Sociologists have increasingly emphasized “turningpoints” in explaining behavioral change over the life course. Is work a turning point in the life course of criminal offenders? If criminals are provided with jobs, are they likely to stop committing crimes? Prior research is inconclusive because work effects have been biased by selectivity and obscured by the interaction of age and employment. This study yields more refined estimates by specifying event history models to analyze assignment to, eligibility for, and current participation in a national work experiment for criminal offenders. Age is found to interact with employment to affect the rate of self-reported recidivism: Those aged 27 or older are less likely to report crime and arrest when provided with marginal employment opportunities than when such opportunities are not provided. Among young participants, those in their teens and early twenties, the experimental job treatment had little effect on crime. Work thus appears to be a turning point for older, but not younger, offenders.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
BachmanJerald G. and SchulenbergJohn. 1993. “How Part-Time Work Intensity Relates to Drug Use, Problem Behavior, Time Use, and Satisfaction among High School Seniors: Are these Consequences or Merely Correlates?”Developmental Psychology29:220–35.
2.
BerkRichard A., LenihanKenneth J., and RossiPeter H.. 1980. “Crime and Poverty: Some Experimental Evidence from Ex-Offenders.”American Sociological Review45:766–86.
3.
BrownRandall. 1979. “Assessing the Effects of Interview Non-Response on Estimates of the Impact of Supported Work.”Princeton, NJ: Mathematica Policy Research.
4.
CampbellDonald T. and StanleyJulian C.. 1963. Experimental and Quasi-Experimental Designs for Research.Boston, MA: Houghton Mifflin.
5.
CaveGeorge, BosHans, DoolittleFred, and ToussaintCyril. 1993. Jobstart: Final Report on a Program for School Dropouts.New York: Manpower Demonstration Research Corporation.
6.
ChungChing-Fan, SchmidtPeter, and WitteAnn D.. 1991. “Survival Analysis: A Survey.”Journal of Quantitative Criminology7:59–98.
7.
CookPhilip. 1975. “The Correctional Carrot: Better Jobs for Parolees.”Policy Analysis1:11–54.
8.
CoxDavid R.1958. The Planning of Experiments.New York: Wiley.
9.
CrutchfieldRobert D. and PitchfordSusan R.. 1997. “Work and Crime: The Effects of Labor Stratification.”Social Forces76:93–118.
10.
Ekland-OlsonSheldon and KellyWilliam R.. 1993. Justice under Pressure: A Comparison of Recidivism Patterns among Four Successive Parolee Cohorts.New York: Springer-Verlag.
11.
ElderGlen H.1985. “Perspectives on the Life Course.” pp. 23–49 in Life Course Dynamics, edited by ElderG. H.. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
12.
FarringtonDavid P., GallagherBernard, MorleyLynda, LedgerRaymond J.St., and WestDonald J.. 1986. “Unemployment, School Leaving, and Crime.”British Journal of Criminology26:335–56.
13.
FrakerThomas and MaynardRebecca A.. 1987. “Evaluating Comparison Group Designs with Employment-Related Programs.”Journal of Human Resources22:194–227.
14.
GartnerRosemary and PiliavinIrving. 1988. “The Aging Offender and the Aged Offender.” pp. 287–315 in Life-Span Development and Behavior, vol. 9, edited by BaltesP. B., FeathermanD. L., and LernerR. M.. Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum.
15.
GottfredsonMichael and HirschiTravis. 1990. A General Theory of Crime.Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.
16.
GreenbergDavid F.1977. “Delinquency and the Age Structure of Society.”Contemporary Crises: Crime, Law, and Social Policy1:189–223.
17.
GreenbergDavid F.1985. “Age, Crime, and Social Explanation.”American Journal of Sociology91:1–21.
18.
GroggerJeff. 1998. “Market Wages and Youth Crime.”Journal of Labor Economics16:756–91.
19.
HaganJohn. 1991. “Destiny and Drift: Subcultural Preferences, Status Attainments, and the Risks and Rewards of Youth.”American Sociological Review56:567–82.
20.
HaganJohn. 1993. “The Social Embeddedness of Crime and Unemployment.”Criminology31: 465–1.
21.
