Three major cycles of reform in public mental health care in the United States—the moral treatment, mental hygiene, and community mental health movements—are described as a basis for assessing the shifting boundaries between the mental health, social welfare, and criminal justice systems. Historical forces that led to the transinstitutionalization of the mentally ill from almshouses to the state mental hospitals in the nineteenth and twentieth centuries have now been reversed in the aftermath of recent deinstitutionalization policies. Evidence is suggestive that the mentally ill are also being caught up in the criminal justice system, a circumstance reminiscent of pre-asylum conditions in the early nineteenth century. These trends shape the current mental health service delivery system and the agenda for policy-relevant research on issues involving the legal and mental health fields.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Joseph P. Morrissey and Howard H. Goldman, “Cycles of Reform in the Care of the Chronically Mentally Ill,”Hospital and Community Psychiatry, 35: 785-793 (1984).
2.
Gerald N. Grob , Mental Institutions in America: Social Policy to 1875 (New York: Free Press, 1973).
3.
Barbara Sicherman , The Quest for Mental Health in America, 1880-1917 (New York: Arno Press, 1980).
4.
Harry A. Foley and Steven S. Sharfstein, Madness and Government: Who Cares for the Mentally Ill? (Washington, DC: American Psychiatric Press, 1983).
5.
Carol Warren , “New Forms of Social Control: The Myth of Deinstitutionalization,”American Behavioral Scientist, 6:724-740 (1981).
6.
idem , Mental Institutions in America, pp. 1-34.
7.
7. Norman Dain , “The Chronic Mental Patient in 19th-Century America,”Psychiatric Annals, 10:323-327 (1980).
8.
8. Dorothea Dix, On Behalf of the Insane Poor (New York: Arno Press, 1975).
9.
9. Rothman, Discovery of the Asylum, pp. 237-295.
10.
10. Grob, Mental Institutions in America, pp. 174-220.
11.
11. Ibid., pp. 193-195.
12.
12. Albert Deutsch, The Mentally Ill in America: A History of Their Care and Treatment from Colonial Times, 2nd ed. rev. (New York: Columbia University Press, 1949).
13.
Leo Srole , “Gheel, Belgium: The Natural Therapeutic Community, 1475-1975,” in New Trends of Psychiatry in the Community, ed. G. Serban and B. Astrachan (Cambridge, MA: Ballinger, 1977).
14.
14. Grob, Mental Institutions in America, pp. 320-339.
15.
For a more extended introduction to the history of commitment laws in the United States, see Deutsch, Mentally Ill in America, pp. 418-441.
16.
16. Grob, Mental Institutions in America, pp. 132-173.
17.
Ernest Gruenberg , “The Social Breakdown Syndrome and Its Prevention,” in American Handbook of Psychiatry, 2nd ed., ed. S. Arieti (New York: Basic Books, 1974), vol. 2.
18.
18. Morrissey, Goldman, and Klerman, Enduring Asylum, pp. 281-305.
19.
19. The origins of the mental hygiene movement are portrayed with insight in Norman Dain, Clifford W. Beers: Advocate for the Insane (Pittsburgh, PA: University of Pittsburgh Press, 1980).
20.
20. Albert Deutsch, “The History of Mental Hygiene,” in One Hundred Years of American Psychiatry, ed. J. K. Hall, G. Zilboorg, and H. A. Bunker (New York: Columbia University Press, 1944).
21.
Grob , Mental Illness and American Society, pp. 144-178.
22.
22. Grob, Mental Illness and American Society, pp. 179-200.
23.
23. Ibid., pp. 89-92.
24.
24. Ibid., p. 196.
25.
25. Ibid., p. 181.
26.
26. Ibid., p. 107.
27.
David Mechanic , Mental Health and Social Policy (Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall, 1969).
28.
28. John A. Talbott, “Twentieth-Century Developments in American Psychiatry,”Psychiatric Quarterly, 54:207-219 (1982).
29.
Lawrence Linn , Frontiers in General Hospital Psychiatry (New York: International University Press, 1961).
30.
30. Richard D. Lyons, “How Release of Mental Patients Began,”New York Times, 30 Oct. 1984.
31.
Joint Commission on Mental Illness and Health , Action for Mental Health.
32.
