This research offers an empirical investigation inspired by Butler's theory of melancholy gender (1995) and a revision of this theory (Jay 2007a). Psychoanalytic feminist theory is drawn on to suggest that melancholy and gender are more likely to be associated in female development than in male development, and Freud's theory of melancholy (1917) is taken to suggest that ambivalence predicts individual differences in melancholy gender among women. In a longitudinal study of women's adult development, an examination of femininity, depressive symptoms, and ambivalence in attachment was conducted in order to evaluate these claims. Findings show that depressive symptoms and femininity are significantly correlated within the sample, but that individual differences in melancholy gender exist. To understand these differences, an analysis was conducted to determine whether ambivalence in attachment accounts for the relation between depressive symptoms and femininity; complementary analyses examined whether low ambivalence in attachment attenuates, or lessens, the relation between femininity and depressive symptoms. Results from these analyses support the notion that it is not the loss and internalization of the same-sex object choice per se that results in melancholy gender in women, as Butler argues; rather, it is the internalization of a lost, ambivalent same-sex attachment that forges the link between melancholy and gender. Narrative material is presented to personify melancholy and unmelancholy gender.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Aiken, L.S., & West, S.G. (1991). Multiple Regression: Testing and Interpreting Interactions. Newbury Park, CA: Sage.
2.
Ainsworth, M.D.S., Blehar, M.C., Waters, E., & Wall, S. (1978). Patterns of Attachment: A Psychological Study of the Strange Situation. Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum.
3.
Baron, R.M., & Kenny, D.A. (1986). The mediator-moderator variable distinction in social psychological research: Conceptual, strategic, and statistical considerations . Journal of Personality & Social Psychology51:1173-1182.
4.
Barrett, A.E., & White, H.R. (2002). Trajectories of gender role orientations in adolescence and early adulthood: A prospective study of the mental health effects of masculinity and femininity. Journal of Health & Social Behavior43:451-468.
5.
Bartholomew, K., & Horowitz, L.M. (1991). Attachment styles among young adults: A test of a four-category model. Journal of Personality & Social Psychology61:226-244.
6.
Beck, A.T. (1978). Beck Depression Inventory. Unpublished manuscript (available from Center for Cognitive Therapy, Room 602, 133 South 36th Street, Philadelphia, PA 19104).
7.
Beirut, L., Heath, A., Bucholz, K., Dinwiddie, S., Madden, P., Statham, D., Dunne, M., & Martin, N. (1999). Major depressive disorder in a community-based twin sample: Are there different genetic and environmental contributions for men and women? Archives ofGeneral Psychiatry56:557-563.
8.
Benjamin, J. (1988). The Bonds of Love. New York : Pantheon.
9.
— (1995). Like Subjects, Love Objects. New Haven: Yale University Press.
10.
Betz, N.E., & Bender, R.S. (1980). Relationships of MMPI Mf and CPI Fe scales to fourfold sex role classifications. Journal of Personality & Social Psychology39:1245-1248.
11.
Bowlby, J. (1969). Attachment and Loss: Vol. 1. Attachment. New York: Basic Books.
12.
— (1973). Attachment and Loss: Vol. 2. Separation: Anxiety and AngerNew York: Basic Books .
13.
— ( 1980). Attachment and Loss: Vol. 3. Loss: Sadness and Depression . New York: Basic Books.
14.
Brazelton, E.W., Greene, K.S., & Gynther, M. (1996). Femininity, depression, and stress in college women. Social Behavior & Personality24:329-334.
15.
Brennan, K.A., Clark, C.L., & Shaver, P.R. (1998). Self-report Measures of adult attachment: An integrative overview. In Attachment Theory and Close Relationships, ed. J.A. Simpson & W.S. Rholes. New York: Guilford Press, pp.46-76.
16.
— & Morris, K.A. (1997). Attachment styles, self-esteem, and patterns of seeking feedback from romantic partners. Journal of Personality & Social Psychology23:23-31.
17.
Butler, J. (1995). Melancholy gender. Psychoanalytic Dialogues5:165-180.