HaganJohn and McCarthyBill. 1997. Mean Streets: Youth Crime and Homelessness.Cambridge, MA: Cambridge University Press.
22.
HeckmanJames J.1992. “Randomization and Social Policy Evaluation.” pp. 201–30 in Evaluating Welfare and Training Programs, edited by ManskiC. F. and GarfinkelI.. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
23.
HeckmanJames J. and Joseph HotzV.. 1989. “Choosing among Alternative Non-Experimental Methods for Estimating the Impact of Social Programs: The Case of Manpower Training.”Journal of the American Statistical Association84:862–74.
24.
HepburnJohn R. and AlbonettiCelesta A.. 1994. “Recidivism among Drug Offenders: A Survival Analysis of the Effects of Offender Characteristics, Type of Offense, and Two Types of Intervention.”Journal of Quantitative Criminology10:159–79.
25.
HindelangMichael J., HirschiTravis, and WeisJoseph G.. 1979. “Correlates of Delinquency: The Illusion of Discrepancy between Self-Report and Official Measures.”American Sociological Review44:995–1014.
26.
HirschiTravis. 1969. Causes of Delinquency.Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
27.
HirschiTravis and GottfredsonMichael. 1983. “Age and the Explanation of Crime.”American Journal of Sociology89:552–84.
28.
HoganDennis P. and AstoneNan M.. 1986. “The Transition to Adulthood.”Annual Review of Sociology12:109–30.
29.
HollisterRobinson G.Jr., KemperPeter, and MaynardRebecca A.. 1984. The National Supported Work Demonstration.Madison, WI: University of Wisconsin Press.
30.
LalondeRobert. 1986. “Evaluating the Econometric Evaluations of Training Programs with Experimental Data.”American Economic Review76:604–20.
31.
LattimorePamela K., WitteAnn D., and BakerJoanna R.. 1990. “Experimental Assessment of the Effect of Vocational Training on Youthful Property Offenders.”Evaluation Review14: 115–33.
32.
LaubJohn H. and SampsonRobert J.. 1993. “Turning Points in the Life Course: Why Change Matters to the Study of Crime.”Criminology31:301–25.
33.
LenihanKenneth J.1977. Unlocking the Second Gate: The Role of Financial Assistance in Reducing Recidivism among Ex-Prisoners. U.S. Department of Labor. Washington, DC: Government Printing Office.
34.
MallarCharles D. and ThorntonCraig V. D.. 1978. “Transitional Aid for Released Prisoners: Evidence from the LIFE Experiment.”Journal of Human Resources13:208–36.
35.
MallarCharles, KerachskyStuart, ThorntonCraig, and LongDavid. 1982. Evaluation of the Economic Impact of the Job Corps Program: Third Follow-Up Report.Princeton, NJ: Mathematica Policy Research.
ManskiCharles F.1995. Anatomy of the Selection Problem.Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
38.
MartinsonRobert. 1974. “What Works?—Questions and Answers about Prison Reform.”The Public Interest35:22–54.
39.
MatsuedaRoss, GartnerRosemary, PiliavinIrving, and PolakowskiMichael. 1992. “The Prestige of Criminal and Conventional Occupations.”American Sociological Review57: 752–70.
40.
MatzaDavid. 1964. Delinquency and Drift.New York: Wiley.
41.
MertonRobert K.1938. “Social Structure and Anomie.”American Sociological Review3: 672–82.
42.
MihalicSharon Wofford and ElliottDelbert. 1997. “Short and Long-Term Consequences of Adolescent Work.”Youth and Society28:464–98.
43.
NamboodiriKrishnan and SuchindranC. M.. 1987. Life Table Techniques and Their Applications.New York: Academic.
44.
OrrLarry L., BloomHoward S., BellStephen H., DoolittleFred, LinWinston, and CaveGeorge. 1996. Does Training for the Disadvantaged Work? Evidence from the National JTPA Study.Washington, DC: Urban Institute Press.
45.
PezzinLiliana E.1995. “Earnings Prospects, Matching Effects, and the Decision to Terminate a Criminal Career.”Journal of Quantitative Criminology11:29–50.
46.
