This article examines the extent to which major sources of political information affect citizen learning. Recent empirical comparisons of mass media channels show, contrary to earlier research, that television news is informative for American voters, albeit in ways different from newspapers. Television news provides more information about candidates; newspapers, more about parties. Both are sources of issue information. Print media are consulted more often than television by people who are actively seeking information. Television reaches groups that tend to lack political information, such as young people, immigrants, and less interested citizens. Newspaper coverage does more to close knowledge gaps between socioeconomic strata. Newsmagazines and radio are receding as political knowledge sources, relative to television and newspapers.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
1. Burns W. Roper, Trends in Attitudes Toward Television and Other Media: A Twenty-Four Year Review (New York: Roper Organization, 1983).
2.
Jack M. McLeod and Daniel G. McDonald, “Beyond Simple Exposure: Media Orientations and Their Impact on Political Processes,”Communication Research, 12:3-33 (June 1985).
3.
3. Thomas E. Patterson and Robert McClure, The Unseeing Eye: The Myth of Television Power in National Elections (New York: Putnam's, 1976), pp. 47-58.
4.
4. Garrett J. O'Keefe and L. Erwin Atwood, “Communication and Election Campaigns,” in Handbook of Political Communication, ed. Dan D. Nimmo and Keith R. Sanders (Beverly Hills, CA: Sage, 1981), pp. 329-357.
5.
Xinshu Zhao and Steven H. Chaffee, “Campaign Advertisements Versus Television News as Sources of Political Issue Information,”Public Opinion Quarterly, 59:41-65 (Spring 1995).
6.
6. Thomas E. Patterson, The Mass Media Election: How Americans Choose Their President (New York: Praeger, 1980), pp. 153-156.
7.
7. Steven H. Chaffee, Xinshu Zhao, and Glenn Leshner, “Political Knowledge and the Campaign Media of 1992,”Communication Research, 21:305-324 (June 1994).
8.
8. Vincent Price and John Zaller, “Who Gets the News? Alternative Measures of News Reception and Their Implications for Research,”Public Opinion Quarterly, 57:133-164 (Summer 1993).
9.
Walter Gantz , “The Diffusion of News About the Attempted Reagan Assassination,”Journal of Communication, 33:55-66 (Winter 1983).
10.
10. Steven H. Chaffee, “Mass Media and Interpersonal Channels: Competitive, Convergent, or Complementary?” in Inter / Media: Interpersonal Communication in a Media World, 2d ed., ed. Gary Gumpert and Robert Cathcart (New York: Oxford University Press, 1982), pp. 57-77.
11.
John P. Robinson and Mark R. Levy, The Main Source: What People Learn from Television News (Beverly Hills, CA: Sage, 1986), pp. 57-132.
12.
12. Colin Berry, “Learning from Television News: A Critique of the Research,”Journal of Broadcasting, 27:359-370 (Fall 1983).
13.
13. Maxwell E. McCombs, “The Agenda-Setting Approach,” in Handbook of Political Communication, ed. Nimmo and Sanders, pp. 121-140.
14.
Wendy M. Rahnet al. , “A Social-Cognitive Model of Candidate Appraisal,” in Information and Democratic Processes, ed. John A. Ferejohn and James A. Kuklinski (Urbana: University of Illinois Press, 1990), pp. 136-159.
15.
Martinelli and Chaffee, “New-Voter Learning.”
16.
16. Chaffee, Zhao, and Leshner, “Political Knowledge.”
17.
17. Steven H. Chaffee and Albert R. Tims, “News Media Use in Adolescence: Implications for Political Cognitions,” in Communication Yearbook 6, ed. Michael Burgoon (Beverly Hills, CA: Sage, 1982), pp. 736-758.
18.
18. Patterson, Mass Media Election, pp. 156-165.
19.
Becker and Dunwoody, “Media Use.”
20.
20. Weaver and Drew, “Voter Learning in 1992.”
21.
21. Chaffee, Zhao, and Leshner, “Political Knowledge.”
22.
22. Martinelli and Chaffee, “New-Voter Learning.”
23.
Patterson , Mass Media Election, pp. 156-165.
24.
24. Chaffee, Zhao, and Leshner, “Political Knowledge.”
25.
25. Weaver and Drew, “Voter Learning in 1992,” p. 11.
26.
26. Chaffee, Zhao, and Leshner, “Political Knowledge,” p. 313.
27.
27. Valerie M. Sue, “Television Reliance and Candidates' Personal Qualities in the 1992 Election” (Ph.D. diss., Stanford University, 1994).
28.
