Children of color are overrepresented in the child welfare system, and Black children have been most significantly impacted by this racial disproportionality. Racial disproportionality in child welfare exists because of influences that are both external to child welfare systems and part of the child welfare system. We summarize the causes of racial disproportionality, arguing that internal and external causes of disproportional involvement originate from a common underlying factor: structural and institutional racism that is both within child welfare systems and part of society at large. Further, we review options for addressing racial disproportionality, arguing that it needs to be rectified because of the harm it causes Black children and families and that forcible separation of children from their parents can no longer be viewed as an acceptable form of intervention for families in need.
BairdChristopherWagnerDennis. 2000. The relative validity of actuarial and consensus-based risk assessment systems. Children and Youth Services Review22:839–71.
2.
BarthRichard. 2005. Child welfare and race: Models of disproportionality. In Race matters in child welfare, eds. DerezotesDennettePoertnerJohnTestaMark, 25–46. Washington, DC: Child Welfare League of America Press.
3.
BartholetElizabeth. 2009. The racial disproportionality movement in child welfare: False facts and dangerous directions. Arizona Law Review51:871–932.
4.
BatesJulia. 2016. The role of race in legitimizing institutionalization: A comparative analysis of early child welfare intiatives in the United States. Journal of the History of Childhood and Youth9:15–28.
5.
BellWinifred. 1965. Aid to dependent children. New York, NY: Columbia University Press.
6.
BergerLawrenceFontSarahSlackKristenWaldfogelJane. 2017. Income and child maltreatment in unmarried families: Evidence from the Earned Income Tax Credit. Review of Economics of the Household15:1345–72.
7.
CancianMariaYangMi-YounSlackKristen. 2013. The effect of additional child support income on the risk of child maltreatment. Social Service Review87:417–37.
8.
Casey Family Programs. 2009. Breakthrough series collaborative: Reducing racial disproportionality and disparate outcomes for children and families of color in the child welfare system. Washington, DC: Casey Family Programs.
9.
Center for the Study of Social Policy. 2019. Key equity terms and concepts. Washington, DC: Center for the Study of Social Policy. Available from www.cssp.org.
10.
ChettyRajHendrenNathanielJonesMaggiePorterSonya. 2018. Race and economic opportunity in the United States: An intergenerational perspective. Cambridge, MA: National Bureau of Economic Research.
11.
Child Welfare Information Gateway. 2018. Placement of children with relatives. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Children’s Bureau.
12.
CooperTanya A.2014. Commentary on chapter 2. In Civil rights in American law, history, and politics, ed. SaratAustin, 64–112. New York, NY: Cambridge University Press.
13.
CourtneyMarkDworskyAmyBrownAdamCaryColleenLoveKaraVorhiesVanessa. 2011. Midwest evaluation of the adult functioning of former foster youth: Outcomes at ages 26. Chicago, IL: Chapin Hall.
14.
DeGruyJoy. 2005. Post traumatic slave syndrome: America’s legacy of enduring injury and healing. Milwaukie, OR: Uptone Press.
15.
DettlaffAlanRivauxStephanieBaumannDonaldFlukeJohnRycraftJoanJamesJoyce. 2011. Disentangling substantiation: The influence of race, income, and risk on the substantiation decision in child welfare. Children and Youth Services Review33:1630–37.
16.
DettlaffAlanRycraftJoan. 2008. Deconstructing disproportionality: Views from multiple community stakeholders. Child Welfare87:37–58.
17.
DettlaffAlanRycraftJoan. 2010. Factors contributing to disproportionality in the child welfare system: Views from the legal community. Social Work55:213–24.
18.
DrakeBrettJolleyJenniferLanierPaulFlukeJohnBarthRichardJonson-ReidMelissa. 2011. Racial bias in child protection? A comparison of competing explanations using national data. Pediatrics127:471–78.
19.
DrakeBrettJonson-ReidMelissaOcampoMaría GandarillaMorrisonMariaDvalishvilDaji. 2021. A practical framework for considering the use of predictive risk modeling in child welfare. The ANNALS of the American Academy of Political and Social Science (this volume).
