Channeling theory posits that external funding for social movements, rather than coopting activism, channels activism into more structured and less militants forms. Studies on channeling, however, focus on private funding. The following article examines whether public funding has a comparable effect on social movements. Using the human rights movement in Canada as a case study, it examines several issues relating to channeling: why funders support activism; funding as social control or altruism; how funding is related to consolidating movement gains; and the impact of funding on mobilization, activism, and internal movement dynamics. To address these questions, this article draws on an innovative new data set that includes lists of grants extracted from more than 30 years of government budgets in Canada. It also draws on several years of archival research on a network of 19 organizations in every region of Canada, as well as interviews with former members of these organizations. In addition to demonstrating that public funding has a comparable channeling effect as private funding, this article provides the first comprehensive survey of the extent of state funding for the human rights movement in Canada.
Attorney General of British Columbia, Human Rights Branch archives. (n.d.) Acc.1989-699-27 and Acc.1989-699-6. Lists of grants provided by the Human Rights Commission.
2.
Attorney General of British Columbia, Human Rights Branch archives. (1981). Public accounts 1989-700-14. Memorandum on Community Organizations.
British Columbia Civil Liberties Association. (1963-1990). Law Society of British Columbia Archives (LSBCA), Vol. 4, f. 1-21, Financial committee reports and statements.
5.
British Columbia Civil Liberties Association. (1963-1995). LSBCA, Vols. 1 to 3. Minutes of the Board of Directors and annual general meetings.
6.
British Columbia Civil Liberties Association. (1978, September11). LSBCA, Vol.1, f. 4. Minutes of the Board of Directors.
7.
British Columbia. (1960-1995). Public accounts. Victoria, British Columbia, Canada: Queen’s Printer.
8.
Canada. (1960-1995). Public accounts of Canada. Ottawa, Ontario, Canada: Department of Finance.
9.
Canadian Civil Liberties Association. (1965-1990). Library and archives Canada (LAC). R9833, Vols. 1 to 4. Minutes of the Board of Directors and the steering committee.
10.
Canadian Civil Liberties Association. (1967-1990). LAC R9833, Vol. 1, f. 1 to 42. Financial Statements.
11.
Canadian Civil Liberties Association. (1968). LAC, June Callwood, MG31, K24, Vol. 18, f. 16. Joint Submission of the Canadian Civil Liberties Association and the Canadian Civil Liberties Education Trust to the Ford Foundation.
12.
Canadian Civil Liberties Association. (1970, July3). LAC R9833, Vol. 4, f. 2. Reg Robson to Alan Borovoy.
13.
Champagne. (1975). LAC, Frank R Scott, MG30 D211, v.47, bilan de Maurice Champagne, sur ses trois années à la Ligue des Droits à titre de directeur général, présenté à l’occasion de l’assemblée général annuelle des membres du 28 mai.
14.
Department of Justice. (1971, December3). Provincial archives of Newfoundland, PRC#23, f. 7-4-7-2, Fred Coates to Cyril Banikhin.
15.
Ligue des droits et libertés. (n.d.). Université du Québec à Montréal [UQAM], Service des archives et de gestion des documents [SAGD]. f. 24P2/b9. Don Whiteside to Eamon Park.
16.
Ligue des droits et libertés. (1963-1995). UQAM, SAGD, f. 24P1/5 to /16. Minutes of the Administrative Council.
17.
Ligue des droits et libertés. (1964-1990). UQAM, SAGD, f. 24P5/12. Financial statements.
18.
Ligue des droits et libertés. (1970a, November18). UQAM, SAGD, f. 24P2/b9. Eamon Park to Don Whiteside.
19.
Ligue des droits et libertés. (1970b, November30). UQAM, SAGD, f. 24P2/b9. Eamon Park to Don Whiteside.
20.
Ligue des droits et libertés. (1971a, June3). UQAM, SAGD, 24P2b/10 Minutes of a meeting of Ontario civil liberties groups in Toronto.
21.
Ligue des droits et libertés. (1971b). UQAM, SAGD, f. 24P5/12. Budget.
22.
Ligue des droits et libertés. (1974, May26). UQAM, SAGD, f. 24P6g/1. Les québécois ont le droit de survivre.
23.
Ligue des droits et libertés. (1976, October13; 1984, May10). UQAM, SAGD, f. 24P1/9, f.24P9f/4. Press releases.
24.
Ligue des droits et libertés. (1977). UQAM, SAGD, f. 24P5/12. History of organizational finances.
25.
