Sage Journals: Discover world-class research

Abstract

This article examines the operation of the ‘no disadvantage test’ (NDT) as it applies to the approval or certification of certain forms of agreements under the Workplace Relations Act 1996 (Cwlth). The purpose is to make an assessment of the effectiveness of the test in meeting the supposed statutory intention that workers would not be made worse-off as a result of entering into agreements which derogated from award and other legally prescribed conditions of employment. The article reports on research which applied the NDT in detail to 36 agreements, and, more partially, to a further 48 agreements. The general conclusion arrived at, though heavily qualified, was that in certain defined respects, the NDT, as presently constructed and applied, is failing adequately to protect employees from a deterioration in their terms and conditions of employment.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

ACIRRT (1999) Australia at Work: Just Managing. Sydney: Prentice Hall .

AIRC (2003–04) Annual Report. Canberra: commonwealth of Australia .

Allan C , O’Donnell M , Peetz D (1999) More tasks, less secure, working harder: Three dimensions of labour utilisation . Journal of Industrial Relations 41: 519-519 .

Bennett L (1995) Bargaining away the rights of the weak: Non-union agreements in the federal jurisdiction. In: Ronfeldt P , McCallum R , eds, Enterprise Bargaining: Trade Unions and the Law, p. 129-129. Sydney: Federation Press .

Bray M , Waring P (1998) The rhetoric and reality of bargaining structures under the Howard government . Labour and Industry 9: 61-61 .

Campling J , Gollan P (1999) Bargained Out. Sydney: Federation Press .

Creighton B , Stewart A (2005) Labour Law, 2nd edn. Sydney: Federation Press .

Fetter J , Mitchell R (2004) The legal complexity of workplace regulation and its impact upon functional .exibility in Australian workplaces . Australian Journal of Labour Law 17: 276-276 .

Ford W (1997) Rearranging workplace relations: Revolution or evolution? University of Western Australia Law Review 27: 86-86 .

10.

Goodman H (1998) The employment advocate: How effective can the role be under the Workplace Relations Act 1996? (Cwlth). In: Naughton R , ed, The Workplace Relations Act in Operation, p. 9-9. Melbourne: Centre for Employment and Labour Relations Law, The University of Melbourne .

11.

MacDonald D , Campbell I , Burgess J (2001) Ten years of enterprise bargaining in Australia: An introduction . Labour and Industry 12: 1-1 .

12.

McCarry G (1998) From industry to enterprise, from award to agreement: Federal laws and workplace change in Australia. In: Nolan DR , ed, The Australasian Labour Law Reforms, p. 52-52. Sydney: Federation Press .

13.

Merlo O (2000) Flexibility and stretching rights: The no disadvantage test in enterprise bargaining . Australian Journal of Labour Law 13: 207-207 .

14.

Mitchell R , Fetter J (2003) The Individualisation of Employment Relationships and the Adoption of High Performance Work Practices: Final Report. Melbourne: Workplace Innovation Unit, Industrial Relations Victoria and Centre for Employment and Labour Relations Law, The University of Melbourne .

15.

Mitchell R , Campbell C , Barnes A (2004) Protecting the Worker's Interest in Enterprise Bargaining: The ‘No Disadvantage Test’ in the Australian Federal Industrial Jurisdiction—Final Report. Melbourne: Workplace Innovation Unit, Industrial Relations Victoria .

16.

Naughton R (1997) New approaches to the vetting of agreements. In: ACIRRT, New Rights and Remedies for Individual Employees—Implications for Employers and Unions, p. 16-16. Sydney: University of Sydney, Australian Centre for Industrial Relations Research and Training , Working Paper No. 48.

17.

Naughton R (1999) A review of the “second wave” legislation . HR Monthly September: 41-41 .

18.

Peetz D (1998) The safety net, bargaining and the role of the Australian Industrial Relations Commission . Journal of Industrial Relations 40: 532-532 .

19.

Peetz D (2001) Individual Contracts, Collective Bargaining, Wages and Power. Canberra: Centre for Economic Policy Research, Australian National University , Discussion Paper No. 437.

20.

Waring P , Lewer J (2001) The no disadvantage test: Failing workers . Labour and Industry 12: 65-65 .

21.

Watson I , Buchanan J , Campbell I , Briggs C (2003) Fragmented Futures. Sydney: Federation Press .

22.

Wooden M (2003) The changing labour market and its impact on work and employment relations. In: Callus R , Lansbury D , eds, Working Futures, p. 51-51. Sydney: Federation Press .

What's Going on with the ‘No Disadvantage Test’? An Analysis of Outcomes and Processes Under the Workplace Relations Act 1996 (CWLTH)

Abstract

Get full access to this article

References