Fluctuations in endogenous opioid activity in the brain, controlled under ordinary conditions by attachment, are capable of producing patterns of dependence in social behavior resembling those appearing in substance abusers. Withdrawal symptoms arising in relation to these fluctuations, short of producing dependence, ordinarily fuel everyday social interaction, and interaction then serves to modulate opioid activity within a range associated with comfort. Comfort-constraints in this sense operate in all settings of social interaction, part of an innate caregiving mechanism conserved by evolution in human behavior. In this paper we present a formal model of the neurosociological mechanism embodying these comfort constraints. Conceptualized as a hyperstructure, the mechanism grounds thinking about social interaction in recent biological discoveries about the brain, and enables sociologists to study how activity in core brain systems constrains deep patterns in social life, including the human tendencies to altruism and reciprocity. Using computational methods, we undertake simulations to study the mechanism, deriving implications about moral behavior. The theory of the hyper-structure leads to new conclusions about reciprocity and altruism, and bears upon sociological understanding of related subjects such as justice and social comparison.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AinsworthM. D.1973. “The Development of Infant-Mother Attachment.” Pp. 1–94 in Review of Child Development Research, vol. 3, edited by CaldwellB. M.RiciuttiH. N.. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
2.
BarkowJerome H.CosmidesLedaToobyJohn, eds. 1992. The Adapted Mind: Evolutionary Psychology and the Generation of Culture.New York: Oxford University Press.
3.
BartholomewK.PerlmanD.1994. Attachment Processes in Adulthood. Advances in Personal Relationships Series, vol. 5. London, England: Jessica Kingsley Publications.
4.
BayartF.HayashiK. T.FaullK. F.BarchasJ. D.1990. “Influence of Maternal Proximity on Behavioral and Physiological Response to Separation in Infant Rhesus Monkeys.”, Behavioral Neuroscience104:98–107.
5.
BeattyW. W.CostelloK. B.1982. “Naloxone and Play Fighting in Juvenile Rats.”, Pharmacology, Biochemistry, and Behavior17:905–08.
6.
BodnarR. J.SikorskyV.1983. “Naloxone and Cold Water Swim Analgesia.”, Learning and Motivation14:223–37.
7.
BowenMurray1978. Family Therapy in Clinical Practice.New York: Aronson.
8.
BowlbyJohn1969. Attachment and Loss. Vol. 1, Attachment.New York: Basic Books.
9.
CapitanioJ. P.WeissbergM.ReiteM.1985. “The Biology of Maternal Behavior.” In The Psychobiology of Attachment and Separation edited by ReiteM.FieldT.. New York: Academic Press.
10.
ChristieM. J.ChesherG. B.1982. “Physical Dependence on Physiologically Released Endogenous Opiates.”, Life Sciences30:1173–77.
11.
CohenM. R.CohenR. M.PickarD.WeingartenH.MurphyD. L.1983. “High Dose Naloxone Infusions in Normals.”, Archives of General Psychiatry40:613–19.
12.
DavisK. L.1980. “Opioid Control of Canine Social Behavior.” Ph.D. dissertation, Bowling Green State University.
13.
DerryberryD.RothbartM. K.1984. “Emotion, Attention, and Temperament.” Pp. 132–66 in Emotion, Cognition, and Behavior, edited by IzardC. E.KaganJ.ZajoncR. B.. Cambridge, England: Cambridge University Press.
FestingerL.1954. “A Theory of Social Comparison Processes.”, Human Relations7:114–40.
21.
FieldTiffany1985. “Attachment as Psychobiological Attunement: Being on the Same Wavelength,” Pp. 415–54 in The Psychobiology of Attachment and Separation, edited by ReiteMartinFieldTiffany. New York: Academic Press.
22.
FoxN. A.DavidsonR. J.1987. “Electroencephalogram Asymmetry in Response to the Approach of a Stranger and Maternal Separation in 10-month-old Infants.”, Developmental Psychology23:233–40.
23.
FoxN. A.PorgesS. W.1985. “The Relation between Neonatal Heart Rate Patterns and Developmental Outcome.”, Child Development56:28–37.