20.
DrakeBrettLeeSang MooJonson-ReidMelissa. 2009. Race and child maltreatment reporting: Are Blacks overrepresented?Children and Youth Services Review31:309–16.
21.
EberhardtJennifer. 2019. Biased: Uncovering the hidden prejudice that shapes what we see, think, and do. New York, NY: Viking.
22.
FlukeJohnHardenBrenda JonesJenkinsMollyRuehrdanzAshleigh. 2011. Disparities and disproportionality in child welfare: Analysis of the research. Washington, DC: Center for the Study of Social Policy.
23.
FlukeJohnYuanYing-YingHeddersonJohnCurtisPatrick. 2003. Disproportionate representation of race and ethnicity in child maltreatment: Investigation and victimization. Children and Youth Services Review25:359–73.
24.
FontSarahBergerLawrenceCancianMaria. 2018. Permanency and the educational and economic attainment of former foster children in emerging adulthood. American Sociological Review83:716–43.
25.
FontSarahBergerLawrenceSlackKristen. 2012. Examining racial disproportionality in child protective services case decisions. Children and Youth Services Review34:2188–2200.
26.
FontSarahCancianMariaBergerLawrence. 2019. Prevalence and risk factors for early motherhood among low-income, maltreated, and foster youth. Demography56:261–84.
27.
GeronimusArlineHickenMargaretKeeneDanyaBoundJohn. 2006. “Weathering” and age patterns of allostatic load scores among Blacks and Whites in the United States. American Journal of Public Health96:826–33.
28.
GouldElise. 2019. State of working America wages 2018. Washington, DC: Economic Policy Institute.
29.
HanksAngelaSolomonDanyelleWellerChristian. 2018. Systemic inequality: How America’s structural racism helped create the Black-White wealth gap. Washington, DC: Center for American Progress.
30.
Hannah-JonesNikole. 2019. 1619 Project. New York Times Magazine.
31.
HardenBrenda JonesSimonsCassandraJohnson-MotoyamaMichelleBarthRichard. 2021. The child maltreatment prevention landscape: Where are we now, and where should we go?The ANNALS of the American Academy of Political and Social Science (this volume).
32.
HarrisMarianHackettWanda. 2008. Decision points in child welfare: An action research model to address disproportionality. Children and Youth Services Review30:199–215.
33.
HinesAliceLemonKathyWyattPaigeMerdingerJoan. 2004. Factors related to the disproportionate involvement of children of color in the child welfare system: A review and emerging themes. Children and Youth Services Review26:507–27.
34.
HopeElanHoggardLoriThomasAlvin. 2015. Emerging into adulthood in the face of racial discrimination: Physiological, psychological, and sociopolitical consequences for African American youth. Translational Issues in Psychological Science1:342–51.
35.
HymelKentLaskeyAntoinetteCrowellKathrynWangMingArmijo-GarciaVeronicaFrazierTerraTievesKellyFosterRobinWeeksKerri. 2018. Racial and ethnic disparities and bias in the evaluation and reporting of abusive head trauma. Journal of Pediatrics198:137–43.
36.
Institute of Medicine and National Research Council. 2014. New directions in child abuse and neglect research. Washington, DC: The National Academies Press.
37.
JamesShermanKeenanNoraStrogatzDavidBrowningStevenGarrettJoanne. 1992. Socioeconomic status, John Henryism, and blood pressure in Black adults: The Pitt County study. American Journal of Epidemiology135:59–67.
38.
JennyCaroleHymelKentRitzenAleneReinertStevenHayThomas. 1999. Analysis of missed cases of abusive head trauma. Journal of the American Medical Association282:621–26.
39.
KendiIbram. 2019. How to be an antiracist. New York, NY: One World.
KIDS Count. 2020. Black children continue to be disproportionately represented in foster care. Available from https://datacenter.kidscount.org/.
42.
KimHyuilDrakeBrett. 2018. Child maltreatment risk as a function of poverty and race/ethnicity in the USA. International Journal of Epidemiology47:780–87.
