Compared to natives, students with immigrant background are – other things being equal – more likely to choose academic tracks over vocational education and training (VET) at upper-secondary level. Evidence of so-called ethnic choice effects is mostly based on education systems where vocational tracks are often regarded as ‘unfavourable’. Our study investigated ethnic choice effects at the end of compulsory school in Switzerland, a country with a strong VET sector offering competitive incentives, particularly for students with lower or average achievement. Based on longitudinal data from the ‘Transitions from Education to Employment’ (TREE) survey, we found that most migrant groups were more likely to choose academic-track pathways preparing for university admission over VET preparing more directly for employment. Nested logistic regression analyses revealed that a large share of these ethnic choice effects was explained by immigrant optimism. Our findings shed light on general educational decision-making processes among migrant families and their potential consequences for ethnic inequality in post-compulsory education.
Backes-GellnerUWolterSCTuorSN. (2010) Risk-return trade-offs to different educational paths: Vocational, academic and mixed. International Journal of Manpower31(5): 495–519.
2.
BolTvan de WerfhorstHG (2013) Educational systems and the trade-off between labor market allocation and equality of educational opportunity. Comparative Education Review57(2): 285–308.
3.
BoudonR (1974) Education, Opportunity, and Social Inequality: Changing Prospects in Western Society. New York, NY: Wiley.
4.
BreenRGoldthorpeJH (1997) Explaining educational differentials towards a formal rational action theory. Rationality and Society9(3): 275–305.
5.
BreenRKarlsonKBHolmA (2013) Total, direct, and indirect effects in logit and probit models. Sociological Methods & Research42(1): 164–191.
6.
BrinbaumYCebolla-BoadoH (2007) The school careers of ethnic minority youth in France: Success or disillusion?Ethnicities7(3): 445–474.
7.
D’hondtFVan PraagLVan HoutteM. (2016) The attitude–achievement paradox in Belgium: An examination of school attitudes of ethnic minority students. Acta Sociologica59(1): 215–231.
8.
DiehlCFriedrichMHallA (2009) Jugendliche ausländischer Herkunft beim Übergang in die Berufsausbildung. Vom Wollen, Können und Dürfen. Zeitschrift für Soziologie38(1): 48–68.
9.
DrebyJ (2010) Divided by Borders: Mexican Migrants and their Children. Los Angeles, CA: University of California Press.
10.
EriksonRJonssonJO (1996) Explaining class inequality in education: The Swedish test case. In: EriksonRJonssonJO (eds) Can Education be Equalized? The Swedish Case in Comparative Research. Boulder, CO: Westview Press, pp.1–63.
11.
FuligniAJPedersenS (2002) Family obligation and the transition to young adulthood. Developmental Psychology38(5): 856–868.
12.
GanglM (2003) Returns to education in context: Individual education and transition outcomes in European labor markets. In: MüllerWGanglM (eds) Transitions from Education to Work in Europe. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press, pp.156–185.
13.
GanzeboomHBDe GraafPMTreimanDJ (1992) A standard international socio-economic index of occupational status. Social Science Research21(1): 1–56.
14.
GrigaD (2014) Participation in higher education of youths with a migrant background in Switzerland. Swiss Journal of Sociology40(3): 379–400.
15.
HaeberlinUImdorfCKronigW (2005) Verzerrte Chancen auf dem Lehrstellenmarkt. Untersuchungen zu Benachteiligungen von ausländischen und von weiblichen Jugendlichen bei der Suche nach beruflichen Ausbildungsplätzen in der Schweiz. Zeitschrift für Pädagogik51(1): 116–134.
16.
HeathABrinbaumY (2007) Explaining ethnic inequalities in educational attainment. Ethnicities7(3): 291–304.
17.
HeathABrinbaumY (2014) Unequal Attainments: Ethnic Educational Inequalities in Ten Western Countries. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.
18.
HeathAFCheungSY (2007) Unequal Chances: Ethnic Minorities in Western Labour Markets. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.
19.
HellandHStørenLA (2006) Vocational education and the allocation of apprenticeships: Equal chances for applicants regardless of immigrant background?European Sociological Review22(3): 339–351.
20.
HunklerC (2010) Ethnische Unterschiede beim Zugang zu Ausbildung und Erwerb von Ausbildungsabschlüssen. In: BeckerBReimerD (eds) Vom Kindergarten bis zur Hochschule. Die Generierung von ethnischen und sozialen Disparitäten in der Bildungsbiographie. Wiesbaden, DE: VS Verlag, pp.213–250.
21.
Hupka-BrunnerSGauppNGeierB. (2011) Chancen bildungsbenachteiligter Jugendlicher: Bildungsverläufe in der Schweiz und in Deutschland. Zeitschrift für Soziologie der Erziehung und Sozialisation31(1): 62–78.
