This study examines the tradeoffs in sourcing and sales strategies (i.e., upstream and downstream supply chain strategies) by considering them as components of an integral end‐to‐end supply chain strategy. We evaluate four end‐to‐end supply chain strategies under various scenarios using a newsvendor model, and compare the model's predictions against the prescriptions in Fisher's (1997) framework, which recommends “cost‐efficient” supply chains for “functional” products and “responsive” supply chains for “innovative” products. We considered combinations of offshore vs. nearshore sourcing, and online vs. brick‐and‐mortar retailing. This study's key finding is that sourcing and sales strategies are not completely modular: an integral end‐to‐end strategy may not decompose into an optimal sourcing strategy and a separately computed optimal sales strategy. Our analyses sharpen strategic supply chain thinking by identifying realistic conditions in which an end‐to‐end strategy with cost‐efficient components could outperform one with responsive components for innovative products, or when one with responsive components could be more profitable than one with cost‐efficient components for functional products.
AryaA.MittendorfB.SappingtonD.. 2007. The bright side of supplier encroachment. Market. Sci.26(5): 651–659.
2.
BalakrishnanA.SundaresanS.ZhangB.. 2014. Browse‐and‐switch: Retail‐online competition under value uncertainty. Prod. Oper. Manag.23(7): 1129–1145.
3.
BalasubramanianS.1998. Mail versus mall: A strategic analysis of competition between direct marketers and conventional retailers. Market. Sci.17(3): 181–195.
4.
BergA.HedrichS.. 2014. What's next in apparel sourcing. Perspectives on retail and consumer goods, edited by McKinsey & Company, (3).
5.
BergA.BrantbergL.HerringL.SilénP.. 2015. Mind the Gap: What Really Matters for Apparel Retailers in Omnichannel. McKinsey & Company.
6.
BermanO.KrassD.TajbakhshM.. 2011. On the benefits of risk pooling in inventory management. Prod. Oper. Manag.20(1): 57–71.
7.
BernsteinF.FedergruenA.. 2005. Decentralized supply chains with competing retailers under demand uncertainty. Management Sci.51(1): 18–29.
8.
Boston Consulting Group. 2015. Reshoring of Manufacturing to the US Gains Momentum. Boston Consulting Group.
9.
BrynjolfssonE.HuY.RahmanM.. 2009. Battle of the retail channels: How product selection and geography drive cross‐channel competition. Management Sci.55(11): 1755–1765.
10.
CalvoE.Martinez‐de‐AlbenizV.. 2016. Sourcing strategies and supplier incentives for short‐life‐cycle goods. Management Sci.62(2): 436–455.
11.
ChiangC.BentonW.. 1994. Sole sourcing versus dual sourcing under stochastic demands and lead times. Nav. Res. Logisti.41(5): 609–624.
12.
ChiangW.ChhajedD.HessJ.. 2003. Direct marketing, indirect profits: A strategic analysis of dual‐channel supply‐chain design. Management Sci.49(1): 1–20.
13.
DanaJ.SpierK.. 2001. Revenue sharing and vertical control in the video rental industry. J. Indus. Econ.49(3): 223–245.
FisherM.1997. What is the right supply chain for your product?Harv. Bus. Rev.75(2): 105–116.
16.
FisherM.RamanA.. 2010. The New Science of Retailing: How Analytics Are Transforming the Supply Chain and Improving Performance. Harvard Business Press, Boston, MA.
17.
Forrester Research. 2014. U.S. e‐commerce forecast: 2013 to 2018. Forrester Research.
GaoF.SuX.. 2017. Omnichannel retail operations with buy‐online‐and‐pick‐up‐in‐store. Management Sci.63(8): 2478–2492.
20.
GhemawatP.NuenoJ.. 2003. Zara: Fast Fashion. Harvard Business School, Boston, MA.
21.
GravesS.MealH.DasuS.QiuY.. 1986. Two‐stage production planning in a dynamic environment. AxaterS.SchneeweissC.SilverE., eds. Multi‐Stage Production Planning and Control. Springer‐Verlag, Berlin, 9–43.
22.
GuideV.JrSouzaG.VanWassenhoveL.BlackburnJ.. 2006. Time value of commercial product returns. Management Sci.52(8): 1200–1214.
23.
HeathD.JacksonP.. 1994. Modeling the evolution of demand forecasts with application to safety stock analysis in production/distribution systems. IIE Trans.26(3): 17–30.
