carolina Press.
14.
BlackDonald1983. “Crime as Social Control.”American Sociological Review48: 34–45.
15.
BlauPeter M.BlauJudith R.1982. “The Cost of Inequality: Metropolitan Structure and Violent Crime.”American Sociological Review47: 114–29.
16.
BowersWilliam J.1984. Legal Homicide: Death as Punishment in America, 1864-1982. Boston, MA: Northeastern University Press.
17.
BridenbaughCarl1971. Myths and Realities: Societies of the Colonial South.NY: Atheneum.
18.
BrundageW Fitzhugh.1993. Lynching in the New South: Georgia and Virginia, 1880–1930. Urbana, IL: University of Illinois Press.
19.
BrundageW Fitzhugh.1997. “Introduction.” Pp. 1–20 in Under Sentence of Death: Lynching in the South, edited by Fitzhugh BrundageW.. Chapel Hill, NC: University of North Carolina Press.
20.
ButterfieldFox1995. All God's Children: The Bosket Family and the American Tradition of Violence.New York: Knopf.
21.
CashWilbur J.1941. The Mind of the South. New York: Vintage.
22.
Census of Population and Housing.1992. Summary Tape File 3 on CD-ROM, prepared by the Bureau of the Census. Washington, DC: Bureau of the Census.
23.
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.1999. CDC WONDER. Available at http://wonder.cdc.gov/.
24.
ChepesiukRonald2000. The Scotch-Irish: From the North of Ireland to the Making of America.Jefferson, NC: McFarland.
25.
ChuRebekahRiveraCraigLoftinColin2000. “Herding and Homicide: An Examination of the Nisbett-Reaves Hypothesis.”Social Forces78: 971–87.
26.
ClarkeJames W.1998. “Without Fear or Shame: Lynching, Capital Punishment and the Subculture of Violence in the American South.”British Journal of Political Science28: 269–89.
27.
CochranJohn K.ChamlinMitchell B.SethMark1994. “Deterrence or Brutalization? An Impact Assessment of Oklahoma's Return to Capital Punishment.”Criminology32: 107–34.
28.
DixonJoLizotteAlan J.1987. “The Burden of Proof: Southern Subculture-of-Violence Explanations of Gun Ownership and Homicide.”American Journal of Sociology95: 182–87.
29.
DoernerWilliam G.1975. “A Regional Analysis of Homicide Rates in the United States.”Criminology13: 90–101.
30.
DoernerWilliam G.1978a. “The Deadly World of Johnny Reb: Fact, Foible, or Fantasy.” Pp. 91–98 in Violent Crime: Historical and Contemporary Issues, edited by InciardiJames A.PottingerAnne E.. Beverly Hills, CA: Sage.
31.
DoernerWilliam G.1978b. “The Index of Southernness Revisited: The Influence of Wherefrom Upon Whodunnit.”Criminology16: 47–56.
32.
DoernerWilliam G.1979. “The Violent World of Johnny Reb: An Attitudinal Analysis of the ‘Regional Culture of Violence’Thesis.”Sociological Forum2: 61–71.
33.
DoernerWilliam G.SpeirJohn C.1986. “Stitch and Sew: The Impact of Medical Resources Upon Criminally Induced Lethality.”Criminology24: 319–30.
34.
EatonClement1961. The Growth of Southern Civilization 1790–1860. New York: Harper and Row.
35.
EatonClement1966. A History of the Old South.2d ed.New York: Macmillan.
36.
EricksonCharlotte1972. Invisible Immigrants: The Adaptations of English and Scottish Immigrants in Nineteenth-Century America.Coral Gables, FL: University of Miami Press.
37.
ErlangerHoward S.1975. “Is There a ‘Subculture of Violence’ in the South?”Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology66: 483–90.
38.
FordHenry Jones [1915]1969. The Scotch-Irish in America.New York: Arno Press.
39.
ForstallRichard L.1996. Population of States and Counties of the United States: 1790 to 1990 from the Twenty-one Decennial Censuses. Prepared by the U.S. Department of Commerce, Bureau of the Census, Population Division. Washington, DC: U.S. Government Printing Office; distributed by the National Technical Information Service.
40.
FoxJames Alan2001. Uniform Crime Reports [United States]: Supplementary Homicide Reports, 1976–1999. Computer file, ICPSR version. Boston, MA: Northeastern University, College of Criminal Justice; distributed by Inter-University Consortium for Political and Social Research, Ann Arbor, MI.
41.
FoxJames Alan2004. “Missing Data Problems in the SHR: Imputing Offender and Relationship Characteristics.”Homicide Studies8: 214–54.
42.
FranklinJohn H.1956. The Militant South.Boston: Beacon.
43.
GastilRaymond1971. “Homicide and a Regional Culture of Violence.”American Sociological Review36: 412–27.
GriffinPatrick2001. The People with No Name: Ireland's Ulster Scots, America's Scots Irish, and the Creation of a British Atlantic World 1689–1764.Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
HainesMichael R. and the Inter-University Consortium for Political and Social Research.2005. Historical, Demographic, Economic, and Social Data: The United States, 1790–2000. Computer file, ICPSR02896-v2. Hamilton, NY, and Ann Arbor, MI: Colgate University and Inter-University Consortium for Political and Social Research; distributed by Inter-University Consortium for Political and Social Research.
