Abstract
A major American news story of 2002 centred on a dispute at Harvard between president Lawrence Summers and Cornel West. This article explores why many commentators erroneously portrayed the dispute between the two men as a matter of civil rights and affirmative action. It also examines the issue at the heart of the fracas, namely a long-running debate about the quality of West's scholarship, and considers whether his commitments to publics outside the classroom detract from his scholarly work. Is the release of a hip-hop CD an appropriate form of intellectual activity for a senior Ivy League professor?
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Cohen
R.
(2002 ), ‘A Negative Impression on Affirmative Action’ , Washington Post , 17 January, p. A23 .
2.
Cross
T.
(2002 ), ‘Cornel West Matters’ , Journal of Blacks in Higher Education , Spring, <http://www.jbhe.com/news_views/34_west.html>.
3.
Dreher
R.
(2002 ), ‘Harvard's Rapper: Cornel West Hits Bottom’ , National Review Online , 4 January, <http://www.nationalreview.com/dreher/dreher010402.shtml>.
4.
Etzioni
A.
(2002 ), ‘Professors Balance Duty to Students, Public Lives’ , USA Today , 14 January, p. 13A .
5.
Hamilton
K.
(2002 ), ‘The State of the African American Professoriate’ , Black Issues in Higher Education 19 (7 ), pp. 30 –31 .
6.
Hollander
P.
(2002 ), ‘Action Figure’ , The New Republic , 3 June, p. 4 .
7.
Hooks
B.
and
West
C.
(1991 ), Breaking Bread: Insurgent Black Intellectual Life , Boston : South End .
8.
Kimball
R.
(2002 ), ‘Dr. West and Mr. Summers: A Harvard Tale’ , National Review 54 (1 ), pp. 24 –25 .
9.
Minow
M.
(1990 ), ‘Cornel West Delivers’ , Reconstruction 1 (2 ), pp. 56 –62 .
10.
Sullivan
J.
(2002 ), ‘Harvard Dispute Sets Bad Example’ , USA Today , 16 January, p. 11A .
11.
Tanenhaus
S.
(2002 ), ‘The Ivy League's Angry Star’ , Vanity Fair , June, pp. 152 –160 .
12.
West
C.
(1984 ), ‘On Christian Intellectuals’ , Christianity and Crisis , 19 March, pp. 77 –78 .
13.
West
C.
(1993a ), Keeping Faith: Philosophy and Race in America , New York : Routledge .
14.
West
C.
(1993b ), Race Matters , Boston : Beacon .
15.
West
C.
(2001a ), Sketches of My Culture , New York : Artemis Records .
16.
West
C.
(2001b ), ‘Philosophy and the Funk of Life’ , in
Yancy
G.
(ed.), Cornel West: A Critical Reader , Oxford : Blackwell .
17.
Wieseltier
L.
(1995 ), ‘All and Nothing at All: The Unreal World of Cornel West , The New Republic , 6 March, pp. 31 –36 .