The subjective poverty line methodology derives a poverty line from responses to a question asking people how much money they need in order to make ends meet. In this paper, we explore the relevance and implications of this approach using sample survey data for Australia and Sweden derived specifically for this purpose. We apply identical techniques to the two sets of data and compare and contrast the resulting poverty lines, before exploring their sensitivity to changes in the methods used to derive them. Finally, analysis focuses on a companson of the characteristics of those families in each country whose incomes are below the subjective poverty line.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Bryson, L.1988. Welfare's Losing Battles. Australian Left Review No. 107, 32-35.
2.
Buhmann, B., Rainwater, L., Schmaus, G. & Smeeding T.M.1988. Equivalence Scales, Well-Being, Inequality, and Poverty: Sensitivity Estimates Across Ten Countries Using the Luxembourg Income Study (LIS) Database. Review of Income and Wealth34(2), 115-142.
3.
Callan, T. & Nolan, B.1991. Concepts of Poverty and the Poverty Line. Journal of Economic Surveys5(3), 243-261.
4.
Callan, T., Nolan, B., Whelan, B.J., Hannan, D.F. & Creighton, S.1989. Poverty, Income and Welfare in IrelandDublin: Economic and Social Research Institute .
5.
Cass, B.1986. The Case for Review of Aspects of the Australian Social Security System Background/Discussion Paper No. 1, Social Security Review, Department of Social Security, Canberra .
6.
Castles, F.G.1985. The Working Class and Welfare. Reflections on the Political Development of the Welfare State in Australia and New Zealand, 1890-1980. Sydney: Allen & Unwin.
7.
Colasanto, D., Kapteyn, A. & van der Gaag, J.1984. Two Subjective Definitions of Poverty: Results from the Wisconsin Basic Needs Study. Journal of Human Resources19(1), 127-138.
8.
Commission of Inquiry into Poverty.1975. First Main Report. Poverty in Australia. Canberra : AGPS.
9.
Danziger, S., van der Gaag, J., Taussig, M.K. & Smolensky, E.1984. The Direct Measurement of Welfare Levels: How Much Does it Cost to Make Ends Meet? Review of Economics and Statistics6(3), 500-505.
10.
Deleeck, H. & Van den Bosch, K.1992. Poverty and Adequacy of Social Security in Europe: A Comparative Analysis. Journal of European Social Policy2(2), 107-120.
11.
Enkson, R. & Åberg, R.1987. Welfare in Transition. A Survey of Living Conditions in Sweden 1968-1981. Oxford: Clarendon Press.
12.
Esping-Andersen, G.1990. The Three Worlds of Welfare Capitalism. Cambridge: Polity Press
13.
Gallagher, P.1985. Targeting Welfare Expenditures on the Poor: Work in Progress on Poverty in Australia, 1981-82. Social Security Journal , December, 19-34.
14.
Goedhart, T., Halberstadt, V., Kapteyn, A. & Van Praag, B.1977. The Poverty Line Concept and Measurement. Journal of Human Resources12(4), 503-520.
15.
Gustafsson, B.1984. En Bok om fattigdom. Lund: Archiv Forlag.
16.
Gustafsson, B. & Lindblom, M.1993. Poverty Lines and Poverty in Seven European Countnes, Australia, Canada and the USA. Journal of European Social Policy3(1), 21-38.
17.
Hagenaars, A.1986. The Perception of Poverty. Amsterdam : North Holland Publishing Company.
18.
Hagenaars, A. & de Vos, K.1988. The Definition and Measurement of Poverty. Journal of Human Resources23(2), 211-221.
19.
Hallerod, B.1991. Den Svenska Fattigdomen: En Studie av Fattigdom och Socialbidragstagande . Lund: Arkiv Forlag.
20.
Halleröd, B. et al. 1993. Konsensuell Fattigdom- En Studie av Konsumtion och Attityder till Konsumtion. Umeå Studies in Sociology No. 104, University of Umeå.
21.
Kapteyn, A., Kooreman, P. & Willemse, R.1988. Some Methodological Issues in the Implementation of Subjective Poverty Definitions. Journal of Human Resources23(2), 222-242.
22.
King, A.1991. Poverty Measurement in Australia: Towards a New Consensus . Australian Quarterly, Spring, 235-246.
23.
Korpi, W.1985. Economic Growth and the Welfare State: Leaky Bucket or Irrigation System? European Sociological Review1 (2), 97-118.
24.
McAlister, C., Ingles, D. & Tune, D.1981. General Revenue Financing of Social Security: The Australian Minimum Income Support System. Social Security Journal, December, 24-38.
25.
