Over the past 20 years there has been a significant refashioning of the labour market within Australia and other industrialised countries. This paper examines the implications of the growth of more flexible work arrangements for mechanisms designed to facilitate worker involvement in occupational health and safety at the workplace—a pivotal feature of post-Robens OHS legislation in Australia. It is argued that the growth of subcontracting, casual and home-based work has undermined both coverage and the effectiveness of these provisions, especially in a context where union membership and influence has also been declining. Looking at international experience, the paper examines a number of ways of remedying these deficiencies.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
ABS (2001) Employment Arrangements and Superannuation. Sydney : Australian Bureau of Statistics Catalogue No 6361.0.
2.
ABS (2002) Teleworking, New South Wales, 2001. Sydney : Australian Bureau of Statistics Catalogue No 1373.1.
3.
Anderson L (1994) Sykefravaevsprosjektet 1991-1994. Oslo: Sintef IFIM.
4.
Aronsson G (1999) Contingent workers and health and safety . Work, Employment and Society15(3), 439-460 .
5.
Assennato G , Navarro V (1980) Workers’ participation and control in Italy: The case of occupational medicine . International Journal of health Services10: 2 .
6.
Australian Centre for Industrial Relations Research and Teaching (ACIRRT) (June 2002) Special issue—Enterprise agreements and working from home. Adam Report No 33. Sydney: ACIRRT .
7.
Australian Council of Trade Unions (ACTU) (September 2002) A Report on the 2001 National Survey of Health and Safety Representatives. Melbourne: ACTU .
8.
Beaumont P , Coyle J , Leopold J , Schuller T (1982) The Determinants of Effective Joint Health and Safety Committees. Centre for Research into Industrial Democracy and Participation, Glasgow University (Report to ERSC).
9.
Bennett L (1994) Making Labour Law in Australia: Industrial Relations, Politics and Law. Sydney: Law Book Company .
10.
Biggins D , Holland T (1995) The training and effectiveness of health and safety representatives, in Eddington, I. Towards Health and Safety at Work: Technical Papers of the Asia Pacific Conference on Occupational Health and Safety, Brisbane .
11.
Biggins D , Phillips M (1991a) A survey of health and safety representatives in Queensland Part 1: Activities, issues, information sources . Journal of Occupational Health and Safety—Australia and New Zealand7(3), 195-202 .
12.
Biggins D , Phillips M (1991b) A survey of health and safety representatives in Queensland Part 2: Comparison of representatives and shop stewards . Journal of Occupational Health and Safety—Australia and New Zealand7(4), 281-286 .
13.
Biggins D , Phillips M , O’Sullivan P (1991) Benefits of worker participation in health and safety . Labour and Industry4(1), 138-159 .
14.
Bohle P , Quinlan M (2000) Managing Occupational Health and Safety: A Multidisciplinary Approach, 2nd edition. Melbourne: Macmillan .
15.
Bryce GK , Manga P (1985) The effectiveness of health and safety committees . Relations Industrielles40(2), 257-284 .
16.
Burgess J , De Ruyter A (2000) Declining job quality in Australia: Another hidden cost of unemployment . Economic and Labour Relations Review11(2), 246-249 .
17.
Burgess J , Mitchell W , Preston A (2003) The Australian Labour Market in 2002 . Journal of Industrial Relations45(2), 125-150 .
18.
Campbell I , Burgess J (2001a) Casual employment in Australia and temporary employment in Europe: Developing a cross-national comparison . Work, Employment and Society15(1), 171-184 .
19.
Campbell I , Burgess J (2001b) Temporary and casual: Rejoinder to wooden . Work, Employment and Society15(4), 885-888 .
20.
Cassou B , Pissaro B (1988) Workers’ participation in occupational health: The French experience . International Journal of Health Services18(1), 139-152 .
21.
CCH Australia OHS Alert, 9 September 2003.
22.
Collins H (1990) Ascription of legal responsibility to groups in complex patterns of economic integration . Modern Law Review53, 731-744 .
23.
Consultative Arrangements Working Party (2001) Working Together: A Review of the Effectiveness of the Health and Safety Representative and Workplace Health and Safety Committee System in South Australia—Final Report and Recommendations. Adelaide: WorkCover Corporation of South Australia .
