In this paper we present the results of an empirical study of the manufacturing sites of foreign electronics companies in Singapore and Taiwan. The manufacturing and R&D capabilities at the sites are assessed. The way in which host government policies interact with R&D development at the sites and the speed of the R&D development are also considered. The results suggest that Singapore and Taiwan are now host to some advanced manufacturing and R&D operations. We show, however, that the product design work at the sites visited is never leading edge for the companies concerned. The speed at which product design responsibilities were designated to the sites is shown to be rapid when compared to an earlier study of foreign sites in the United Kingdom. We indicate areas in which national strategies in Singapore and Taiwan may have contributed to this faster development. In Singapore, we identify tax holidays and R&D grants as contributing to the pace of development.
AbernathyW. J., and TownsendP. L. (1975), “Technology, Productivity and Process Change,”Technological Forecasting and Social Change, 7, 379–396.
2.
AboT. (1984), “US Subsidiaries of Japanese Electronic Companies Enter a New Phase of Activities: A Report of On‐the‐Spot Observations,”Annals of the Institute of Social Science, 26.
3.
AgarwalS. M. (1985), “Electronics in India: Past Strategies and Future Possibilities,”World Development, 13, 3, 273–292.
4.
BehrmanJ. N., and FischerW. A. (1980), “Transnational Corporations: Market Orientations and R&D Abroad,”Columbia Journal of World Business, 15, 3, 55–60.
5.
CaneA. (1992). “Information Technology and Competitive Advantage: Lessons from the Developed Countries,”World Development, 20, 12, 1721–1736.
6.
CapannelliG. (1992), “Transfer of Japanese Electronics Industry to Malaysia,”Graduate School of Economics, Hitosubashi University, Tokyo, September.
7.
ChenE. K. Y. (1983), Multi‐national Corporations, Technology and Employment, MacMillan, New York.
8.
De MeyerA. (1991), “Tech Talk: How Managers Are Stimulating Global R&D Communication,”Sloan Management Review, Spring, 49–58.
9.
DobsonW. (1993). Japan in East Asia, Trading and Investment Strategies, ISEAS Series on Japan and the Asia Pacific, Institute of Southeast Asian Studies.
10.
Economic Development Board (1993), Singapore Electronics Manufacturers Directory.
11.
EncarnationdD. J. (1992), “Americans and Japanese in East Asia,” in Rivals Beyond Trade, America Versus Japan in Global Competition, Cornell University Press, Ithaca, NY.
12.
ErberF. S. (1985), “The Development of the Electronics Complex and Government Policies in Brazil,”World Development, 13, 3, 293–309.
13.
FerdowsK. (1989), “Mapping International Factory Networks,” in Managing International Manufacturing, FerdowsK. (ed.), North‐Holland, New York, 3–21.
14.
FerdowsK. (1993), “Foreign Operations,” in The American Edge, KleinJ. and MillerJ. (eds.), McGraw Hill, New York, 180–202.
15.
Financial Times (1994a), August 19, 21.
16.
Financial Times (1994b), August 24, 19.
17.
GhoshalS., and BartlettC. A. (1988), “Creation, Adoption and Diffusion of Innovations by Subsidiaries of Multinational Corporations,”Journal of International Business Studies, Fall, 365–388.
18.
Government Information Office (1992), Questions and Answers About the Republic of China on Taiwan, Government Information Office, Taipei.
19.
HaugP. (1986), “US High Technology Multi‐nationals and Silicon Glen,”Regional Studies, 20, 2, 103–116.
20.
HaugP.HoodN., and YoungS. (1983) “R&D Intensity in the Affiliates of US Owned Electronics Companies Manufacturing in Scotland,”Regional Studies, 17, 6, 383–392.
21.
HelleinerG. K., and LavergneR. (1979). “Intra‐Firm Trade and Industrial Exports to the United States,”Oxford Bulletin of Economics and Statistics, 41, 297–311.
22.
HirscheyrR. C., and CavesR. E. (1981), “Research and Technology Transfer by Multi‐national Enterprises,”Oxford Bulletin of Economics and Statistics, 43, 2, 115–130.
23.
HobdayM. (1994), “Export‐led Technology Development in the Four Dragons: The Case of Electronics,”Development and Change, 25, 2, 333–361.
24.
HoodN., and YoungS. (1982). “US Multi‐national R&D: Corporate Strategies and Policy Implications for the UK,”Multi-national Business, 2, 10–23.
25.
HowellsJ. (1990), “The Internationalisation of R&D and the Development of Global Research Networks,”Regional Studies, 24, 6, 495–512.
26.
Institute for Information Industry (1993), R.O.C. Information Industry, (on Computer Disc).
