This paper makes a contribution to the still relatively undeveloped literature on the sociology of counselling, using a detailed case study of one organisation. Styles of intervention are explored in the work of the National Marriage Guidance Council/Relate. The paper rejects a simple linear development model based on transitions from ‘guidance’, to ‘counselling’ to ‘therapy’ Influences deriving from Rogerian models of counselling, from psychodynamic and behavioural theory are explored and are placed in the context of wider organisational factors. Attention is given to the varying fortunes of the medical model within Marriage Guidance. The paper concludes with an examination of the contradictions thrown up by recent attempts to develop an eclectic model of marital counselling, which appear to founder on the absence of any clearly defined goals for intervention.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AlfredJ.B. (1953), ‘Non-directive counselling’, Marriage Guidance, September: 4–5.
2.
BakerJ. (1978), ‘Is counselling value-free?’, Marriage Guidance, September: 91–5.
3.
BannisterKathleen (1955), ‘A professional casework approach to marriage counselling’, Marriage Guidance, June: 7–8.
4.
BannisterKathleen (1955), Social Casework in Marital Problems: The Development of the Psychodynamic Approach, London: Tavistock.
5.
BlackieS.ClarkD. (1987), ‘Men in marriage counselling’, LewisC.O'BrienM. (eds), Reassessing Fatherhood, London. Sage.
6.
BrannenJuliaCollardJean (1982), Marriages in Trouble, London: Tavistock.
7.
BrownP.T. (1979), ‘Practical modifications of Masters' and Johnson's approach to the treatment of sexual dysfunction’, PhD Thesis, University of Leicester.
8.
CarkhuffR.R. (1969), Helping and Human Relations, Vols 1 and 2, New York: Holt, Rinehart & Winston.
DrydenWindyBrownPaul (1985), ‘Issues in the training of marital therapists’, in DrydenWindy (ed.), Marital Therapy in Britain, Vol. 2, London: Harper & Row.
16.
EganGerald (1975), The Skilled Helper, Monterey, California: Brooks/Cole.
17.
EichenbaumL.OrbachS. (1984), What Do Women Want?, New York: Berkley.
18.
FinchJ.SummerfieldP. (1991), ‘Social reconstruction and the emergence of companionate marriage 1945–59’, in ClarkD. (ed.), Marriage, Domestic Life and Social Change: Writings for Jacqueline Burgoyne (1944–88), London: Routledge.
19.
FoucaultM. (1973), The Birth of the Clinic, London: Tavistock.
20.
GauntS. (1987), ‘Reception interviews in Marriage Guidance’, Research Report No 6, Rugby: National Marriage Guidance Council.
21.
GrayKenneth (1976), ‘A personal definition of counselling’, Marriage Guidance, November/December: 228–33.
22.
GreenspanM. (1983), A New Approach to Women and Therapy, New York: McGraw-Hill.
23.
de GrootM. (1985), Marriage Guidance Counsellors in the Medical Setting, Research Report No 1, Rugby: National Marriage Guidance Council.
24.
GuiverPamela (1973), The Trouble Sharers, Rugby: National Marriage Guidance Council.
25.
HalmosPaul (1965), The Faith of the Counsellors, London: Constable.
26.
HalmosPaul (1966), ‘Counselling morality’, Marriage Guidance, July: 116–18.
HeislerJ. (1974), Why Counsellors Resign, Rugby: National Marriage Guidance Council.
29.
HeislerJ. (1983), Sex Therapy in NMGC, Rugby: National Marriage Guidance Council.
30.
HoltNancy (1971), Counselling in Marriage Problems, London: National Marriage Guidance Council.
31.
HooperD. (1976), ‘Yesterday's counsellors for tomorrow's problems?’, Marriage Guidance, September/October: 147–53.
32.
HooperD. (1978), ‘Counselling: The meaning, the message and the market place’, Marriage Guidance, March: 4–8.
33.
HooperD. (1985), ‘Marital therapy: An overview of research’, in DrydenW. (ed.), Marital Therapy in Britain, Vol. 1, London: Harper & Row.
34.
HuntPat (1985), Clients' Responses to Marriage Counselling, Research Report No. 3, Rugby: National Marriage Guidance Council.
35.
InglebyA.H.B. (1957), ‘Old wine in new bottles’, Marriage Guidance, March: 58–60.
36.
KeithleyJ. (1982), ‘Marriage counselling in general practice: An assessment of the work of marriage counsellors in a general medical practice, unpublished PhD thesis, University of Durham.
37.
LewisJaneClarkDavidMorganDavid (1992), Whom God Hath Joined Together: The Work of Marriage Guidance 1920–90, London: Routledge.
38.
MaceDavid (1948a), Marriage Crisis, London: Delisle.
39.
MaceDavid (1948b), Marriage Counselling: The First Full Account of the Remedial Work of the MGC, London: J. and A, Churchill.
