Police compliance with the law is one of the most important aspects of a democratic society. Americans expect the police to enforce laws to promote safety and to reduce crime, victimization, and fear, but no one believes that the police should have unlimited power to do so. We expect police to enforce laws fairly according to law and rules that circumscribe their enforcement powers. The existence of these rules justify the claim that police are a rule-bound institution engaged in the pursuit of justice and the protection of individual liberties, as well as the battle against crime. This article reviews research on the extent to which police follow laws and rules, especially constitutional criminal procedure rules, addressing seizures, searches, interrogations, and deadly force. Also reviewed is research pertaining to police adherence to rules governing excessive force, corruption, and racial profiling.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Black, Donald, and Albert J. Reiss Jr. 1967. Interrogation and the criminal process . The Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science374: 47-57 .
2.
Cassell, Paul G., and Bret S. Hayman. 1996. Dialog on Miranda-police interrogation in the 1990s: An empirical study of the effects of Miranda . UCLA Law Review43: 840-929 .
3.
City of New York, Commissionto Investigate Allegations of Police Corruption. 1973. The Knapp Commission report on police corruption. New York: George Braziller .
4.
City of New York, Commission to Investigate Allegations of Police Corruption and the Anti-Corruption Procedures of the Police Department. 1994. Mollen Commission report. New York: Mollen Commission .
5.
Fagan, Jeffrey, and Garth Davies. 2000. Street stops and broken windows: Terry, race and disorder in New York City . Fordham Urban Law Journal28: 457-482 .
6.
Fyfe, James J. 1979. Administrative interventions on police shooting discretion: An empirical examination . Journal of Criminal Justice7: 309-323 .
7.
Fyfe, James J. 1982. Blind justice: Police shootings in Memphis . Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology73: 702-722 .
8.
Fyfe, James J. 2002. Too many missing cases: Holes in our knowledge about police use of force . Justice Research and Policy4: 87-102 .
9.
Garner, Joel H., and Christopher D. Maxwell. 1999. Measuring the amount of force used by and against the police in six jurisdictions. In Use of force by police: Overview of national and local data, edited by Jeremy Travis, Jan M. Chaiken, and Robert J. Kaminski, 25-44. Washington, DC: National Institute of Justice and Bureau of Justice Statistics .
10.
Gould, Jon B., and Stephen D. Mastrofski. Forthcoming. Suspect searches: Assessing police behavior under the U.S. Constitution. Criminology and Public Policy.
11.
Klockars, Carl B., Sanja Kutnjak Ivkovich, William E. Harver, and Maria R. Haberfeld. 2000. The measurement of police integrity. Washington, DC: National Institute of Justice .
12.
Leo, Richard. 1996. The impact of Mirandarevisited . Journal of CriminalLawand Criminology86: 621-693
13.
Manning, Peter K., and Lawrence J. Redlinger. 1977. Invitational edges of corruption: Some consequences of narcotics law enforcement. In Drugs and politics, edited by Paul Rock, 279-310. Rutgers, NJ: Transaction Books .
14.
Meares, Tracey L., and Bernard E. Harcourt. 2000. Transparent adjudication and social science research in constitutional criminal procedure . Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology90: 733-769 .
15.
Meyer, Marshall W. 1980. Police shootings of minorities: The case of Los Angeles . The Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science452: 98-110 .
16.
Milton, Catherine H., Jeanne W. Halleck, James Lardner, and Gary Albrecht. 1977. Police use of deadly force. Washington, DC: Police Foundation .
17.
New York Office of the Attorney General. 1999. The New York City Police Department’s “stop& frisk” practice: A report from the Office of the Attorney General. New York: Author .
18.
Patton, Alison L. 1993. The endless cycle of abuse: Why 42 U.S.C. § 1983 is ineffective in deterring police brutality . Hastings Law Journal44: 753-768 .
19.
Robin, Gerald. 1963. Justifiable homicide by police officers . Journal of Criminal Law, Criminology, and Police Science54: 225-254 .
20.
Sherman, Lawrence W. 1978. Scandal and reform: Controlling police corruption. Berkeley: University of California Press .
21.
Sutton, Peter. 1986. Fourth Amendment in action: An empirical view of the search warrant process . Criminal Law Bulletin22: 405-429 .
22.
Sparger, Jerry R., and David J. Giacopassi. 1992. Memphis revisited: A reexamination of police shootings after the Garnerdecision . Police Quarterly9: 211-225 .
23.
Tennenbaum, Abraham N. 1994. The influence of the Garnerdecision on police use of lethal force . Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology85: 241-260 .
24.
Uchida, Craig D., and Timothy S. Bynum. 1991. Search warrants, motions to suppress, and “lost cases”: The effects of the exclusionary rule in seven jurisdictions . Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology81: 1034-1066 .
25.
U.S. General Accounting Office. 1998. Law enforcement: Information on drug-related police corruption. Washington, DC: Author .
26.
Walker, Samuel. 2001a. The trees and the forest: Reflections on whether American policing has improved over time. Unpublished manuscript, University of Nebraska–Omaha.
27.
Walker, Samuel. 2001b. Police accountability: The role of citizen oversight. Belmont, CA: Wadsworth .
28.
Walker, Samuel. 2001c. Problems with traffic stop data and an early warning system solution . Justice Research and Policy3: 63-95 .
