Abstract
This article revisits the thesis put forward by Kent Calder that Japan's foreign policy is made by a reactive state incapable of sustained, innovative policy. Reviewing six recent books, we find that, while the reactive state thesis continues to inform scholarsip on the subject, new frameworks offer possibilities for seeing Japan's foreign policy as innovative and at times strategic. This article considers the strengths and weaknesses in recent attempts to create a more proactive foreign policy.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Anderson
S.
(1993 ) ‘Japan as an Active state in the Pacific Basin’ , Journal of East Asian Studies , 7 , 498 –544 .
2.
Blechinger
V.
Legewie
J.
(eds) (2000 ) Facing Asia: Japan's Role in the Political and Economic Dynamism of Regional Cooperation . Munchen : Iudicium .
3.
Cable
J.
(1994 ) ‘Foreign Policy Making: Planning or Reflex?’ , in
Hill
C.
Beshoff
P.
(eds), Two Worlds of International Relations . London : Routledge , pp. 93 –117 .
4.
Calder
K.
(1988 ) ‘Japanese Foreign Economic Policy Formation’ , World Politics , 40 , 517 –41 .
5.
Drifte
R.
(1996 ) Japan's Foreign Policy in the 1990s . London : Macmillan .
6.
Fallows
J.
(1994 ) Looking at the Sun . New York : Pantheon .
7.
Fukushima
A.
(1999 ) Japanese Foreign Policy: the Emerging Logic of Multilateralism . London : Macmillan .
8.
Garby
C.
Bullock
M.
(1993 ) Japan: A New Kind of Superpower? Baltimore MD : Johns Hopkins University Press .
9.
Gilpin
R.
(1981 ) War and Change in World Politics . Cambridge : Cambridge University Press .
10.
Green
M.
(2001 ) Japan's Reluctant Realism: Foreign Policy Challenge in an Era of Uncertain Power . New York : Palgrave .
11.
Haar
R.
(2001 ) Nation-States as Schizophrenics: Germany and Japan as Post-Cold War Actors . Westport CT : Preager .
12.
Hirata
K.
(2001 ) ‘Reaction and action’ , in
Maswood
S. J.
(ed), Japan and East Asian Regionalism . London : Routledge .
13.
Hook
G.
Gilson
J.
Hughes
C.
Dobson
H.
(2001 ) Japan's International Relations . London : Routledge .
14.
Inoguchi
T.
(1993 ) Gendai Nihon Gaiko . Tokyo : Chikuma Shobo .
15.
Inoguchi
T.
Jain
P.
(eds) (2000 ) Japanese Foreign Policy Today . New York : Palgrave .
16.
Iokibe
M.
(ed.) (1999 ) Sengo Nihon Gaikoshi . Tokyo : Yuhikaku .
17.
Jain
P.
Inoguchi
T.
(1996 ) Japanese Politics Today . London and New York : St. Martin's Press .
18.
Katzenstein
P.
Okawara
N.
(2001/02 ) ‘Japan, Asia-Pacific Security, and the Case for Analytical Eclecticism’ , International Security , 26 , 153 –85 .
19.
Kusano
A.
Umemoto
T.
(eds) (1995 ) Gendai Nihon Gaiko no Bunseki . Tokyo : Tokyo Daigaku Shuppankai .
20.
Lam
P.
(2001 ) ‘Japan's diplomatic initiatives in Southeast Asia’ , in
Maswood
S. J.
(ed.), Japan and East Asian Regionalism . London : Routledge .
21.
Leitch
R.
Kato
A.
Weinstein
M.
(eds) (1995 ) Japan's Role in the Post-Cold War World . Westport VA : Greenwood .
22.
Lincoln
E.
(1993 ) Japan's New Global Role . Washington DC : The Brookings Institution .
23.
Maswood
S. J.
(ed.) (2001 ) Japan and East Asian Regionalism . London : Routledge .
24.
Miyashita
A.
(1999 ) ‘Gaiatsu and Japan's Foreign Aid: Rethinking the Reactive-Proactive Debate’ , International Studies Quarterly , 48 , 695 –732 .
25.
Miyashita
A.
Sato
Y.
(eds) (2001 ) Japanese Foreign Policy in Asia and the Pacific . New York : Palgrave .
26.
Miyazato
S.
(ed.) (1998 ) Ajia Taiheiyo ni okeru Kokusai Kyoryoku . Tokyo : Sanrei Shobo .
27.
Prestowitz
C.
(1988 ) Trading Places . New York : Basic .
28.
Rix
A.
(1993 ) ‘Japan and the Region: Leadership from Behind’ , in
Higgott
R.
(eds), Pacific Economic Relations in the1990s. Boulder CO : Lynne Rienner .
29.
Rosecrance
R.
Taw
J.
(1990 ) ‘Japan and the Theory of International Leadership’ , World Politics , 42 , 184 –209 .
30.
Terry
E.
(2000 ) ‘How Asia Got Rich’ , The Japanese Economy , 28 , 76 –96 .
31.
Unger
D.
Blackburn
P.
(eds) (1993 ) Japan's Emerging Global Role . Boulder CO : Lynne Rienner .
32.
Wan
M.
(2001 ) Japan between Asia and the West . Armonk NJ : M. E. Sharpe .
33.
Yasutomo
D.
(1995 ) The New Multilateralism in Japan's Foreign Policy . New York : St. Martin's Press .
34.
Yasutomo
D.
(2001 ), in
Maswood
S. J.
(ed.), Japan and East Asian Regionalism . London : Routledge .
35.
Yeung
C. K.
(2001 ) ‘Japan's Role in the Making of the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation’ , in
Miyashita
A.
Sato
Y.
(eds), Japanese Foreign Policy in Asia and the Pacific . New York : Palgrave .