Donald Trump and Trumpism have transformed the Heritage Foundation and the Federalist Society, two institutions at the heart of the conservative legal movement. In this article, I use the conservative philosophy of fusionism as a lens for understanding the causes and consequences of the transformation. The original fusionism of William F. Buckley and Frank S. Meyer brought disparate factions of conservatives together under the mantle of libertarian means to conservative ends. Here, I show that Trump and Trumpism have transmogrified that original concept into a “new fusionism” of authoritarian means to Christian nationalist ends. I investigate the extent to which this “new fusionism” has been embraced or endorsed by the Heritage Foundation and the Federalist Society and what the consequences might be for the respectability and efficacy of the conservative legal movement after Trump.
ABC News. 23October2016. Clinton vaults to a double-digit lead, boosted by broad disapproval of Trump (poll). Available from abcnews.go.com.
2.
AdlerJonathan H.2004. Frank Meyer: The fusionist as federalist. Publius34(4): 51–67.
3.
AdlerJonathan H.5April2022. Judge Bill Pryor challenges common-good constitutionalism. Volokh Conspiracy. Available from reason.com/volokh (accessed 19 October 2024).
4.
AshbeeEdwardWaddanAlex. 2024. US Republicans and the new fusionism. Political Quarterly95(1): 148–156.
5.
Associated Press. 18May2024. Upside-down flag at Justice Alito’s home another blow for Supreme Court under fire. Politico. Available from www.politico.com (accessed 13 August 2024).
6.
BalkinJack M.2001. Bush v. Gore and the boundary between law and politics. Yale Law Journal110(8): 1407–1458.
7.
BarnesRobert. 18November2017. Federalist Society, White House cooperation on judges paying benefits. Washington Post.
8.
Barrón-LópezLauraPopatShrai. 23May2024. Flag associated with Christian nationalism flown at Alito’s beach house, report says. PBS News Hour. Available from www.pbs.org/newshour (accessed 13 August 2024).
9.
BradnerEric. 23October2016. New poll shows Clinton over Trump by double-digits. CNN.
10.
Brown v. Board of Education of Topeka. 1954. 347 U.S. 483.
11.
CalabresiSteven G.5December2022. Can the Supreme Court define a state’s “legislature”?Wall Street Journal. Available from www.wsj.com (accessed 13 August 2024).
12.
CooneyDan. 17June2022. Who is Ginni Thomas and why is she important to the Jan. 6 hearings?PBS News. Available from www.pbs.org (accessed 13 August 2024).
13.
CruzLisetBlancoAliMesserlyMeganBhattacharyyaAbhinandaWiederkehrAnna. 5February2025. 37 ways Project 2025 has shown up in Trump’s executive orders. Politico. Available from www.politico.com (accessed 5 February 2025).
14.
CurryTodd A.HurwitzMark S.2016. Strategic retirements of elected and appointed justices: A hazard model approach. Journal of Politics78(4): 1061–1075.
15.
DallekMatthew. 31March2023. Debunking a longstanding myth about William F. Buckley. Politico Magazine. Available from www.politico.com (accessed 8 August 2024).
16.
DazeyMargot. 2021. Rethinking respectability politics. British Journal of Sociology72(3): 580–593.
17.
DorfMichael C.14November2022. Federalist Society tries to cancel its co-founder. Dorf on Law. Available from www.dorfonlaw.org (accessed 13 August 2024).
18.
DowieMark. 6July2002. Learning from the right wing. New York Times.
19.
DurkeeAlison. 6February2025. Here’s how Trump’s executive orders align with Project 2025—as co-author nears Senate confirmation. Forbes. Available from www.forbes.com.
20.
EverettBurgessThrushGlenn. 13February2016. McConnell throws down the gauntlet: No Scalia replacement under Obama. Politico. Available from www.politico.com.
21.
FaganE. J.2024. The thinkers: The rise of partisan think tanks and the polarization of American politics. Oxford University Press.
22.
FelzenbergAlvin S. 20June2017. The inside story of William F. Buckley Jr.’s crusade against the John Birch Society. National Review. Available from www.nationalreview.com (accessed 8 August 2024).
23.
Garcia-NavarroLulu. 21January2024. Inside the Heritage Foundation’s plans for “institutionalizing Trumpism.” New York Times Magazine. Available from www.nytimes.com (accessed 9 August 2024).
24.
HagleTimothy M.1993. Strategic retirements: A political model of turnover on the United States Supreme Court. Political Behavior15(1): 25–48.
25.
HarrisFrederick C.2014. The rise of respectability politics. Dissent61(1): 33–37.
26.
Hollis-BruskyAmanda. 2011. Helping ideas have consequences: Political and intellectual investment in the unitary executive theory, 1981–2000. Denver Law Review89(1): 197–244.
27.
Hollis-BruskyAmanda. 2015. Ideas with consequences: The Federalist Society and the conservative counterrevolution, 1st ed. Oxford University Press.
28.
Hollis-BruskyAmanda. 2019. Ideas with consequences: The Federalist Society and the conservative counterrevolution, updated paperback edition. Oxford University Press.
29.
Hollis-BruskyAmanda. 22September2020. Maintaining judicial independence and the rule of law: Examining the causes and consequences of court capture. Testimony before the Subcommittee on Courts, Intellectual Property and the Internet of the House Committee on the Judiciary, 116th Cong. Available from www.congress.gov.
30.
Hollis-BruskyAmandaWilsonJoshua C.2020. Separate but faithful: The Christian right’s radical struggle to transform law & legal culture. Oxford University Press.
31.