40.
MaceDavid (1951), ‘What is counselling?’, Marriage Guidance, September: 1–3.
41.
MaceDavid (1966), ‘Marriage counselling in the USA’, Marriage Guidance, January: 7–10.
42.
MaceDavid (1972), Sexual Difficulties in Marriage, Rugby: National Marriage Guidance Council.
43.
MaclayDavid (1955), ‘First year impressions’, Marriage Guidance, May: 3–4.
44.
MannAnthony (1974), The Human Paradox, Rugby: National Marriage Guidance Council.
45.
MastersW.H.JohnsonVirginia E. (1970), Human Sexual Inadequacy, London: Churchill.
46.
MorganD.H.J. (1985), The Family, Politics and Social Theory, London: Routledge & Kegan Paul.
47.
MurchMervyn (1980), Justice and Welfare in Divorce, London: Sweet & Maxwell.
48.
NMGC (1954–5), Annual Report, National Marriage Guidance Council.
49.
NMGC (1964–5), Annual Report, National Marriage Guidance Council.
50.
NMGC (1987), Counsellor Basic Training Prospectus, Rugby: National Marriage Guidance Council.
51.
NessMary (1976), ‘Co-therapy and psychosexual dysfunction’, Marriage Guidance, November/December: 201–7.
52.
O'BrienM. (1988), ‘Men and fathers in therapy’, Journal of Family Therapy, 10: 109–23.
53.
PaolinoT.J.McCradyB.S. (eds) (1978), Marriage and Marital Therapy, New York: Brunner/Mazel.
54.
JonesW.Ll. Parry (1978), ‘Change to survive? Reflections on the future of marriage counselling services’, Marriage Guidance, September: 75–83.
55.
PincusLily (ed.) (1960), Marriage: Studies in Emotional Conflict and Growth, London: Family Discussion Bureau/Methuen.
56.
CarlR. Rogers (1957), ‘Communication between people’, Marriage Guidance, November: 167–9.
57.
de M. RudolphG. (1955), ‘Psychiatry and the marriage guidance counsellor’, Marriage Guidance, September: 9–12.
58.
SkynnerRobin (1975), ‘Some consequences of work with natural groups’, Marriage Guidance, May/June: 319–24.
59.
SkynnerRobin (1976), ‘Some approaches to marital therapy’, Marriage Guidance, September/October: 156–62.
60.
SkynnerRobin (1980), ‘Recent developments in marital therapy’, Journal of Family Therapy, 2: 271–96.
61.
StaffordAline (1962), ‘Case discussion or what goes on’, Marriage Guidance, January/February: 201–3.
62.
ThornboroughPeggy (1975), ‘Groups in sensitivity training’, Marriage Guidance, January/February: 261–5.
63.
TorrieA. (1958), ‘The place of marriage counselling in family practice’, Marriage Guidance, December: 376–80.
64.
TorrieMargaret (1959), ‘Counselling for widows’, Marriage Guidance, December: 213–14.
65.
TyndallN. (1985), ‘The work and impact of the National Marriage Guidance Council’, in DrydenWindy (ed.), Marital Therapy in Britain, Vol. 1, London: Harper & Row.
66.
WallisJ.H. (1955), ‘What is counselling?’, Marriage Guidance, June: 5–6.
67.
WallisJ.H. (1959), ‘A modern approach to marriage counselling, book review’, Marriage Guidance, November: 29.
68.
WallisJ.H. (1960), Counselling and Social Welfare, London: Routledge & Kegan Paul.
69.
WallisJ.H., (1964), ‘Difficulties in the selection and training of marriage counsellors’, Marriage Guidance, May: 67–9.
70.
WallisJ.H. (1966), ‘Marriage counselling and the professions I’, Marriage Guidance, June: 163–5.
71.
WallisJ.H. (1968a), Marriage Guidance: A New Introduction, London: Routledge & Kegan Paul.
72.
WallisJ.H. (1968b), ‘Is the therapist a real person?’, Marriage Guidance, November: 167–70.
73.
WallisJ.H.BookerH.S. (1958), Marriage Counselling, London: Routledge & Kegan Paul.
74.
WeeksJeffrey (1981), Sex, Politics and Society, London: Longman.
75.
WilliamsRuth (1975), ‘Psychodrama at the Moreno Institute’, Marriage Guidance, March/April: 283–5.
76.
WoodhouseDouglas (1990), ‘Non-medical marital therapy”, in ClulowC. (ed.), Marriage: Disillusion and Hope, London: Karnac Books.
77.
WoolfeR. (1983), ‘Counselling in a world of crisis: Towards a sociology of counselling’, International Journal of Advanced Counselling, 6: 167–76.
78.
Working Party on Marriage Guidance (1979), Marriage Matters, London: HMSO.
