Adolf Grünbaum's (1984) The Foundations of Psychoanalysis has received extensive attention in psychoanalytic and philosophical circles. Aspects of Grünbaum's argument are reviewed and criticized. While his volume is an important contribution to the epistemological assessment of psychoanalysis, it reflects serious shortcomings in at least four areas: its treatment of the role of suggestion in the analytic enterprise, its scrutiny of the psychoanalytic genetic method, its appreciation of analytic methodology as actually practiced, and, above all, its predication on a unidimensional, positivistic vision of science. Alternative approaches to the philosophy of psychoanalysis are suggested.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
American Psychiatric Association (1980). Diagnostic and Statistical Manual-III. Washington, D.C.: Amer. Psychiat. Assn.
2.
Atwood, G. & Stolorow, R. (1984). Structures of Subjectivity: Explorations in Psychoanalytic Phenomenology. Hillsdale, N.J.: Analytic Press.
3.
Birtchnell, J. (1980). Women whose mothers died in childhood: an outcome studPsychol. Med., 10:699–713.
4.
Blanck, G. & Blanck, R. (1974). Ego Psychology: Theory and Practice, Vol. 1. New York: Columbia Univ. Press.
5.
Bonaparte, M. (1945). Notes on the analytical discovery of a primal scene. Psychoanal. Study Child, 1:119–125.
6.
Brown, G. (1979). The social etiology of depression—London studies. In The Psychobiology of the Depressive Disorders: Implications for the Effects of Stress, ed. R. DePue. New York: Academic Press, pp. 263–287.
7.
Brown, G.Harris, T. & Copeland, J. (1981). Depression and loss. Brit. J. Psychiat., 130:1–18.
8.
Dahl, H. (1972). A quantitative study of a psychoanalysis. Psychoanal. Contemp. Soc, 1:237–257.
9.
Dewald, P. (1972). The Psychoanalytic Process: A Case Illustration. New York: Basic Books.
10.
Edelson, M. (1984). Hypothesis and Evidence in Psychoanalysis. Chicago: Univ. Chicago Press.
11.
Edelson, M. (1986). The evidential value of the psychoanalyst's clinical data. Behav. Brain Sci., 9:232–234.
12.
Erdelyi, M. (1986). Psychoanalysis has a wider scope than the retrospective discovery of etiologies. Behav. Brain Sci, 9:234–235.
13.
Ezriel, H. (1956). Experimentation within the psychoanalytic session. In Psychoanalytic Clinical Interpretations, ed. L. Paul. New York: Free Press, 1963, pp. 112–142.
14.
Farrell, B. (1981). The Standing of Psycho-Analysis. New York: Oxford Univ. Press.
15.
Fine, D. & Forbes, M. (1986). Grünbaum on Freud: three grounds for dissent. Behav. Brain Sci., 9:287–288.
16.
Fisher, S. & Greenberg, R. (1977). The Scientific Credibility of Freud's Theory and Therapy. New York: Basic Books.
17.
Freud, S. (1896). The etiology of hysteria. S. E., 7.
18.
Freud, S. (1899). Screen memories. S. E., 3.
19.
Freud, S. (1900). The interpretation of dreams. S. E., 4 & 5.
20.
Freud, S. (1912). A note on the unconscious in psycho-analysis. S. E., 12.
21.
Freud, S. (1915–1917). Introductory lectures on psycho-analysis. S. E., 15 & 16.
22.
Freud, S. (1920). The psychogenesis of a case of homosexuality in a woman. S. E., 18.
23.
Freud, S. (1937). Analysis terminable and interminable. S. E., 23.
24.
Gardiner, A. (1961). Egypt of the Pharaohs. New York: Oxford Univ. Press.
25.
Gershoy, L. (1963). Relativism and some problems of the working historian. In Philosophy and History, ed. S. Hook. New York: Columbia Univ. Press, 1963, pp. 59–75.
26.
Gill, M. M. (1982). The Analysis of Transference, Vol. I. Psychol. Issues, Monogr. 53. New York: Int. Univ. Press.
27.
Gill, M. M. & Hoffman, I. (1983). The Analysis of Transference, Vol. 2. Psychol. Issues, Monogr. 54. New York: Int. Univ. Press.
28.
Glymour, C. (1982). Freud, Kepler, and the clinical evidence. In Philosophical Essays on Freud, ed. R. W. Wolheim & J. Hopkins. Cambridge, Eng.: Cambridge Univ. Press, pp. 12–31.
29.
Gould, S. J. (1982). The Panda's Thumb. New York: Norton.
30.
Grünbaum, A. (1984). The Foundations of Psychoanalysis: A Philosophical Critique. Berkeley: Univ. Calif. Press.
31.
Grünbaum, A. (1986a). Is Freud's theory well-founded?Behav. Brain Sci, 9:266–281.
32.
Grünbaum, A. (1986b). Precis of The Foundations of Psychoanalysis. Behav. Brain Sci., 9:212–228.
33.
Haviland, W. (1987). Cultural Anthropology. New York: Holt Rinehart & Winston.
34.
Holt, R. R. (1986). Some reflections on testing psychoanalytic hypotheses. Behav. Brain Sci., 9:242–244.
35.
Holzman, P. S. (1986). Psychoanalysis: is the therapy destroying the science?J. Amer. Psychoanal. Assn., 33:725–770.
36.