PiliavinIrving and GartnerRosemary. 1981. The Impact of Supported Work on Ex-Offenders.New York: Institute for Research on Poverty and Mathematica Policy Research.
47.
PiliavinIrving, GartnerRosemary, ThorntonCraig, and MatsuedaRoss. 1986. “Crime, Deterrence, and Rational Choice.”American Sociological Review51:101–19.
48.
PloegerMathew. 1997. “Youth Employment and Delinquency: Reconsidering a Problematic Relationship.”Criminology35:659–75.
49.
RubinDonald B.1974. “Estimating Causal Effects of Treatments in Randomized and Nonrandomized Studies.”Journal of Educational Psychology66:688–701.
50.
SampsonRobert J. and LaubJohn H.. 1990. “Crime and Deviance over the Life Course: The Salience of Adult Social Bonds.”American Sociological Review55:609–27.
51.
SampsonRobert J. and LaubJohn H.. 1993. Crime in the Making: Pathways and Turning Points through Life.Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
52.
SampsonRobert J. and LaubJohn H.. 1996. “Socioeconomic Achievement in the Life Course of Disadvantaged Men: Military Service as a Turning Point, Circa 1940–1965.”American Sociological Review61:347–67.
53.
SchmidtPeter and WitteAnn D.. 1988. Predicting Recidivism Using Survival Models.New York: Springer-Verlag.
54.
SchoreJennifer, MaynardRebecca, and PiliavinIrving. 1979. “The Accuracy of Self-Reported Arrest Data.”Princeton, NJ: Mathematica Policy Research.
55.
ShermanLawrence W., GottfredsonDenise C., MacKenzieDoris L., EckJohn, ReuterPeter, and BushwayShawn D.. 1998. Preventing Crime: What Works, What Doesn't, What's Promising, National Institute of Justice. Washington, DC: Government Printing Office.
56.
ShoverNeil. 1996. Great Pretenders: Pursuits and Careers of Persistent Thieves.Boulder, CO: Westview.
57.
SteffensmeierDarrell J., AllanEmilie Andersen, HarerMiles D., and StreifelCathy. 1989. “Age and the Distribution of Crime.”American Journal of Sociology94:803–31.
58.
SullivanMercer L.1989. Getting Paid—Youth Crime and Work in the Inner City.Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
59.
ThornberryTerence P. and ChristensonR. L.. 1984. “Unemployment and Criminal Involvement: An Investigation of Reciprocal Causal Structures.”American Sociological Review49:398–411.
60.
TittleCharles R. and GrasmickHarold G.. 1998. “Criminal Behavior and Age: A Test of Three Provocative Hypotheses.”Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology88:309–42.
61.
TumaNancy Brandon, HannanMichael T., and GroeneveldLyle P.. 1979. “Dynamic Analysis of Event Histories.”American Journal of Sociology84:820–54.
62.
UggenChristopher and PiliavinIrving. 1998. “Asymmetrical Causation and Criminal Desistance.”Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology88:1399–1422.
63.
U.S. Census Bureau.1998. Statistical Abstract of the United States.Washington, DC: Government Printing Office.
64.
U.S. Department of Justice.1993. Survey of State Prison Inmates, 1991.Washington, DC: Government Printing Office.
65.
U.S. Department of Justice.1999. Prisoners in 1998.Washington, DC: Government Printing Office.
66.
WarrMark. 1998. “Life-Course Transitions and Desistance from Crime.”Criminology36:183–216.
67.
WilsonJames Q.1975. Thinking about Crime.New York: Basic Books.
68.
WinshipChristopher and MareRobert D.. 1992. “Models for Sample Selection Bias.”Annual Review of Sociology18:327–50.
69.
WrightJohn P., CullenFrancis T., and WilliamsNicolas. 1997. “Working While in School and Delinquent Involvement: Implications for Social Policy.”Crime and Delinquency43: 203–21.
70.
WuLawrence L. and TumaNancy Brandon. 1991. “Assessing Bias and Fit of Global and Local Hazard Models.”Sociological Methods and Research19:354–87.
71.
ZeiselHans. 1982. “Disagreement over the Evaluation of a Controlled Experiment.”American Journal of Sociology88:378–38.
