The psychoanalytic reconstruction of specific influential past events has been a regular feature of psychoanalytic practice from its inception. More recently, as reconstructions of incestuous sexual abuse have become more frequent, the reconstructive process has attracted attention, and doubts have been expressed about the validity of the analytic evidence used to substantiate their inference. Over the years, psychoanalytic discourse about the adequacy of this evidence has moved from Freud's uneasy confidence to a rather sharply divided debate between advocates and skeptics. From beyond psychoanalysis, memory research raises questions about the validity of this evidence, and research on influence raises questions about the procedures by which it has been collected. A reexamination of several cases in which reconstructions emerged from unstable therapeutic circumstances leads to the conjecture that dynamics located in the analytic present may have been displaced to the historical past. Although logically “truth in the past” need not foreclose on “truth in the present,” in practice, once a reconstruction surfaces, the latter seems to disappear behind the former.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Alpert, J. (1994). Analytic reconstruction in the treatment of an incest survivor. Psychoanalytic Review81:217—235.
2.
Bernstein, A. (1990). The impact of incest trauma on ego development . In Adult Analysis and Childhood Sexual Abuse, ed. H. Levine.Hillsdale NJ: Analytic Press, pp. 65—91.
3.
Blum, H. (1983). The psychoanalytic process and analytic inference . International Journal of Psycho-Analysis64:17—33.
4.
——— (1994). Reconstructions in Psychoanalysis: Childhood Revisited and Recreated. Madison CT: International Universities Press.
5.
Bonaparte, M. (1945). Notes on the analytic discovery of a primal scene . Psychoanalytic Study of the Child1:119—125.
6.
Brenneis, B. (1994a). Belief and suggestion in the recovery of memories of childhood sexual abuse. Journal of the American Psychoanalytic Association42:1027—1053.
7.
——— (1994b). Can early trauma be reconstructed from dreams?: On the relationship of dreams to trauma. Psychoanalytic Psychology11:429—447.
8.
——— (1996). Memory systems and the psychoanalytic retrieval of memories of trauma. Journal of the American Psychoanalytic Association44:1159—1181.
9.
——— (1997). Recovered Memory of Trauma: Transferring the Present to the Past. Madison, CT: International Universities Press.
10.
Brenner, I. (1994). The dissociative character. Journal of the American Psychoanalytic Association42:819—846.
11.
——— (1996). On trauma, perversion, and “multiple personality .” Journal of the American Psychoanalytic Association44:785—814.
12.
Calogeras, R. (1982). Sleepwalking and the traumatic experience. International Journal of Psycho-Analysis63:483—489.
13.
Ceci, S., Huffman, M., & Smith, E. (1994). Repeatedly thinking about a non-event: Source misattribution among preschoolers. Consciousness and Cognition3:388—407.
14.
Davies, J. (1996). Dissociation, repression and reality testing in the counter-transference: The controversy over memory and false memory in the psychoanalytic treatment of adult survivors of childhood sexual abuse . Psychoanalytic Dialogues6:189—218.
15.
——— (1998). Multiple perspectives on multiplicity. Psychoanalytic Dialogues8:195—206.
16.
Droga, J. (1997). Realities lost and found: Trauma, dissociation, and somatic memories in a survivor of childhood sexual abuse. Psychoanalytic Inquiry17:173—191.
17.
Fonagy, P. (1997). Opening comment: Internet discussion of Brenneis (1994). March 1, 1997.
18.
Freud, S. (1896). The aetiology of hysteria. Standard Edition3:191—221. ———( 1918). From the history of an infantile neurosis. Standard Edition17:3—123.
19.
——— (1937). Constructions in analysis. Standard Edition23:257—269.
20.
Friedman, S. (1997). On the “true-false” memory syndrome: The problem of clinical evidence. American Journal of Psychotherapy51:102—122.
21.
Furman, E. (1956). An ego disturbance in a young child. Psychoanalytic Study of the Child11:312—335.
22.
Good, M. (1994). The reconstruction of early childhood trauma: Fantasy, reality, and verification. Journal of the American Psychoanalytic Association42:79—101.
23.
——— (1998). Screen reconstructions: Traumatic memory, conviction, and the problem of verification in psychoanalysis. Journal of the American Psychoanalytic Association46:149—183.
24.
Greenacre, P. (1953a). A contribution to the study of screen memories . In Trauma, Growth, and Personality. London : Hogarth Press, pp. 174—188.
25.
——— (1953b). The prepuberty trauma in girls. In Trauma, Growth, and Personality. London: Hogarth Press, pp. 189—207.
26.
Hyman, I., Husband, T., & Billings, F. (1995). False memories of childhood experiences. Applied Cognitive Psychology9:181—195.
27.
Hyman, I., & Pentland, J. (1996). The role of mental imagery in the creation of false childhood memories. Journal of Memory and Language35:101—117.
28.
Katan, A. (1973). Children who were raped. Psychoanalytic Study of the Child28:208—224.
29.
Kris, E. (1956). The recovery of childhood memories in psychoanalysis . Psychoanalytic Study of the Child11:54—91.
30.
Person, E., & Klar, H. (1994). Establishing trauma: The difficulty distinguishing between memories and fantasies. Journal of the American Psychoanalytic Association42:1055—1081.
31.
Richards, A. (1988). Self-mutilation and father-daughter incest: A psychoanalytic case report. In Fantasy, Myth, and Reality: Essays in Honor of Jacob A. Arlow, ed. H. Blum, Y. Kramer, A.K. Richards, & A.D. Richards.Madison, CT: International Universities Press, pp. 465—478.
32.
Rosen, V. (1955). The reconstruction of a traumatic childhood event in a case of derealization. Journal of the American Psychoanalytic Association3:211—221.
33.
Ross, M. (1989). Relation of implicit theories to the construction of personal histories. Psychological Review96:341—357.
34.
Sachs, O. (1967). Distinctions between fantasy and reality elements in memory and reconstructions. International Journal of Psycho-Analysis48:416—423.
35.
Schimek, J. (1987). Fact and fantasy in the seduction theory: A historical review. Journal of the American Psychoanalytic Association35:937—965.
36.
Simon, B. (1992). “Incest—see under oedipus complex”: The history of an error in psychoanalysis. Journal of the American Psychoanalytic Association40:955—988.
37.
Spence, D. (1982). Narrative Truth and Historical Truth. New York: Norton.
38.
——— (1994). Narrative truth and putative child abuse. International Journal of Clinical amd Experimental Hypnosis42:289—303.
39.
Stewart, W. (1969). Comments on the manifest content of certain types of unusual dreams. In The Mechanism of Denial and the Manifest Content of the Dream. Monograph 3, Kris Study Group, New York Psychoanalytic Institute. New York: International Universities Press, pp. 81—113.
40.
Szajnberg, N. (1993). Recovering a repressed memory, and representational shift in an adolescent. Journal of the American Psychoanalytic Association41:711—717.
41.
Viederman, M. (1995). The reconstruction of a repressed sexual molestation fifty years later. Journal of the American Psychoanalytic Association43:1169—1195.
42.
Williams, M. (1987). Reconstruction of early seduction and its aftereffects . Journal of the American Psychoanalytic Association35:145—163.