Newfoundland–Labrador Human Rights Association. (1968, February-December). Centre for Newfoundland Studies, coll. 111, f. 3.29.101 (human rights), correspondence between human rights committee to Premier Joseph Smallwood.
26.
Newfoundland–Labrador Human Rights Association. (1972-1990a). CNS, coll. 111, f. 1.03.001. Budgets and financial statements.
27.
Newfoundland–Labrador Human Rights Association. (1972-1990b). CNS, coll. 111, f. 2.08. Minutes of the Executive Council.
28.
Nova Scotia. (1960-1995). Public accounts. Halifax, Nova Scotia, Canada: Queen’s Printer.
29.
Nova Scotia Civil Liberties Association. (1971-1974). Public archives of Nova Scotia, MG20 Vol. 625, No. 1-14. Minutes of the Board of Directors.
30.
Renate Shearer. (1979-1982). Lists of grants provided by the Human Rights Commission. Renate Vol.1, file 15. Shearer collection. UBC RBSC.
31.
Rights and Freedoms. (1972-1992). Newsletter of the Canadian Rights and Liberties Federation/Canadian Rights and Liberties Federation.
32.
Secretary of State of Canada. (1960-1990), Annual reports of the Department of the Secretary of State of Canada.
33.
Secretary of State of Canada. (1968, February). LAC, RG6, Vol. 661, f. 2-2-4. Memorandum to Cabinet-Confirmation of Citizenship Branch Role.
34.
Secretary of State of Canada. (1992). Client funding histories. Ottawa, Ontario, Canada: Secretary of State of Canada.
35.
Status of Women Action Group. (1988, February17). Claudette Deshaies to Status of Women Action Group, University of Victoria Archives, Acc.2004-005.
36.
Alberta Law Foundation. (1972-2014). Annual report. Calgary, Alberta, Canada: Author.
37.
ArmalineW. T.GlasbergD. S.PyrkayasthaB. (2015). The human rights enterprise. Cambridge, England: Polity Press.
38.
ArthursH. (2004, March13). Interview by author.
39.
Association of Universities and Colleges of Canada. (1978). A Canadian directory to foundations and other granting agencies (Vol. 4). Ottawa, Ontario, Canada: Author.
40.
BasokT.IlcanS. (2003). The voluntary sector and the depoliticization of civil society: Implications for social justice. International Journal of Canadian Studies, 28(1), 113-132.
41.
BeerS.TremblayF. (2014). Sex workers’ rights organizations and government funding in Canada. In MajicS.ShowdenC. R. (Eds.), Negotiating sex work: Unintended consequences of policy and activism (pp. 287-309). Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.
42.
BeresM. A.CrowB.GotellL. (2009). The perils of institutionalization in Neoliberal times: Results of a National Survey of Canadian Sexual Assault and Rape Crisis Centres. Canadian Journal of Sociology, 34, 135-165.
43.
BernheimJ.-C. (2005, June26). Interview by author.
44.
BorovoyA. (1991). Uncivil obedience: The tactics and tales of a democratic agitator. Toronto, Ontario, Canada: Lester.
45.
BorovoyA. (2004, March12). Interview by author.
46.
BorovoyA. (2013). At the barricades: A memoir. Toronto, Ontario, Canada: Irwin Law.
47.
BouzaneL. (2002, March13). Interview by author.
48.
British Columbia. (1960-2014). Public accounts. Victoria, British Columbia, Canada: Queen’s Printer.
49.
BruelleR. J.JenkinsJ. C. (2005). Foundations and the environmental movement: Priorities, strategies and impact. In FaberD.McCarthyD. (Eds.), Foundations for social change: Critical perspectives on philanthropy and popular movements (pp. 151-174). Lanham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield.
50.
BrushettK. (2013). “Federally financed felquistes”: The company of young Canadians and the prelude to theOctobercrisis. Quebec Studies, 55, 77-99.
51.
BurtS. (1990). Canadian women’s groups in the 1980s: Organizational development and policy influence. Canadian Public Policy, 16, 17-28.
52.
BurtS. (1993). The changing patterns of public policy. In BurtS.CodeL.DorneyL. (Eds.), Changing patterns: Women in Canada (pp. 212-241). Toronto, Ontario, Canada: McClelland & Stewart.
53.
CampbellR.BakerC. K.MazurekT. L. (1998). Remaining radical? Organizational predictors of rape crisis centers’ social change initiatives. American Journal of Community Psychology, 26, 457-483.
54.
ChavesM.StephensL.GalaskiewiczJ. (2004). Does government funding suppress nonprofits’ political activity?American Sociological Review, 69, 292-316.
