This paper outlines a refinement of the sociological usage of the concept ‘civilization’ by distinguishing between three different ‘faces’ of civilization – as the opposite of barbarism, as equivalent to culture, and in Elias's sense as capturing a particular trajectory of socio-historical development. I then illustrate how this distinction between three different faces of civilization can be deployed in relation to the history of the various attempts by the English to civilize the population of Ireland. Finally, I reflect on the centrality of the experience of the colonization of Ireland for the English conception of how ‘barbarism’ should be understood and opposed to ‘civilization’ (which was then later mobilized in the colonization of the New World), as well as on the ways in which the colonization of Ireland constituted a binding together of both civilizing and decivilizing processes.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Dates given in square brackets are those of first publication.
2.
AbellPeter, (1977), ‘The many faces of power and liberty: revealed preferences, autonomy and teleological explanation’, Sociology, 11: 3–24.
3.
ArnoldBruce, (2009), The Irish Gulag, Dublin: Gill & Macmillan.
4.
AugusteijnJoost, (2006), ‘Ireland and Europe: A Dutch perspective’, Radharc: A Journal of Irish and Irish-American Studies, 5/7: 265–86.
5.
BachrachPeter and BaratzMorton S., (1962), ‘Two Faces of Power’, American Political Science Review, 56, 4: 947–52.
6.
BartlettRobert, (1993), The Making of Europe: Conquest, Colonization and Cultural Change 950–1350, London: BCA.
7.
BartlettRobert, (2006 [1982]), Gerald of Wales: A Voice of the Middle Ages, Stroud: Tempus.
8.
BaumanZygmunt, (1987), Legislators and Interpreters, Cambridge: Polity.
9.
BeardCharles A. and BeardMary R., (1942), The American Spirit: a study of the idea of civilization in the United States, New York: Collier Books.
10.
BendixRichard, (1952), ‘Compliant behaviour and individual personality’, American Journal of Sociology, 58, 2: 292–303.
11.
BenedictRuth, (1934), Patterns of Culture, London: Routledge & Kegan Paul.
12.
BouldingKenneth E., (1989), Three Faces of Power, Newbury Park: Sage.
13.
BowdenBrett, (2004), ‘The Ideal of Civilisation: its Origins and Socio-Political Character’, Critical Review of International Social & Political Philosophy, 7, 1: 25–50.
14.
BradshawBrendan, (1978), ‘Sword, word and strategy in the Reformation in Ireland’, The Historical Journal, 21, 3: 475–502.
15.
BranniganJohn, (1998), ‘A particular vice of that people: Giraldus Cambrensis and the discourse of English colonialism’, Irish Studies Review, 6, 2: 121–30.
16.
BurumaIan, (2004), ‘Lost in translation: the two minds of Bernard Lewis’, The New Yorker, 14 June.
17.
ByrneJohn F., (1993), ‘The trembling sod: Ireland in 1169’, in CosgroveArt, (ed.), A New History of Ireland, Vol. II: Medieval Ireland 1169–1534, Oxford: Clarendon Press: 3–42.
18.
CambrensisGiraldus, (1982), The History and Topography of Ireland, Mountrath: Dolmen Press.
19.
CannyNicholas P., (1973), ‘The ideology of English colonization: From Ireland to America’, The William & Mary Quarterly, 30, 4: 575–98.
20.
CannyNicholas P., (1976), The Elizabethan Conquest of Ireland: A Pattern Established 1565–76, Hassocks: Harvester Press.
21.
CannyNicholas P., (1989), ‘Early modern Ireland c.1500–1700’, in FosterRobert F., (ed.), The Oxford Illustrated History of Ireland, Oxford: Oxford University Press: 104–60.
22.
CareyVincent P., (1999), ‘John Derricke's ‘Image of Irelande’, Sir Henry Sidney, and the massacre at Mullaghmast, 1578’, Irish Historical Studies, 31, 123: 305–27.
23.
