Sage Journals: Discover world-class research

Abstract

This article examines how the military engagement in Afghanistan has been framed in the Norwegian public sphere and by veterans who have participated on the ground. Drawing on public documents and personal interview data, the analysis demonstrates how different frames were used in the public and private spheres to convey the meaning of the operation. The analysis focuses in particular on the mismatch experienced by the veterans between the official framing of the operation as a humanitarian endeavor, and their perception of having been at war. In the discussion of the findings, we argue that the study sheds light on broader questions concerning the place of contemporary soldiers in Western societies, where people in general have become largely detached from the direct experience of warfare.

Keywords

Cultural analysis framing military operations qualitative research war and society veterans

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Alexander

(2011) War and performance: Afghanistan and Iraq. In: Alexander

(ed.) Performance and Power. Cambridge: Polity, pp.184–194.

Battistelli

(1997) Peacekeeping and the postmodern soldier. Armed Forces & Society 23(3): 467–484.

Bergman

(2015) Derfor er Norge i Afghanistan [Therefore is Norway in Afghanistan]. Internasjonal Politikk 72(1): 89–101.

Bondevik

(2001a) Redegjørelse om situasjonen etter terrorangrepene mot USA [Report on the situation after the terrorist attack against the United States]. Speech by Prime Minister in Parliament. Available at: http://www.regjeringen.no/no/aktuelt/statsministerens_redegjorelse_for/id265217 (accessed June 26, 2016).

Bondevik

(2001b) Framgang i kampen mot terror [Progress in the battle against terror]. Aftenposten (newspaper), 15 November.

Bondevik

(2001c) Sammen for freden [Together for peace]. Dagsavisen (newspaper), 24 December.

Bondevik

(2002a) Norge er i krig mot internasjonal terror [Norway is at war with international terror]. Vårt Land (newspaper), 2 October.

Bondevik

(2002b) Ikke krig mot Afghanistan [Not a war against Afghanistan]. Adresseavisen (newspaper), 5 October.

Bondevik

(2004) Verdier i internasjonal politikk [Values in international politics]. Aftenposten (newspaper), 6 February.

10.

Borger

(2012) Germany slowly comes to terms with sending its armed forces abroad. Available at: http://www.theguardian.com/world/2012/sep/18/germany-military-modernise-foreign-intervention (accessed June 27, 2016).

11.

Brekhus

(2015) Culture and Cognition: Patterns in the Social Construction of Reality. Cambridge: Polity.

12.

Butler

(2010) Frames of War: When is lIfe Grievable? London: Verso.

13.

Callahan

Dubnick

Olshfski

(2006) War narratives: Framing our understanding of the war on terror. Public Administration Review 66(4): 554–568.

14.

Devold

(2003) Hva vi vil og hvor vi skal: Mål og prioriteringer for forsvarspolitikken i 2003. [What do we want and where are we going. Goals and priorities in the defence politics in 2003]. Annual speech by Minister of Defence to the Military Community of Oslo. Available at: http://www.oslomilsamfund.no/archive/2003/59/2003-01-06-Hva+vi+vil+og+hvor+vi+skal%3A+m%E5l+og+prioriteringer+for+forsvarspolitikken+i+2003 (accessed July 1, 2016).

15.

Dyvik

(2016) “Valhalla rising”: Gender, embodiment and experience in military memoirs. Security Dialogue 47(2): 133–150.

16.

Eide

(2010) Om “krig” og folkerett [On “war” and international law]. Klassekampen (newspaper), 15 July.

17.

Faremo

(2010) Min sorg, mitt ansvar [My grief, my responsibility]. VG, 2 July.

18.

Fillmore

(1976) Frame semantics and the nature of language. Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences, 280(1): 20–32.

19.

Foster

(1997) To serve and protect: Textualizing the Falklands conflict. Cultural Studies 11(2): 235–252.

20.

Gibson

Abell

(2004) For Queen and country? National frames of reference in the talk of soldiers in England. Human Relations 57(7): 871–891.

21.

Goffman

(1974) Frame Analysis: An Essay on the Organization of Experience. New York: Harper & Row.

22.

Gustavsen

(2016) The construction of meaning among Norwegian Afghanistan veterans. International Sociology 31(1): 21–36.

23.

