The paper reviews Durkheim's theory of suicide, with particular reference to his treat ment of alcohol as a causal factor. It is argued that Durkheim views alcohol as an individual-level factor, rather than as a socio-cultural factor on a par with other social facts This conception is criticized, as is Durkheim's analysis of his data It is argued that the rate of alcohol abuse in society is a social fact that has an explanatory power beyond the level of individual suicides. Some possible causal links between the social suicide rate and rates of alcohol abuse are discussed.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Bacon, S.D.1945Alcoholism and Social Isolation In M. Bell (ed.), Cooperation in Crime Control.New York: National Probation Association.
2.
Bruun. K. et al.1975Alcohol Control Policies in Public Health PerspectiveHelsinki : Finnish Foundation for Alcohol Studies.
3.
Cahalan, D. & Room, R.1974. Problem Drinking Among American MenNew Brunswick, N.J.: Rutgers Center of Alcohol Studies .
4.
Cloninger, C.R. , Bohman, M. & Sigvardsson, S.1981Inheritance of Alcohol Abuse: Crossfostenng Analysis of Adopted MenArchive of Gen. Psychiatry38, 861-868
5.
Cloninger, C.R., Sigvardsson, S. & Bohman, M.1988. Childhood Personality Predicts Alcohol Abuse in Young AdultsAlcoholism Clinical and Experimental Research12, 494-505.
6.
Durkheim, E.1966. SuicideNew York. The Free Press
7.
Elekes, Z.1988. Relationship Between the Regional Differences of Alcoholism and SuicidePaper presented at the 14th Annual Alcohol Epidemiology Symposium, Berkeley, June 1988.
8.
Edwards, G. , Gross, M. M. , Keller, M., Moser, J. & Room, R.1977. Alcohol-related DisabilitiesGeneva: World Health Organization.
9.
Goodwin, D.1976. Is Alcoholism Hereditary?NY: Oxford University Press.
10.
Gove, W. & Hughes, M.1980. Re-examining the Ecological Fallacy: A Study in Which Aggregated Data are Critical in Investigating the Pathological Effects of Living AloneSocial Forces58, 1157-1177.
11.
Gustafson, R.1986. Alcohol and Human Physical Aggression the Mediating Role of FrustrationUppsala: University of Uppsala
12.
Hornqvist, J.O., Hansson, B. & Åkerlind, I.1988. The Working Capacity of the Alcohol AbuserScandinavian Journal of Social Medicine16, 27-33.
13.
Jellinek, E.M.1960. The Disease Concept of AlcoholismNew Haven: Hillhouse Press.
14.
Ledermann, S.1956Alcool, Alcoolism, AlcoolisationParis : Presses Universitaires de France
15.
Lenke, L.1989. Alcohol and Criminal Violence. Time Series Analyses in a Comparative PerspectiveEdsbruk: Akademitrykk.
16.
MacAndrew, C. & Edgerton, R.B.1969Drunken ComportmentA Social Explanation.Chicago.
17.
Makela, K.1975Consumption Level and Cultural Drinking Patterns as Determinants of Alcohol ProblemsJournal of Drug Issues5, 344-357.
18.
Mayfield, D.G. & Montgomery, D.1972. Alcoholism, Alcohol Intoxication, and Suicide AttemptsArchive of Gen. Psychiatry27, 349-353.
19.
Mowrer, H.R. & Mowrer, E.R.1945. Ecological and Familial Factors Associated with InebrietyQuarterly Journal of Studies on Alcohol6, 36-44.
20.
Norstrom, T.1988. Alcohol and Suicide in ScandinaviaBritish Journal of Addiction83, 553-559.
21.
Norström, T.1960. Alcohol and Suicide - A Neglected LinkPaper presented at the 16th Annual Alcohol Epidemiology Symposium, Budapest, June 1990.
22.
Partanen, J., Bruun, K. & Markkanen, T.1966. Inheritance of Drinking BehaviorHelsinki: Finnish Foundation for Alcohol Studies.
23.
Phillips, D.P.1974. The Influence of Suggestion on SuicideAmerican Sociological Review39, 340-354.
24.
Phillips, D.P.1979. Suicide, Motor Vehicle Fatalities, and the Mass MediaAmerican Journal of Sociology, 84, 1150-1174.
25.
Phillips, L.A.1976. An Application of Anomy Theory to the Study of AlcoholismJournal of Studies on Alcohol37, 78-84.
26.
Popham, R.E.1970. Indirect Methods of Alcoholism Prevalence Estimation In R. E. Popham (ed ), Alcohol and Alcoholism.Toronto: Toronto University Press.
27.
Singer, E.Blane, H.T. & Kasschau, T.1964. Alcoholism and Social IsolationJournal of Abnormal and Social Psychology69, 681-685.
28.
Skog, O.J.1979. Modeller for DrikkeatferdOslo: National Institute for Alcohol Research.
29.
Skog, O.J.1980. Social Interaction and the Distribution of Alcohol Consumption . Journal of Drug Issues10, 71-92.
30.
Skog, O.J.1985a. The Collectivity of Drinking Cultures. A Theory of the Distribution of Alcohol ConsumptionBritish Journal of Addiction80, 83-99.
31.
Skog, O.J.1985b. The Wetness of Drinking Cultures: A Key Variable in Epidemiology of Alcoholic Liver CirrhosisActa Medica Scandinavica Supplement703, 157-184.
32.
Skog, O.J.1986The Long Waves of Alcohol Consumption - A Social Network Perspective on Cultural ChangeSocial Networks8, 1-32.
33.
Skog, O.J.1989The Socio-cultural Foundation of Drinking Problems In R B. Waahlberg (ed.), Proceedings of the 35th International Congress on Alcoholism and Drug Dependence. Oslo. National Directorate for the Prevention of Alcohol and Drug Problems.
34.
Stack, S.1982. Suicide: A Decade Review of the Sociological LiteratureDeviant Behavior4, 41-66.
