This paper uses research from the field of international business to investigate when a multinational corporation’s threat to leave a country is likely to have substance. Some multinationals have broad flexibility to relocate. Others do not. Customer expectations, transportation costs and organisational factors may limit their flexibility. The challenge for trade unions in high wage countries like Australia is to be able to assess these factors and judge whether threats to ‘move to Asia’ are viable. Often they are not.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Australian Bureau of Statistics (2000) Australian Direct Investment Abroad Outward Stocks. Catalogue Number 5352.0. Canberra .
2.
Bamber G , Lansbury R (1998) International and Comparative Industrial Relations. Sydney: Allen and Unwin .
3.
Bean R (1994) Comparative Industrial Relations: an introduction to cross-national perspective. 2nd edn, New York: Routledge .
4.
Beeson P , Husted S. (1989) Patterns and determinants of productive efficiency in state manufacturing . Journal of Regional Science29(1), 15-28 .
5.
Billington S (1999) The location of foreign direct investment: An empirical analysis . Applied Economics31 (1), 65-66 .
6.
Birkinshaw (1996) How multinational subsidiary mandates are gained and lost . Journal of International Business Studies26 (4), 729-754 .
7.
Bray M , Lansbury R (2000) The conditions for convergence: multinationals, product markets, production systems and employment relations . Journal of Industrial Relations42(2), 295-313 .
8.
Breitenfellner A (1999) Global unionism: A potential player . International Labour Review. 136(4), 531-555
9.
Buckley PJ , Casson M (1976) The Future of the Multinational Enterprise. London: Macmillan .
10.
Buckley and Enderwick (1983) Comparative pay levels in domestically-owned and foreign-owned plants in UK manufacturing - Evidence from the 1980 Workplace Industrial Relations survey . British Journal of Industrial Relations21 (3), 395-400 .
11.
Calof JL , Beamish PW (1995) Adapting to foreign markets: explaining internationalisation . International Business Review4, 115-131 .
12.
Cantwell J (1992) The Effects of integration on the structure of multinational corporation activity in the EC. In: Klein MW , Welfens PJ , eds, Multinationals in the New Europe and Global Trade. Berlin: Springer-Verlag .
13.
Daser S , Meric HJ (1987) Does patriotism have any market value: exploratory findings for the ‘Crafted with Pride in the USA’ campaign. In: Wallendorf M , Anderson P , eds, Advances in Consumer Research, Provo, Utah: Association for Consumer Research .
14.
Davidson W (1982) Global Strategic Management. New York: Wiley and Sons .
15.
Destler I , Balint P (1999) The New Politics of American Trade: Trade, Labour and the Environment. Washington: Institute for International Economics .
16.
Dunning J (1993) Multinational Enterprises and the Global Economy. Wokingham: Addison-Wesley .
17.
Edwards R , Muthaly S (1999) Perceptions of risk and opportunity: Why some Australian firms have invested in Thailand . Journal of Asian Business15(2) 79-84 .
18.
Edwards RW and Buckley PJ (1997) European integration: Strategic consequences for Australian multinationals . International Journal of Business Studies5(2) 22-32 .
19.
Enderwick P (1984) The labour utilization practices of multinationals and obstacles to multinational collective bargaining . The Journal of Industrial Relations26, 345-364 .
20.
Enderwick P (1985) Multinational Business and Labour. Sydney: Croom Helm .
21.
Fittock S , Edwards R (1998) The determinants of Australian direct investment in China . Journal of Asian Business14(3), 41-52 .
22.
Frenkel S (1993) Workplace Relations in the Global Corporation: A Comparative Analysis of Subsidiaries in Malaysia and Taiwan. Centre for Corporate Change, Paper No. 039. Sydney: University of New South Wales .
23.
Gallin D (1994) Address to the Global Labour Summit. 31 May - 1 June, Copenhagen: Global Labour Institute.
24.
Greider W (1997) One world ready or not: The manic logic of global capitalism. New York: Simon and Schuster .