24.
Daykin N (1997) Workplace health promotion: Issues and strategies for an insecure workforce . Paper presented to the 12th Employment Research Unit Conference. Cardiff Business School, 11-12 December.
25.
Dedobbeleer N , Champagne F , German P (1990) Safety performance among Union and Nonunion Workers in the Construction Industry . Journal of Occupational Medicine32(11), 1099-1103 .
26.
Eaton A , Nocerino T (2000) The effectiveness of Health and Safety Committees: Results of a Survey of Public Sector Workplaces . Industrial Relations39(2), 265-290 .
27.
Fairbrother P (2000) Trade Unions at the Crossroads. London: Mansell .
28.
Frick K , Walters DR (1998) Worker representation on health and safety in small enterprises: Lessons from a Swedish approach . International Labour Review137, 3 .
29.
Fuller D , Suruda A (2000) Occupationally related hydrogen sulphide deaths in the United States from 1984 to 1994 . Journal of Occupational and Environmental Medicine42(9), 939-942 .
30.
Gall G (2003) Union Organising: Campaigning for Trade Union Recognition. London: Routledge .
31.
Gaines J , Biggins D (1992) A survey of health and safety representatives in the Northern Territory . Journal of Occupational Health and Safety—Australia and New Zealand8(5), 421-428 .
32.
Gospel H , Wood S (2003) Representing Workers. London: Routledge .
33.
Grunberg L (1983) The effects of the social relations of production on productivity and workers’ safety . International Journal of Health Services13(4), 621-634 .
34.
Harcourt M , Harcourt S (2000) When can an employee refuse unsafe work and expect to be protected from discipline? Evidence from Canada . Industrial and Labor Relations Review55(4), 684-703 .
35.
Havlovic S , McShane SL (1997) The Effectiveness of Joint Health and Safety Committees and Safety Training in Reducing Fatalities and Injuries in British Columbia Forest Product Mills. Burnaby: Workers Compensation Board of British Columbia .
36.
HSC (2003) Consultative Document: New Regulations on Worker Representation in Health and Safety. Sudbury: HSE Books .
37.
Industry Commission (1995) Work, Health and Safety, Vols. I and II. Melbourne: Industry Commission .
38.
James P , Walters D (1997) Non-union rights of involvement: The case of health and safety at work . Industrial Law Journal26: 35-50 .
39.
James P , Walters D (2002) Worker representation in health and safety: Options for regulatory reform . Industrial Relations Journal33(2), 141-156 .
40.
Johnstone R (1999) Paradigm crossed? The statutory occupational health and safety obligations of the business undertaking . Australian Journal of Labour Law12, 73-112 .
41.
Johnstone R (2004) Occupational Health and Safety Law and Policy: Text and Materials, 2nd edition. Sydney: LBC Information Services .
42.
Kochan TA , Dyer L , Lipsky DB (1977) The Effectiveness of Union-Management Safety and Health Committees. Kalamazoo: W.E. Upjohn Institute for Employment Research .
43.
Lewchuk W , Robb L , Walters V (1996) The effectiveness of Bill 70 and joint health and safety commitees in reducing injuries in the workplace. The Case of OntarioCanadian Public Policy12(3), 225-243 .
44.
Litwin AS (2000) Trade Unions and Industrial Injury in Great Britain. Discussion Paper 468. London: Centre for Economic performance, London school of Economics and political Science .
45.
Markey R , Hodgkinson A , Kowalczyk J (2002) Gender, part-time employment and employee participation in Australian workplaces . Employee Relations24(2), 129-150 .
46.
McDonald N , Hyrmak V (2002) Safety Behaviour in the Construction Sector. HAS/HSE Northern Ireland, Dublin .
47.
Montruill S , Lippel K (2002) Telework and occupational health: Overview and reflections based on empirical research conducted in Quebec . Safety Science41(4), 339-358 .
48.
Murtough G , Waite M (2000) The Growth of Non-Traditional Employment: Are Jobs Becoming More Precarious? Productivity Commission Staff Research Paper, AusInfo, Canberra .
49.
New South Wales Labour Hire Task Force (2001) Final Report. Sydney: Department of Industrial Relations .
50.
Nichols T (1997) The Sociology of Industrial Injury. London: Mansell .