24.
IBISWorld. 2014a. IBISWorld industry report 44811: Men's clothing stores in the US. IBISWorld.
25.
IBISWorld. 2014b. IBISWorld industry report 44812: Women's clothing stores in the US. IBISWorld.
26.
IBISWorld. 2016. IBISWorld industry report C1311‐GL: Global apparel manufacturing. IBISWorld.
27.
International Apparel Federation. 2017. About IAF. Available at http://iafnet.eu/about/ (accessed date February 25, 2017).
LarsenM.ManningS.PedersenT.. 2013. Uncovering the hidden costs of offshoring: The interplay of complexity, organizational design, and experience. Strateg. Manag. J.34(5): 533–552.
30.
LiC.2013. Sourcing for supplier effort and competition: Design of the supply base and pricing mechanism. Management Sci.59(6): 1389–1406.
31.
LiD.O'BrienC.. 2001. A quantitative analysis of relationships between product types and supply chain strategies. Int. J. Prod. Econ.73(1): 29–39.
32.
LiZ.GilbertS.LaiG.. 2014. Supplier encroachment under asymmetric information. Management Sci.60(2): 449–462.
33.
LoudinA. 2007. Bean there, returned that. Available at http://www.inboundlogistics.com/cms/article/bean-there-returned-that/ (accessed date October 15, 2015).
34.
eMarketer, 2017. Commerce snapshot. Available at https://www.emarketer.com/public_media/docs/ (accessed date February 25, 2017).
35.
ManyikaJ.BughinJ.LundS.NottebohmO.PoulterD.JauchS.RamaswamyS.. 2014. Global flows in a digital age: How trade, finance, people and data connect the world economy. McKinsey Global Institute. Available at http://www.mckinsey.com/business-functions/strategy-and-corporate-finance/our-insights/global-flows-in-a-digital-age (accessed date December 1, 2014).
36.
New York Times. 2017. Amazon to open retail store in Manhattan in Time Warner Center.
37.
OfekE.KatonaZ.SarvaryM.. 2011. “Bricks and clicks”: The impact of product returns on the strategies of multichannel retailers. Market. Sci.30(1): 42–60.
38.
PetersenJ.KumarV.. 2009. Are product returns a necessary evil? Antecedents and consequences. J. Market.73(3): 35–51.
39.
PisanoG.AdamsP.. 2009. VF Brands: Global Supply Chain Strategy. Harvard Business School, Boston, MA.
40.
ReitzigM.WagnerS.. 2010. The hidden costs of outsourcing: Evidence from patent data. Strateg. Manag. J.31(11): 1183–1201.
41.
SchweitzerM.CachonG.. 2000. Decision bias in the newsvendor problem with a known demand distribution: Experimental evidence. Management Sci.46(3): 404–420.
TaylorT.2002. Supply chain coordination under channel rebates with sales effort effects. Management Sci.48(8): 992–1007.
44.
TrelevenM.SchweikhartS.. 1988. A risk/benefit analysis of sourcing strategies: Single vs. multiple sourcing. J. Oper. Manag.7(4): 93–114.
45.
deTrevilleS.TrigeorgisL.. 2010. It may be cheaper to manufacture at home. Harv. Bus. Rev.88(10): 84–87.
46.
U.S. Census Bureau. 2017. Quarterly retail e‐commerce sales: 4th quarter 2016. Report, U.S. Census Bureau, Washington, DC.
47.
WeinswigD. 2017. Five ways that Amazon is shaking up retail.Available at https://www.forbes.com/sites/deborahweinswig/2016/05/24/5-ways-that-amazon-is-shaking-up-retail/ (accessed date April 30, 2017).
48.
WoodS.2001. Remote purchase environments: The influence of return policy leniency on two‐stage decision processes. J. Mark. Res.38(2): 157–169.
49.
WSJ. 2013. Rampant returns plague e‐retailers. Wall Street Journal.
50.
WuX.ZhangF.. 2014. Home or overseas? An analysis of sourcing strategies under competition. Management Sci.60(5): 1223–1240.
51.
YoonD.2016. Supplier encroachment and investment spillovers. Prod. Oper. Manag.25(11): 1839–1854.
52.
ZhangW.HuaZ.BenjaafarS.. 2012. Optimal inventory control with dual‐Sourcing, heterogeneous ordering costs and order size constraints. Prod. Oper. Manag.21(3): 564–575.