CavanaghSheila T., (1993), ‘The fatal destiny of that land: Elizabethan views of Ireland’, in BradshawBrendanMaleyAndrew and MaleyWilly, (eds), Representing Ireland: Literature and the Origins of Conflict, 1534–1660: 116–31, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
24.
ChibnallMarjorie, (1999), The Debate on the Norman Conquest, Manchester: Manchester University Press.
25.
CollinsRandall, (2009), ‘A dead end for a trend theory’, Archives Europeénnes de Sociologie, 50, 3: 431–41.
26.
CorriganPhilip and SayerDerek, (1985), The Great Arch: English State Formation as Cultural Revolution, Oxford: Basil Blackwell.
27.
CosgroveArt, (2001), ‘The Gaelic resurgence and the Geraldine supremacy c. 1400–1534’, in MoodyTheodore W. and MartinFrancis X., (eds), The Course of Irish History, (revised edn.), Dublin: Mercier Press/RTÉ: 125–38.
28.
CoughlanPatricia, (1989), ‘Some secret scourge which shall by her come unto England’: Ireland and incivility in Spenser’, in CoughlanPatricia, (ed.), Spenser and Ireland: an interdisciplinary perspective, Cork: Cork University Press: 46–74.
29.
DaviesRobert R., (1990), Domination and Conquest: the Experience of Ireland, Scotland and Wales 1100–1300, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
30.
DaviesRobert R., (1993), ‘The English state and the ‘Celtic’ Peoples 1100–1400’, Journal of Historical Sociology, 6 (1): 1–14.
31.
DaviesRobert R., (1994), ‘The Peoples of Britain and Ireland 1100–1400. I. Identities’, Transactions of the Royal Historical Society, Sixth Series, 4: 1–20.
32.
Den BoerPim, (2001), ‘Vergelijkende begripsgechiedenis’, in Den BoerPim, (ed.), Beschaving: Een geschiedenis van de begrippen hoofsheid, heusheid, bechaving en cultuur, Amsterdam: Amsterdam University Press: 15–78.
33.
DuffySeán, (1997), Ireland in the Middle Ages, Houndmills: Macmillan.
34.
EdwardsDavid, (2007), ‘The escalation of violence in sixteenth-century Ireland’, in EdwardsDavidLenihanPadraig and TaitClodagh, (eds), Age of Atrocity: Violence and Political Conflict in Early Modern Ireland, Dublin: Four Courts Press: 34–78.
35.
EliasNorbert, (1996 [1989]), The Germans: Studies of Power Struggles and the Development of Habitus in the Nineteenth and Twentieth centuries, Cambridge: Polity Press.
36.
EliasNorbert, (2000 [1939]), The Civilizing Process: Sociogenetic and Psychogenetic Investigations, Oxford: Blackwell.
37.
EliasNorbert, (2000 [1969]), ‘Postscript (1968)’, in The Civilizing Process, rev. edn, Oxford: Blackwell: 449–83 [further rev. edn On the Process of Civilisation, Collected Works, Vol. 3, forthcoming].
EliasNorbert, (2009a [1985]), ‘On the creed of a nominalist: observations on Popper's The Logic of Scientific Discovery’, in Essays I: On the Sociology of Knowledge and the Sciences, Collected Works, Vol. 14, Dublin: UCD: 161–90.
40.
EliasNorbert, (2009b [1985]), ‘Science or sciences: contribution to a debate with reality-blind philosophers’, in Essays I: On the Sociology of Knowledge and the Sciences, Collected Works, Vol. 14, Dublin: UCD Press: 191–211.
41.
EllisSteven G., (1995), Tudor Frontiers and Noble Power: the Making of the British State, Oxford: Clarendon Press.
42.
EllisSteven G., (1998), Ireland in the Age of the Tudors 1447–1603: English Expansion and the End of Gaelic Rule, London: Longman.
43.
