The contrasting perspectives of historical (actual, material) truth as opposed to narrative (intrapsychic) truth in psychoanalytic reconstruction parallel the controversial shift in Freud's thinking from a traumatic theory of neurosogenesis to a greater emphasis on fantasy and psychic reality. Freud and analysts since have sought to tease apart psychic and material reality as they dovetail in the transference. However, published cases in which a patient's memory of a childhood trauma turned out to be a verifiable fantasy or false belief and not an actuality appear to be remarkably scarce. This paper describes a case in which the patient indicated that in early childhood she had been subjected to antimasturbatory measures and finally to clitoridectomy that had ongoing traumatic effects. The case strikingly illustrates how a false memory of shock trauma may represent effects of strain traumatization interacting with fantasy and the state of drives and ego development in early childhood. It also highlights issues in the areas of trauma and memory, historical and intrapsychic truth, and the theory and technique of psychoanalytic reconstruction. Although it may not always be possible in the psychoanalytic situation to differentiate actual and plausible past events, in some cases the distinction between these perspectives on truth has clinical relevance that is more than academic.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Barglow, P., Jaffe, C. M. & Vaughn, B. (1989). Psychoanalytic reconstructions and empirical data: reciprocal contributions. J. Amer. Psychoanal. Assn., 37:401–435.
2.
Blum, H. P. (1977). The prototype of preoedipal reconstruction. J. Amer. Psychoanal. Assn., 25:757–785.
3.
Blum, H. P. (1980). The value of reconstruction in adult psychoanalysis. Int. J. Psychoanal., 61:39–52.
4.
Blum, H. P. (1986). The concept of the reconstruction of trauma. In The Reconstruction of Trauma: Its Significance in Clinical Work, ed. A. Rothstein. Madison, CT: Int. Univ. Press, pp. 7–27.
5.
Bonaparte, M. (1945). Notes on the analytic discovery of a primal scene. Psychoanal. Study Child, 1:119–125.
6.
Bunker, H. A. (1934). The voice as (female) phallus. Psychoanal. Q., 3:391–429.
7.
Davidoff-Hirsch, H. (1985). Oedipal and preoedipal phenomena: some thoughts on their interrelation as manifest in adult analytic reconstructions. J. Amer. Psychoanal. Assn., 33:821–840.
8.
DeSaussure, J. (1982). Dreams and dreaming in relation to trauma in childhood. Int. J. Psychoanal., 63:167–175.
9.
Ekstein, R. & Rangell, L. (1961). Reconstruction and theory formation. J. Amer. Psychoanal. Assn., 9:684–697.
10.
Fine, B. D., Joseph, E. D. & Waldhorn, H. F. (1971). Recollection and Reconstruction; Reconstruction in Psychoanalysis. Kris Study Group of the New York Psychoanalytic Institute, Monogr. 4. New York: Int. Univ. Press.
11.
Flumerfelt, J. M. (1962). On reconstruction. Bull. Phila. Assn. Psychoanal., 12:53–68.
12.
Freud, S. (1908). Character and anal eroticism. S. E., 9.
13.
Freud, S. (1917). General theory of the neuroses. S. E., 16.
14.
Freud, S. (1933). New introductory lectures on psycho-analysis. S. E., 22.
15.
Freud, S. (1937). Constructions in analysis. S. E., 23.
16.
Glover, E. (1929). The ‘screening’ function of traumatic memories. Int. J. Psychoanal., 10:90–93.
17.
Good, M. I. (1992). Witnessing pornography and the reconstruction of suspected child sexual molestation (letter). J. Amer. Psychoanal. Assn., 40:630–633.
18.
Greenacre, P. (1967). The influence of infantile trauma on genetic patterns. In Psychic Trauma, ed. S. S. Furst. New York: Basic Books, 1967, pp. 108–153.
19.
Greenacre, P. (1975). On reconstruction. J. Amer. Psychoanal. Assn., 23:693–712.
20.
Harris, H. I. (1957). Telephone anxiety. J. Amer. Psychoanal. Assn., 5:342–346.