55.
ChildC. D.GronbjergK. A. (2007). Nonprofit advocacy organizations: Their characteristics and activities. Social Science Quarterly, 88, 259-281. doi:10.1111/j.1540-6237.2007.00457.x
56.
ClémentD. (2008). The October crisis of 1970: Human rights abuses under the War Measures Act. Journal of Canadian Studies, 42, 160-186.
57.
ClémentD. (2012). Human rights in Canadian domestic and foreign politics: From “nigardly acceptance” to enthusiastic embrace. Human Rights Quarterly, 34, 751-778.
58.
ClémentD. (2014). Equality deferred: Sex discrimination and British Columbia’s human rights state, 1953-1984. Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada: UBC Press.
59.
ClémentD. (2015). The social movement society and the human rights state. In RamosH.RodgersK. (Eds.), Protest and politics: The promise of social movement societies (pp. 61-78). Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada: UBC Press.
60.
ClowardR. A.PivenF. F. (1977). Poor people’s movements: How they succeed, why they fail. New York, NY: Pantheon.
61.
Corrigall-BrownC. (2016). Funding for social movements. Sociology Compass, 10, 330-339.
62.
Corrigall-BrownC.HoM. (2015). How the state shapes social movements: An examination of the environmental movement in Canada. In RamosH.RodgersK. (Eds.), Protest and politics: The promise of the social movement society (pp. 101-117). Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada: UBC Press.
63.
DayS. (2014). Reflections on government hostility, systemic discrimination, and human rights institutions. In DayS.LamarcheL.NormanK. (Eds.), 14 Arguments in favour of human rights institutions (pp. 19-54). Toronto, Ontario, Canada: Irwin Law.
64.
DobrowolskyA. (2004). The Chrétien legacy and women: Changing policy priorities with little cause for celebration. Review of Constitutional Studies, 9(1), 171-198.
65.
DybikowskiJ. (2004, December1). Interview by author.
66.
FindlayS. (1988). Feminist struggles with the Canadian state: 1966-1988. Resources for Feminist Research, 17(3), 5-9.
67.
FragerR.PatriasC. (2001). “This is our country, these are our rights”: Minorities and the origins of Ontario’s human rights campaigns. Canadian Historical Review, 82, 1-35.
68.
GagnonT. (2004, June20). Interview by author.
69.
GettyN. (2003, October14). Interview by author.
70.
Government of Canada. (1960-2014). Public accounts of Canada. Ottawa, Ontario, Canada: Department of Finance.
71.
HainesH. H. (1984). Black radicalization and the funding of civil rights. Social Problems, 32, 31-43.
72.
HarderL. (2003). State of struggle: Feminism and politics in Alberta. Edmonton, Alberta, Canada: University of Alberta Press.
73.
HaydayM. (2005). Bilingual today, united tomorrow: Official languages in education and Canadian federalism. Kingston, Ontario, Canada: McGill-Queen’s University Press.
74.
HoweR. B.AndradeM. J. (1994). The reputations of human rights commissions in Canada. Canadian Journal of Law and Society, 9(2), 1-20.
75.
HoweR. B.JohnsonD. (2000). Restraining equality: Human rights commissions in Canada. Toronto, Ontario, Canada: University of Toronto Press.
76.
International Year for Human Rights Canadian Commission. (1969). Report of the proceedings, National Conference on Human Rights and Activities of the Canadian Commission. Ottawa, Ontario, Canada: Author.
77.
JenkinsJ. C. (1998). Channeling social protest: Foundation patronage of contemporary social movements. In PowellW. W.ClemensE. S. (Eds.), Private action and the public good (pp. 206-217). New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
78.
JenkinsJ. C.EckertC. M. (1986). Channeling black insurgency: Elite patronage and professional social movement organizations in the development of the black movement. American Sociological Review, 51, 812-829.
79.
JenkinsJ. C.HalcliA. L. (1999). Grassrooting the system? The development and impact of social movement philanthropy. In LagemannE. C. (Ed.), Philanthropic foundations (pp. 229-256). Bloomington: Indiana University Press.
80.
KerwinP. (2003, July2). Interview by author.
81.
KnightM.RodgersK. (2012). “The government is operationalizing neo-liberalism”: Women’s organizations, status of women Canada, and the struggle for progressive social change in Canada. Nordic Journal of Feminist and Gender Research, 20, 266-282.
82.
KnopffR.MortonF. L. (2000). The charter revolution and the court party. Peterborough, England: Broadview Press.
83.