24.
GeorgeM. S.KetterT. A.PapekhP. I.HorowitzB.HerscovitchP.PostR. M.1995. “Brain Activity during Transient Sadness and Happiness in Healthy Women,”, American Journal of Psychiatry152:341–51.
25.
GouldnerAlvin W.1960. “The Norm of Reciprocity,”, American Sociological Review25:161–78.
26.
GrayJeffrey A., ed. 1990. Psychobiological Aspects of Relationships between Emotion and Cognition.Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum.
27.
GreenbergJ.MitchellS.1983. Object Relations in Psychoanalytic Theory.Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
28.
GreenspanS. I.1981. “Psychopathology and Adaptation in Infancy and Early Childhood.” In Clinical Infant Reports, no. 1. New York: International Universities Press.
29.
GunnerM.MangelsdorfS.LarsonM.HertsgaardL.1989. “Attachment, Temperament and Adrenocortical Activity in Infancy: A Study of Psychoendocrine Regulation.”, Developmental Psychology.25:355–63.
30.
HealyB.1989. “Autonomic Nervous System Correlates of Temperament.”, Infant Behavior and Development12:289–304.
31.
HermanJudith Lewis1992. Trauma and Recovery.New York: Basic Books.
32.
HillR. G.AyliffeS. J.1981. “The Antinociceptive Effect of Vaginal Stimulation in the Rat is Reduced by Naloxone.”, Pharmacology, Biochemistry, and Behavior14: 631–33.
33.
HoferM. A.1990. “Early Symbiotic Processes: Hard Evidence from a Soft Place.” Pp. 55–78 in Pleasure Beyond the Pleasure Principle, edited by GlickR. A.BoneS.. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
34.
InselT. R.1992. “Oxytocin: A Neuropeptide for Affiliation: Evidence from Behavioral, Receptor Autoradiographic, and Comparative Studies.”, Psychoneuroendocrinology17:3–35.
35.
InselT. R.WangZ.1994. “Patterns of Brain Vasopressin Receptor Distribution Associated with Social Organization in Microtine Rodents.”, Journal of Neuroscience14: 5381–92.
36.
JassoG.1980. “A New Theory of Distributive Justice.”, American Sociological Review45:3–32.
37.
JassoG.1988. “Principles of Theoretical Analysis,”, Sociological Theory6:1–20.
38.
JassoG.1993. “Building the Theory of Comparison Processes: Construction of Postulates and Derivation of Predictions.” Pp. 213–64 in Theoretical Research Programs: Studies in the Growth of Theory, edited by BergerJosephZelditchMorrisJr. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.
39.
KaganJ.1982. “Heart Rate and Heart Variability as Signs of Temperamental Dimensions in Infants.” In Measuring Emotions in Infants and Children, edited by IzardC.. New York: Cambridge University Press.
40.
KerrMichaelBowenMurray1988. Family Evaluation.New York: Basic Books.
41.
KrystalH.1988. Integration and Self-Healing: Affect-trauma-alexithymia.Hillsdale, NJ: Analytic Press.
42.
LeDouxJoseph1996. The Emotional Brain.New York: Simon and Schuster.
43.
LeshemM.KreiderM.1987. “Brain Serotonin Depletion and Nipple Attachment in Rat Pups.”, Pharmacology, Biochemistry, and Behavior27:7–14.
44.
McGivernR.BerkaC.BerntsonG. G. et al. 1979. “Effect of Naloxone on Analgesia Induced by Food Deprivation.”, Life Sciences25:885–88.
45.
McGuireM. T.RaleighM. J.BrammerG. T.1984. “Adaptation, Selection, and Benefit-Cost Balances.”, Ethology and Social Biology5:269–77.
46.
MahlerMargaretFurerM.1968. On Human Symbiosis and the Vicissitudes of Individuation.New York: International Universities Press.
47.
MellerR. E.KeverneE. B.HerbertJ.1980. “Behavioral and Endocrine Effects of Naltrexone in Male Talpoin Monkeys.”, Pharmacology, Biochemistry, and Behavior13:435–41.