EllisSteven G., (1999), ‘The English state and its frontiers in the British Isles, 1300–1600’, in PowerDaniel and StandenNaomi, (eds), Frontiers in Question: Eurasian Borderlands 700–1700: Houndmills: Macmillan: 153–81.
44.
EllisSteven G., (2003), ‘Racial discrimination in late medieval Ireland’, in HálfdanarsonGudmundur, (ed.), Racial Discrimination and Ethnicity in European History, Pisa: Università di Pisa: 21–32.
45.
FebvreLucier, (1973 [1930]), ‘Civilisation: Evolution of a word and a group of ideas’, in BurkePeter, (ed.), A New Kind of History: From the Writings of Lucien Febvre. London: Routledge & Kegan Paul: 219–57.
46.
FletcherJonathan, (1995), ‘Towards a theory of decivilizing processes’, Amsterdams Sociologisch Tijdschrift, 22, 2: 283–96.
47.
FletcherJonathan, (1997), Violence and Civilization, Cambridge: Polity.
FrameRobin, (1995), ‘Overlordship and reaction, c.1200–c.1450’, in GrantAlexander and StringerKeith J., (eds), Uniting the Kingdom? The Making of British History, London: Routledge: 65–84.
50.
Gerald of Wales, (1978), The Journey through Wales and the Description of Wales, Harmondsworth: Penguin Classics.
51.
GillinghamJohn, (1987), ‘Images of Ireland, 1170–1600: the origins of English imperialism’, History Today, 37, 2: 16–22.
52.
GillinghamJohn, (1992), ‘The beginnings of English imperialism’, Journal of Historical Sociology, 5, 4: 393–409.
53.
GillinghamJohn, (1993), ‘The English invasion of Ireland’, in BradshawBrendanHudfieldAndrew and MaleyWilly, (eds), Representing Ireland: Literature and the Origins of Conflict 1534–1660. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press: 24–42.
54.
GillinghamJohn, (1994), ‘1066 and the introduction of chivalry into England’, in GarnettGeorge and HudsonJohn, (eds), Law and government in medieval England and Normandy: essays in honour of Sir James Holt, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press: 31–55.
55.
GillinghamJohn, (1995), ‘Foundations of a disunited kingdom’, in GrantAlexander and StringerKeith J., (eds), Uniting the Kingdom? The Making of British History, London: Routledge: 48–64.
56.
GillinghamJohn, (1999), ‘Killing and mutilating political enemies in the British Isles from the late twelfth to the early fourteenth century: a comparative study’, in SmithBrendan, (ed.), Britain and Ireland 900–1300: insular responses to medieval European change, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press: 114–34.
57.
GillinghamJohn, (2001), ‘Civilizing the English? The English histories of William of Malmesbury and David Hume’, Historical Research, 74: 17–43.
58.
GillinghamJohn, (2002), ‘From Civilitas to Civility: codes of manners in medieval and early modern England’, Transactions of the Royal Historical Society, Sixth Series, 12: 267–89.
59.
GoldthorpeJohn H., (1987), Family Life in Western Societies: A Historical Sociology of Family Relationships in Britain and North America, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
60.
GoodyJack, (1983), The Development of Family and Marriage in Europe, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
61.
GoudsblomJohan, (2006), ‘Civilization: the career of a controversial concept’, History & Theory, 45: 288–97.
62.
HadfieldAndrew, (1993), ‘Briton and Scythian: Tudor representations of Irish origins’, Irish Historical Studies, 28, 112: 390–408.
63.
HadfieldArdrew, (1999), ‘Rethinking early-modern colonialism: the anomalous state of Ireland’, Irish Studies Review, 7, 1: 13–27.
64.
HardingDavid, (2005), ‘Objects of English colonial discourse: The Irish and Native Americans’, Nordic Irish Studies, 4: 37–60.
65.
HaywoodEric G., (1996), ‘Is Ireland worth bothering about? Classical perceptions of Ireland revisited in Renaissance Italy’, International Journal of the Classical Tradition, 2, 4: 467–86.
