The model of governance bequeathed by Britain to the Caribbean has long been praised for ensuring that vibrant democratic practice has generally prevailed since the era of decolonisation. Yet it has also become increasingly clear that the Westminster system of politics, as it is applied to the region's tiny polities, has come to exhibit serious deficiencies and is in need of reform. The current government of St Vincent and the Grenadines has recently made a serious attempt to address the issue, engaging in an expansive process of public consultation and constitutional reform which was ultimately rejected by the populace in a referendum held in November 2009. This article seeks to analyse both the form and content of the constitutional reform process, situating it within broader debates about the Westminster Model itself.
BagehotW. (2009 [1867]) The English Constitution (Oxford: Oxford Paperbacks).
2.
BevirM. and RhodesR. (2006) ‘Prime ministers, presidentialism and Westminster smokescreens’, Political Studies, 54:4, 671–690.
3.
BishopM. L. (2010) ‘Tourism as a small state development strategy: Pier pressure in the Eastern Caribbean?’, Progress in Development Studies, 10:2, 99–114.
4.
BishopM. L. and PayneA. (2010) ‘Caribbean regional governance and the sovereignty/statehood problem’, Waterloo, ON: Centre for International Governance Innovation (CIGI) Caribbean Paper No. 8.
5.
BogdanorV. (2009) The New British Constitution (Oxford: Hart Publishing).
6.
Braveboy-WagnerJ. A. (2008) Small States in Global Affairs: The Foreign Policies of the Caribbean Community (CARICOM) (Basingstoke: Palgrave MacMillan).
7.
BriguglioL. (1995) ‘Small island developing states and their economic vulnerabilities’, World Development, 23:9, 1615–1632.
8.
DeosaranR. (2004) ‘A portrait of crime in the Caribbean: Realities and challenges’, in GriffithI. (ed.), Caribbean Security in the Age of Terror (Kingston: Ian Randle, 104–128.
9.
De SmithS. A. (1961) ‘Westminster's export models: The legal framework of responsible government’, Commonwealth and Comparative Politics, 1:1, 2–16.
10.
De SmithS. A. (1964) The New Commonwealth and Its Constitutions (London: Stevens and Sons).
11.
DiceyA. V. (1902 [1885]) An Introduction to the Study of the Law of the Constitution (London: MacMillan).
12.
EmmanuelP. (1992) Elections and Party Systems in the Commonwealth Caribbean, 1944–1991 (Barbados: Caribbean Development Research Services).
13.
FoleyM. (1993) The Rise of British Presidency (Manchester: Manchester University Press).
14.
GambleA. (1990) ‘Theories of British politics’, Political Studies, 38:3, 404–420.
15.
GeiserH. (2009) ‘From Westminster to Westmonster?’, Trinidad Express, 29 May.
16.
GhanyH. (1994a) ‘The creation of legislative institutions in the Commonwealth Caribbean: The myth of the transfer of the Westminster Model’, Congressional Studies Journal, 2:1, 34–49.
17.
GhanyH. (1994b) ‘The myth of the Westminster Model’, Caribbean Affairs, 7:3, 62–82.
18.
GhanyH. (2009) Changing Our Constitution: A Comparison of the Existing Constitution of Trinidad and Tobago and the Working Document on Constitutional Reform for Public Consultation (St Augustine, Trinidad and Tobago: University of the West Indies).
19.
GirvanN. (2006) ‘The search for policy autonomy in the global south’, in UttingP. (ed.), Reclaiming Development Agendas: Knowledge, Power and International Policy Making (Basingstoke: Palgrave MacMillan, 73–89.
20.
GonsalvesR. (2005) ‘The International Airport Project at Argyle’, Speech delivered at the Methodist Church Hall, Kingstown, 8 August.
21.
GonsalvesR. (2009a) ‘Constitutional reform in St Vincent and the Grenadines’, Kingstown, St Vincent: Statement to Parliament Consequent upon the Introduction and First Reading of the Constitution Bill, 28 May.
22.
GonsalvesR. (2009b) ‘Making the case for a referendum’, Port-of-Spain, Trinidad: Speech given to the Conference on Strengthening Democratic Processes and Good Governance, 9 November.
23.
Government of St Vincent and the Grenadines (2003) Information Booklet on the Constitution of St Vincent and the Grenadines, Kingstown, St Vincent.
24.
Government of St Vincent and the Grenadines (2004a) First Interim Report to the House of Assembly, Kingstown, St Vincent.
25.
Government of St Vincent and the Grenadines (2004b) Looking at Our Constitution: Choices for Change, Kingstown, St Vincent.
26.
Government of St Vincent and the Grenadines (2005) Final Report to the House of Assembly, Kingstown, St Vincent.
27.
Government of St Vincent and the Grenadines (2006) Revised Final Report to the House of Assembly, Kingstown, St Vincent.
28.
Government of St Vincent and the Grenadines (2009) Bill for an Act to Provide a New Constitution for St Vincent and the Grenadines, Kingstown, St Vincent.
29.
GriffinC. E. (2007) ‘CARICOM: Confronting the challenges of mediation and conflict resolution’, Commonwealth and Comparative Politics, 45:3, 303–322.
30.
HayC. (2007) Why We Hate Politics (Cambridge: Polity Press).
31.
HeffernanR. (2003) ‘Prime ministerial predominance? Core executive politics in the UK’, British Journal of Politics and International Relations, 5:3, 347–372.
32.
HeffernanR. (2005) ‘Exploring (and explaining) the British prime minister’, British Journal of Politics and International Relations, 7:4, 605–620.
33.