48.
HarperMarjory1988. Emigration from North-East Scotland: Beyond the Broad Atlantic.Vol. 2. Aberdeen, Scotland: Aberdeen University Press.
49.
HawleyF. FrederickMessnerSteven F.1989. “The Southern Violence Construct: A Review of Arguments, Evidence, and the Normative Context.”Justice Quarterly6: 481–511.
50.
HoranPatrick M.HargisPeggy G.1995. County Longitudinal Template, 1840–1990.Ann Arbor, MI: Inter-university Consortium for Political and Social Research.
51.
Huff-CorzineLinCorzineJayMooreDavid C.1986. “Southern Exposure: Deciphering the South's Influence on Homicide Rates.”Social Forces64: 906–24.
52.
Huff-CorzineLinWeaverGreg S.CorzineJayWittekindJanice CliffordPeteeThomas A.2001. “The Importance of Disaggregation in Specifying the Southern Subculture of Violence.” New Directions in Homicide Research. Proceedings of the 2001 Annual Meeting of the Homicide Research Working Group, Orlando, FL, June 22–25.
53.
Inter-university Consortium for Political and Social Research.2003. Historical, Demographic, Economic, and Social Data: The United States, 1790-1970. Computer file. Ann Arbor, MI: Interuniversity Consortium for Political and Social Research.
54.
KingDavid R.1978. “The Brutalization Effect: Execution Publicity and the Incidence of Homicide in South Carolina.”Social Forces57: 683–87.
55.
KowalskiGregory S.PeteeThomas A.1991. “Sunbelt Effects on Homicide Rates.”Sociology and Social Research75: 73–79.
56.
LandKenneth C.McCallPatricia L.CohenLawrence E.1990. “Structural Covariates of Homicide Rates: Are There Any Invariances across Time and Social Space?”American Journal of Sociology95: 922–63.
57.
LiaoTim Futing1994. Interpreting Probability Models: Logit, Probit, and Other Generalized Linear Models.Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
58.
LeeMatthew R.BartowskiJohn P.2004. “Civic Participation, Regional Subcultures, and Violence: The Differential Effects of Secular Religious Participation on Adult and Juvenile Homicide.”Homicide Studies8: 5–39.
59.
LeyburnJames G.1962. The Scotch-Irish: A Social History.Chapel Hill, NC: University of North Carolina Press.
60.
LoftinColinHillRobert H.1974. “Regional Subculture and Homicide: An Examination of the Gastil-Hackney Thesis.”American Sociological Review39: 714–24.
61.
LottierStuart1938. “Distribution of Criminal Offenses in Sectional Regions.”Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology29: 329–44.
62.
McCallPatricia L.LandKenneth C.CohenLawrence E.1992. “Violent Criminal Behavior: Is There a General and Continuing Influence of the South.”Social Science Research21: 286–310.
63.
McFeelyWilliam S.1997. “Afterword.” Pp. 318–21 in Under Sentence of Death: Lynching in the South, edited by Fitzhugh BrundageW.. Chapel Hill, NC: University of North Carolina Press.
64.
McWhineyGrady1988. Cracker Culture: Celtic Ways in the Old South.Tuscaloosa, AL: University of Alabama Press.
65.
MessnerSteven F.1983. “Regional and Racial Effects on the Urban Homicide Rate: The Subculture of Violence Revisited.”American Journal of Sociology88: 997–1007.
66.
MessnerSteven F.1988. “Research on Cultural and Socioeconomic Factors in Criminal Violence.”Psychiatric Clinics of North America11: 511–25.
67.
National Center for Health Statistics (NCHS).1986-95. Public use data tapes: Mortality detail data. [Electronic data files, one file per year, 1986-95]. Hyattsville, MD: National Center for Health Statistics.
68.
NelsonCandiceCorzineJayHuff-CorzineLin1994. “The Violent West Reexamined: A Research Note on Regional Homicide Rates.”Criminology32: 149–61.
69.
NisbettRichard E.CohenDov1996. Culture of Honor: The Psychology of Violence in the South.Boulder, CO: Westview.
70.
OsgoodD Wayne.2000. “Poisson-Based Regression Analysis of Aggregate Crime Rates.”Journal of Quantitative Criminology16: 21–43.
71.
OsterweisRollin G.1949. Romanticism and Nationalism in the Old South.Baton Rouge, LA: Louisiana State University Press.
72.
ParkerKaren F.McCallPatricia L.LandKenneth C.1999. “Determining Social-Structural Predictors of Homicide: Units of Analysis and Related Methodological Concerns.” Pp. 107–24 in Homicide: A Sourcebook of Social Research, edited by Dwayne SmithM.ZahnMargaret A.. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
73.
ParkerKaren F.PruittMatthew V.2000. “How the West Was One: Explaining the Similarities in Race-Specific Homicide Rates in the West and South.”Social Forces78: 1483–508.
