This study explored the hypothesis that clergywomen tend to hold a more inclusive attitude toward ministry than is the case among clergymen. The hypothesis was tested against data provided by 311 clergymen and 66 clergywomen, generated from a 66% response rate to a survey of all stipendiary parochial clergy in the Church in Wales concerning views on Christian initiation. The data confirmed the hypothesis across all five aspects of Christian initiation included in the questionnaire. This finding was employed to challenge recent theologically-informed claims denying consistent gender differences in approaches to ministry.
Church of England (2006), Guildford Report, GS1630, London, General Synod of the Church of England.
2.
FraserG. (2006), Forward, in Rayment-PickardH., and ShakespeareS., The Inclusive God: reclaiming theology for an inclusive church, Norwich, Canterbury Press, pp. vii–xi.
3.
HarriesR. (2006), The female mitre,The Tablet, 15 July, pp. 4–5.
4.
JonesI. (2004), Women and the Priesthood in the Church of England: ten years on, London, Church House Publishing.
5.
PembertonC. (2004), We wish you were here: some views from the pews, in HarriesH., and ShawJ. (eds.), The Call for Women Bishops, London, SPCK, pp. 175–183.
6.
Rayment-PickardH., and ShakespeareS. (2006), The Inclusive God: reclaiming theology for an inclusive church, Norwich, Canterbury Press.
7.
RigneyJ. (ed.) (2006), Women and the Episcopate, London, Church House Publishing.
8.
RobbinsM. (1998), A different voice: a different view,Review of Religious Research, 40, 75–80.
9.
RobbinsM. (2007), Clergymen and Clergywomen: the same inclusive gospel?Journal of Beliefs and Values, 28, pp. 55–64.
10.
RuetherR.R. (2002), Sexism and God-talk, Norwich, SCM Press.
11.
ThorneH. (2000), Journey to Priesthood: an in-depth study of the first women priests in the Church of England, Bristol, Centre for Comparative Studies in Religion and Gender.
12.
TreasureC. (1991), Walkingon Glass: women deacons speak out, London, SPCK.
