Morality in Three Social Theories: Parsons,Analytical Marxism and Habermas

Abstract

The current growth in sociological works on morality is generating topical fundamental metatheoretical and philosophical questions concerning the relationship between sociological theory and ethics - descriptive and nor mative ethics and meta ethics It is commonly accepted that sociological theory can include descriptive ethics On the other hand, the relationship to normative ethics and meta ethics has been very much disputed or ambiguous The article analyses the position, of three representative and significant theories concerning this question Parsons' theories of social action and social systems. Analytical Marxism and Habermas's theory of communicative action and his discourse ethics The basic point ot departure is that if sociological theory and ethics are to maintain a stable position, it is imperative to incorporate the double role of sociology as a spectator and a participator in collective self-reflection and enlightenment in societv

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Alexander, J. 1984 Theoretical Logic in Sociology Vol 4 London. Routledge & Kegan Paul

Alexy. R. 1978: Eine Theorie des praktischen Diskurses In W Oelmuller (ed), Normbegrundung, Normdurchsetzung Paderborn.

Andersen, H. 1988: Rationalitet, velfœrd og retfœrdighed København Nyt Nordisk Forlag

Andersen, H. (forthcoming): Social orden, rationalitet og livsverden In P. Gundelach et al.

(ed ), Sociologiske teorier under forandring. København: Gyldendal .

Berger, P.L. & Luckmann, T. 1967: The Social Construction of Reality New York- Anchor Books

Bowles, S. & Gintis, H. 1987 Democracy and Capitalism London

Routledge & Kegan Paul

Brante, T. 1988: Moralfilosolins elande Om den moderna moraldiskursens metafysiske antaganden och ideologiska slutsatser VEST , s3-31

Cohen, G.A. 1980: Karl Marx's Theory of History. A Defence Princeton Princeton University Press

10.

Cohen, G.A. 1981: Freedom, Justice and Capitalism New Left Review 126.

11.

Cohen. G.A. 1983

The Structure of Proletarian Unfreedom

Philosophy & Public Affairs 12.

12.

Cohen, G.A. 1985: Are Workers Forced to Sell their Labor Power? Philosophy, & Public Affairs 14.

13.

14.

Elster, J. & Hylland, A 1986 (eds.) Foundations of Social Choice Theory Cambridge: Cambridge University Press/Oslo. Universitetsforlaget

15.

Eriksson, B. 1988. Den skotska historiska skolan och den sociologiska samhallsanalysens genombrott In M. Bertilsson och B. Hansson (eds.), Samhallsvetenskapens klassiker. Lund: Studentlitteratur

16.

Etzioni A. 1988 The Moral Dimension New York The Free Press.

17.

Habermas. J. 1981 Theorie des kommunikativen Handelns Frankfurt a M.: Suhrkamp.

18.

Habermas. J. 1983 Moralhewusstein und kommunikatives Handeln Frankfurt a M.: Suhrkamp

19.

20.

Habermas, J. 1986 Entgegnung In A Honneth & H Joas (eds), Kommunikativen Handeln. Frankfurt a M Suhrkamp.

21.

Habermas, J. & Nielsen, T. H 1990: Morality. Society and Ethics-an Interview with Torben Hviid Nielsen Acta Soctologica 33. 93-114

22.

Halfpenny, P. 1981: Two-Variable and Three-Variable Functional Explanation Philosophy of the Social Sciences 11.

23.

24.

Lukes. S. 1987: Marxism and Morality Oxford Oxford University Press

25.

26.

Merton. R.K. 1968: Manifest and Latent Functions. Social Theory and Social Structure New York The Free Press

27.

Parsons. T. 1964a: The Structure of Social Action New York The Free Press (1937)

28.

Parsons, T. 1964b- The Social System N.Y.: The Free Press (1951).

29.

30.

Parsons, T. 1978: Action Theory and the Human Condition New York The Free Press.

31.

Parsons, T. & Shils, E. 1951 Toward a General Theory of Action Cambridge, Mass : Harvard University Press

32.

Parsons. T. & Platt, G. 1974 The American University Cambridge Mass. : Harvard University Press.

33.

Phillips, D.L. 1986: Toward a Just Social Order Princeton, N.J.: Pnnceton University Press.

34.

Roemer, J.E. 1982: A General Theory of Exploitation and Class Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press .

35.

Roemer, J.E. 1985

Should Marxist Be Interested in Exploitation

Philosophy & Public Affairs 14.

36.

Roemer, J.E. 1986a: An Historical Materialist Alternative to Welfarism In J. Elster & A. Hylland (eds ), Foundations of Social Choice Theory. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press/Oslo. Universitetsforlaget

37.

Roemer, J. E (ed.) 1986b Analytical Marxism Cambridge Cambridge University Press.

38.

Sen, A. 1979: Collecttue Choice and Social Welfare Amsterdam North-Holland

39.

40.

Weber, M. 1985 Wirtschaft und Gesellschaft Tubingen: J C B. Mohr (1922).

41.

Wolfe, A. 1989: Whose Keeper? Social Science and Moral Obligation Berkeley : University of California Press.

42.

Wuthnow, R. 1987: Meaning and Moral Order Berkeley: University of California Press.