HenkeH. and RénoF. (2003) ‘Is there a new political culture in the Caribbean? Challenges and opportunities’, in HenkeH. and RénoF. (eds), Modern Political Culture in the Caribbean (Kingston: UWI Press, 3–20.
34.
HindsD. (2008) ‘Beyond formal democracy: The discourse on democracy and governance in the anglophone Caribbean’, Commonwealth and Comparative Politics, 46:3, 388–406.
35.
MarshD.RichardsD. and SmithM. J. (2003) ‘Unequal power: Towards an asymmetric power model of the British polity’, Government and Opposition, 38:3, 306–322.
36.
MeighooK. and JamadarV. (2007) Democracy and Constitution Reform in Trinidad and Tobago (Kingston: Ian Randle).
37.
MidgettD. (2003) ‘Democracy and electoral reform in the anglophone Eastern Caribbean’, in Barrow-GilesC. and MarshallD. D. (eds), Living at the Borderlines: Issues in Caribbean Sovereignty and Development (Kingston: Ian Randle, 397–413.
38.
MoranM. (2005) Politics and Governance in the UK (Basingstoke: Palgrave MacMillan).
39.
MunroeT. (2000) ‘Caribbean thought and the political process’, in HallK. O. and BennD. (eds), Contending with Destiny: The Caribbean in the 21st Century (Kingston: Ian Randle, 237–247.
40.
PayneA. (1993) ‘Westminster adapted: The political order of the Commonwealth Caribbean’, in DomínguezJ. I.PastorR. A. and WorrelR. D. (eds), Democracy in the Caribbean: Political, Economic and Social Perspectives (Baltimore, MD: The Johns Hopkins University Press, 57–73.
41.
PayneA. (2006) ‘The end of green gold? Comparative development options and strategies in the Eastern Caribbean banana-producing islands’, Studies in Comparative International Development, 41:3, 25–46.
42.
PayneA. and SuttonP. (2007) ‘Repositioning the Caribbean within globalisation’, Waterloo, ON: Centre for International Governance Innovation (CIGI) Caribbean Paper No. 1.
43.
PhillipsF. (1977) Freedom in the Caribbean: A Study in Constitutional Change (Dobbs Ferry, NY: Oceana).
44.
PremdasR. R. (2002) ‘Self-determination and sovereignty in the Caribbean: Migration, transnational identities and deterritorialisation of the state’, in RamsaranR. (ed.), Caribbean Survival and the Global Challenge (Kingston: Ian Randle, 49–64.
45.
RapleyJ. (2006) ‘State capacity and development in a post-modern age’, Progress in Development Studies, 6:2, 167–172.
46.
RhodesR. (1997) Understanding Governance: Policy Networks, Governance, Reflexivity and Accountability (Buckingham: Open University Press).
47.
RhodesR. and WellerP. (2005) ‘Westminster transplanted and Westminster implanted: Explanations for political change’, in WannaJ. and WellerP. (eds), Westminster Legacies: Democracy and Responsible Government in Asia, Australasia and the Pacific (Sydney: University of New South Wales Press, 1–12.
48.
RyanS. (1999) Winner Takes All: The Westminster Experience in the Caribbean (St Augustine: ISER, The University of the West Indies).
49.
RyanS. (2000) ‘Caribbean political thought, from Westminster to Philadelphia’, in HallK. O. and BennD. (eds), Contending with Destiny: The Caribbean in the 21st Century (Kingston: Ian Randle, 248–273.
50.
RyanS. (2001) ‘Democratic governance in the anglophone Caribbean’, in MeeksB. and LindahlF. (eds), New Caribbean Thought: A Reader (Kingston: UWI Press, 73–103.
51.
SearwarL. (1991) ‘The small state in the Caribbean: Policy options for survival’, in BeruffJ. R.FigueroaJ. P. and GreenJ. E. (eds), Conflict, Peace and Development in the Caribbean (Basingstoke: Palgrave MacMillan, 219–240.
52.
SivesA. (2002) ‘Changing patrons, from politician to drug don: Clientelism in downtown Kingston, Jamaica’, Latin American Perspectives, 29:5, 66–89.
53.
SivesA. (2010) Elections, Violence and the Democratic Process in Jamaica 1944–2007 (Kingston: Ian Randle).
54.
SmithM. J. (1999) The Core Executive in Britain (Basingstoke: MacMillan).
55.
StoneC. (1986) Class, State and Democracy in Jamaica (New York: Praeger).
56.
SuttonP. (1999) ‘Democracy in the Commonwealth Caribbean’, in CalvertP. and BurnellP. J. (eds), The Resilience of Democracy: Persistent Practice, Durable Idea (London: Frank Cass, 67–86.
57.
SuttonP. (2008) ‘Public Sector Reform in the Commonwealth Caribbean: A Review of Recent Experiences’, Waterloo, ON: Centre for International Governance Innovation (CIGI) Caribbean Papers.
58.
ThorndikeT. (1993) ‘Revolution, democracy, and regional integration in the Eastern Caribbean’, in PayneA. and SuttonP. (eds), Modern Caribbean Politics (Baltimore, MD: The Johns Hopkins University Press, 147–175.
59.
WellerP. (1985) First among Equals: Prime Ministers in Westminster Systems (Hemel Hempstead: George Allen & Unwin).
60.
West Indian Commission (1992) Time for Action: Report of the West Indian Commission (Bridgetown, Barbados: West Indian Commission).
61.
Wolf-PhillipsL. (1984) ‘A long look at the British constitution’, Parliamentary Affairs, 37:4, 385–402.
