Kais Saied’s July 2021 power grab in Tunisia is a clear case of democratic backsliding, and the nation’s judiciary, political parties, and civil society organizations have been unable to slow the democratic erosion that is occurring under the Saied regime. I describe the political resistance to backsliding and why it has failed to date, analyzing the roles of specific institutions and individual actors in that resistance. I argue that two key dynamics explain why efforts to mobilize against Saied’s power grab have failed to slow democratic erosion in Tunisia: top-down regime control of key government institutions and a deep popular frustration with the country’s political class, which limited bottom-up mobilization against Saied’s power grab.
Agence Tunis Afrique Presse. 3October2021d. MP Aloui, TV host Amer Ayed arrested over remarks critical to President Saied.
6.
Agence Tunis Afrique Presse. 13December2021e. Saïed announces parliamentary elections for December 17, 2022, and constitutional reform referendum for next July 25.
AlirizaFadil. 17October2022. Saied’s new rules for Tunisia’s elections. Middle East Institute. Available from www.mei.edu.
15.
AlirizaFadil. 26March2024. Saied’s emerging economic strategy for Tunisia. Middle East Institute. Available from www.mei.edu.
16.
AmaraTarek. 6February2022a. Tunisian judges accuse president of seeking control, setting up new struggle. Reuters.
17.
AmaraTarek. 6February2022b. Tunisian president dissolves Supreme Judicial Council. Reuters.
18.
AmaraTarek. 10August2024a. Tunisia’s electoral commission accepts just three candidates for presidential election. Reuters.
19.
AmaraTarek. 2September2024b. Tunisia presidential candidate arrested, three removed from the race. Reuters.
20.
Arab Weekly. 22July2021. Mismanagement of vaccinations exacerbates Tunisia’s political tensions. Available from thearabweekly.com.
21.
Arab Weekly. 28December2022. Tunisia elections authority accused of acting like “media police.” Available from thearabweekly.com.
22.
The Associated Press. 18December2022. There is pressure on the Tunisian president after election turnout was less than 9%. NPR. Available from www.npr.org.
23.
Association Tunisienne de Défense des Libertés Individuelles. 28August2021. Les mesures exceptionnelles jusqu’à quand et quelle issue?Tunis: Association Tunisienne de Défense des Libertés Individuelles. Available from adlitn.org.
24.
BellinEva. 2004. The robustness of authoritarianism in the Middle East: Exceptionalism in comparative perspective. Comparative Politics36 (2): 139–157.
25.
Ben SalahFaïrouz. 19July2022. To vote or not to vote? That is Tunisia’s constitutional question. Middle East Eye.
26.
BermeoNancy. 2016. On democratic backsliding. Journal of Democracy27 (1): 5–19.
27.
Bou NassifHicham. 2022. Coup in Tunisia: Why the military abandoned democracy. Journal of Democracy33 (1): 27–39.
28.
BrooksRisa. 2013. Abandoned at the palace: Why the Tunisian military defected from the Ben Ali regime in January 2011. Journal of Strategic Studies36 (2): 205–220.
29.
Business News (Tunisia). 29March2022a. Abir Moussi saisit la justice pour annuler la plénière du 30 mars. Available from www.businessnews.com.tn.
30.
Business News (Tunisia). 27July2022b. Isie : une erreur s’est glissée dans les documents des résultats préliminaires du référendum. Available from www.businessnews.com.tn.
Deutsche Welle. 30March2022a. Tunisian president announces dissolution of parliament.
33.
Deutsche Welle. 25July2022b. Tunisians vote to give President Saied more power.
34.
do Céu Pinto ArenaMaria. 2024. The US and EU response to Tunisia’s democratic backsliding: Promoting democracy or protecting interests?The International Spectator59 (3): 158–178.
35.
EbelFrancesca. 26July2021a. Tunisia: Rivals hold rallies outside parliament after presidential power grab. Middle East Eye.
36.
EbelFrancesca. 21November2021b. Tunisian trial shines light on use of military courts. Associated Press.
37.
France 24. 8July2021a. Tunisia virus situation catastrophic: health ministry.
