Alcohol and illicit substance abuse in the workplace is an important human resource and industrial relations issue. Although more sophisticated measures have been developed to test and monitor drug use in the workplace, and despite tacit union support on occupational health and safety grounds, the implementation of drug testing procedures remains contentious. This paper examines the arguments for and against drug testing in the workplace using an Australian case study where drug testing resulted in industrial disputation that led to legal intervention and remedy.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
ABC Radio National (1996) The Business Report: Protecting Privacy in the Workplace, 18 March. http://www.abc.net.au/rn/talks/8.30/busrpt/bstories/br181096.htm.
2.
ABC Radio National (1998) The World Today: Interview with Caitlin Shea, 9 August.
3.
ACIRRT (1999) Australia at Work: Just Managing. Sydney: Prentice-Hall .
4.
AIRC (2000) SBCL and CFMEU and CUPE. Decision 9 August: Print S9023.
5.
Alcohol and other Drugs Council of Australia (2004) Submission to: The Department of Transport and Regional Services and the Civil Aviation Safety Authority—Review of the safety benefits of introducing drug and alcohol testing for safety-sensitive personnel in the aviation industry, June.
6.
Allsop S , Phillips M , Calogero C (2001) Drug and Work: Responding to Alcohol and Other Drug Problems in Australian Workplaces. Melbourne: IP Communications .
7.
Allsop S , Pidd K (2001) The nature of drug related harm in the workplace. In: Allsop S , Phillips M , Calogero C , eds, Drug and Work: Responding to Alcohol and Other Drug Problems in Australian Workplaces, pp. 4–21. Melbourne: IP Communications .
8.
Ames G , Grube JW (1999) Alcohol availability and workplace drinking: Mixed method analysis . Journal of Studies of Alcohol60 (3): 383–393 .
9.
Bahls JE (1998) Drugs in the workplace. HRMagazine, February, 81–87.
10.
BHP Iron Ore Pty Ltd v Construction, Mining Energy Timberyards Sawmills and Woodworkers Union, WA Branch , WAIRC 130, 19 June (1998).
11.
Bohle P , Quinlan M (2000) Managing Health and Safety: A Multidisciplinary Approach, 2nd edition. Melbourne: Macmillan .
12.
Bowie NE , Duska RF (1990) Business Ethics, 2nd edition. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall .
13.
Cranford M (2001) Drug testing and the right to privacy . Journal of Business Ethics17: 1805–1815 .
14.
Daly A , Philp A (1995) Alcohol Consumption in Western Australia, July 1991 to June 1992. Perth, WA: Health Department of Western Australia .
15.
DesJardine JR , Duska RF (2001) Drug testing in employment. In: Beauchamp TL , Bowie NE , eds, Ethical Theory and Business, 6th edition, pp. 283–293. New Jersey: Prentice-Hall .
16.
DesJardine JR , McCall JJ (1990) Contemporary Issues in Business Ethics, 2nd edition. Belmont, CA: Wadsworth Publishing Company .
17.
Flynn G (1999) How to prescribe drug testing . Workforce78 (1): 107-107 .
18.
Gip MA (1999) Drug testing assailed . Security Management43 (12): 16-16 .
19.
Greenburg E (1992) Test positive drop as more companies screen employees . HR Focus69 (6): 7-7 .
20.
Greenburg E , Greenburg S (1995) Work alienation and problem alcohol behavior . Journal of Health and Social Behavior36 (1): 83–102 .
21.
Hagen R , Egan D , Eltringham A (1992) Work, Drugs and Alcohol. Melbourne: Occupational Health and Safety Commission Inquiry into Alcohol, Drugs and the Workplace, Victorian Occupational Health and Safety Commission .
22.
Hartwell TD , Steele PD , French MT , Rodman NE (1996) Prevalence of drug testing in the workplace . Monthly Labour Review19 (11): 35–42 .
23.
Hendy P (2004) Common sense needed on workplace drug testing. Australian Chamber of Commerce and Industry Media Release, 7 August.
24.
Holland PJ , Wickham M (2001) Drug testing in the workplace: The case of the South Blackwater Mine . The Management Case Study Journal1 (2): 1–17 .
25.
Independent Inquiry into Drug Testing at Work (IIDT) (2004) Drug Testing in the Workplace: Summary Conclusions of the Independent Inquiry into Drug Testing at Work, June. http://www.jrf.org.uk/knowledge/.ndings/foundations/694.asp.