Harpviken

(2011) A peace nation takes ups arms: The Norwegian engagement in Afghanistan. PRIO paper. Oslo: Peace Research Institute of Oslo.

24.

Hedlund

(2011) What motivates Swedish soldiers to participate in peacekeeping missions: Research note. Armed Forces & Society 37(1): 180–190.

25.

Ignazi

Giacomello

Coticchia

(2012) Italian Military Operations Abroad: Just Don’t Call it War. New York: Palgrave Macmillan.

26.

Jarvinen

(2000) The biographical illusion: Constructing meaning in qualitative interviews. Qualitative Inquiry 6(3): 370–391.

27.

King

(2010) The Afghan war and “postmodern” memory: Commemoration and the dead of Helmand. British Journal of Sociology 61(1): 1–25.

28.

King

(2013) The Combat Soldier: Infantry Tactics and Cohesion in the Twentieth and Twenty-first Centuries. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

29.

Leira

(2013) “Our entire people are natural born friends of peace”: The Norwegian foreign policy of peace. Swiss Political Science Review 19(3): 338–356.

30.

Lakoff

(2002) Moral Politics: How Liberals and Conservatives Think. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.

31.

Lakoff

(2008) The Political Mind: Why You Can’t Understand 21st-Century Politics with an 18th-Century Brain. New York: Viking.

32.

Lomsky-Feder

(1995) The meaning of war through veteran’s eyes: A phenomenological analysis of life stories. International Sociology 10(4): 463–482.

33.

Lomsky-Feder

(2004) Life stories, war, and veterans: On the social distribution of memories. Ethos 32(1): 1–28.

34.

Malešević

(2010) The Sociology of War and Violence. New York: Cambridge University Press.

35.

Malešević

(2017) Sociological Theory and Warfare. Available at: http://www.fhs.se/documents/externwebben/om-fhs/organisation/ilm/sociologi%20och%20ledarskap/dokument/sociological%20theory%20and%20warfare.pdf (accessed June 15, 2017).

36.

Mann

(1988). States, War and Capitalism: Studies in Political Sociology. Oxford: Blackwell.

37.

Mastorianni

Scott

(2011) Reframing suicide in the military. Parameters (Summer): 6–21.

38.

Matlary

(2009) Annerledes tenkende [Those who think differently]. Dagens Næringsliv (newspaper), 16 July.

39.

McInnes

(1999) Spectator sport warfare. Contemporary Security Policy 20(3): 142–165.

40.

McInnes

(2002) Spectator-Sport War: The West and Contemporary Conflict. London: Lynne Rienner.

41.

Moxnes

(2010) Faremo opptrer feigt [Faremo acts cowardly]. VG (newspaper), 10 July.

42.

Norges offentlige utredninger(2016) En god alliert – Norge i Afghanistan 2001-2014 [A good allied – Norway in Afghanistan 2001–2014]. Oslo: Departementenes sikkerhets- og serviceorganisasjon informasjonsforvaltning.

43.

NTB (2013) Intern rapport: SV er historisk svekket [Internal report: SV is historically diminished]. Available at: http://e24.no/makro-og-politikk/intern-rapport-sv-er-historisk-svekket/22674574 (accessed January 22, 2017).

44.

Nystuen

Hellestveit

(2010) Krig og folkerett [War and international law]. Klassekampen (newspaper), 22 July.

45.

Oma

(2011) Unngåelse av innenrikspolitisk risiko? – Stoltenberg II-regjeringens beslutninger om styrkebidrag til ISAF [Avoidance of domestic political risk? The Stoltenberg II government’s decisions about force contribution to ISAF]. Internasjonal Politikk 69(2): 159–181.

46.

Oma

Ekhaugen

(2014) Norwegian lead in Afghanistan: A small State approach to a Large commitment. In: Allers

Masala

Tamnes

(eds) Common or Divided Security? German and Norwegian Perspectives on Euro-Atlantic Security. Frankfurt am Main: Peter Lang, pp.237–257.

47.

Petersen

(2001) Mulige norske styrkebidrag i Afghanistan [Possible Norwegian force contribution in Afghanistan]. Speech by Foreign Minister to parliament. Available at: http://www.regjeringen.no/no/aktuelt/mulige_norske_styrkebidrag_til/id265324/ (accessed June 27, 2017).

48.