21.
Harrison, S. I. (1970). Psychoanalysis, our science?. J. Amer. Psychoanal. Assn., 18:125–149.
22.
Huschka, M. (1938). The incidence and character of masturbation threats in a group of problem children. Psychoanal. Q., 7:338–356.
23.
Jacobson, J. G. (1984). Review of Narrative Truth and Historical Truth: Meaning and Interpretation in Psychoanalysis, by D. P. Spence. Psychoanal. Q., 53:459–466.
24.
Khan, M. M. R. (1964). Ego distortion, cumulative trauma, and the role of reconstruction in the analytic situation. Int. J. Psychoanal., 45:272–279.
25.
Klumpner, G. H. & Frank, A. (1991). On methods of reporting clinical material. J. Amer. Psychoanal. Assn., 39:537–551.
26.
Kris, E. (1950). Notes on the development and on some current problems of psychoanalytic child psychology. Psychoanal. Study Child, 5:24–46.
27.
Kris, E. (1956). The recovery of childhood memories in psychoanalysis. Psychoanal. Study Child, 11:54–88.
28.
Levine, H. B. (1990). Clinical issues in the analysis of adults who were sexually abused as children. In Adult Analysis and Childhood Sexual Abuse, ed. H. B. Levine. Hillsdale, NJ: Analytic Press, pp. 197–218.
29.
Novey, S. (1964). The significance of the actual historical event in psychiatry and psychoanalysis. Brit. J. Medical Psychol., 37:279.
30.
Novey, S. (1966). Why some patients conduct actual investigations of their biographies. J. Amer. Psychoanal. Assn., 14:376–387.
31.
Panel (1988). The seduction hypothesis. A. E. Marans, reporter. J. Amer. Psychoanal. Assn., 36:759–771.
32.
Renik, O. (1992). A case of premenstrual distress: bisexual determinants of a woman's fantasy of damage to her genital. J. Amer. Psychoanal. Assn., 40:195–210.
33.
Ritvo, S. (1974). Current status of the concept of infantile neurosis: implications for diagnosis and technique. Psychoanal. Study Child, 29:159–181.
34.
Roiphe, H. & Galenson, E. (1973). Object loss and early sexual development. Psychoanal. Q, 42:73–90.
35.
Rosen, V. H. (1955). The reconstruction of a traumatic childhood event in a case of derealization. J. Amer. Psychoanal. Assn., 3:211–221.
36.
Sandler, J. (1967). Trauma, strain, and development. In Psychic Trauma, ed. S. S. Furst. New York: Basic Books, 1967, pp. 154–173.
37.
Schimek, J. G. (1987). Fact and fantasy in the seduction theory: a historical review. J. Amer. Psychoanal. Assn., 35:937–965.
38.
Schwaber, E. A. (1986). Reconstruction and perceptual experience: further thoughts on psychoanalytic listening. J. Amer. Psychoanal. Assn., 34:911–932.
39.
Serota, H. (1964). Movies of early childhood: correlative developmental data in the psychoanalysis of adults. Science, 143:1195.
40.
Shengold, L. (1982). The symbol of telephoning. J. Amer. Psychoanal. Assn., 30:461–170.
41.
Simon, B. (1992). “Incest—see under Oedipus complex”: the history of an error in psychoanalysis. J. Amer. Psychoanal. Assn., 40:955–988.
42.
Spitz, R. A. (1975). Authority and masturbation: some remarks on a bibliographical investigation. In Masturbation from Infancy to Senescence, ed. I. M. Marcus & J. J. Francis. New York: Int. Univ. Press, pp. 381–409.
43.
Suslick, A. (1963). The phallic representation of the voice. J. Amer. Psychoanal. Assn., 11:345–359.
44.
Wetzler, S. (1985). The historical truth of psychoanalytic reconstructions. Int. Rev. Psychoanal., 12:187–197.
45.
Wilkinson, S. M. (1991). Penis envy: libidinal metaphor and experiential metonym. Int. J. Psychoanal., 72:335–346.