43.
KramerAbigail. 2018. Child welfare surge continues: Family court cases, emergency child removals remain up. New York, NY: New School Center for New York City Affairs.
44.
KraseKathryn. 2013. Difference in racially disproportionate reporting of child maltreatment across report sources. Jouranl of Public Child Welfare7:351–69.
45.
KraseKathryn. 2015. Child maltreatment reporting by educational personnel: Implications for racial disproportionality in the child welfare system. Children & Schools37:89–99.
46.
LaneWendyRubinDavidMonteithRaginChristianCindy. 2002. Racial differences in the evaluation of pediatric fractures for physical abuse. Journal of the American Medical Association288:1603–9.
47.
Lassiter v. Department of Social Services, 452 U.S. 18 (1981).
48.
LauritsenJanet. 2005. Racial and ethnic difference in juvenile offending. In Our children, their children, eds. HawkinsDarnellKempf-LeonardKimberly, 83–104. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
49.
Lawrence-WebbClaudia. 1997. African American children in the modern child welfare system: A legacy of the Flemming rule. Child Welfare76:9–30.
50.
LemonKathyD’AndradeAmyAustinMichael. 2008. Understanding and addressing racial/ethnic disparities in the front end of the child welfare system. Journal of Evidence-Based Social Work5:9–30.
51.
LindbergDanielShapiroRobertLaskeyAntoinettePallinDanielBloodEmilyBergerRachel. 2012. Prevalence of abusive injuries in siblings and household contacts of physically abused children. Pediatrics130:193–201.
52.
Maguire-JackKathrynFontSarahDillardRebecca. 2020. Child protective services decision-making: The role of children’s race and county factors.American Journal of Orthopsychiatry90:48–62.
53.
MerrittDarcey. 2021. How do families experience and interact with CPS?The ANNALS of the American Academy of Political and Social Science (this volume).
54.
Michigan Department of Human Services. 2006. Equity: Moving toward better outcomes for all of Michigan’s children. Lansing, MI: Michigan Department of Human Services.
55.
MillerKevaCahnKatherineOrellanaE. Roberto. 2012. Dynamics that contribute to racial disproportionality and disparity: Perspectives from child welfare professionals, community partners, and families. Children and Youth Services Review34:2201–7.
56.
MillerMarna. 2008. Racial disproportionality in Washington State’s child welfare system. Olympia, WA: Washington State Institute for Public Policy.
57.
MillerOrondeEsenstadAmelia. 2015. Strategies to reduce racially disparate outcomes in child welfare. Washington, DC: Center for the Study of Social Policy.
58.
MitchellMoniqueKuczynskiLeon. 2009. Does anyone know what is going on? Examining children’s lived experience of the transition into foster care. Children and Youth Services Review32:437–44.
59.
National Child Traumatic Stress Network. 2016. Racial injustice and trauma: African Americans in the U.S. Washington DC: National Child Traumatic Stress Network.
60.
O’ConnorStephen. 2004. Orphan trains: The story of Charles Loring Brace and the children he saved and failed. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
61.
ParadiesYinBenJehonathanDensonNidaEliasAmanuelPriestNaomiPieterseAlexGuptaArpanaKelaherMargaretGeeGilbert. 2015. Racism as a determinant of health: A systematic review and meta-analysis. PloS One10(9).
62.
PecoraPeterKesslerRonaldWilliamsJasonO’BrienKirkDownsA. ChrisEnglishDianaWhiteJames, et al2005. Improving family foster care: Findings from the Northwest Foster Care Alumni Study. Seattle, WA: Casey Family Programs.
63.
PeltonLeroy. 2015. The continuing role of material factors in child maltreatment and placement. Child Abuse & Neglect41:30–39.
64.
Putnam-HornsteinEmilyNeedellBarbaraKingBrynJohnson-MotoyamaMichelle. 2013. Racial and ethnic disparities: A population-based examination of risk factors for involvement with child protective services. Child Abuse & Neglect37:33–46.