38.
France 24. 25July2021b. En Tunisie, des milliers de manifestants défilent contre leurs dirigeants.
39.
France 24. 7September2022. Tunisia opposition to boycott polls, slams electoral law written “by president alone.”
40.
GallCarlotta. 28July2021. Why Tunisia’s promise of democracy struggles to bear fruit. New York Times.
41.
GrewalSharan. 7May2024. Why militaries support presidential coups. Journal of Democracy. Available from www.journalofdemocracy.org.
42.
Human Rights Watch. 27February2023. Tunisia: president intensifies attacks on judicial independence. New York, NY: Human Rights Watch. Available from www.hrw.org.
43.
Human Rights Watch. 20August2024. Tunisia: Prospective presidential candidates barred. New York, NY: Human Rights Watch. Available from www.hrw.org.
KhanHumzah. 9April2024. From Tunis to Cairo: Europe extends its border across North Africa. Carnegie Endowment for International Peace Sada. Available from carnegieendowment.org/sada.
46.
LakhalMalek. 23March2022. The ghost people and populism from above: The Kais Saied case. Arab Reform Initiative. Available from www.arab-reform.net.
MaherAhmed. 26July2021. What is Article 80 of Tunisia’s constitution?The National. Available from www.thenationalnews.com.
49.
Middle East Eye. 30July2021. Tunisia coup: MP Yassine Ayari “abducted by presidential security forces.”
50.
Middle East Monitor. 22July2021. Tunisia: president describes vaccination crowds as a “crime.” Available from www.middleeastmonitor.com.
51.
MohammedAmira. 15September2022. Election for individuals in two rounds: Al-Mansari reveals the details of the election law [trans. from Arabic]. Mosaïque FM. Available from www.mosaiquefm.net.
52.
Mosaïque FM. 30September2021. Des députés appellent à la reprise des activités de l’ARP, demain. Available from www.mosaiquefm.net.
53.
Présidence Tunisie (@Presidence.tn). 19January2022. Announcement: Decree regarding the revision of Basic Law No. 34 of 2016 related to the Supreme Judicial Council [trans. from Arabic]. Facebook. https://www.facebook.com/Presidence.tn/posts/297059225786018
54.
Reuters. 15September2021a. Tunisian president rejects dialogue with “traitors.”
55.
Reuters. 21September2021b. Tunisia military judge jails two members of parliament.
56.
Reuters. 14October2021c. Tunisia withdraws diplomatic passport of ex-leader as Western pressure mounts.
57.
Reuters. 27January2022a. Tunisian opposition leader warns of social explosion.
58.
Reuters. 25February2022b. Tunisia’s Saied will bar foreign funding for civil society.
59.
Reuters. 22April2022c. Tunisian president seizes control of electoral commission.
60.
Reuters. 2June2022d. Tunisian president purges judges after instituting one-man rule.
61.
Reuters. 3December2022e. Tunisia’s powerful labour union rejects December election, attacks president’s agenda.
62.
SchaerCathrinGuizaniTarak. 20September2021. Tunisian crisis: What role for the military?Deutsche Welle.
63.
SorgiGregorioBarigazziJacopo. 17July2023. The EU has revealed its blueprint to curb migration. Politico Europe.
64.
VolkmanEliza. 25November2021. Tunisia’s Interior Ministry takes control of local government. The National. Available from www.thenationalnews.com.
65.
WaldnerDavidLustEllen. 2018. Unwelcome change: Coming to terms with democratic backsliding. Annual Review of Political Science21:93–113.
66.
WathanHabib.2022. Legislative elections: seven constituencies without a candidate, and 10 constituencies with a single candidate [trans. from Arabic]. Mosaïque FM. November3, 2022.
67.
YerkesSarah. 24September2024. How Tunisia’s president has used the law to secure his election victory. Carnegie Endowment for International Peace. Available from carnegieendowment.org.
68.
YerkesSarahal-MailamMohammad. 11October2022. Tunisia’s new electoral law is another blow to its democratic progress. Carnegie Endowment for International Peace. Available from carnegieendowment.org.