22.
Hupka-BrunnerSSacchiSStalderBE (2010) Social origin and access to upper secondary education in Switzerland: A comparison of company-based apprenticeship and exclusively school-based programmes. Swiss Journal of Sociology36(1): 11–31.
23.
ImdorfC (2011) Wie Ausbildungsbetriebe soziale Ungleichheit reproduzieren: Der Ausschluss von Migrantenjugendlichen bei der Lehrlingsselektion. In: KrügerH-HRabe-KlebergUKramerR-T. (eds) Bildungsungleichheit revisited. Bildung und soziale Ungleichheit vom Kindergarten bis zur Hochschule. Wiesbaden, DE: Springer, pp.261–276.
24.
JacksonM (2012) Bold choices: How ethnic inequalities in educational attainment are suppressed. Oxford Review of Education38(2): 189–208.
25.
JacksonMEriksonRGoldthorpeJH. (2007) Primary and secondary effects in class differentials in educational attainment: The transition to A-Level courses in England and Wales. Acta Sociologica50(3): 211–229.
26.
JacksonMJonssonJORudolphiF (2012) Ethnic inequality in choice-driven education systems: A longitudinal study of performance and choice in England and Sweden. Sociology of Education85(2): 158–178.
27.
JonssonJORudolphiF (2011) Weak performance—strong determination: School achievement and educational choice among children of immigrants in Sweden. European Sociological Review27(4): 487–508.
28.
KalterF (2008) Ethnische Ungleichheit auf dem Arbeitsmarkt. In: AbrahamMHinzT (eds) Arbeitsmarktsoziologie. Probleme, Theorien, empirische Befunde. Wiesbaden, DE: Springer, pp.303–332.
29.
KaoGTiendaM (1995) Optimism and achievement: The educational performance of immigrant youth. Social Science Quarterly76(1): 1–19.
30.
KaoGTiendaM (1998) Educational aspirations among minority youth. American Journal of Education106(1): 349–384.
31.
KarlsonKBHolmABreenR (2012) Comparing regression coefficients between same-sample nested models using logit and probit: A new method. Sociological Methodology42(1): 286–313.
32.
KellerAHupka-BrunnerSMeyerT (2010) Post-compulsory Education Pathways in Switzerland: The First Seven Years. Results of the Swiss Youth Panel Survey TREE, Update 2010. Basel, CH: TREE.
33.
Kilpi-JakonenE (2011) Continuation to upper secondary education in Finland: Children of immigrants and the majority compared. Acta Sociologica54(1): 77–106.
34.
KristenCDollmannJ (2010) Sekundäre Effekte der ethnischen Herkunft: Kinder aus türkischen Familien am ersten Bildungsübergang. In: BeckerBReimerD (eds) Vom Kindergarten bis zur Hochschule: Die Generierung von ethnischen und sozialen Disparitäten in der Bildungsbiographie. Wiesbaden, DE: Springer, pp.117–144.
35.
KristenCReimerDKoganI (2008) Higher education entry of Turkish immigrant youth in Germany. International Journal of Comparative Sociology49(3): 127–151.
36.
LaganàFChevillardJGauthierJ-A (2014) Socio-economic background and early post-compulsory education pathways: A comparison between natives and second-generation immigrants in Switzerland. European Sociological Review30(1): 18–34.
37.
Lessard-PhillipsLBrinbaumYHeathA (2014) Academic and vocational tracking in upper secondary education. In: HeathABrinbaumY (eds) Unequal Attainments: Ethnic Educational Inequalities in Ten Western Countries. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press, pp.149–167.
38.
LouieV (2001) Parents’ aspirations and investment: The role of social class in the educational experiences of 1.5- and second-generation Chinese Americans. Harvard Educational Review71(3): 438–475.
39.
MeyerT (2005) School-to-Work Transition in Switzerland. Results as of 2004 from the TREE Panel Survey. Bern, CH: TREE.
40.
MeyerTStalderBEMatterM (2003) Bildungswunsch und Wirklichkeit. Bern, CH: Swiss Federal Statistical Office.
41.
MoodC (2010) Logistic regression: Why we cannot do what we think we can do, and what we can do about it. European Sociological Review23(1): 67–82.
42.
Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) (2004) Trends in International Migration. Continuous Reporting System on Migration: Annual Report. Paris, FR: OECD.
43.
Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) (2012) Labour Market Integration in Austria, Norway and Switzerland. Jobs for Immigrants. Paris, FR: OECD.
44.
Programme for International Student Assessment (PISA) (2002). Für das Leben gerüstet? Die Grundkompetenzen der Jugendlichen − Nationaler Bericht der Erhebung PISA 2000. Neuchâtel, CH: Bundesamt für Statistik & EDK.