27.
KleinschmidtE. J., and CooperR. G. (1991), “The Impact of Product Innovativeness on Performance,”Journal of Product Innovation Management, 8, 4, 240–251.
28.
LallS. (1979), “The International Allocation of Research Activity by US Multi‐nationals,”Oxford Bulletin of Economics and Statistics, 41, 313–331.
29.
LeeT. Y. (1991). Growth Triangle: The Johor‐Singapore‐Riau Experience, Institute of South East Asian Studies, Singapore.
30.
LevyJ. C. (1994), UK Manufacturing: Facing International Change, Institution of Electrical Engineers, London, UK.
31.
LiuH. L. (1987), “ROC‐US Cooperative Relations in the Development of Science and Technology,” in ROCUS Relations Under the Taiwan Relations Act: Practice and Prospects, King‐yuhChang (ed.), Institute of International Relations English Monograph Series No. 33, National Chengchi University, Taiwan.
32.
LowL.HengT. M.WongS. T.YamT. K., and HughesH. (1993), Challenge and Response: Thirty Years of the Economic Development Board, Times Academic Press, Singapore.
33.
MansfieldE.TeeceD., and RomeoA. (1979), “Overseas Research and Development by US‐Based Firms,”Economica, 46, 187–196.
34.
Ministry of Trade and Industry (1992), Economic Survey of Singapore, Singapore.
35.
MoxonR. W. (1975), “The Motivation for Investment in Off‐shore Plants: The Case of the US Electronics Industry,”Journal of International Business Studies, 6, 1, 51–66.
36.
NatarajanS., and MiangT. J. (1992), The Impact of MNC Investments in Malaysia, Singapore and Thailand, Institute of Southeast Asian Studies, Singapore.
37.
National Technology Plan (1991), Window of Opportunities, National Technology Plan, National Science and Technology Board, Singapore.
38.
O'ConnorD. C. (1985). “The Computer Industry in the Third World: Policy Options and Constraints,”World Development, 13, 3, 311–332.
39.
ParryT. G., and WatsonJ. F. (1979), “Technology Flows and Foreign Investment in the Australian Manufacturing Sector,”Australian Economic Papers, 18, 103–118.
40.
PearceR. D. (1989), The Internationalisation of Research and Development by Multinational Enterprises, MacMillan, New York.
41.
PearceR. D. and SinghS. (1991), “The Overseas Laboratory,” in Global Research Strategy and International Competitiveness, CassonM. (ed.), Blackwell, New York, 183–212.
42.
ReichR. (1990), “Who is Us?,”Harvard Business Review, Jan‐Feb, 53–64.
43.
RonstadtR. C. (1978). “International R&D: The Establishment and Evolution of Research and Development Abroad by Seven US Multi‐nationals,”Journal of International Business Studies, 9, 1, 7–24.
44.
RosenbloomR. S., and AbernathyW. J. (1982), “The Climate for Innovation in Industry. The Role of Management Attitudes and Practices in Consumer Electronics,”Research Policy, 11, 209–225.
45.
Sectoral Planning Department (1992), Imports and Exports of Electronics Products, Republic of China, 1991, Council for Economic Planning and Development, Taiwan.
46.
StaceyM. (1969). Methods of Social Research, Pergamon Press, New York.
47.
StreetenP. (1993), “The Special Problems of Small Countries,”World Development, 21, 2, 197–202.
48.
TEAMA (1993), Taiwan Electric and Electronic Products Buyers' Guide 1992–1993, Taiwan Electric Appliance Manufacturers' Association.
49.
ThomsenS. (1992), “We Are All Us,”Columbia Journal of World Business, Winter, 7–14.
50.
TilleyK. J.WilliamsD. J., and ConwayP. P. (1994), “Off‐shore Development of Electronics Products,”Engineering Management Journal, 4, 4, 185–192.
51.
VernonR. (1966), “International Investment and International Trade in the Product Cycle,”Quarterly Journal of Economics, May, 80, 190–207.
52.
VogelE. F. (1991), The Four Little Dragons, Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA.
53.
WhiteR. E., and PoynterT. A. (1984), “Strategies for Foreign‐owned Subsidiaries in Canada,”Business Quarterly, Summer, 59–69.
54.
WongP. K. (1993), “Managing Technological Innovation in MNC Subsidiaries: The Role of Local Champions and Gatekeepers,”Asian Technology Management Conference: Strategies for Global Competitiveness, 18–20 August.
55.
World Bank (1993), The East Asian Miracle, Oxford University Press, New York.
56.
YoshidaM. (1987), Japanese Direct Manufacturing Investment in the United States, Praeger, New York.