51.
Nichols T , Dennis A , Guy W (1995) Size of employment unit and industrial injury rates in British manufacturing industry: A secondary analysis of WIRS 1990 data . Industrial Relations Journal26(1), 45-56 .
52.
Nossar I , Johnstone R , Quinlan M (2004) Regulating supply-chains to address the occupational health and safety problems associated with precarious employment: The case of home-based clothing workers in Australia . Australian Journal of Labour Law17(2), 1-24 .
53.
Quinlan M (2001) Report of Inquiry into Safety in the Long Haul Trucking Industry. Sydney: Motor Accidents Authority of New South Wales .
54.
Quinlan M (forthcoming) Developing strategies to address OHS and workers’ compensation responsibilities arising from changing employment relationships. Research project commissioned by the WorkCover Authority of New South Wales, Sydney .
55.
Quinlan M , Bohle P (2003) Contingent work and safety. In: Barling J , Frone M , eds, The Psychology of Workplace Safety. Washington, DC: American Psychological Association .
56.
Quinlan M , Mayhew C , Bohle P (2001) The global expansion of precarious employment, work disorganisation, and consequences for occupational health: A review of recent research . International Journal of Health Services31(2), 335-414 .
57.
Reilly B , Paci P , Holl P (1995) Unions, safety committees and workplace injuries . British Journal of Industrial Relations33, 273-288 .
58.
Robinson A , Smallman C (2000) The Healthy Workplace? Research Papers in Management Studies WP 05/2000, Judge Institute of Management Studies, University of Cambridge, Cambridge .
59.
Saksvik P (1996) Attendance pressure during organisational change . International Journal of Stress Management3(1), 47-59 .
60.
Shannon H , Mayr JS , Haines T (1997) Overview of the relationship between organisational and workplace factors and injury rates . Safety Science26, 201-217 .
61.
Shannon H , Walters V , Lewchuck W , Richardson J , Moran DLA , Haines T , Verma DK (1996) Workplace organisational correlates of lost time accident rates in manufacturing . American Journal of Industrial Medicine29, 258-268 .
62.
Shannon H , Walters V , Lewchuck W , Richardson J , Verma D , Haines T , Moran L (1992) Health and Safety Approaches in the Workplace. Toronto: MacMaster University .
63.
Sverke M , Hellgren J (2001) Exit, voice and loyalty reactions to job insecurity in Sweden: Do unionized and non-unionized employees differ?British Journal of Industrial Relations39(2), 167-182 .
64.
Vandenheuvel A , Wooden M (1995) Self-employed contractors in Australia: How many and who are they?Journal of Industrial Relations37: 263 .
65.
Walters D , Frick K (2000) Worker participation and the management of occupational health and safety: Reinforcing or conflicting strategies. In: Frick K , Jensen PL , Quinlan M , Wilthagen T , eds, Systematic Occupational Health and Safety Management: Pespectives on an International Development. Amsterdam: Pergamon .
66.
Walters DR (2001) Health and Safety in Small Enterprises: European Strategies for Managing Improvement. Brussels: Peter Lang .
67.
Walters DR , ed (2002) Regulating Health and Safety Management in the European Union. Brussels: Peter Lang .
68.
Walters DR (2003) The Legacy of Robens? Workplace Arrangements for Health and Safety at Work in the Twenty First Century. National Research Centre for Occupational Health and Safety Regulation Working Paper No 10, August.
69.
Walters DR , Kirby P , Daly F (2001) The Impact of Trade Union Education and Training in Health and Safety on the Workplace Activity of Health and Safety Representatives. Health and Safety Executive Contract Research Reports, No 321/2001.
70.
Warren-Langford P , Biggins D , Phillips M (1993) Union participation in occupational health and safety in Western Australia . Journal of Industrial Relations35(4), 585-606 .
71.
Wooden M (2001) How temporary are Australia’s casual jobs?Work, Employment and Society15(4), 875-884 .
72.
WorkCover NSW (2001) OHS Consultation—Effective Decision Making and How to Establish OHS Consultation Arrangements: Code of Practice. Sydney: WorkCover New South Wales .
73.
WorkCover NSW (2002) OHS Regulation 2001 with Margin Notes. Sydney: WorkCover New South Wales .