32. Joseph Morrissey, “Deinstitutionalizing the Mentally Ill: Process, Outcomes, and New Directions,” in Deviance and Mental Illness, ed. W. Gove (Beverly Hills, CA: Sage, 1982).
33.
and Charles Windle and Diana Scully, “Community Mental Health Centers and the Decreasing Use of State Mental Hospitals,”Community Mental Health Journal, 12:239-243 (1976).
34.
34. Bachrach, Deinstitutionalization: An Analytical Review and Sociological Perspective.
35.
35. Uri Aviram and Steven Segal, “Exclusion of the Mentally Ill: Reflections on an Old Problem in a New Context,”Archives of General Psychiatry, 29:126-131 (1973).
36.
36. Morrissey, “Deinstitutionalizing the Mentally Ill.”
37.
37. For an informative and comprehensive review of recent law and mental health issues, see Saleem A. Shah, “Legal and Mental Health System Interactions: Major Developments and Research Needs,”International Journal of Law and Psychiatry, 4:219-270 (1981).
38.
38. See, for example, Jonas Robitscher, “Legal Standards and Their Implications Regarding Civil Commitment Procedures,” in Dangerous Behavior: A Problem in Law and Mental Health, ed. C. J. Frederick, National Institute of Mental Health, Department of Health, Education, and Welfare pub. no. (ADM) 78-563 (Washington, DC: Government Printing Office, 1978).
39.
Bassuk and Gerson, “Deinstitutionalization and Mental Health Services.”
40.
William Shadish and Richard Bootzin, “Nursing Homes and Chronic Mental Patients,”Schizophrenia Bulletin, 7:488-498 (1981).
41.
41. Warren, “New Forms of Social Control.”
42.
42. Howard Goldman, Neal H. Adams, and Carl Taube, “Deinstitutionalization: The Data Demythologized,”Hospital and Community Psychiatry, 34:129-134 (1981).
43.
Linda Teplin , “Criminalizing Mental Disorder: The Comparative Arrest Rate of the Mentally Ill,”American Psychologist, 39(7):794-803 (1984).
44.
For a thoughtful analysis of the systemic interdependency between civil and criminal commitment laws, see David Wexler, “The Structure of Civil Commitment: Patterns, Pressures, and Interactions in Mental Health Legislation,”Law and Human Behavior, 7(1):1-18 (1983).
45.
45. Jeffry Geller and Eric Lister, “The Process of Criminal Commitment for Pretrial Psychiatric Examination: An Evaluation,”American Journal of Psychiatry, 135:53-63 (1978).
46.
46. William Dickey, “Incompetency and the Nondangerous Mentally Ill Client,”Criminal Law Bulletin, 16:22-40 (1980).
47.
For some contrasting data that suggest that police invoke the penal code for mentally disordered persons only as a last resort, see Jennifer C. Bonovitz and Jay S. Bonovitz, “Diversion of the Mentally Ill into the Criminal Justice System: The Police Intervention Perspective,”American Journal of Psychiatry, 138(7):973-976 (1981).
48.
48. Henry J. Steadmanet al., “The impact of State Mental Hospital Deinstitutionalization on United States Prison Populations, 1968-1978,”Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology, 75(2):474-490 (1984).
49.
Gary Whitmer , “From Hospitals to Jails: The Fate of California's Deinstitutionalized Mentally Ill,”American Journal of Orthopsychiatry, 50:65-75 (1980).
50.
50. Unpublished statistical data from the 1980 Sample Survey of State and County Mental Hospitals, Survey and Reports Branch, Division of Biometry and Epidemiology, National Institute of Mental Health, Rockville, MD.
51.
51. Ibid.
52.
52. For a more comprehensive profile of the volume and range of facilities serving mentally disordered offenders in the United States, see Henry J. Steadmanet al., “Mentally Disordered Offenders: A National Survey of Patients and Facilities,”Law and Human Behavior, 6(1):31-38 (1982).
53.
53. Richard C. Tessler and Howard H. Goldman, The Chronically Mentally Ill: Assessing Community Support Programs (Cambridge, MA: Ballinger, 1982).
54.
54. Howard H. Goldman and Joseph P. Morrissey, “The Alchemy of Mental Health Policy: Homelessness and the Fourth Cycle of Reform,”American Journal of Public Health, 75(7):727-731 (1985).