18.
— (1998). Analysis to the core: Commentary on papers by James H. Hansell and Dianne Elise. Psychoanalytic Dialogues8:373-377.
19.
Carnelley, K.B., Pietromonaco, PR, & Jaffe, K. (1994). Depression, working models of others, and relationship functioning. Journal of Personality & Social Psychology66:127-140.
20.
Chodorow, N.J. (1978). The Reproduction of Mothering. Berkeley: University of California Press.
21.
— (1979). Gender, relation, and difference in psychoanalytic perspective. In Essential Papers on the Psychology of Women , ed. C. Zanardi.New York: NYU Press, pp. 420-436.
22.
— (1994). Femininities, Masculinities, and Sexualities: Freud and Beyond. Lexington: University of Kentucky Press.
Colin, VL (1996). Human Attachment. New York : McGraw-Hill.
25.
Consulting Psychologists Press (2003). Comprehensive Bibliography of the CPI Assessment: 1948-2002. Palo Alto, CA: Consulting Psychologists Press.
26.
Coyne, J.C. (1994). Self-reported distress: Analog or ersatz depression?Psychological Bulletin116:29-45.
27.
Crowell, J.A., Fraley, R.C., & Shaver, PR (1999). Measurement of individual differences in adolescent and adult attachment. In Handbook of Attachment, ed. J. Cassidy & P.R. Shaver.New York: Guilford Press , pp. 434-468.
28.
Culbertson, FM (1997). Depression and gender. American Psychologist52:25-31.
29.
Dimen, M., & Goldner, V. (2002). Gender in Psychoanalytic Space. New York: NYU Press.
30.
Doane, J., & Hodges, D. (1992). From Klein to Kristeva: Psychoanalytic Feminism and the Search for the "Good Enough " Mother. Ann Arbor : University of Michigan Press.
31.
Dozier, M., Stovall, K.C., & Albus, K.E. (1999). Attachment and psychopathology in adulthood. In Handbook of Attachment, ed. J. Cassidy & P.R. Shaver.New York: Guilford Press, pp. 497-519.
32.
Dunn, E.F., & Steiner, M. (2000). The functional neurochemistry of mood disorders in women. In Mood Disorders in Women, ed. M. Steiner, K.A. Yonkers , & E. Eriksson, London: Martin Dunitz, pp. 71-82.
33.
Elise, D. (2000). Woman and desire: Why women may not want to want . Studies in Gender & Sexuality1:125-145.
34.
Fast, I. (1978). Developments in gender identity: The original matrix. International Journal of Psychoanalysis5:265-273.
35.
— (1979). Developments in gender identity: Gender differentiation in girls. International Journal of Psychoanalysis60:443-453.
36.
Fonagy, P. (1999). Psychoanalytic theory from the viewpoint of attachment theory and research. In Handbook of Attachment, ed. J. Cassidy & P.R. Shaver.New York: Guilford Press , pp. 595-624.
37.
Foucault, M. (1972). Madness and Civilization: A History of Insanity in the Age of Reason. New York: Vintage Books.
38.
— (1981). The History of Sexuality: Vol. 1. An Introduction . Harmondsworth, UK: Pelican.
39.
Frazier, PA, Tix, A.P., & Barron, K.E. (2004). Testing moderator and mediator effects in counseling psychology research. Journal of Counseling Psychology51:115-134.
40.
Freud, S. (1905). Three essays on the theory of sexuality. Standard Edition7:125-243.
41.
— (1917). Mourning and melancholia. Standard Edition14:243-258.
42.
— (1923). The ego and the id. Standard Edition19:12-59.
43.
— (1931). On female sexuality. Standard Edition21.223-246.
44.
— (1933). Femininity. Standard Edition22:112-135.
45.
Goldner, V. (1991). Toward a critical relational theory of gender . Psychoanalytic Dialogues1:249-272.
46.
Gough, H.G. (1957). Manual for the California Psychological Inventory . Palo Alto, CA: Consulting Psychologists Press.
47.
— (1960). The Adjective Checklist as a personality assessment research technique. Psychological Reports6:107-122.