65.
RivauxStephanieJamesJoyceWittenstromKimBaumannDonaldSheetsJanessHenryJudithJeffriesVictoria. 2008. The intersection of race, poverty, and risk: Understanding the decision to provide services to clients and to remove children. Child Welfare87:151–68.
66.
RobertsDorothy. 2002. Shattered bonds: The color of child welfare. New York, NY: Civitas.
67.
RothsteinRichard. 2017. The color of law: A forgotten history of how our government segregated America. New York, NY: Liveright Publishing.
68.
RoygardnerDebangshuHughesKelli N.PalusciVincent J.2021. Leveraging family and community strengths to reduce child maltreatment. The ANNALS of the American Academy of Political and Social Science (this volume).
69.
RuddenJennifer. 2019. Homeownership rate in the U.S. 2019, by ethnicity. Available from www.statista.com.
70.
SankaranVivekChurchChristopherMitchellMonique. 2019. A cure worse than the disease? The impact of removal on children and their families. Marquette Law Review102:1163–94.
71.
SedlakAndreaMettenburgJaneBasenaMonicaPettaIanMcPhersonKarlaGreeneAngelaLiSpencer. 2010. Fourth National Incidence Study of Child Abuse and Neglect (NIS–4). Washington, DC: Department of Health and Human Services, Administration for Children and Families.
72.
SemegaJessicaKollarMelissaCreamerJohnMohantyAbinash. 2019. Current population reports, P60-266, income and poverty in the United States: 2018. Washington, DC: U.S. Government Printing Office.
73.
SheetsJanessWittenstromKimFongRowenaJamesJoyceTecciMichaleBaumannDoanldRodriguezCarolyne. 2009. Evidence-based practice in family group decision-making for Anglo, African American and Hispanic families. Children and Youth Services Review31:1187–91.
74.
ShollenbergerTracey. 2015. Racial disparities in school suspension and subsequent outcomes. In Closing the school discipline gap, ed. LosenDaniel, 31–43. New York, NY: Teachers College Press.
75.
SlackKristenBergerLawrenceDuMontKimberlyYangMi-YounKimBomiEhrhard-DietzelSusanHollJane. 2011. Risk and protective factors for child neglect during early childhood: A cross-study comparison. Children and Youth Services Review33:1354–63.
76.
SlackKristenLeeBong JooBergerLawrence. 2007. Do welfare sanctions increase child protective services involvement? A cautious answer. Social Service Review81:207–28.
77.
SotoJoséDawson-AndohNanaBeLueRhonda. 2011. The relationship between perceived discrimination and generalized anxiety disorder among African Americans, Afro Caribbeans, and non-Hispanic Whites.Journal of Anxiety Disorders25:258–65.
78.
Stanford Center on Poverty and Inequality. 2017. State of the union: The poverty and inequality report. Stanford, CA: Stanford Center on Poverty and Inequality.
79.
SummersAliciaWoodSteveRussellJesse. 2012. Disproportionality rates for children of color in foster care. Reno, NV: National Council of Juvenile and Family Court Judges.
80.
TestaMark. 2002. Subsidized guardianship: Testing an idea whose time has finally come. Social Work Research26:145–58.
81.
Texas Health and Human Services Commission. 2006. Disproportionality in child protective services: Statewide reform effort begins with examination of the problem. Austin, TX: Texas Health and Human Services Commission.
82.
U.S. Government Accountability Office. 2007. Black children in foster care: Additional HHS assistance needed to help states reduce the proportion in care. Washington, DC: U.S. Government Accountability Office.
83.
WilliamsDavidLawrenceJourdynDavisBrigette. 2019. Racism and health: evidence and needed research.Annual Review of Public Health40:105–12.
84.
WilliamsHeather. 2012. Help me to find my people: The African American search for family lost in slavery. Chapel Hill, NC: University of North Carolina Press.
85.
ZimmermanFrancieMercyJames. 2010. A better start: Child maltreatment prevention as a public health priority. Zero to Three30:4–10.
