In an earlier article, Lamb (1991) showed that journal authors, when writing about men battering women, wrote in a way that avoided assigning responsibility to men as perpetrators, and that this kind of writing was more common among male authors as well as female authors who wrote with men. This study examines first whether this kind of writing occurs in newspaper articles on men battering women, and whether two problematic styles of writing have an effect on the reader. Three versions of a newspaper article were developed to differentiate active voice, passive voice, and writing that implies shared responsibility for a man's violence. One hundred and eighty subjects read one of the three versions and endorsed one of five possible punishments for the man in the story who had been violent. Results showed that subjects did not differ in their selection of punishments for the active voice versus the passive voice version, but were much more lenient towards the man after reading the shared responsibility version.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
BarrettM. J.TrepperT. S.FishL. S. (1990). Feminist-informed family therapy for the treatment of intrafamily child sexual abuse.Journal of Family Psychology, 4, 151–166
2.
BenedictH. (1992). Virgin or vamp: How the press covers sex crimes.New York: Oxford University Press
3.
BeazleyJ.HenleyN.MillerM. (1994). Effects of using passive voice in describing violence against women. Unpublished poster proposal submitted to the American Psychological Association Conference for August, 1994
4.
BerkR. A.BerkS. F.LosekeD. R.RaumaD. (1983). Mutual combat and other family violence myths. In FinkelhorD.GellesR. S.HotalingG. T.StrausM. A. (Eds.), The dark side of families: Current family violence research (pp. 197–212). Beverly Hills, CA: Sage
5.
BernsteinA. (1994). Profile of Rhea Almeida. AFTA Newsletter, Spring, 38–42
6.
BogradM. (1984). Family systems approaches to wife battering: A feminist critique.American Journal of Orthopsychiatry, 54, 558–568
7.
BreinesW.GordonL. (1983). The new scholarship on family violence.Signs: Journal of Women in Culture and Society, 8, 490–531
8.
BrowneA. (1987). When battered women kill.New York: Macmillan
9.
BrowneA.DuttonD. G. (1990). Escape from violence: Risks and alternatives for abused women. In RoeschR.DuttonD. G.SaccoV. F. (Eds.), Family violence: Perspectives in research and practice (pp. 67–91). Simon Fraser University Press
10.
DobashE. R.DobashR. (1979). Violence against wives: A case against the patriarchy.New York: Free Press
11.
EttemaJ. S.GlasserT. L. (1988). Journal of Communication, 8, 8–22
12.
FishV. (1990). Introducing causality and power into Family therapy theory: A correction to the systemic paradigm.Journal of Marital and Family Therapy, 16, 21–37
13.
FrenchM. (1992). The war against women.New York: Ballantine
14.
GallagherM. (1981). Unequal opportunities: The case of women and the media.Vendome, France: UNESCO
15.
GraberD. (1984). Processing the news: How people tame the information tide.New York: Longman
16.
Hare-MustinR. (1978). A feminist approach to family therapy.Family Process, 12, 181–194
17.
HenleyN.MillerM.BeazleyJ. A. (1993a). Use of passive voice in reports of violence against women. Paper presented at the Western Psychological Association, Phoenix, AZ, April
18.
HenleyN.MillerM.BeazleyJ. A. (1993b). Syntax, semantics, and violence in the Print Media. Paper presented at the Society of Experimental Social Psychology Meetings, Santa Barbara, CA, October
19.
HillA. (1986). Mother tongue, father time.Indianapolis: Indiana University Press
20.
JamesK.McIntyreD. (1983). The reproduction of families: The social role of family therapy?Journal of Marital and Family Therapy, 9, 119–129
21.
LaFranceM.HahnE. (1993). The disappearing agent: Gender stereotypes, interpersonal verbs, and implicit causality. In RomanC.JuhaszS.MillerC. (Eds.), The women & language debate: A sourcebook.New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press
22.
LambS. (1991). Acts without agents: An analysis of linguistic avoidance in journal articles on men who batter women.American Journal of Orthopsychiatry, 61, 250–257
23.
Le GuinU. K. (1989). Dancing at the edge of the world: Thoughts on words, women, places (pp. 147–160). New York: Harper & Row
24.
MackinnonL. K.MillerD. (1987). The new epistemology and the Milan approach. Feminist and sociopolitical consideration.Journal of Marital and Family Therapy, 13, 139–155
25.
McHughM. C.FriezeI. H.BrowneA. (1993). Research on battered women and their assailants. In DenmarkF. L.PaludiM. A. (Eds.), Psychology of women: Handbook of issues and theories (pp. 513–552). Westport, CT: Greenwood Press
26.
PagelowM. D. (1984). Family violence.New York: Praeger
27.
PenelopeJ. (1990). Speaking freely: Unlearning the lies of the fathers' tongues.New York: Pergamon Press
28.
PleckE.PleckJ. H.GrossmanM.BartP. B. (1977-1978). The battered data syndrome: A comment on Steinmetz.Victimology, 2, 680–683
29.
RichA. (1979). On lies, secrets, and silence: Selected prose 1966–1978.New York: Norton
30.
RobbinsS.StanleyJ. (1979). Forced inferences: Uses and abuses of the passive.Papers in Linguistics, 10, 299–311
31.
SalemJ. C. (1980). On naming the oppressor: What Woolf avoids saying inA Room of One's Own. Women's Studies International Quarterly, 3, 209–218
32.
SandersR. (1994). Passive voice use in media reports of violence against gays. Proposal submitted to American Psychological Association for presentation at annual convention, August
33.
SaundersD. (1990). Wife abuse, husband abuse, or mutual combat? A feminist perspective on the empirical findings. In YllöK.BogradM. (Eds.), Feminist perspectives on wife abuse.London: Sage
34.
SchechterS. (1982). Women and male violence: The visions and struggles of the battered women's movement.Boston: South End Press
35.
SpenderD. (1980). Man made language.London: Routledge & Kegan Paul
SteinmetzS. (1977). The cycle of violence: Assertive, aggressive, and abusive family interaction.New York: Praeger
38.
TaggartM. (1985). The feminist critique in epistemological perspective: Questions of context in family therapy.Journal of Marital and Family Therapy, 11, 113–126
39.
ThomeB.KramaraeC.HenleyN. (1983). Language, gender, and society: Opening a second decade of research. In ThorneB.KramaraeC.HenleyN. (Eds.), Language, gender, and society.New York: Harper & Row
