In this study, we estimate earnings differentials for knowledge of thirteen minority languages in Canada's three largest urban areas. We find that conditional on knowledge of a majority language, knowledge of a minority language is associated with lower earnings. However, the negative differential diminishes for those languages with large local populations. This suggests a positive human capital effect which is for the most part swamped by a negative factor. We argue that this factor is a reflection of ethnicity operating either through ethnolinguistic labor market enclaves or labor market discrimination against minorities.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
BakerM., and BenjaminD.1997“Ethnicity, Foreign Birth and Earnings: A Canada/U.S. Comparison.” In Transition and Structural Change in the North American Labour Market. Ed. AbbottM., BeachC., and ChaykowskiR.Kingston, Ontario: Industrial Relations Centre and John Deutsch Institute. Pp. 281–313
2.
BlaisA., MartinP., and NadeauR.1995“Attentes Economiques et Linguistiques et Appui a la Souverainete du Quebec: Une Analyse Prospective et Comparative,”Canadian Journal of Political Science, 28: 637–657. December.
3.
BloomD. E., and GrenierG.1992“Earnings of the French Minority in Canada and the Spanish Minority in the United States.” In Immigration, Language, and Ethnicity: Canada and the United States. Ed. ChiswickB. R.Washington, DC: The AEI Press.
4.
BonacichE., and ModellJ.1980The Economic Basis of Ethnic Solidarity.Berkeley: University of California Press.
5.
BretonR.1974“Ethnic Stratification Viewed from Three Theoretical Perspectives.” In Social Stratification: Canada, 2nd edition. Ed. CurtisJ. E., and ScottW.Toronto: Prentice-Hall.
6.
ChiswickB. R.1991“Speaking, Reading, and Earnings among Low-skilled Immigrants,”Journal of Labor Economics, 9: 149–170. April.
7.
ChristofidesL., and SwidinskyR.1997“Bilingualism and Earnings: A Study Based on 1971, 1981 and 1991 Census Data.”Ottawa: Official Languages Branch, Dept. of Canadian Heritage.
8.
DavilaA., BoharaA. K., and SaenzR.1993“Accent Penalties and Earnings of Mexican Americans,”Social Science Quarterly, 74: 902–916. December.
9.
DustmannC.1997“The Effects of Education, Parental Background and Ethnic Concentration on Language,”Quarterly Review of Economics and Finance, 37: 245–262.
10.
DustmannC.1996“Temporary Migration, Human Capital and Language Fluency of Migrants,” University College London Working Paper. Pp. 96–21.
11.
DustmannC.1994“Speaking Fluency, Writing Fluency and Earnings of Migrants,”Journal of Population Economics, 7(2): 133–156.
12.
FenwickR.1982“Ethnic Culture and Economic Structure: Determinants of French-English Earnings Inequality in Quebec,”Social Forces, 61(1): 1–23. September.
13.
GouveiaL., and RousseauM. O.1995“Talk is Cheap: The Value of Language in the World Economy - Illustrations from the United States and Quebec,”Sociological Inquiry, 65: 156–180. Spring.
14.
GrinF.1994“The Economics of Language: Match or Mismatch?,”International Political Science Review, 15: 25–42. January.
15.
KanazawaH., and LovedayL.1988“The Japanese Immigrant Community in Brazil: Language Contact and Shift,”Journal of Multilingual and Multicultural Development, 9(5): 423–435.
16.
KossoudjiS. A.1988“English Language Ability and the Labor Market Opportunities of Hispanic and East Asian Immigrant Men,”Journal of Labor Economics, 6: 205–228. April.
17.
KraltJ., and PendakurR.1991“Ethnicity, Immigration and Language Shift.”Ottawa: Policy and Research, Multiculturalism Sector.
18.
LachapelleR.1989“Evolution of Language Groups and the Official Languages Situation in Canada.” Paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the American Sociological Association.
19.
LangK.1993“Language and Economists' Theories of Discrimination,”International Journal of the Sociology of Language, 103: 165–183.
20.
LangK.1986“A Language Theory of Discrimination,”Quarterly Journal of Economics, 101: 363–382. May.
21.
LangK., and KroppD.1986“Human Capital Versus Sorting: The Effects of Compulsory Attendance Laws,”Quarterly Journal of Economics, 101: 609–624. August.
22.
LazearE. P.1997“Culture and Language.” Unpublished working paper. Stanford University.
23.
LazearE. P.1995“Culture and Language.” NBER Working Paper No. 5249. Cambridge, MA: National Bureau of Economic Research.
24.
LianJ. Z., and MatthewsD.R.1998“Does the Vertical Mosaic Still Exist? Ethnicity and Income in Canada, 1991,”Canadian Review of Sociology and Anthropology, 35(4): 461–482.
25.
LightI.1997“Immigrant and Ethnic Enterprise in North America,”Ethnic and Racial Studies, 7: 195–216.
26.
LopezD. E.1978“Chicano Language Loyalty in an Urban Setting,”Sociology and Social Research, 62(2): 267–278. January.
27.
NadeauR., and FleuryC. J.1995“Gains Linguistiques Anticipes et Appui a la Souverainete du Quebec,”Canadian Journal of Political Science, 28: 35–50. March.
28.
PendakurK., and PendakurR.1998a “The Colour of Money: Income Differentials across Ethnic Groups,”Canadian Journal of Economics, 31(3): 518–548. August.
29.
PendakurK., and PendakurR.1998b “Speak and Ye Shall Receive: Language Knowledge as Human Capital.” In Economic Approaches to Languages and Bilingualism. Ed. BretonA.Ottawa: Official Languages Promotion and Education, Dept. of Canadian Heritage.
30.
StolzenbergR. M., and TiendaM.1997“English Proficiency, Education, and the Conditional Economic Assimilation of Hispanic and Asian Origin Men,”Social Science Research, 26: 25–51. March.
31.
ShapiroD., and StelcnerM.1996“Language and Earnings in Quebec: Trends over Twenty Years, 1970–1990.” RUM Working Paper 96–05. Burnaby, Canada: Research on Immigrants and Integration in the Metropolis, Simon Fraser University.
32.
ShapiroD., and StelcnerM.1987“The Persistence of the Male-Female Earnings Gap in Canada, 1970–1980: The Impact of Equal Pay Laws and Language Policies,”Canadian Public Policy, 13(4): 462–476.
33.
TiendaM., and NeidertL.1984“Language, Education, and the Socioeconomic Achievement of Hispanic Origin Men,”Social Science Quarterly, 65: 519–536. June.
34.
TimmL.1980“Bilingualism, Diglossia and Language Shift in Brittany,”International Journal of the Sociology of Language, 25: 29–42.
35.
VaillancourtF.1992“An Economic Perspective on Language and Public Policy in Canada and the United States.” In Immigration, Language, and Ethnicity: Canada and the United States. Ed. ChiswickB. R.Washington, DC: The American Enterprise Institute Press.
36.
WilsonK., and PortesA.1980“Immigrant Enclaves: An Analysis of the Labor Market Experiences of Cubans in Miami,”American Journal of Sociology, 86: 295–319.
37.
YoungR.1988“Language Maintenance and Language Shift in Taiwan,”Journal of Multilingual and Multicultural Development, 9(4): 323–338.
