Looking for Signs of the Presence of God in Northern Ireland: Religious Experience among Catholic and Protestant Sixth-form Pupils

Abstract

A sample of 2,359 sixth-form pupils (between the ages of 16 and 18 years) in Northern Ireland (1,093 attending seven Protestant schools and 1,266 attending nine Catholic schools) responded in 1998 to Greer's classic question ‘Have you ever had an experience of God, for example, his presence or his help or anything else?’ Religious experience was reported by 29% of Protestant males, 29% of Catholic males, 39% of Protestant females and 38% of Catholic females. Compared with earlier data these figures reveal a particularly marked decline in reported religious experience among Catholic females (64% in 1981, 56% in 1984, 61% in 1992 and 38% in 1998). The content of the reported religious experience is analysed and illustrated within nine descriptive categories characterised as: help and guidance, exams, God's presence, answered prayer, death, sickness, conversion, difficulty in describing, and miscellaneous.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Barnes

L. P.

(2005a), Was the Northern Ireland conflict religious? Journal of Contemporary Religion, 20, 53–67.

Barnes

L. P.

(2005b), Religion, education and conflict in Northern Ireland, Journal of Beliefs and Values, 26, 123–138.

Beardsworth

(1977), A Sense of Presence, Oxford, Religious Experience Research Unit.

Cairns

, and Darby

(1998), The conflict in Northern Ireland: causes, consequences and controls, American Psychologist, 53, 754–760.

Elkind

, and Elkind

(1962), Varieties of religious experience in young adolescents, Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion, 2, 102–112.

Erricker

, Erricker

, Sullivan

, Ota

, and Fletcher

(1997), The Education of the Whole Child, London, Cassell.

Farmer

L. J.

(1992), Religious experience in childhood: a study of adult perspectives on early spiritual awareness, Religious Education, 87, 259–268.

Francis

L. J.

, and Greer

J. E.

(1993), The contribution of religious experience to Christian development: a study among fourth, fifth and sixth year pupils in Northern Ireland, British Journal of Religious Education, 15, 38–43.

Francis

L. J.

, and Greer

J. E.

(1999), Religious experience and attitude toward Christianity among Protestant Catholic adolescents in Northern Ireland, Research in Education, 61, 1–7.

10.

Greer

J. E.

(1981), Religious experience and religious education, Search, 4(1), 23–34.

11.

Greer

J. E.

(1982), The religious experience of Northern Irish pupils, The Irish Catechist, 6(2), 49–58.

12.

Greer

J. E.

, and Francis

L. J.

(1992), Religious experience and attitude toward Christianity among secondary school children in Northern Ireland, Journal of Social Psychology, 132, 277–279.

13.

Hardy

(1979), The Spiritual Nature of Man, Oxford, Oxford University Press.

14.

Hay

(1982), Exploring Inner Space, Harmondsworth, Penguin.

15.

Hay

, and Heald

(1987), Religion is good for you, New Society, 80, 20–22.

16.

Hay

, and Morisy

(1978), Reports of ecstatic, paranormal or religious experience in Great Britain and the United States: a comparison of trends, Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion, 17, 255–268.

17.

Hay

(1985), Secular society, religious meanings: a contemporary paradox, Review of Religious Research, 26, 213–227.

18.

Hay

with Nye

(1998), The Spirit of the Child, London, Fount.

19.

Hoge

D. R.

, and Smith

E. I.

(1982), Normative and non-normative religious experience among high school youth, Sociological Analysis, 43, 69–82.

20.

Miles

G. B.

(1983), A critical and experimental study of adolescents’ attitudes to and understanding of transcendental experience, Unpublished Ph.D. dissertation, University of Leeds.

21.

Mitchell

(2005), Behind the ethnic marker: religion and social identification in Northern Ireland, Sociology of Religion, 66, 3–21.

22.

Paffard

(1973), Inglorious Wordsworths: a study of transcendental experiences in childhood and adolescence, London, Hodder and Stoughton.

23.

Robinson

(1977a), The Original Vision, Oxford, Religious Experience Research Unit.

24.

Robinson

(1977b), This Time-Bound Ladder, Oxford, Religious Experience Research Unit.

25.

Robinson

(1978), Living the Questions, Oxford, Religious Experience Research Unit.

26.

Robinson

, and Jackson

(1987), Religion and Values at 16+, Oxford, Alister Hardy Research Centre and CEM.

27.

Scott

D. G.

(2004), Retrospective spiritual narratives: exploring recalled childhood and adolescent spiritual experiences, International Journal of Children's Spirituality, 9, 67–79.

28.

Tamminen

(1991), Religious Development in Childhood and Youth: an empirical study, Helsinki, Suomalainen Tiedeakatemia.