48.
MiczekK. A.ThompsonM. L.ShusterL.1982. “Opioid-Like Analgesia in Defeated Mice.”, Science215:1520–21.
49.
NadelL.CooperL.CulicoverP.HarnishR.1989. “Nalaxone-Reversible Suppression of Isolation Call Production after Morphine Injections in Squirrel Monkeys.”, Social Neuroscience Abstracts8:940.
50.
NewmanJ. D.MurphyM. R.HarboughC. R.1982. “Naloxone-Reversible Suppression of Isolation Call Production after Morphine Injections in Squirrel Monkeys.”, Social Neuroscience Abstracts8:940.
51.
PankseppJaak, 1990. “Gray Zones at the Emotion/Cognition Interface.” Pp. 289–304 in Psychobiological Aspects of Relationships Between Emotion and Cognition, edited by GrayJeffrey A.. Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.
52.
PankseppJaak, 1998. Affective Neuroscience: The Foundations of Human and Animal Emotions.New York: Oxford University Press.
53.
PilcherC. W. T.JonesS. M.1981. “Social Crowding Enhances Aversiveness of Naloxone in Rats.”, Pharmacology, Biochemistry, and Behavior16:569–71.
54.
PitmanR.van der KolkB. A.OrrS. P. et al. 1990. “Naloxone-Reversible Analgesic Response to Combat- Related Stimuli in Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder.”, Archives of General Psychiatry47:541–47.
55.
PlonskyM.FreemanP. R.1982. “The Effect of Methadone on the Social Behavior and Activity of the Rat.”, Pharmacology, Biochemistry, and Behavior.16:569–71.
56.
PrigogineIlyaAllenP. M., 1982. “The Challenge of Complexity.” Pp. 3–39 in Self-Organization and Dissipative Structures, edited by SchieveW. C.AllenP. M.. Austin, TX: University of Texas Press.
57.
ReiteN.FieldT.1985. The Psychobiology of Attachment and Separation.Orlando, FL: Academic Press.
58.
RidleyMatt1996. The Origins of Virtue: Human Instincts and the Evolution of Cooperation.New York: Viking.
59.
RothbartM. K.DerryberryD.1981. “Development of Individual Differences in Temperament.” Pp. 383–400 in Advances in Developmental Psychology, vol. 1, edited by LambM. E.BrownA. L.. Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.
60.
SahlinsMarshall1965. “On the Sociology of Primitive Exchange.” Pp. 139–227 in The Relevance of Models for Social Anthropology, A.S.A. Monographs 1. London, England: Tavistock Publications.
61.
SahlinsMarshall1972. Stone Age Economics.Chicago, IL: Aldine-Atherton.
62.
SchoreA. N.1994. Affect Regulation and the Origin of the Self: The Neurobiology of Emotional Development.Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.
63.
SmithThomas S.1984. “Personal Ties and Institutionalized Action.” Pp. 23–51 in The Challenge of Social Control, edited by SuttlesGeraldZaldMeyer. Norwood, NJ: Ablex Publishing Company.
64.
SmithThomas S.1992. Strong Interaction.Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
65.
SmithThomas S.1994. “Catastrophes in Interaction,”, Social Psychology Quarterly57(3):274–82.
66.
SmithThomas S.1997. “Nonlinear Dynamics and the Micro-Macro Bridge.” Pp. 52–63 in Chaos, Complexity, and Sociology, edited by EveRaymondHorsfallSaraLeeMary. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications.
67.
SmithThomas S.FranksDavid1999. “Emergence, Reduction, and Levels of Analysis.” Pp. 3–18 in Mind, Brain, and Society, vol. 5, Social Perspectives on the Emotions, edited by FranksDavidSmithThomas. Stamford, CT: JAI Press.
68.
SmithThomas S.StevensGregory T.1996. “Emergence, Self-Organization, and Social Interaction: Arousal- Dependent Structure in Social Systems.”, Sociological Theory14(July):131–53. [Also: Santa Fe Institute Publication Series, Paper No. 94–08–046.].