Marklund, S.1988. Paradise Lost? The Nordic Welfare States and the Recession 1975-1985. Lund: Arkiv Forlag.
26.
Marklund, S. & Svallfors, S.1987. Dual Welfare: Segmentation and Work Enforcement in the Swedish Welfare System. Research Report No. 94, Department of Sociology, University of Umeå.
27.
Mitchell, D.1991. Income Transfers in Ten Welfare States. Aldershot: Avebury.
28.
Muffels, R., Bergham, J. & Dirven, H.J.1992. A Multi-Method Approach to Monitor the Evolution of Poverty . Journal of European Social Policy2(3), 193-213.
29.
Oecd.1988. Aging Populations: The Social Policy Implications. Pans: OECD.
30.
Oecd1992. National Accounts: Deratled Tables, Volume I. Pans: OECD
31.
O'Higgins, M. & Jenkins, S.1990. Poverty in the EC: Estimates for 1975, 1980 and 1985. In R. Teekens & B. Van Praag (eds.), Analysing Poverty in the European Community , pp. 187-212. Luxembourg: Eurostat News Special Edition, Office for Official Publications of the European Communities.
32.
Persson, I.1990. Generating Equality in the Welfare State. Oslo: Norwegian University Press.
33.
Rainwater, L.1990. Poverty and Equivalence as Social Constructions Working Paper No. 55, Luxembourg Income Study, CEPS at Luxembourg.
34.
Ringen, S.1987The Possibility of Politics. A Study in the Political Economy of the Welfare State. Oxford: Clarendon Press.
35.
Room, G., Lawson, R. & Laczko, F.1989. 'New Poverty' in the European Community. Policy and Politics17(2), 165-176.
36.
Saunders, P.1993. The Economy, Economists and the Welfare State: Crisis or Crusade? In P. Saunders & S. Graham (eds.), Beyond Economic Rationalism: Alternative Futures for Social Policy, pp. 33-70. SPRC Reports and Proceedings No. 105. Sydney : Social Policy Research Centre, University of New South Wales.
37.
Saunders, P. & Bradbury, B.1991. Some Australian Evidence on the Consensual Approach to Poverty Measurement. Economic Analysis and Policy21(1), 47-78.
38.
Saunders, P. & Matheson, G.1991. An Ever-Rising Tide? Poverty in Australia in the Eighties . Economic and Industrial Relations Review2(2), 143-171.
39.
Saunders, P. & Matheson, G.1992. Perceptions of Poverty, Income Adequacy and Living Standards in Australia. SPRC Reports and Proceedings No. 99, Sydney : Social Policy Research Centre, University of New South Wales.
40.
Saunders, P. & Whiteford, P.1991. Assessing Recent Australian Social Security Developments and Reform Proposals. In F. H. Gruen (ed.), Australian Economic Policy. Conference Proceedings, pp. 119-196. Canberra: Centre for Economic Policy Research, Australian National University.
41.
Smeeding, T. & Torrey, B.1988. Poor Children in Rich Countries. Science No.242, 873-877.
42.
Smeeding, T., Torrey, B. & Rein, M.1988. Levels of Well-Being and Poverty Among the Elderly and Children in the U.S. and Other Major Countries. In J. Palmer, T. Smeeding & B. Torrey (eds.), The Vulnerable: America's Young and Old in the Industrial World, pp. 89-119. Washington DC : The Urban Institute.
43.
Stanton, D.1980. The Henderson Poverty Line-A Critique. Social Security Journal, December, 14-24.
44.
Stattin, M.1993. Datamaterial och Bortfall. In B. Halleröd et al., Konsensuell Fattigdom- En Studie av Konsumtion och Attityder till Konsumtion. Umeå Studies in Sociology No. 104, University of Umeå.
45.
Townsend, P. & Gordon, D.1991. What Is Enough? New Evidence on Poverty Allowing the Definition of a Minimum Benefit. In M. Adler, C. Bell, J. Classen & A. Sinfield (eds.), The Sociology of Social Security, pp. 35-69. Edinburgh : Edinburgh University Press.
46.
Van Praag, B.M.S., Hagenaars, A. & van Weeren, J.1982. Poverty in Europe. Review of Income and Wealth28(3), 345-359.
47.
Van denBosch, K., Callan, T., Estivill, J., Hausman, P., Jeandidier, B., Muffels, R. & Yfantopoulos, J.1993. A Comparison of Poverty in Seven European Countries and Regions Using Subjective and Relative Measures . Journal of Population Economics No.3, 235-259.
48.
Walker, R.1987. Consensual Approaches to the Definition of Poverty: Towards an Alternative Methodology. Journal of Social Policy16(2), 213-226.