45.
RelikowskiI (2012) Primäre und sekundäre Effekte am Übertritt in die Sekundarstufe I. Zur Rolle von sozialer Herkunft und Migrationshintergrund. Wiesbaden, DE: Springer Fachmedien Wiesbaden.
46.
RelikowskiIYilmazEBlossfeldH-P (2012) Wie lassen sich die hohen Bildungsaspirationen von Migranten erklären? Eine Mixed-Methods-Studie zur Rolle von strukturellen Aufstiegschancen und individueller Bildungserfahrung. In: BeckerRSolgaH (eds) Soziologische Bildungsforschung. Wiesbaden, DE: Springer, pp.111–136.
47.
SacchiS (2013) Construction of TREE Panel Weights. Documentation for the Panel Waves from 2000 to 2010. Basel/Zurich, CH: TREE & CUE Sozialforschung.
48.
SacchiSMeyerT (2016) Übergangslösungen beim Eintritt in die Schweizer Berufsbildung: Brückenschlag oder Sackgasse?Swiss Journal of Sociology42(1): 9–39.
49.
SacchiSHupka-BrunnerSStalderBE. (2011) Die Bedeutung von sozialer Herkunft und Migrationshintergrund für den Übertritt in anerkannte nachobligatorische Ausbildungen in der Schweiz. In: BergmanMMHupka-BrunnerSKellerA. (eds) Transitionen im Jugendalter: Ergebnisse der Schweizer Längsschnittstudie TREE. Zurich, CH: Seismo, pp.120–156.
50.
ScharenbergKRudinMMüllerB. (2016) Education and employment pathways from the end of compulsory school to young adulthood. In: ScharenbergKHupka-BrunnerSMeyerT. (eds) Transitions in Youth and Young Adulthood: Results from the Swiss TREE Panel Study. Zurich, CH: Seismo, pp.20–44.
51.
SeibertHHupka-BrunnerSImdorfC (2009) Wie Ausbildungssysteme Chancen verteilen. Kölner Zeitschrift für Soziologie und Sozialpsychologie61(4): 595–620.
52.
ShahBDwyerCModoodT (2010) Explaining educational achievement and career aspirations among young British Pakistanis: Mobilizing ‘ethnic capital’?Sociology44(6): 1109–1127.
53.
ShavitYMüllerW (2000) Vocational secondary education: Where diversion and where safety net?European Societies2(1): 29–50.
54.
SheldonG (2007) Migration, Integration und Wachstum: Die Performance und wirtschaftliche Auswirkung der Ausländer in der Schweiz. Basel, CH: Universität Basel.
55.
Swiss Coordination Centre for Research in Education (SCCRE) (2010) Swiss Education Report 2010. Bern, CH: SCCRE.
56.
Suárez-OrozcoCSuárez-OrozcoMTodorovaI (2008) Learning a New Land: Immigrant Students in American Society. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
57.
Swiss Federal Office for Professional Education and Technology (OPET) (2008) Vocational Education and Training in Switzerland 2008. Facts and Figures. Bern, CH: OPET.
58.
Swiss Federal Statistical Office (FSO) (2003) Wege in die nachobligatorische Ausbildung. Bildungsmonitoring Schweiz. Bern, CH: FSO.
TeneyCDevleeshouwerPHanquinetL (2013) Educational aspirations among ethnic minority youth in Brussels: Does the perception of ethnic discrimination in the labour market matter? A mixed-method approach. Ethnicities13(5): 584–606.
61.
TREE (2013a) Codebook: Variables Based on PISA. Basel, CH: TREE.
62.
TREE (2013b) TREE Project Documentation 2000–2012. Basel, CH: TREE.
63.
Van BuurenS (2012) Flexible Imputation of Missing Data. Boca Raton, FL: CRC Press.
64.
Van de WerfhorstHGVan TubergenF (2007) Ethnicity, schooling, and merit in the Netherlands. Ethnicities7(3): 416–444.
65.
WatersMCHeathATranVC. (2013) Second-generation attainment and inequality: Primary and secondary effects on educational outcomes in Britain and the United States. In: AlbaRDHoldawayJ (eds) The Children of Immigrants in School. New York, NY: New York University Press, pp.120–159.
66.
WolbersMH (2007) Patterns of labour market entry: A comparative perspective on school-to-work transitions in 11 European Countries. Acta Sociologica50(3): 189–210.
67.
WolterSCWeberB (2005) Bildungsrendite: Ein zentraler ökonomischer Indikator des Bildungswesens. Die Volkswirtschaft: Das Magazin für Wirtschaftspolitik10(1): 38–42.
68.
WolterSCWeberBA (1999) A new look at private rates of return to education in Switzerland. Education + Training41(8): 366–373.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