25.
Hill C (1997) International Business: Competing in the Global Market Place. Chicago: Irwin .
26.
Hill S , Monday M (1994) The regional distribution of foreign manufacturing investment in the UK. In: Christodoulou P , ed, Inward Investment: An Overview and Guide to the Literature, London: The Bristish Library .
27.
Industry Commission (1997) The Textiles, Clothing and Footwear Industries, Report Number 59, Melbourne .
28.
Johanson JK , Ronkainan IA , Czinkota MR (1994) negative country of origin effects: The case of the new Russia . Journal of International Business Studies1, 157-176 .
29.
Kaynak E , Cavusgil ST (1983) consumer attitudes toward products of foreign origin: Do they vary across product classes?International Journal of Advertising2, 147-157 .
30.
Khachaturian J , Morganosky M (1990) Quality perceptions by country of origin . International Journal of Retail and Distribution Management18(5), 21-30 .
31.
Kim CH and Chung JY (1997) Brand popularity, country image and market share: An empirical study . Journal of International Business Studies2, 361-386 .
32.
Kwon YC , Hu MY (1995) Comparative analysis of export-oriented and foreign production-oriented firms’ foreign market entry decisions . Management International Review35, 325-336 .
33.
Liebhaberg B (1980) Industrial Relations and Multinational Corporations in Europe. Cower: ECSIM .
34.
Lucio M , Weston S (1994) new management practices in a multinational corporation: The restructuring of worker representation and rights . Industrial Relations Journal, 25(2) 110-121 .
35.
Marginson P , Armstrong P , Edwards PK , Purcell J (1995) Extending beyond borders: Multinational companies and the international management of labour . The International Journal of Human Resource Management6(3), 702-719 .
36.
Mueller F , Purcell J (1991) The Europeanisation of manufacturing and the decentralisation of bargaining: Multinational management strategies in the European automobile industry . The International Journal of Human Resource Management3(1), 15-31 .
37.
Newman B (1981) Ford threatens to move production abroad . Wall Street Journal 22 April, pp. 3 .
38.
Olsen J , Granzin K , Biswas A (1993) influencing consumers’ selection of domestic versus imported products: Implications for marketing based on a model of helping behaviour . Journal of Academy of Marketing Science21, 307-321 .
39.
Papadopolous N , Heslop LA (1993) Product-Country-Images: Impact and Role in International Marketing. New York: Haworth Press .
40.
Porter M (1990) The Competitive Advantage of Nations. New York: The Free Press .
41.
Rodrik D (1997) Has Globalization Gone Too Far?Washington: Institute for International Economics .
42.
Rodwell J , Teo S (1999) The value of employment relations in multinationals: Finding the right balance . International Business Review8, 309-321 .
43.
Rosenzweig PM , Nohria N (1994) Influences on human resource management practices in multinational corporations . Journal of International Business Studies25(2) 229-251 .
44.
Sim AB (1977) Decentralised management of subsidiaries and their performance . Management International Review17(2) 45-51 .
45.
Stopford J , Wells L (1972) Managing the Multinational Enterprise. New York: Basic Books .
46.
UNCTAD (1998) World Investment Report 1998: Trends and Determinants. New York: United Nations .
47.
UNCTAD (2000a) Trade and Development Report 2000: Global Economic Growth and Imbalances. New York: United Nations .
48.
UNCTAD (2000b) World Investment Report: Cross-Border Mergers and Acquisitions and Development, New York: United Nations .
49.
Van Liemt G (1992) Economic globalisation: Labour options and business strategies in high labour cost countries . International Labour Review131(4-5), 453-471 .
50.
Wade P (1988) The Japanese of the Malaysia trade union movement. In: Southall R , ed, Trade Unions and the New Industrialization of the Third World, London: Zed Book .
51.
Zhao L (1998) Labour-management bargaining and transfer pricing in multinational corporations . Canadian Journal of Economics31(4), 815-829 .