74.
ParkerRobert Nash1989. “Poverty, Subculture of Violence, and Type of Homicide.”Social Forces67: 983–1007.
75.
ParkerRobert NashDwayne SmithM.1979. “Deterrence, Poverty, and Type of Homicide.”American Journal of Sociology85: 614–24.
76.
PfeiferMichael J.2004. Rough Justice: Lynching and American Society, 1874–1947. Urbana, IL: University of Illinois Press.
77.
PorterfieldAustin L.1949. “Indices of Suicide and Homicide by States and Cities: Some Southern-Nonsouthern Contrasts with Implications for Research.”American Sociological Review14: 481–90.
78.
ReavesAndrew Leo1992. The Cultural Ecology of Rural White Homicide in the Southern United States. Ph.D. dissertation, University of Michigan.
79.
RedfieldHorace V.1880. Homicide, North and South.Philadelphia, PA: Lippincott.
80.
ReedJohn Shelton1971. “To Live—and Die—in Dixie: A Contribution to the Study of Southern Violence.”Political Science Quarterly86: 429–43.
81.
ReedJohn Shelton1972. The Enduring South.Lexington, MA: Lexington Books.
82.
ReedJohn Shelton1982. One South: An Ethnic Approach to Regional Culture.Baton Rouge, LA: Louisiana State University.
83.
ReidWhitelaw1911. Edinburgh Philosophical Institution Opening Address, Season of 1911-1912, Synod Hall, November 1st: The Scot in America and The Ulster Scot.London: Harrison.
84.
RiceTom W.GoldmanCarolyn R.1994. “Another Look at the Subculture of Violence Thesis: Who Murders Whom under What Circumstances?”Sociological Spectrum14: 371–84.
85.
RiedelMarc1999. “Sources of Homicide Data: A Review and Comparison.” Pp. 75–95 in Homicide: A Sourcebook of Social Research, edited by Dwayne SmithM.ZahnMargaret A.. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
86.
RokawWilliam M.MercyJames A.SmithJack C.1990. “Comparing Death Certificate Data with FBI Crime Reporting Statistics on U.S. Homicides.”Public Health Reports105: 447–55.
87.
Scotch-Irish Society of America.1890. The Scotch-Irish in America. Proceedings of the Scotch-Irish Congress at Columbia, Tennessee May 8-11, 1889 (First Congress). Cincinnati, OH: Clarke and The Scotch-Irish Society of America.
88.
ShannonLyle W.1954. “The Spatial Distribution of Criminal Offenses by State.”Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology45: 264–73.
89.
SimpsonMiles E.1985. “Violent Crime, Income Inequality, and Regional Culture: Another Look.”Sociological Focus18: 199–208.
90.
SmithM. DwayneParkerRobert Nash1980. “Type of Homicide and Variation in Regional Rates.”Social Forces59: 136–47.
91.
StackSteve1994. “Execution Publicity and Homicide in Georgia.”American Journal of Criminal Justice18: 25–39.
92.
StataCorp2001. Stata Statistical Software: Release 7.0. College Station, TX: Stata Corporation.
93.
TolnayStewart E.BeckE. M.1995. A Festival of Violence: An Analysis of Southern Lynchings, 1882–1930. Urbana, IL: University of Illinois Press.
94.
TolnayStewart E.DeaneGlennBeckE. M.1996. “Vicarious Violence: Spatial Effects on Southern Lynchings, 1890-1919.”American Journal of Sociology102: 788–815.
95.
U.S. Bureau of the Census.USA Counties 1996 on CD-ROM.1996. Washington, DC: Bureau of the Census.
96.
U.S. Department of Justice, Bureau of Justice Statistics.2000. Law Enforcement Agency Identifiers Crosswalk [United States], 1996. Computer file. ICPSR ed. Ann Arbor, MI: Interuniversity Consortium for Political and Social Research.
97.
WebbJames2004. Born Fighting: How the Scots-Irish Shaped America.New York: Broadway.
98.
WiersemaBrianLoftinColinMcDowallDavid2000. “A Comparison of Supplementary Homicide Reports and National Vital Statistics System Homicide Estimates for U.S. Counties.”Homicide Studies4: 317–40.
99.
WilliamsKirk R.1984. “Economic Sources of Homicide: Reestimating the Effects of Poverty and Inequality.”American Sociological Review49: 283–89.
100.
WilliamsKirk R.FlewellingRobert L.1988. “The Social Production of Criminal Homicide: A Comparative Study of Disaggregated Rates in American Cities.”American Sociological Review53: 421–31.
101.
WolfgangMarvin E.FerracutiF.1967. The Subculture of Violence.London: Tavistock.
102.
Wyatt-BrownBertram1982. Southern Honor: Ethics and Behavior in the Old South.Oxford, England: Oxford University Press.
103.
Wyatt-BrownBertram1986. Honor and Violence in the Old South.Oxford, England: Oxford University Press.
104.
ZimringFranklin E.2003. The Contradictions of American Capital Punishment.New York: Oxford University Press.
