The commonly held view that liberal democracies cannot effectively control unwanted migration is unwarranted despite the intensification of migration pressures in recent years. To develop a more accurate position built on less sweeping generalizations, I disaggregate migration policy into four parts: managing legal immigration, controlling illegal migration, administering temporary worker programs, and processing asylum seekers and refugees. A review of the experiences of the liberal democracies with each of these migration challenges indicates that although there are numerous instances of policy failure, there is also considerable capacity to regulate migration. I argue that this capacity is certainly growing, not declining, over time, that some states possess more capacity than others, that the control capacities of particular states vary substantially across the four areas, and that these capacities fluctuate periodically in conjunction with contingent cycles of salience and effort.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Doris M. Meissneret al. , International Migration Challenges in a New Era (New York: Trilateral Commission, 1993).
2.
Kitty Calavita, “Italy and the New Immigration,” ibid.
3.
Daniel Kubat , “Canada,” in The Politics of Migration Policies, ed. Daniel Kubat (Staten Island, NY: Center for Migration Studies, 1979), pp. 22-23.
4.
4. Charles A. Price, The Great White Walls Are Built: Restrictive Immigration to North America and Australasia 1836-1888 (Canberra: Australian National University Press, 1974).
5.
Cornelius , “Controlling Illegal Immigration: The Case of Japan.”
6.
Kathryn Cronin , “A Culture of Control,” in The Politics of Australian Immigration, ed. James Jupp and Marie Kabala (Canberra: Australian Government Printing Service, 1993), pp. 83-104.
7.
Robert Holton and Judith Sloan, “Immigration Policy: Intake and Settlement Issues,” in Australian Immigration: A Survey of the Issues, ed. Mark Woodenet al. (Canberra: Australian Government Printing Service, 1990), pp. 304-305.
8.
Gary P. Freeman and Katharine Betts, “The Politics of Interests and Immigration Policymaking in Australia and the United States,” in ibid., pp. 72-88.
9.
Robert Birrell , “Problems of Immigration Control in Liberal Democracies: The Australian Experience,” in Nations of Immigrants, ed. Freeman and Jupp, pp. 23-40.
10.
10. Burstein, “Immigration Management Control and Policy Concerns,” chart 1.
11.
11. For a description of the points system in Canada, see Economic Council of Canada, Economic and Social Impacts of Immigration (Ottawa: Minister of Supply and Services, 1991), pp. 5-19.
12.
12. Burstein, “Immigration Management: Control and Policy Concerns.”
13.
13. Bean and Fix, “Significance of Recent Immigration Policy Reforms.”
14.
14. Lloyd, “Political Economy of Immigration,” tab. 4.3, p. 77.
15.
15. Employment and Immigration Canada, Managing Immigration: A Framework for the 1990s (Ottawa: Employment and Immigration Canada, 1992), pp. 6-8.
16.
16. For a comprehensive overview of the various sorts of illegal migration and the wide range of policy options available to deal with them, see David S. North, Enforcing the Immigration Law: A Review of the Options (Washington, DC: Center for Labor and Migration Studies, 1980).
17.
17. Charles Price, “Australia: A New Multicultural Country?” in The Politics of Migration Policies, 2d ed., ed. Daniel Kubat (Staten Island, NY: Center for Migration Studies, 1993), p. 17.
18.
18. Daniel Kubat, “Canada: Immigration's Humanitarian Challenge,” in The Politics of Migration Policies, ed. Kubat.
19.
19. U.S., General Accounting Office, Prospects Dim for Effectively Enforcing Immigration Laws (Washington, DC: General Accounting Office, 1980), p. i.
20.
20. David Simcox, “Overview: A Time of Reform and Reappraisal,” in U.S. Immigration in the 1980s: Reappraisal and Reform, ed. David Simcox (Boulder, CO: Westview Press, 1988), tab. 1.10, pp. 28-29.
21.
Mark J. Miller , “Never Ending Story: The US Debate over Illegal Immigration,” in Nations of Immigrants, ed. Freeman and Jupp, pp. 65-68.
22.
22. Simcox, “Overview,” p. 43.
23.
23. Austin American Statesman, 26-28 Nov. 1993.
24.
Mark J. Miller , Employer Sanctions in Europe (Staten Island, NY: Center for Migration Studies, 1987), pp. 19-23.
25.
Immigration Reform: Employer Sanctions and the Question of Discrimination (Washington, DC: General Accounting Office, 1990).
26.
26. Miller, Employer Sanctions in Western Europe, p. 46.
27.
Malcolm R. Lovell, Jr., “Europe's Lessons for America,” in ibid., pp. 229-44.
28.
28. Thomas Straubhaar, “Allocational and Distributional Aspects of Future Immigration to Western Europe,”International Migration Review, 26(2):462-483 (Summer 1992).
29.
Kitty Calavita , Inside the State: The Bracero Program, Immigration and the I.N.S. (New York: Routledge, 1992).
30.
30. See Mark J. Miller and Philip A. Martin, Administering Foreign-Worker Programs (Lexington, MA: Lexington Books, 1982), p. xv.
31.
31. Ibid., pp. 88-90.
32.
32. James F. Hollifield, Immigrants, Markets, and States: The Political Economy of Postwar Europe (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1992), p. 94.
33.
33. See his review of Hollifield's book in French Politics and Society, 11(2):95-102 (Spring 1993).
36. United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees, The State of the World's Refugees: The Challenge of Protection (New York: Penguin Books, 1993). A convention refugee is any person who, owing to well-founded fear of being persecuted for reasons of race, religion, nationality, membership of a particular social group or political opinion, is outside the country of his nationality and is unable to or, owing to such fear, is unwilling to avail himself of the protection of that country. 1951 Convention and 1967 Protocol relating to the Status of Refugees.
37.
37. Gary P. Freeman, “Migration Policy and Politics in the Receiving States,”International Migration Review26(4): 1144-1167 (Winter 1992).
38.
38. The German reforms had immediate effect, with numbers of applicants dropping by one-third to two-thirds over the first several months. See Judy Dempsey, “Refugees Entering Germany on Decline,”Financial Times, 5 Nov. 1993.
39.
Sarah Collinson , Europe and International Migration (London: Pinter, 1993), pp. 109-138.