Hollis-BruskyAmandaParryCelia. 2021. “In the mold of Justice Scalia”: The contours & consequences of the Trump judiciary. The Forum19(1): 117–142. https://doi.org/10.1515/for-2021-0006.
32.
JonesPhilip Edward. 2022. Respectability politics and straight support for LGB rights. Political Research Quarterly75(4): 935–949.
33.
KatzJosh. 18October2016. Hillary Clinton has a 91% chance to win. New York Times Presidential Forecast (newsletter). Available from www.nytimes.com.
34.
KrugmanPaul. 15July2024. Don’t lose sight of Project 2025. That’s the real Trump. New York Times.
35.
Lambda Legal. 2021. Courts, confirmations & consequences: How Trump restructured the federal judiciary and ushered in a climate of unprecedented hostility toward LGBTQ+ people and civil rights. Available from https://www.lambdalegal.org/sites/default/files/judicial_report_2020.pdf (accessed 3 February 2021).
36.
LeingangRachel. 1July2024. The force behind Project 2025: Kevin Roberts has the roadmap for a second Trump term. Guardian (U.S.)
37.
LevitskyStevenZiblattDaniel. 2023. Tyranny of the minority. Penguin Random House.
38.
LewisAndrew R.2017. The rights turn in conservative Christian politics: How abortion transformed the culture wars. Cambridge University Press.
39.
LozadaCarlos. 29February2024. What I learned when I read 887 pages of Project 2025. New York Times.
40.
MontgomeryPeter. 15March2024. Project 2025: How Trump loyalists and right-wing leaders are paving a fast road to fascism. Religion Dispatches. Available from religiondispatches.org.
41.
Moore v. Harper. 2023. 600 U.S. 1.
42.
MSNBC. 22June2024. Top Project 2025 architect talks conservative blueprint for Trump second term. The Weekend. Available from www.msnbc.com (accessed 9 August 2024).
43.
NeidigHarper. 13February2016. McConnell: Don’t replace Scalia until after election. The Hill. Available from thehill.com.
44.
NPR. 17December2011. William F. Buckley, father of American conservatism. Available from www.npr.org (accessed 11 August 2024).
45.
PerlmanAllison. 12October2020. Lessons from Buckley: Race and the American right. Media Commons. Available from mediacommons.org (accessed 8 August 2024).
46.
PrzybylaHeidi. 2May2023. Leonard Leo used Federalist Society contact to obtain $1.6B donation. Politico. Available from www.politico.com (accessed 13 August 2024).
47.
SaldinRobert P.TelesSteven M.2020. Never Trump: The revolt of the conservative elites. Oxford University Press.
48.
SchmidtChristopher W.2018. The forgotten issue? The Supreme Court and the 2016 presidential campaign. Chicago-Kent Law Review93(2): 411–452.
49.
SouthworthAnn. 2008. Lawyers of the right: Professionalizing the conservative coalition. University of Chicago Press.
50.
SpriggsJames F.IIWahlbeckPaul J.1995. Calling it quits: Strategic retirement on the federal courts of appeals, 1893–1991. Political Research Quarterly48(3): 573–597.
51.
StabenowDebbieSchumerChuckWhitehouseSheldon. 2020. Captured courts: The GOP’s big money assault on the Constitution, our independent judiciary, and the rule of law. Democratic Policy and Communications Committee. Available from wwww.whitehouse.senate.gov.
52.
SteinJeffTorbatiYeganeh. 7February2022. Heritage Foundation, former powerhouse of GOP policy, adjusts in face of new competition from Trump allies. Washington Post.
53.
StrolovitchDara Z.CrowderChaya Y.2018. Respectability, anti-respectability, and intersectionally responsible representation. PS: Political Science & Politics51(2): 340–344.
54.
SwanJonathan. 18November2018. Axios sneak peek: Trump’s private Saudi line – Inside his G-20 plans – Maxine Waters targets the banks. Axios Sneak Peek (newsletter). Available from www.axios.com (accessed 19 October 2024).
55.
TelesSteven M.2008. The rise of the conservative legal movement: The battle for control of the law. Oxford University Press.
56.
TelesSteven M.2009. Transformative bureaucracy: Reagan’s lawyers and the dynamics of political investment. Studies in American Political Development23(1): 61–83.
57.
TerBeekCalvin. 2021. “Clocks must always be turned back”: Brown v. Board of Education and the racial origins of constitutional originalism. American Political Science Review115(3): 821–834.
58.
TotenbergNina (@NinaTotenberg). 11November2022. OMG! #FedSoc tries to muzzle 1 of its own leaders! See transcript of interview I did this A.M. w Steve Calabresi abt his ISL brief at #SCOTUS. X. https://x.com/ninatotenberg/status/1591119064440635396 (accessed 13 August 2024).
59.
TushnetMark. 2004. Constitutional hardball. The John Marshall Law Review37(2): 523–553.
60.
UMass (University of Massachusetts Amherst). 8August2024. Americans widely oppose “Project 2025” according to new UMass Amherst poll. University of Massachusetts Amherst News. Available from www.umass.edu (accessed 9 August 2024).
WaldmanMichael. 10July2024. A dangerous vision for the presidency: Project 2025 proposes a giant leap for authoritarianism. Brennan Center for Justice. Available from www.brennancenter.org (accessed 9 August 2024).
63.
WangHansi Lo. 12August2022. This conservative group helped push a disputed election theory. NPR. Available from www.npr.org (accessed 10 August 2024).
64.
WeaverRichard M.1948. Ideas have consequences. University of Chicago Press.
65.
WheelerRussell. 4June2018. Senate obstructionism handed a raft of judicial vacancies to Trump—What has he done with them?FixGov (blog). Available from www.brookings.edu.
