This paper is a critique of the social movement unionism (SMU) theory. Arguing that characteristics of social movement unions reflect the very contradictory nature of unions under capitalism, it renders a view that the SMU theory romanticizes so-called social movement type unions (the COSATU in South Africa, the CUT in Brazil, and the KCTU in South Korea) and falls short of prescriptive measures for social transformation and a clear vision of a future society. Focusing on the case of the Korean Confederation of Trade Unions (KCTU) and Democratic Labor Party (DLP) in South Korea, it examines whether the SMU theory can adequately address the limitations of the current trade union movement in South Korea.
Back, Jung-Gook.1994. “Elections as Transformation: Explaining the Reorganization of a Ruling Coalition.” Pp. 238—241 in Korea in the Global Wave of Democratization , edited by Doh Chul Shin, Myeong-Han Zoh, and Myung Chey.Seoul, Korea: Seoul National University Press.
2.
Bello, Walden and Stephanie Rosenfeld .1990. Dragons in Distress: Asia's Miracle Economies in Crisis. San Francisco: The Institute of Food and Development Policy.
3.
Chae, Man Soo.2003. “A Critique of the DLP Political Program (Minju Nodongdang Gangryung Beepan).” Jinbo Pyongron No. 3. Retrieved 3 October 2005(http://jbreview.jinbo.net/maynews/article_print.php?table=organ&item=3&no=74) .
4.
Cho, Soon Kyoung.1985. “The Labor Process and Capital Mobility: The Limits of the New International Division of Labor.” Politics & Society14(2):185—222.
5.
Choi, Kwang Eun.2005. “Socialist Transformation, Party, and Political Forces (Sahoijueueu hyukshin, dang, keurigo jewapa),” Jinbo Pyongron No. 22. Retrieved 3 October 2005(http://jbreview.jinbo.net/maynews/article_print.php?table=organ&item=2&no=477) .
6.
Compton, Jr. Robert W.2000. East Asian Democratization: Impact of Globalization, Culture, and Economy. London, UK: Praeger .
7.
Eder, Mine.1997. “Shop Floor Politics and Labor Movements: Democratization in Brazil and South Korea.” Critical Sociology23(2).
8.
Economist Intelligence Unit.1990. Country Report on South Korea. London: The Economist Intelligence Unit.
9.
Grinker, Roy Richard.1998. “Elementary Forms of Korean Historical Representation: School Textbooks in South Korea.” Social Analysis42(1):88—109.
10.
Hankyoreh.2005. “Will the DLP Escape From `the Swamp of Tokdo'? (Minnodang `tokdoeu neup aesuh but-suh-nal-ka?).” March 25. Retrieved 3 October 2005 ( http://www.hani.co.kr/section003000000/2005/03/p003000000200503251010001.html ).
11.
Hirschsohn, Philip.1998. “From Grassroots Democracy to National Mobilization: COSATU as a Model of Social Movement Unionism.”Economic and Industrial Democracy19(4):633—666.
12.
Hwang, Eui Bong.1985. The Student Movement of the 1980s (Palshipnyundae haksaeng undon)Seoul, Korea: Yesogak .
13.
Hyman, Richard.1997. “Trade Unions and Interest Representation in the Context of Globalization.”Transfer3(3):3515—3533.
14.
———. 1971. Marxism and the Sociology of Trade Unionism. London, UK: Pluto Press
15.
International Monetary Fund.1997. “ IMF Approves SDR 15.5 Billion Stand-by Credit for Korea” International Monetary Fund Press Release No. 97/55 Dec. 4. Retrieved 3 October 2005(http://www.kimsoft.com/1997/imfsdr.htm).
16.
Jo, Hee Yon.1998. Democracy and Social Movements in Korea (Hakkookeu minjujueuwha sahoi undong). Seoul, Korea: Dangdae.
17.
Kcia.1991. No-Hae Park, the Leader of Socialist Workers' League of South Korea: Investigation Results (Sanomaeng chongchaek Park No-Hae chosa gyulkwa). Seoul : Korean Central Intelligence Agency (KCIA: Kookga-anchun-kihyukboo) .
18.
Kctu.1997. “The KCTU Proposal for an Agreement to Overcome the Economic Crisis.” Korean Confederation of Trade Unions Dec. 15. Retrieved 3 October 2005(http://www.kctu.org/arguments/sp004.htm) .
19.
———. 1998a. “Proposal for consultation.” Korean Confederation of Trade Unions Jan. 7. Retrieved 3 October 2005. (http://www.kctu.org/arguments/sp007.htm) .
20.
———. 1998b. “KCTU — IMF Dialogue `Unbridled Freedom to Sack Workers Is No Solution At All.'”Korean Confederation of Trade Unions Jan. 13. Retrieved 3 October 2005(http://www.kctu.org/arguments/sp009.htm) .
21.
———. 1998c. May 5. Retrieved 3 October 2005(http://www.solinet.org/Lee/korea_myths.html).
22.
———. 1998d. “IMF Policy Regime and the Challenges for the Labour Movement.” Korean Confederation of Trade Unions Sept.7. Retrieved 3 October 2005(http://www.kctu.org/arguments/sp016.htm).
23.