28. Ibid.
29.
29. Nancy B. Lowdenet al., “Media Use in the Primary Election: A Secondary Medium Model,”Communication Research, 21:293-304 (June 1994).
30.
30. Zhao and Chaffee, “Campaign Advertisements.”
31.
31. Martinelli and Chaffee, “New-Voter Learning.”
32.
32. Becker and Dunwoody, “Media Use.”
33.
33. Culbertson and Stempel, “Media Use and Reliance.”
34.
34. Angus Campbellet al., Elections and the Political Order (New York: John Wiley, 1966).
35.
35. Chaffee and Tims, “News Media Use,” pp. 736-758.
36.
36. Chaffee, Zhao, and Leshner, “Political Knowledge,” p. 313.
37.
Sidney Kraus and Dennis K. Davis, The Effects of Mass Communication on Political Behavior (University Park: Pennsylvania State University Press, 1976), pp. 48-54.
38.
Chaffee , Zhao, and Leshner, “Political Knowledge.”
39.
39. Gantz, “Diffusion of News.”
40.
Rosengren , “Comparative Study.”
41.
41. Elihu Katz, Michael Gurevitch, and Hadassah Haas, “On the Use of Mass Media for Important Things,”American Sociological Review, 38:164-181 (Apr. 1973).
42.
42. Stacey Blair Frank, “Situational Influence on Political Involvement and Information Seeking: A Field Experiment” (Ph.D. diss., Stanford University, 1995).
43.
43. Charles K. Atkin, “Anticipated Communication and Mass Media Information-Seeking,”Public Opinion Quarterly, 36:188-199 (Summer 1972).
44.
44. Steven H. Chaffeeet al., “Stimulation of Communication: Reconceptualizing the Study of Political Socialization” (Paper delivered at the annual meeting of the Association for Education in Journalism and Mass Communication, Washington, DC, Aug. 1995).
45.
45. Pettey, “Interaction.”
46.
46. Sue, “Television Reliance.”
47.
47. Lowdenet al., “Media Use.”
48.
48. Herbert Krugman, “The Impact of Television Advertising: Learning Without Involvement,”Public Opinion Quarterly, 29:349-356 (Fall 1965).
49.
49. Patterson, Mass Media Election, pp. 163-165.
50.
50. W. Russell Neuman, Marion R. Just, and Ann N. Crigler, Common Knowledge: News and the Construction of Political Meaning (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1992), p. 114.
51.
Rosengren , “Comparative Study.”
52.
Stephen Earl Bennett , “The Persian Gulf War's Impact on Americans' Political Information,”Political Behavior, 16:179-201 (June 1994).
53.
Steven H. Chaffee and Seung-Mock Yang, “Communication and Political Socialization,” in Political Socialization for Democracy, ed. Orit Ichilov (New York: Columbia University Teachers College Press, 1990), pp. 137-157.
54.
54. Robert W. Connell, The Child's Construction of Politics (Melbourne, Australia: University of Melbourne Press, 1971).
55.
55. Chaffee and Yang, “Communication and Political Socialization.”
56.
56. Chaffee and Tims, “News Media Use.”
57.
57. Atkin, “Political Socialization.”
58.
Chaffee and Schleuder, “Measurement and Effects.”
59.
Chaffee and Schleuder, “Measurement and Effects.”
60.
60. Chaffeeet al., “Stimulation of Communication.”
61.
61. K. Kyoon Hur, “Impact of `Roots' on Black and White Teenagers,”Journal of Broadcasting, 22:289-298 (Summer 1978).
62.
62. John H. Flavell, Cognitive Development (Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall, 1977), pp. 6-11.
63.
63. Chaffeeet al., “Stimulation of Communication.”
64.
Martinelli and Chaffee, “New-Voter Learning.”
65.
65. Phillip J. Tichenor, Clarice N. Olien, and George A. Donohue, “Mass Media Flow and Differential Growth in Knowledge,”Public Opinion Quarterly, 34:159-170 (Summer 1970).
66.
Walter Gantz , “How Uses and Gratifications Affect Recall of Television News,”Journalism Quarterly, 55:664-672, 681 (Winter 1978).
67.
67. Cecilie Gaziano, “The Knowledge Gap: An Analytical Review of Media Effects,”Communication Research, 10:447-486 (Oct. 1983).
68.
68. Phillip J. Tichenoret al., “Community Issues, Conflict, and Public Affairs Knowledge,” in New Models for Mass Communication Research, ed. Peter Clarke (Beverly Hills, CA: Sage, 1973), pp. 45-79.