Petersen

(2003) Norske bidrag til internasjonale operasjoner og samlet innsats i Afghanistan og Irak i 2004 [Norwegian contributions to international operations and overall effort in Afghanistan and Iraq in 2004]. Speech by Foreign Minister in parliament. Available at: http://www.regjeringen.no/no/aktuelt/utenriksministerens_redegjorelse/id267722 (accessed June 26, 2016).

49.

Reese

Lewis

(2009) Framing the war on terror. The internalization of policy in the US press. Journalism 10(6): 777–797.

50.

Reese

Gandy

Grant

(2001) Framing Public Life. Perspectives on Media and our Understanding of the Social World. Routledge: New York.

51.

Reichelt

(2010) Norske soldater er i krig [Norwegian soldiers are at war]. Aftenposten (newspaper), 6 July.

52.

Reynolds

Wetherell

Taylor

(2007). Choice and chance: Negotiating agency in narratives of singleness. The Sociological Review 55(2): 331–351.

53.

Ruffa

Sandberg

(2017). Breaking the frame: Frame disputes of war and peace. Acta Sociologica. Epub ahead of print July 17, 2017: 1–16.

54.

Schok

Kleber

Boeije

(2010) Men with a mission: Veterans’ meanings of peacekeeping in Cambodia. Journal of Loss and Trauma 15(4): 279–303.

55.

Skånland

ØH

(2010) “Norway is a peace nation”: A discourse analytic reading of the Norwegian peace engagement. Cooperation and Conflict 45(1): 34–54.

56.

Smith

(2005) Why War? The Cultural Logic of Iraq, the Gulf War, and Suez. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.

57.

Støre

G (2005) Utenrikspolitisk redegjørelse for Stortinget [Foreign policy address to Parliament]. Available at:http://www.regjeringen.no/nb/dep/ud/aktuelt/taler_artikler/jgs_taler_artikler/2005/redegjorelse-om-norges-engasjement-i-afg.html?id=273193 (accessed June 26, 2016).

58.

Støre

(2007) Utenrikspolitisk redegjørelse for Stortinget [Foreign policy address to Parliament]. Speech by Foreign Minister to parliament. Available at: http://www.regjeringen.no/no/aktuelt/utenrikspolitisk-redegjorelse-/id450698 (accessed June 26, 2016).

59.

Stoltenberg

(2010) Tale til de norske styrkene i Afghanistan på 17. mai [Speech to the Norwegian troops in Afghanistan on 17 May]. Speech by Prime Minister. Available at: http://www.regjeringen.no/no/aktuelt/tale-til-de-norske-styrkene-i-afghanista/id604988 (accessed June 26, 2016).

60.

Taylor

(2015) Norwegian cops fired their guns twice last year and didn’t hit anyone either time. Washington Post, Available at: http://www.washingtonpost.com/news/worldviews/wp/2015/07/08/norwegian-cops-fired-their-guns-twice-last-year-and-missed-both-times (accessed June 27, 2016).

61.

Tilly

(1985) War making and state making as organized crime. In: Evans

Rueschemeyer

Skocpol

(eds) Bringing the State Back In. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, pp.169–191.

62.

Tjora

(2012) Kvalitative forskningsmetoder i praksis [Qualitative Research Methods in Practice]. Oslo: Gyldendal akademisk.

63.

Tversky

Kahneman

(1981) The framing of decisions and the psychology of choice. Science 211(4481): 453–458.

64.

Von Hofer

(2004) Crime and reactions to crime in Scandinavia. Journal of Scandinavian Studies in Criminology & Crime Prevention 5(2): 148–166.

65.

Woodward

(2008) “Not for Queen and Country or any of that shit…” Reflections on citizenship and military participation in contemporary British soldier narratives. In: Cowen

Gilbert

(eds) War, Citizenship, Territory. London: Routledge, pp.362–384.

66.

Woodward

Jenkings

(2011) Military identities in the situated accounts of British military personnel. Sociology 45(2): 252–268.

67.

Woodward

Jenkings

(2012) “This place isn’t worth the left boot of one of our boys”: Geopolitics, militarism and memoirs of the Afghanistan war. Political Geography 31(8): 495–508.

Soldiers without a war? Public and private framings of Norway’s engagement in Afghanistan

Abstract

Keywords

Get full access to this article

References