69.
SmithThomas S.StevensGregory T.1997a. “Comfort-Regulation as a Morphogenetic Principle.” Pp. 113–55 in Advances in Group Processes, edited by MarkovskyBarry et al. Vol. 14Stamford, CT: JAI Press.
70.
SmithThomas S.StevensGregory T.1997b. “Biological Foundations of Social Interaction: Computational Explorations of Nonlinear Dynamics in Arousal-Modulation.” Pp. 197–212 in Chaos, Complexity, and Sociology, edited by EveRaymondHorsfallSaraLeeMary. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications.
71.
SmithThomas S.StevensGregory T.1999. “The Architecture of Small Networks: Strong Interaction and Dynamic Organization in Small Social Systems.”, American Sociological Review64:403–20.
72.
SmithThomas S.StevensGregory T.Hyperstructures: The Biological Architecture of Social Life..
73.
SmithThomas S.StevensG. T.CaldwellSarah1999. “The Familiar and the Strange: Hopfield Network Models for Prototype Entrained Attachment-Mediated Neurophysiology.” Pp. 213–45 in Mind, Brain, and Society, vol. 5, Social Perspectives on the Emotions. edited by FranksDavidSmithThomas. Stanford, CT: JAI Press.
74.
SteklisH. D.KlingA.1985. “Neurobiology of Affiliation in Primates.” In The Psychobiology of Attachment and Separation, edited by ReiteM.FieldT.. New York: Academic Press.
75.
SternDaniel, 1985. The Interpersonal World of the Infant.New York: Basic Books.
76.
SternDaniel, 1990. Diary of a Baby.New York: Basic Books.
77.
StifterC. A.FoxN. A.1987. “A Study of the Causal Relationship between Physiological Functioning and Later Development from Birth to Five Months of Age.” Ph.D. dissertation, University of Maryland.
78.
SuJeanC.WeissbergS.KelloggC.1999. “Depolarized Release of Endogenous Norepinephrine in the Hypothalamus Is Altered by Adolescent Development in the Male Rat.”University of Rochester. Unpublished Paper. [Under review.].
TaylorG.1987. Psychosomatic Medicine and Contemporary Psychoanalysis.Madison, CT: International Universities Press.
81.
TennesK.1982. “The Role of Hormones in Mother-Infant Transactions.” In The Development of Attachment and Affiliative Systems, edited by EmdeR. N.HarmonR. J.. New York: Plenum Press.
82.
ThompsonR. A.1990. “Emotion and Self-Regulation.” Pp. 367–467 in Nebraska Symposium on Motivation.Lincoln, NB: University of Nebraska Press.
83.
TimirasP. S.1982. “The Timing of Hormone Signals in the Orchestration of Brain Development.” In The Development of Attachment and Affiliative Systems, edited by EmdeR. N.HarmonR. J.. New York: Plenum Press.
84.
TitelmanPeter, ed. 1999. Clinical Applications of Bowen Family Systems Theory.New York: Haworth Press.
85.
TrevarthanColin1980. “The Foundations of Intersubjectivity.” In The Social Foundation of Language and Thought, edited by OlsenD. R.. New York: Norton.
86.
TrevarthanColin1983. “Emotions in Infancy.” Pp. 129–57 in Approaches to Emotion, edited by SchererK.EkmanP.. Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum.
87.
TriversRobert1971. “The Evolution of Reciprocal Altruism.”, Quarterly Review of Biology46:35–57.
88.
TriversRobert1985. Social Evolution.Menlo Park, CA: Benjamin/Cummings.
89.
Uvnas-MobergK.1994. “Oxytocin and Behavior.”, Annals of Medicine26:315–17.
90.
van der KolkBessel1987. Psychological Trauma.Washington, DC: American Psychiatric Press.
91.
WilliamsGeorge C.1992. Natural Selection Domains, Levels, and Challenges.Oxford, England: Oxford University Press.
92.
WiseR. A.RompreP.1989. “Brain Dopamine and Reward.”, Annual Review of Psychology40:191–225.
