Stealing from someone is not as bad as torturing, killing or raping them. But is the difference between theft and these fundamental violations simply a difference in degree (of severity)? I begin this article by outlining several ways in which the moral grounds for property rights differ in kind from those for basic human rights, differences that underpin and explain the difference in severity. I go on to ask whether, despite these differences, there might be some property rights that we should still classify as basic human rights.
CruftR. (forthcoming) ‘On the non-instrumental value of basic rights’, Journal of Moral Philosophy.
6.
Dan-CohenM. (2001) ‘The value of ownership’, Journal of Political Philosophy, 9:4, 404–434.
7.
DworkinR. (2002) Sovereign Virtue (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press).
8.
GeussR. (2001) History and Illusion in Politics (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press).
9.
GriffinJ. (2008) On Human Rights (Oxford: Oxford University Press).
10.
HarrisJ. W. (1996) Property and Justice (Oxford: Oxford University Press).
11.
HegelG. W. F. (1991 [1821]) Elements of the Philosophy of Right (trans. NisbetH. B.) (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press).
12.
HohfeldW. N. (1964 [1913 and 1917]) Fundamental Legal Conceptions as Applied in Judicial Reasoning (New Haven, CT: Yale University Press).
13.
KammF. M. (2007) Intricate Ethics (Oxford: Oxford University Press).
14.
Meckled-GarcíaS. and ÇaliB. (2006) ‘Lost in translation: The human rights ideal and international human rights law’, in Meckled-GarcíaS. and ÇaliB. (eds), The Legalization of Human Rights (London: Routledge), 11–31.
15.
MunzerS. (1990) A Theory of Property (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press).
16.
NussbaumM. (2006) Frontiers of Justice (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press).
17.
OtsukaM. (2003) Libertarianism without Inequality (Oxford: Clarendon).
18.
PoggeT. (2002) World Poverty and Human Rights (Cambridge: Polity).
19.
RazJ. (1986) The Morality of Freedom (Oxford: Clarendon).
20.
RazJ. (1994) Ethics in the Public Domain (rev. edn) (Oxford: Clarendon).
21.
SenA. (2004) ‘Elements of a theory of human rights’, Philosophy and Public Affairs, 32:4, 315–356.
22.
ShueH. (1996) Basic Rights (2nd edn) (Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press).
23.
TasioulasJ. (2007) ‘The moral reality of human rights’, in PoggeT. (ed.), Freedom from Poverty as a Human Right (Oxford: Oxford University Press), 75–101.
24.
WaldronJ. (1988) The Right to Private Property (Oxford: Clarendon).
25.
WaldronJ. (2001) ‘Property, honesty and normative resilience’, in MunzerS. (ed.), New Essays in the Legal and Political Theory of Property (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press), 10–35.
26.
WellmanC. (1985) A Theory of Rights (Totawa, NJ: Owman and Allanheld).