66.
HechterMichael, (1975), Internal Colonialism: The Celtic Fringe in British National Development, 1537–1966, London: Routledge & Kegan Paul.
67.
HumeDavid, (1987), ‘Of refinement in the arts’, in Essays Moral, Political and Literary, Indianapolis: Liberty Classics.
JohnstonDorothy, (1980), ‘Richard II and the Submissions of Gaelic Ireland’, Irish Historical Studies, 22, 85: 1–20.
70.
JonesWilliam R., (1971), ‘The image of the barbarian in medieval Europe’, Comparative Studies in Society & History, 13, 3: 376–407.
71.
KennyGillian, (2006), ‘Anglo-Irish and Gaelic marriage laws and traditions in late medieval Ireland’, Journal of Medieval History, 32: 27–42.
72.
van KriekenRobert, (1990), ‘Social Discipline and State Formation: Weber and Oestreich on the Historical Sociology of Subjectivity’, Amsterdams Sociologisch Tijdschrift, 17, 1: 3–28.
73.
van KriekenRobert, (1998), Norbert Elias, London: Routledge.
74.
van KriekenRobert, (1999), ‘The barbarism of civilization: cultural genocide and the “stolen generations”,’British Journal of Sociology, 50, 2: 297–315.
75.
van KriekenRobert, (2002), ‘Reshaping civilization: liberalism between assimilation and cultural genocide’, Amsterdams Sociologisch Tijdschrift, 29, 2: 1–38.
76.
van KriekenRobert, (2003), ‘The organization of the soul: Elias and Foucault on discipline and the self’, in DunningEric and MennellStephen, (eds), Norbert Elias, Vol. 1 (Sage Masters of Modern Social Thought), London: Sage: 135–53.
77.
LeerssenJoep, (1995), ‘Wildness, wilderness, and Ireland: medieval and early-modern patterns in the demarcation of civility’, Journal of the History of Ideas, 56, 1: 25–39.
LewisBernard, (1956), ‘The Middle East reaction to Soviet pressures’, The Middle East Journal, 10, 2: 125–37.
80.
LewisBernard, (2001), ‘The revolt of Islam’, The New Yorker, 19 November 2001.
81.
LockeJohn, (1960 [1690]), Two Treatises on Government, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
82.
LukesSteven, (2005), Power: a Radical View, Houndmills: Palgrave Macmillan.
83.
LydonJames, (1993), ‘A land of war’, in CosgroveArt, (ed.), A New History of Ireland, Vol. II: Medieval Ireland 1169–1534, Oxford: Clarendon Press: 240–74.
84.
LydonJames, (1995), ‘Ireland and the English Crown, 1171–1541’, Irish Historical Studies, 29, 115: 281–94.
85.
LydonJames, (1997), ‘Ireland in 1297: “At peace after its manner”’, in LydonJames, (ed.), Law and Disorder in Thirteenth-Century Ireland: The Dublin Parliament of 1297, Dublin: Four Courts Press: 11–24.
86.
LydonJames, (2001), ‘The medieval English colony (1300–c. 1400)’, in MoodyTheodore W. and MartinFrancis X., (eds), The Course of Irish History, rev. edn., Dublin: Mercier Press/RTÉ: 113–24.
87.
LydonJames, (2008), ‘The problem of the frontier in medieval Ireland’, in CurtisEdmundOtway-RuthvenAnnette J. and LydonJames, (eds), Government, War and Society in Medieval Ireland, Dublin: Four Courts Press: 317–31.
88.
MachiavelliNicolò, (1961 [c.1514]), The Prince. Harmondsworth: Penguin.
89.
MazlishBruce, (2004), Civilization and its Contents, Stanford: Stanford University Press.
90.
McVeighRobbie and RolstonBill, (2009), ‘Civilising the Irish’, Race & Class, 51, 1: 2–28.
91.