26.
Keenoy T , Kelly D (1998) The Employment Relationship in Australia. Sydney: Harcourt Brace .
27.
Maltby L (1987) Why Drug Testing Is a Bad Idea. Inc, June, p. 152-152.
28.
Mansfield B (2001) Impairment of Employees –The Union View. http://www.actu.asn.au/public/news/1056670370_26248.html.
29.
Midford R (2001) The nature and extent of drug related harm in the workplace. In: Allsop S , Phillips M , Calogero C , eds, Drug and Work: Responding to Alcohol and Other Drug Problems in Australian Workplaces, pp. 42–56. Melbourne: IP Communications .
30.
Midford R, Marsden , Phillips M, Lake (1997) Workforce alcohol consumption: Patterns at two Pilbara mining related work sites . Journal of Occupational Health and Safety Australia and New Zealand13: 267–274 .
31.
Miletic B (2004) The Dilemma of Drug Testing in the Workplace. Safety Solutions, Feature Article. http://www.safetysolutions...safety/feature_article/item_012004a.asp.
32.
Moodie A (1998) Precedent for random drug, alcohol tests at work . Australian Financial Review3: 50-50 .
33.
National Health and Medical Research Council (1997) Workplace Injury and Alcohol. A report prepared by a Working Party of the Health Advancement Standing Committee for the NHMRC, Department of Health and Family Services. Canberra: AGPS .
Nolan J , Nomchong K (2000) Fitness for Duty—Recent Legal Development. ACIRRRT Working Paper No. 69.
36.
Norington B (2004) Random drug tests at frontline of workplace battleground. The Australian 26th March.
37.
Oliver W (1994) Fight drugs with knowledge . Training & Development48 (5): 105–108 .
38.
Osterloh J , Becker C (1990) Chemical dependency and drug testing in the workplace . Western Journal of Medicine152 (2): 506–513 .
39.
Phillips M (2001) The prevalence of drug use and risk of drug related harm in the workplace. In: Allsop S , Phillips M , Calogero C , eds, Drug and Work: Responding to Alcohol and Other Drug Problems in Australian Workplaces. pp. 20–41. Melbourne: IP Communications .
40.
Richmond R , Heather N , Holt P , Hu W (1992) Workplace Policies and Programs for Tobacco, Alcohol and Other Drugs in Australia. Canberra: AGPS .
41.
Redeker J , Segal J (1989) Profits low? Your employees may be high!Personnel66 (6): 72–77 .
42.
Roman RM , Johnson JA , Blum T (2000) The workplace, employer andemployee. In: Cooper DB , ed, Alcohol Use, pp. 121–133. Abingdon, Oxen: Radcliffe Medical Press .
43.
Scott-Howman A (2004) Developments in Employment Law. pp. 1–7. LexisNexis Professional Development In-House Counsel Legal Summit . http://www.lexisnexis.com.au/nz/conferences/seminars/papers/2003/Andrew_Scott_Howman.pdf.
44.
Seeman M , Seeman AZ (1992) Life strains, alienation and drinking behaviour . Alcoholism: Clinical and Experimental Research16: 199–205 .
45.
Thomas I (2002) Drug Testing a Red Herring. Victorian Trades Hall Council OHS Reps. http://www/ohsrep.org.au/news/1039050804_5940.html
46.
Tices HM , Sonnenstuhl WJ (1990) On the construction of drinking norms in work organisations . Journal of Studies in Alcohol51 (3).
47.
Wall PS (1992) Drug testing in the workplace: An update . Journal of Applied Business Research8 (2): 127–132 .
48.
Wasserstrom R (1978) Today's Moral Problems, 2nd edition. London: Macmillan .
49.
Webb G , Festa J (1994) Alcohol and other drug problems in the workplace: Is drug testing the appropriate solution . Journal of Occupational Health and Safety—Australia and New Zealand10 (2): 95–106 .
50.
Wright P (2004) Alcohol and Drugs in the Workplace. HR Connection, 18, Davidson Trahaire Corpsych, ACOR Services.
51.
Zwerling C , Ryan J , Orav EJ (1990) The efficacy of pre-employment drug screening for marijuana and cocaine in predicting employment outcome . Journal of the American Medical Association264 (20): 2630–2643 .