48.
— & Bradley, P. (1996). Manual for the California Psychological Inventory . Palo Alto, CA: Consulting Psychologists Press.
Hammen, C. (1999). The emergence of an interpersonal approach to depression. In The Interactional Nature of Depression, ed. T. Joiner & J.C. Coyne.Washington, DC: American Psychological Association, pp. 21-36.
51.
— ( 2000). Interpersonal factors in an emerging model of depression . In Stress, Coping, and Depression, ed. S.L. Johnson, A.M. Hayes , T.M. Field, N. Schneiderman, & P.M. McCabe.Mahwah, NJ: Erlbaum, pp. 71-88.
52.
— (2003). Interpersonal stress and depression in women. Journal of Affective Disorders74:49-57.
Harris, A. (1991). Gender as contradiction. Psychoanalytic Dialogues1:197-224.
55.
Hauser, S.T. (2004). Creative alliances: Enhancing interfaces between psychoanalysis and research. Journal of the American Psychoanalytic Association52:385-391.
56.
Hegelson, VS, & Fritz, H.L. (2000). The implications of unmitigated agency and unmitigated communion for domains of problem behavior. Journal of Personality68:1032-1057.
57.
Helson, R., Jones, C., & Kwan, V.S.Y. (2002). Personality change over 40 years of adulthood: Hierarchical linear modeling analyses of two longitudinal samples. Journal of Personality & Social Psychology83:752-766.
58.
& Kwan, V.S.Y. (2000). Personality development in adulthood: The broad picture and processes in one longitudinal sample. In Advances in Personality Psychology, ed. S.E. Hampson. Vol. 1. Philadelphia: Psychologists Press, pp. 77-106.
59.
—— John, O.P., & Jones, C. (2002). The growing evidence for personality change in adulthood: Findings from research with personality inventories. Journal of Research in Personality36:287-306.
60.
— & Soto, C.J. (2005). Up and down in middle age: Monotonic and non-monotonic changes in roles, status, and personality. Journal of Personality & Social Psychology89:194-204.
61.
Horney, K. (1926). The flight from womanhood. International Journal of Psychoanalysis7:324-339.
62.
Jay, M. ( 2007a). Melancholy femininity and obsessive-compulsive masculinity: Sex differences in melancholy gender. Studies in Gender & Sexuality8:115-136.
63.
— (2007b). Straw men, straight women, and the role of ambivalence in melancholy gender: Reply to Balsam and Salamon. Studies in Gender & Sexuality8:165-175.
64.
— & John, O.P. (2004). A depressive symptom scale for the California Psychological Inventory: Construct validation of the CPI-D. Psychological Assessment16:299-309.
65.
Klohnen, E.C., & John, O.P. (1998). Working models of attachment: A theory-based prototype approach. In Attachment Theory and Close Relationships, ed. J. Simpson & S. Rholes. New York: Guilford Press, pp. 115-140.
66.
Krames, L., England, R., & Flett, G.L. (1988). The role of masculinity and femininity in depression and social satisfaction in elderly females. Sex Roles19:713-721.
67.
Kristeva, J. (1989). Black Sun: Depression and Melancholia. New York: Columbia University Press.
68.
Lampl-De Groot, J. (1928). The evolution of the Oedipus complex in women . International Journal of Psychoanalysis9:332-345.
69.
Laplanche, J., & Pontalis, J.-B. (1967). The Language of Psycho-Analysis, transl. D. Nicholson-Smith. New York: Norton, 1973.
70.
Lengua, L.J., & Stormshak, E.A. (2000). Gender, gender roles, and personality: Gender differences in the prediction of coping and psychological symptoms. Sex Roles43:787-820.
71.
Lippa, R. (2001). On deconstructing and reconstructing masculinity-femininity . Journal of Research in Personality35:168-207.
72.
Lyons-Ruth, K. (1995). Broadening our conceptual frameworks: Can we re-introduce relational strategies and implicit representational systems to the study of psychopathology?Developmental Psychology3:432-436.
73.