MennellStephen, (1990), ‘Decivilizing processes: theoretical significance and some lines of research’, International Sociology, 5, 2: 205–23.
92.
MennellStephen, (2007), The American Civilizing Process, Cambridge: Polity.
93.
MorrillJohn, (1995), ‘Three kingdoms and one commonwealth? The enigma of mid-seventeenth-century Britain and Ireland’, in GrantAlexander and StringerKeith J., (eds), Uniting the Kingdom? The Making of British History, London: Routledge: 170–90.
94.
MuldoonJames, (2003), Identity on the Medieval Irish Frontier: Degenerate Englishmen, Wild Irishmen, Middle Nations, Gainesville, FL: University Press of Florida.
95.
MuldoonJames, (2009), The North Atlantic Frontier of Medieval Europe, Aldershot: Ashgate.
96.
MurphyAndrew, (1999), But the Irish Sea Betwixt Us: Ireland, Colonialism, and Renaissance Literature, Lexington, KY: University Press of Kentucky.
NiebuhrReinhold, (1952), ‘Culture and civilization (a summary)’, Confluence, 1, 1: 66–76.
99.
OhlmeyerJane H., (1998), ‘Civilizinge of those Rude Partes': Colonization within Britain and Ireland, 1580s–1640s’, in CannyNicholas, (ed.), The Origins of Empire; British Overseas Enterprise to the Close of the Seventeenth Century, Oxford History of the British Empire, Oxford: Oxford University Press: 125–147.
100.
Otway-RuthvenAnnette J., (1950), ‘The native Irish and English law in medieval Ireland’, Irish Historical Studies, 7, 25: 1–16.
101.
PagdenAnthony, (1982), The Fall of Natural Man: The American Indian and the Origins of Comparative Ethnology, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
102.
PattersonNerys, (1991), ‘Gaelic Law and the Tudor Conquest of Ireland: The Social Background of the Sixteenth-Century Recensions of the Pseudo-Historical Prologue to the Senchas Már’, Irish Historical Studies, 27, 107: 193–215.
103.
PawlischHans S., (1985), Sir John Davies and the conquest of Ireland: A Study in Legal Imperialism, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
104.
QuinnDavid B., (1947), Raleigh and the British Empire, London: Hodder & Stoughton.
105.
QuinnDavid B., (1958), ‘Ireland and sixteenth-century European expansion’, Historical Studies, 1.
106.
RafteryMary and O'SullivanEoin, (1999), Suffer the little children: the inside story of Ireland's industrial schools, Dublin: New Island.
SpenserEdmund, (1934 [1596]), A View of the Present State of Ireland, London: Eric Partridge.
109.
StarobinskiJean, (1993), ‘The word civilization’, in Blessings in Disguise; or, The Morality of Evil, Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press: 1–35.
110.
de SwaanAbram, (2001), ‘Dyscivilization, Mass Extermination and the State’, Theory, Culture & Society, 18, 2–3: 265–76.
111.
TaatgenHendrik A., (1992), ‘The Boycott in the Irish Civilizing Process’, Anthropological Quarterly, 65, 4: 163–76.
112.
TaitClodaghEdwardsDavid and LenihanPadraig, (2007), ‘Early modern Ireland: a history of violence’, in EdwardsDavidLenihanPadraig and TaitClodagh, (eds), Age of Atrocity: Violence and Political Conflict in Early Modern Ireland, Dublin: Four Courts Press: 9–33.
113.
WeberEugen, (1979), Peasants into Frenchmen: The Modernization of Rural France, 1870–1914. London: Chatto & Windus.
114.
WilliamsRobert A.Jnr, (1990), The American Indian in Western Legal Thought: The Discourses of Conquest, New York: Oxford University Press.
115.
ZwaanTon, (2003), ‘On Civilizing and Decivilizing Processes: A Theoretical Discussion’, in DunningEric, and MennellStephen, (eds), Norbert Elias – Vol. 4 (Sage Masters of Modern Social Thought), London: Sage: 167–75.
