What are the ethics of foreign policy? How do foreign policymakers decide between competing ethics? Could policymakers make more ethical decisions? These questions achieved prominence in the UK context when Robin Cook—then Foreign Secretary—announced in 1997 that British foreign policy should have an ‘ethical dimension’. Subsequent commentary on New Labour's foreign policy would often use the phrase ‘ethical foreign policy’ to disparage the moralistic rhetoric of Tony Blair and Robin Cook. This article utilises interviews with former Foreign Secretaries and Ministers of State at the Foreign and Commonwealth Office to explore why ethics should be so controversial in British foreign policy discourse. Using Mark Bevir's concepts of the ‘traditions’ and ‘dilemmas’ of governance, it conducts an interpretivist analysis of this data; aiming to understand how policymakers posit themselves as ethical agents, define what it means to be ethical, and rationalise their own ethical judgments in policymaking.
AtkinsJ. (2012) ‘A renewed social democracy for an “age of internationalism”: An interpretivist account of New Labour's foreign policy’, British Journal of Politics and International Relations, 15:2, 175–191.
2.
BeckettM. (2010) Interview with author.
3.
BevirM. (2002) The Logic of the History of Ideas (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press).
4.
BevirM. (2005) New Labour: A Critique (London: Routledge).
5.
BevirM. (2011) ‘The logic of the history of ideas—then and now’, Intellectual History Review, 21:1, 105–119.
6.
BevirM. and RhodesR. A. W. (2003) Interpreting British Governance (London: Routledge).
7.
BevirM. and RhodesR. A. W. (2010) The State as Cultural Practice (Oxford: Oxford University Press).
8.
BinyonM. (1999) ‘Cook's new think-tank will reassess “ethical” foreign policy’, The Times, 4 February.
9.
BryantC. (2010) Interview with author.
10.
BulleyD. (2009a) Ethics as Foreign Policy: Britain, the EU and the Other (London: Routledge).
11.
BulleyD. (2009b) ‘Textualising British politics: Deconstructing the subject of British foreign policy’, British Politics, 4:3, 291–314.
12.
ChandlerD. and HeinsV. (2006) Rethinking Ethical Foreign Policy (New York: Routledge).
CookR. (2001) ‘Human rights—A priority of Britain's foreign policy’, speech delivered at FCO, London, 28 March.
15.
DaddowO. and GaskarthJ. (2011) ‘Introduction: Blair, Brown and New Labour's foreign policy, 1997–2010’, in DaddowO. and GaskarthJ. (eds), British Foreign Policy: The New Labour Years (Basingstoke: Palgrave), 1–28.
16.
GaskarthJ. (2006) ‘Discourses and ethics: The social construction of British foreign policy’, Foreign Policy Analysis, 2:4, 325–341.
McCourtS. (2012) ‘Embracing humanitarian intervention: Atlanticism and the UK interventions in Bosnia and Kosovo’, British Journal of Politics and International Relations, 15:2, 246–262.
27.
MeyerC. (2010) Getting Our Way (London: Phoenix).
28.
OwenD. L. (2003) Interview with author.
29.
PalmerstonL. (1848) ‘Speech on the Polish question’, 1 Mar reproduced in JonesE. (ed.), (1914) Selected Speeches on British Foreign Policy, 1738–1914 (London: Oxford University Press), 232–245.
30.
RammellB. (2011) Interview with author.
31.
RiessmanC. (2002) ‘Analysis of personal narratives’, in GubriumJ. F. and HolsteinJ. A. (eds), Handbook of Interview Research (Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications), 695–710.
32.
RifkindM. S. (2003) Telephone interview with author.
33.
SmithK. E. and LightM. (2001) Ethics and Foreign Policy (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press).