Maciejewski, P.K., Prigerson, H.G., & Mazure, C.M. (2001). Sex differences in event-related risk for major depression. Psychological Medicine31:593-604.
74.
Main, M. (1999). Attachment theory: Eighteen points with suggestions for future studies. In Handbook of Attachment, ed. J. Cassidy & P.R. Shaver.New York: Guilford Press , pp. 845-886.
75.
Mazure, C.M., Keita, G.P., & Blehar, M.C. (2002). Summit on Women and Depression: Proceedings and Recommendations. Washington, DC: American Psychological Association.
76.
Ncgrath, E., Keita, G.P , Strickland, B.R., Russo, N.F, EDS. (1990). Women and Depression: Risk Factors and Treatment Issues: Final Report of the American Psychological Association's National Task Force on Women and Depression . Washington, DC: American Psychological Association.
77.
Moi, T. ( 1999). What Is a Woman?Oxford: Oxford University Press.
78.
Nezu, A.M., & Nezu, C.M. (1987). Psychological distress, problem solving, and coping reactions: Sex role differences. Sex Roles16:205-214.
79.
Nolen-Hoeksema, S. (2000). The role of rumination in depressive disorders and mixed anxiety/depressive symptoms. Journal of Abnormal Psychology109:504-511.
80.
Phillips, A. (1995). Keeping it moving: Commentary on Judith Butler's "Melancholy Gender—Refused Identification." Psychoanalytic Dialogues5:181-188.
81.
Radloff, L.S. (1977). The CES-D Scale: A self-report depression scale for research in the general population. Applied Psychological Measurement1:385-401.
82.
Riviere, J. (1929). Womanliness as a masquerade. In The Inner World and Joan Riviere: Collected Papers, ed. A. Hughes.London: Karnac Books, 1991, pp. 90-102.
83.
Rubin, G. (1975). The traffic in women: Notes on the political economy of sex. In Toward an Anthropology of Women, ed. R. Reiter.New York: Monthly Review Press, pp. 157-210.
84.
Sayers, S.L., Baucom, D.H., & Tierney, A.M. (1993). Sex roles, interpersonal control, and depression: Who can get their way?Journal of Research in Personality27:377-395.
85.
Shaver, PR, & Clark, C.L. (1994). The psychodynamics of adult romantic attachment . In Empirical Perspectives on Object Relations Theory, ed. J.M. Masling & R.F. Bornstein.Washington, DC: American Psychological Association, pp. 105-156.
86.
Shors, T., Pickett, J., Wood, G.E., & Paczynski, M. (1990). Acute stress enhances estrogen levels in the female rat. Stress3:163-171.
87.
Solomon, J., & George, C. (1999). The measurement of attachment security in infancy and childhood. In Handbook of Attachment, ed. J. Cassidy & P.R. Shaver.New York: Guilford Press , pp. 287-318.
88.
Stewart, A.J., Ostrove, J., & Helson, R. (200 1). Middle aging in adult women: Patterns of personality change from the 30s to the 50s. Journal of Adult Development8:23-37.
89.
Stoller, R.J. (1968). The sense of femaleness. Psychoanalytic Quarterly37:42-55.
90.
Tinsley, E.G., Sullivan-Guest, S., & Mcguire, J. (1984). Feminine sex role and depression in middle-aged women. Sex Roles11:25-32.
91.
Tyson, P. (1982). A developmental line of gender identity, gender role, and choice of love object. Journal of the American Psychoanalytic Association30:61-86.
92.
Weissman, M.M., & Klerman, G.L. (1977). Sex differences and the epidemiology of depression . Journal of Health & Social Behavior26:156-182.
93.
—— (1992). Depression: Current understanding and changing trends. Annual Review ofPublic Health13:319-339.
94.
Whitley, B.E. (1984). Sex role orientation and psychological well-being: Two meta-analyses. Sex Roles12:207-225.
95.
Wood, G.E., & Shors, T.J. (1998). Stress facilitates classical conditioning in males but impairs conditioning in females through activational influences of ovarian hormones. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences95:4066-4071.
