Differences in mathematical competence between U S and Chinese children first emerge during the preschool years, favor Chinese children, and are limited to specific aspects of mathematical competence The base-10 structure of number names is less obvious in English than in Chinese, differences between these languages are reflected in children's difficulties learning to count Language differences do not affect other aspects of early mathematics, including counting small sets and solving simple numerical problems Because later mathematics increasingly involves manipulation of symbols, this early deficit in apprehending the base-10 structure of number names may provide a basis for previously reported differences in mathematical competence favoring Chinese schoolchildren
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
FusonK.C.FravilligJ.D.BurghardiB.H. (1991) Relationship children construct among English number word, baseten blocks. and written multidigit additionInCampbellJ.I.D., (Ed), The nature and origins of mathematical skills (pp.39–112) New YorkNorth-Holland.
2.
FusonK.C.KwonY. (1992) Effects of the system of number words and other cultural tools on children's addition and subtractionInBideaudJ.MeljacC., (Eds), Pathway' to number Children's developing numerical-abilities (pp.127–149) Hillsdale, N.J.Eribaum.
3.
GearyD.C.FanL.Bow-ThomasC.C. (1992) Numerical cognition Locus of ability differences comparing children from China and the United States. Psychological Science, 3, 180–185.
4.
GelmanR. (1991) Epegenetic foundation of knowledge structures Initial and transcendent constructionInCareyS.GelmanR., (Eds), The epigenesis of mind Essays on biology and cognition (pp.293–322) Hillsdale, N.J.Eribaum.
5.
GelmanR.GallistelC.R. (1978) The child's understanding of numberCambridge, M.A.Harvard University Press.
6.
HitchG.CundickJ.HaugheyM.PughR.WrightH. (1987) Aspects of counting in children's arithmeticInSlobodaJ.A.RogersD., (Eds), Cognitive process In mathematics (pp.26–41) OxfordClarendon Press.
7.
HurfordJ.R. (1975) The linguistic theory of numeralCambridge, EnglandCambridge University Press.
8.
HurfordJ.R. (1987) Language and numberCambridge, EnglandCambridge University Press.
9.
HusenT. (1967) International study of achievement in mathematicsNew YorkWiley.
10.
LynnR.DziobonJ. (1980) On the intelligence of Japanese and other Mongolod peoples. Personality and Individual Differences, 1, 95–96.
11.
McCullaghP.NelderJ.A. (1991) Generalized linear modelsNew YorkChapman & Hall.
12.
MenningerK. (1969) Number words and number symbolsCambridge, M.A.MIT press.
13.
MillerK.F. (1990, November.) Language, orthography, and number When surface structure matters. Paper presented at the annual meeting of the Psychonomic Society, New Orleans.
14.
MillerK.F.StiglerJ. (1987) Counting in Chinese Cultural variation in a basic cognitive skill. Cognitive Developments, 2, 279–305.
15.
MillerK.F.ZhuJ. (1991) The trouble with teens Accessing the structure of number names. Journal of Memory and Language, 30, 48–68.
16.
MiuraI.T. (19C7) Mathematics achievement as a function of language. Journal of Educational Psychology, 79, 79–82.
17.
MiuraI.T.KimC.C.ChangC.M.OkamotoY. (1988) Eflects of language characterstics on children's cognitive representation of number Cross-national comparisons. Child Development, 59, 1445–50.
18.
StieglerR.S. (1987) The perils of averaging data over strateges An example from children's addition. Journal of Experimental psychology General, 116, 250–4.
19.
StevensonH.W.LeeS.Y.StiglerJ.W. (1986) Mathematics achievement of Chinese, Japanese, and American children. Science, 233, 693–699.
20.
StevensonH.W.StiglcrJ.W. (1992) The learning gapNew YorkSummit.
21.
StiglerJ.W.LeeS.Y.LuckerG.W.StevensonH.W. (1982) Curriculum and achievement in mathematics A study of elementary school children in Japan, Taiwan and the United States. Journal of Educational Psychology, 74, 315–322.
22.
TraversK.J.CrosswhiteF.J.DosseyJ.A.SwaffordJ.O.McKnightC.C.CooneyT.J. (1987) Second international mathematics study summary report for the United States Champaign. I.L Stipes.
