In this article, we claim that animal ethics and environmental ethics are incompatible ethical positions. This is because they have incompatible criteria of moral considerability and they have, at least in some cases, incompatible normative implications regarding the interests of sentient individuals. Moreover, we claim that environmentalist views lead to an insurmountable dilemma between inconsistency and implausibility and fail to properly account for the importance of wild animal suffering. From this it follows not only that (a) we can endorse one of the two views but not both at the same time but also that (b) we have overriding reasons to reject environmentalism and endorse some animal ethics view.
CallicottJ. B. (1980). Animal Liberation: a triangular affair, Environmental Ethics, 2, 311-338.
7.
CallicottJ. B. (1989). In defense of the land ethic: Essays in environmental philosophy. Albany: State University of New York Press.
8.
CallicottJ. B. (1998). Back together again’ again. Environmental Values, 7, 461-475.
9.
DombrowskiD. A. (1997). Babies and beasts: The argument from marginal cases. Chicago: University of Illinois Press.
10.
DunayerJ. (2004). Speciesism. Derwood, MD: Ryce.
11.
FariaC. (2016). Animal ethics goes wild: The problem of wild animal suffering and intervention in nature (Unpublished octoral dissertation), Universitat Pompeu Fabra, Barcelona, Spain.
12.
FariaC.PaezE. (2014). Anthropocentrism and speciesism: Conceptual and normative issues. Revista de Bioética y Derecho, 32, 82-90.
13.
FariaC.PaezE. (2015). Animals in need. Relations: Beyond Anthropocentrism, 3(1), 7-13.
14.
GoodpasterK. E. (1978). On being morally considerable. Journal of Philosophy, 75, 308-325.
15.
HortaO. (2010a). What is speciesism?Journal of Agricultural & Environmental Ethics, 23, 243-266.
16.
HortaO. (2010b). The ethics of the ecology of fear against the nonspeciesist paradigm: A shift in the aims of intervention in nature. Between the Species, 13(10), 163-187.
17.
HortaO. (2010c). Debunking the idyllic view of natural processes: Population dynamics and suffering in the wild. Télos, 17, 73-88.
18.
HortaO. (2014). The Scope of the Argument from Species Overlap. Journal of Applied Philosophy, 31, 142-154.
19.
HortaO. (2017). Animal suffering in nature: The case for intervention. Environmental Ethics, 39, 261-279.
20.
JamiesonD. (1998). Animal liberation is an environmental ethic. Environmental Values, 7, 41-57.
21.
JohnsonL. E. (1993). A morally deep world: An essay on moral significance and environmental ethics. Cambridge, England: Cambridge University Press.
22.
LackD. (1954). The natural regulation of animal numbers. Oxford, England: Clarendon.
23.
LeopoldA. (1949). A Sand County almanac, and sketches here and there. New York, NY: Oxford University Press.
MacArthurR. H.WilsonE. O. (1967). The theory of island biogeography. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
26.
NgY.-K. (1995). Towards welfare biology: Evolutionary economics of animal consciousness and suffering. Biology & Philosophy, 10, 255-285.
27.
O’SullivanS. (2011). Animals, equality and democracy. Basingstoke, England: Palgrave Macmillan.
28.
PluharE. (1987). The personhood view and the argument from marginal cases. Philosophica, 39, 23-38.
29.
ReznickD.BryantM. J.BasheyF. (2002). r-and K-selection revisited: The role of population regulation in life-history evolution. Ecology, 83, 1509-1520.
30.
RyderR. D. (2010). Speciesism again: The original leaflet. Critical Society, 2(Spring), 1-2. (Original work published 1970)
31.
SagoffM. (1984). Animal liberation and environmental ethics: Bad marriage, quick divorce. Osgoode Hall Law Journal, 22, 297-307.
32.
SapontzisS. F. (1987). Morals, reason, and animals. Philadelphia, PA: Temple University Press.
33.
SchweitzerA. (1923). The philosophy of civilization. Civilization and ethics. London, England: A. & C. Black.
34.
SheltonJ.A. (2004). Killing Animals That Don’t Fit In: Moral Dimensions of Habitat Restoration. Between the Species, 4, 1-21.
35.
SingerP. (1990). Animal liberation. New York: New York Review of Books.
36.
StearnsS. C. (1992). The evolution of life histories. Oxford, England: Oxford University Press.
37.
SteinerG. (2005). Anthropocentrism and its discontents: The moral status of animals in the history of Western philosophy. Pittsburgh, PA: University of Pittsburgh Press.
38.
TaylorP. (1986). Respect for nature. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
39.
TomasikB. (2015). The importance of wild-animal suffering. Relations: Beyond Anthropocentrism, 3, 133-152. (Original work published 2009)