Kohl-ArenasE. (2014). Will the revolution be funded? Resource mobilization and the California Farm Worker Movement. Social Movement Studies, 13, 482-498.
84.
KorinekV. (2003). “The most openly gay person for at least a thousand miles”: Doug Wilson and the politicization of a province. Canadian Historical Review, 84, 516-551.
85.
KrashinskyM. (1990). Management implications of government funding of nonprofit organizations: Views from the United States and Canada. Nonprofit Management, 1, 39-54.
86.
LaforestR. (2011). Voluntary sector organizations and the state: Building new relations. Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada: UBC Press.
87.
LaforestR.OrsiniM. (2005). Evidence-based engagement in the voluntary sector: Lessons from Canada. Social Policy and Administration, 39, 481-497.
88.
LambertsonR. (2003, August26). Interview by author.
89.
LambertsonR. (2005). Repression and resistance: Canadian human rights activists, 1930-1960. Toronto, Ontario, Canada: University of Toronto Press.
90.
LamoureuxD. (1997). Les services feministe: De l’antietatisme a l’integration subsidaire [Feminists services - from anti-slavery to subsidized integration]. In AndrewC.RogersS. (Eds.), Women and the Canadian state (pp. 145-154). Montreal, Québec, Canada: McGill-Queen’s University Press.
91.
LangerR. L. (2007). Defining rights and wrongs: Bureaucracy, human rights, and public accountability. Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada: UBC Press.
92.
LaurinL. (1985). Des Luttes et Des Droits: Antécédants et histoire de la Ligue des Droits de l’Homme de 1936-1975 [Struggles and Rights: Antecedents and History of the League of Human Rights of 1936-1975]. Montreal, Québec, Canada: Éditions du Meridien.
93.
Law Foundation of British Columbia. (1972-2014). Annual report. Victoria, British Columbia, Canada: Author.
94.
Law Foundation of Ontario. (1972-2014). Report of the Law Foundation of Ontario. Victoria, British Columbia, Canada: Author.
95.
LeviN. (2002, June25). Interview by author.
96.
Ligue des droits de l’homme. (1972). Les droits de l’homme dans la société actuelle: Manifeste [Human rights in today’s society: manifesto]. Montreal, Québec, Canada: Author.
97.
LittleM. H. (2007). Militant mothers fight poverty: The Just Society Movement, 1968-1971. Labour/Le Travail, 59, 179-198.
98.
LoneyM. (1972). A political economy of citizen participation. In PantichL. (Eds.), The Canadian State: Political economy and political power (pp. 447-460). Toronto, Ontario, Canada: University of Toronto Press.
99.
MadsenM. R.VerschraegenG. (2013). Making human rights intelligible: An introduction to a sociology of human rights. In MadsenM. R.VerschraegenG. (Eds.), Making human rights intelligible (pp. 1-24). Portland, OR: Hart.
100.
MassonD. (2012). Changing state forms, competing state projects: Funding women’s organizations in Quebec. Studies in Political Economy, 89, 79-104.
101.
MassonD. (2015). Institutionalization, state funding and advocacy. In RamosH.RodgersK. (Eds.), Protest and politics: The promise of the social movement society (pp. 61-78). Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada: UBC Press.
102.
MatthewsN. (1994). Confronting rape: The feminist anti-rape movement and the state. New York, NY: Routledge.
103.
McAdamD. (1982). Political process and the development of black insurgency. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
104.
McCarthyJ. D.BrittD.WolfsonM. (1991). The institutional channeling of social movements by the state in the United States. In CoyP. G. (Ed.), Research in social movements, conflicts and change (pp. 45-76). Bingley, England: Jai Press.
105.
MooreD. E. (1980). Multiculturalism: Ideology or social reality (Unpublished doctoral dissertation). Boston University, Boston, MA.
106.
NevilleA. (2005). Funding through the women’s program: Women’s groups speak out. Ottawa, Ontario, Canada: Standing Committee on the Status of Women.
107.
NgR. (1996). The politics of community services: Immigrant women, class and state. Halifax, Nova Scotia, Canada: Fernwood Press.
108.
Nova Scotia. (1960-2014). Public accounts. Halifax, Nova Scotia, Canada: Queen’s Printer.
109.
OstranderS. A. (1987). Elite domination in private social service agencies: How it happens and how it is challenged. In DomhoffG. W.DyeT. (Eds.), The power elite and organizations (pp. 85-102). Newbury Park, CA: Sage.
110.
OstranderS. A. (1995). Money for change: Social movement philanthropy at Haymarket people’s fund: Philadelphia, PA: Temple University Press.
