Rome and American Catholics

Abstract

This article considers the paradox evidenced by American Catholics' simultaneous rejection of papal teaching and their enduring commitment to Rome. This issue is explored by focusing on one group of apparently anomalous Catholics, members of the Women's Ordination Conference (WOC), who contest Vatican opposition to women priests. It is suggested that the legitimation narratives that WOC members use to validate their identity as Catholics committed to a doctrinal stance denounced by Rome illuminate one of the mechanisms that enable Catholics in general to maintain their religious identity while disagreeing with papal teaching. Derived from their lived knowledge of Catholicism, WOC respondents claim the authority to interpret doctrine and use that interpretive autonomy to offer doctrinally grounded reasons in favor of change. Empowered by Catholicism to reflexively critique church doctrine and practices, WOC members both validate their particularized interpretations of Catholicism and maintain communion with the church's more universal community of memory.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Abbott, Walter , ed. 1966. The Documents of Vatican II. New York: Herder & Herder.

Ahlstrom, Sydney . 1972. A Religious History of the American People. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.

Bellah, Robert N. , Richard Madsen , William M. Sullivan , Ann Swidler , and Steven M. Tipton . 1985. Habits of the Heart: Individualism and Commitment in American Life. Berkeley: University of California Press.

Bellah, Robert N. , Richard Madsen , William M. Sullivan , Ann Swidler , and Steven M. Tipton . 1991. The Good Society. New York: Knopf.

Boyle, John . 1985. The Academy and Church Teaching Authority: Current Issues. CTSA Proceedings 40:172-180.

Calhoun, Craig . 1995. Critical Social Theory: Culture, History and the Challenge of Difference. Cambridge, MA: Basil Blackwell.

Chaves, Mark . 1994. Secularization as Declining Religious Authority. Social Forces 72:749-774.

Congar, Yves . [1957] 1965. Lay People in the Church. Westminster, MD: Newman Press.

Cuneo, Michael . 1997. The Smoke of Satan: Conservative and Traditionalist Dissent in Contemporary American Catholicism. New York: Oxford University Press.

10.

D'Antonio, William , James Davidson , Dean Hoge , and Ruth Wallace . 1996. Laity, American and Catholic: Transforming the Church. Kansas City, MO: Sheed & Ward.

11.

Dillon, Michele . Forthcoming. Reason, Faith, and Power: Redrawing the Boundaries of Catholic Identity. New York: Cambridge University Press.

12.

Etzioni, Amitai . 1997. The New Golden Rule. New York: Basic Books.

13.

Finke, Roger and Rodney Stark . 1992. The Churching of America: Winners and Losers in Our Religious Economy. New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press.

14.

Foley, Felician and Rose Avato . 1997. 1997 Catholic Almanac. Huntington, IN: Our Sunday Visitor.

15.

Gallup, George . 1994. The Gallup Poll 1993. Wilmington, DE: Scholarly Resources.

16.

Glendon, Mary Ann . 1991. Rights Talk. New York: Free Press.

17.

Goodstein, Laura and Richard Morin . 1995. Love the Messenger, Not His Message. Washington Post, 9-15 Oct., 37.

18.

Greeley, Andrew and Michael Hout . 1996. Survey Finds Catholics Want More Say. National Catholic Reporter, 14 June.

19.

Iannaccone, Lawrence . 1992. Sacrifice and Stigma: Reducing Free-Riding in Cults, Communes, and Other Collectives. Journal of Political Economy 100:271-291.

20.

Iannaccone, Lawrence . 1995. Risk, Rationality, and Religious Portfolios. Economic Inquiry 33:285-295.

21.

McCool, Gerald . 1977. Catholic Theology in the Nineteenth Century: The Quest for a Unitary Method. New York: Seabury Press.

22.

Reese, Thomas . 1996. Inside the Vatican: The Politics and Organization of the Catholic Church. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

23.

Sanks, T. Howland . 1974. Authority in the Church: A Study in Changing Paradigms. Missoula, MT: Scholars' Press.

24.

Schussler Fiorenza, Elisabeth . [1983] 1994. In Memory of Her: A Feminist Theological Reconstruction of Christian Origins. New York: Crossroad.

25.

Seidman, Steven . 1994. Contested Knowledge: Social Theory in the Postmodern Era. Cambridge, MA: Basil Blackwell.

26.

Smith, Dorothy . 1990. The Conceptual Practices of Power. Boston: Northeastern University Press.

27.

Sullivan, Francis A. 1983. Magisterium: Teaching Authority in the Catholic Church. New York: Paulist Press.

28.

Tierney, Brian . 1971. Origins of Papal Infallibility. Journal of Ecumenical Studies 8:841-864.