James, W. (1907). Pragmatism: A New Name for Some Old Ways of Thinking. London: Longmans, Green.
37.
Kline, P. (1981). Fact and Fantasy in Freudian Theory (2nd ed). London: Me-thuen.
38.
Laor, N. (1985). Psychoanalysis as science: The inductivist's resistance revisited. J. Amer. Psychoanal. Assn., 32: 149–166.
39.
Lichtenberg, J. (1983). Psychoanalysis and Infant Research. Hillsdale, N.J.: Analytic Press.
40.
Luborsky, L. (1984). Principles of Psychoanalytic Psychotherapy. New York: Basic Books.
41.
Luborsky, L.Mellon, J.; Van Ravenswany, P.; Childress, A.; Cohen, K.; Hole, A.; Ming, S.; Crits-Christoph, P.; Levine, F. & Alexander, K. (1985). A verification of Freud's grandest clinical hypothesis: the transference. Clin. Psychol. Rev., 5:231–246.
42.
Mandelbaum, M. (1977). The Anatomy of Historical Knowledge. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins Univ. Press.
43.
Marmor, J. (1970). Limitations of free association. In Psychiatry in Transition: Selected Papers of Judd Marmor.New York: Brunner/Mazel, 1974, pp. 265–275.
Nissim-Sabat, M. (1986). Psychoanalysis and Husserlian phenomenology: a new synthesis. Psychoanal. Rev., 73:273–299.
46.
Novey, S. (1968). The Second Look: The Reconstruction of Personal History in Psychiatry and Psychoanalysis. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins Univ. Press.
47.
Peterfreund, E. (1983). The Process of Psychoanalytic Therapy: Models and Strategies. Hillsdale, N.J.: Analytic Press.
48.
Pollock, G. H. (1986). Is there a “two-cultures” model for psychoanalysis?Behav. Brain Sci., 9:253–254.
49.
Reiser, M. F. (1986). Grünbaum's critique of clinical psychoanalytic evidence: a sheep in wolfs clothing?Behav. Brain Sci, 9:255–256.
50.
Roy, A. (1981). Vulnerability factors and depression in men. Brit. J. Psychiat., 138:75–77.
51.
Rubinstein, B. B. (1980). The problem of confirmation in clinical psycho-analysis. J. Amer. Psychoanal. Assn., 28:397–417.
52.
Russell, D. (1983). The incidence and prevalence of intrafamilial and extrafamilial sexual abuse of female children. Child Abuse & Neglect, 7:133–146.
53.
Sandler, J. & Rosenblatt, B. (1962). The concept of the representational world. Psychoanal. Study Child, 17:128–145.
54.
Saul, L. (1972). Psychodynamically Based Psychotherapy. New York: Science House.
55.
Searle, J. (1983). Intentionality: An Essay in the Philosophy of Mind. Cambridge, Eng.: Cambridge Univ. Press.
56.
Serota, H. (1964). Home movies of early childhood: correlative developmental data in the psychoanalysis of adults. Science, 143:1195.
57.
Shevrin, H. (1986). An argument for the evidential standing of psychoanalytic data. Behav. Brain Sci., 9:257–259.
58.
Spence, D. P. (1982). Narrative Truth and Historical Truth: Meaning and Interpretation in Psychoanalysis. New York: Norton.
59.
Stern, D. (1985). The Interpersonal World of the Infant. New York: Basic Books.
60.
Tennant, CBebbington, P. & Hurry, J. (1980). Parental death in childhood and risk of adult depressive disorders: a review. Psychol. Med., 10:289–299.
61.
Toulmin, S. (1976). Knowing and Acting: An Initiation to Philosophy. New York: Macmillan.
62.
Wallace, E. (1983). Freud and Anthropology: A History and Reappraisal. Psychol. Issues, Monogr. 55. New York: Int. Univ. Press.
63.
Wallace, E. (1985). Historiography and Causation in Psychoanalysis: An Essay on Psychoanalytic and Historical Epistemology. Hillsdale, N.J.: Analytic Press.
64.
Wallace, E. (1986a). The scientific status of psychoanalysis: editorial book review of Grünbaum'sThe Foundations of Psychoanalysis. J. Nerv. Ment. Dis., 174:379–386.
65.
Wallace, E. (1986b). Determinism, possibility, and ethics. J. Amer. Psychoanal. Assn., 34:933–974.
66.
Wallace, E. (1988a). Mind/body: monistic dual-aspect interactionism. J. Nerv. Ment. Dis., 176:4–22.
67.
Wallace, E. (1988b). What is truth?: some philosophical contributions to psychiatric issues. Amer. J. Psychial., 145:137–147.
68.
Wallace, E. (1989). Toward a phenomenological and minimally theoretical psychoanalysis. Annual Psychoanal., 17, in press.
69.
Wallerstein, R. (1986). Psychoanalysis as science. Psychoanal. Q., 55:414–451.
70.
Weiner, H. (1975). Psychobiology and Human Disease. N. Holland: Elsevier.
71.
Weiner, H. (1986). Die Geschichte der psychosomatische Medizin und das Korperseele Problem. Psychosomatik, 36:361–391.
72.
Weiss, J. & Sampson, H. (1986). The Psychoanalytic Process: Theory, Clinical Observation and Empirical Research. New York: Guilford Press.
73.
Wisdom, J. D. (1984). What is left of psychoanalytic theory?Int. Rev. Psychoanal., 11:313–325.