111.
OstranderS. A. (2005). Legacy and promise for social justice funding: Charitable foundations and progressive social movements. In FaberD.McCarthyD. (Eds.), Foundations for social change: Critical perspectives on philanthropy and popular movements (pp. 33-60). Lanham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield.
112.
OstranderS. A. (2007). The growth of donor control: Revisiting the social relations of philanthropy. Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Quarterly, 36, 356-372.
113.
PalL. (1993). Interests of state: The politics of language, multiculturalism, and feminism in Canada. Montreal, Québec, Canada: McGill-Queen’s University Press.
114.
PeddleJ. (2002, April12). Interview by author.
115.
PhillipsS. D. (2000). More than stakeholders: Reforming state-voluntary sector relations. Journal of Canadian Studies, 35, 182-204.
116.
PhillipsS. D. (2009). The Harper government and the voluntary sector: Whither a policy agenda? In LaforestR. (Ed.), The new federal policy agenda and the voluntary sector: On the cutting edge (pp. 7-34). Montreal, Québec, Canada: McGill-Queen’s University Press.
117.
RamosH. (2008). Opportunity for whom? Political opportunity and critical events in Canadian aboriginal mobilization, 1951-2000. Social Forces, 87, 795-824.
118.
RiggsB. (2003, July15). Interview by author.
119.
RodgersK.KnightM. (2011). “You just felt the collective wind being knocked out of us”: The deinstitutionalization of feminism and the survival of women’s organizing in Canada. Women’s Studies International Forum, 34, 570-581.
120.
RodgersK.RamosH. (2015). Introduction. In RamosH.RodgersK. (Eds.), Protest and politics: The promise of social movement societies (pp. 3-20). Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada: UBC Press.
121.
RoelofsJ. (2003). Foundations and public policy: The mask of pluralism. New York: SUNY Press.
122.
RoelofsJ. (2005). Liberal foundations: Impediments or supports for social change. In FaberD.McCarthyD. (Eds.), Foundations for social change: Critical perspectives on philanthropy and popular movements (pp. 61-88). Lanham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield.
123.
RussellJ. (2004, December23). Interview by author.
Secretary of State of Canada. (1992). Client funding histories. Ottawa, Ontario, Canada: Author.
127.
SmithM. (2005). A civil society? Collective actors in Canadian political life. Peterborough, England: Broadview Press.
128.
SmithS. R. (1989). Federal funding, nonprofit agencies, and victim services. In DemoneH. W.GibelmanM. (Eds.), Services for sale: Purchasing health and human services (pp. 215-227). New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press.
129.
SmithS. R.LipskyM. (1993). Nonprofits for hire: The welfare state in the age of contracting. Cambridge, England: Harvard University Press.
130.
StaggenborgS. (1988). The consequences of professionalization and formalization in the pro-choice movement. American Sociological Review, 53, 585-606.
131.
StaggenborgS. (2015). Social movements. Toronto, Ontario, Canada: Oxford University Press.
132.
StasiulisD. K. (1980). The political structuring of ethnic community action: A reformulation. Canadian Ethnic Studies, 12(3), 20-46.
133.
StasiulisD. K. (1982). Race, ethnicity and the state: The political structuring of South Asian and West Indian communal action in combating racism (Unpublished doctoral dissertation). University of Toronto, Ontario, Canada.
134.
StoneS. D.DoucetteJ. (1988). Organizing the marginalized: The disabled women’s network. In CunninghamF.FindlayS.KadaM.LennonA.SilvaE. (Eds.), Social movements/social change: The politics of practice and organizing (pp. 81-97). Toronto, Ontario, Canada: Between the Lines.
135.
ThompsonW. (2003, June1). Interview by author.
136.
TillotsonS. (2008). Contributing citizens: Modern charitable fundraising and the making of the welfare state. Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada: UBC Press.
137.
VinkJ. (2002, March11). Interview by author.
138.
VivianG. (2004, August4). Interview by author.
139.
WalkerJ. (2002). The “Jewish phase” in the movement for racial equality in Canada. Canadian Ethnic Studies, 34(1), 1-29.
140.
WebkingE. (2003, August26). Interview by author.
141.
WhalenN. (2002, April4). Interview by author.
142.
ZaldM.McCarthyJ. D. (1987). The trend of social movements in America: Professionalization and resource mobilization. In ZaldM.McCarthyJ. D. (Eds.), Social movements in an organizational society (pp. 337-391). New Brunswick, NJ: Transaction.