———. 1998e. “107 Trade Unionists Imprisoned 125 Wanted for Arrest by the Korean Government Led by President Kim Dae Jung, a Nobel Peace Prize Aspirant and the Most Famous Human Rights Violation Victim in Korea .” Korean Confederation of Trade Unions Sept. 19. Retrieved 3 October 2005(http://www.kctu.org/news/archive/aa021.htm).
24.
———. 1998f. “The Reality of Migrant Workers and Trade Union Solidarity.” Korean Confederation of Trade Unions Nov . 4. Retrieved 3 October 2005(http://www.kctu.org/arguments/sp018.htm).
25.
———. 1998g. “Globalisation and Liberalisation: The Challenge for People's Struggle and Solidarity.” Korean Confederation of Trade Unions Nov. 10. Retrieved 3 October 2005(http://www.kctu.org/arguments/sp019.htm) .
26.
———. 1999a. “Chaebol Reform: The Missing Agenda in `Corporate Governance.'”Korean Confederation of Trade Unions March15. Retrieved 3 October 2005(http://www.kctu.org/arguments/www._0305.htm).
27.
———. 1999b. “KCTU Withdrawals from the Tripartite Commission .” Korean Confederation of Trade Unions March17. Retrieved 3 October 2005(http://www.kctu.org/news/news_990317_tripartite.htm).
28.
Kim, Eun-Mee.1997. Big Business, Strong State: Collusion and Conflict in South Korean Development. 1960—1990. Albany : State University of New York Press.
29.
Kim, Se Kwyun.2005 “The Left, Which Direction Should it Take? ( Jwapa-undong, uh-dirogaya-hana?),” Jinbo Pyongron . No. 22. Retrieved 3 October 2005(http://jbreview.jinbo.net/maynews/article_print.php?table=organ&item=2&no=481&PHPSESSID=bec508972885eb61d835bce444833b08).
30.
———. 2002. “How Shall We Assess the CV21 Movement? (Kookmin SeungRi 21` Undongeul Uh-tuh-ge Bolgut-inga?).” Retrieved 3 October 2005(http://www.pwc.or.kr/jsboard/read.php?table=js_social&no=11) .
31.
Kim, Sung Gu.2004. “The Analysis of 4.15 Election and the Prospect of Minjung Movement (4.15 Chongsun Pyunkwaya Minjung undongeu daeung banghyang) .” Retrieved 24 November 2005(http://jbreview.jinbo.net/maynews/article_print.php?table=organ&item=3&no=442) .
32.
Kim, Young-Soo.1999. The Political Movement of Korean Workers (Hankook nodongja chungchee undong). Seoul: Hyunjangaeso Miraerul.
33.
Koo, Hagen.1991. “Middle classes, Democratization, and Class Formation: The Case of South Korea.”Theory and Society20(4):485—509.
34.
Koon, Woo-Nam.1989. South Korean Politics. The Search for Political Consensus and Stability. Lanham: University Press of America.
35.
KH. 1998a. The Korea Herald. Feb.14. Seoul: Herald.
36.
———. 1998b. The Korea Herald. Sept.3. Seoul: Herald.
37.
Lee, Chang-Hee.1998. “New Unionism and the Transformation of the Korean Industrial Relations System.” Economic and Industrial Democracy19(2):347—373.
38.
Lee, Kwang-IL.2005. “The Democratic Labor Party, the Progressive Movement, and Social Transformation (Minju nodongdang, `Jinbo chungchee keurigo sahoi-eehaeng'.)” Jinbo Pyongron No. 22. Retrieved 3 October 2005(http://jbreview.jinbo.net/maynews/article_print.php?table=organ&item=5&no=485) .
39.
Lee, Man-Woo.1990. The Odyssey of Korean Democracy: Korean Politics, 1987—1990. New York: Praeger .
40.
Lee, Monk-Hee.1996. The Prospect of South Korean Labor Movements (Hankkook nodong undongeul daejungjok kichowha jinro). Seoul: Poolbit.
41.
Miliband, Ralph.1997. Marxism and Politics. Oxford : Oxford University Press.
42.
Moody, Kim.1997. “Towards an International Social-Movement Unionism .” New Left Review225(September-October):52—72.
43.
Park, Mi.2005. “Organizing Dissent Against Authoritarianism: The South Korean Student Movement in the 1980s.” Korea Journal45(3):261—288.
44.
Scipes, Kim.1993. “Understanding the New Labor Movements in the Third World: The Emergence of Social Movement Unionism.” Critical sociology19(2):81—101.
45.
Seidman, Gay W.1994. Manufacturing Militance: Workers' Movements in Brazil and South Africa, 1970—1985. Berkeley: University of California Press.
46.
Sonn, Hochul.1997. “The `Late Blooming' of the South Korean Labor Movement ,” Monthly Review49(3):117—130
47.
Trotsky, Leon.1990. Trade Unions in the Epoch of Imperialist Decay . Second Edition. New York : Pathfinder.
48.
Waterman, Peter.2004. “Adventures of Emancipatory Labour Strategy as the New Global Movement Challenges International Unionism.” Journal of World-System Research10(1):217—253.
49.
YNA.1993. Korea Annual. Seoul, Korea: Hapdong News Agency.
