The claims made by Bougainville's secessionist leaders correspond with five theoretical perspectives on the morality of secession – based, respectively, on notions of political consent, national identity, cultural preservation, distributive justice and territorial title. Each is tackled in turn, as a means to both assessing the justness of the Bougainvillean case, while also testing the limits of applicability of the moral perspectives themselves. Overall, it is concluded that the complexities of the Bougainville/Papua New Guinea case militate against outright separation. Rather, a balanced resolution of injustices is more likely to be attained by modifications to institutions and patterns of distribution within the existing state. Furthermore, this highly complex case throws up important challenges from which normative theory can profitably learn.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
‘The Arrows of Bougainville’ (1992), The Economist323, 23 May, 37.
2.
BarryB. (1991) ‘Self-Government Revisited’, in BarryB. (ed.), Democracy and Power: Essays in Political Theory, vol. 1. Oxford: Clarendon Press, pp. 156–86.
3.
BeranH. (1984) ‘A liberal theory of secession’, Political Studies, 32 (1), 21–31.
4.
BeranH. (1998) ‘A Democratic Theory of Political Self-Determination for a New World Order’, in LehningP. B. (ed.) Theories of Secession. London; New York: Routledge, pp. 32–59.
5.
BirchA. (1984) ‘Another liberal theory of secession’, Political Studies, 32 (4), 596–602.
6.
BuchananA. (1991) Secession: The Morality of Political Divorce from Fort Sumter to Lithuania and Quebec. Boulder: Westview Press.
7.
ConnellJ. (1990) ‘Perspectives on a Crisis (4)’, in PolomkaP. (ed.), Bougainville: Perspectives on a Crisis. Canberra: Australian National University, pp. 29–34.
8.
FilerC. (1992) ‘The Escalation of Disintegration and the Reinvention of Authority’, in SpriggsM.DenoonD. (eds), The Bougainville Crisis: 1991 Update. Bathurst: Crawford House Press, pp. 112–40.
9.
FilerC. (1990) ‘The Bougainville Rebellion, the Mining Industry and the Process of Social Disintegration in Papua New Guinea’, in MayR. J.SpriggsM. (eds), The Bougainville Crisis. Bathurst: Crawford House, pp. 73–112.
10.
GriffinJ. (1990) ‘Bougainville is a Special Case’, in MayR. J.SpriggsM. (eds), The Bougainville Crisis. Bathurst: Crawford House, pp. 1–16.
11.
HaviniM. (1998) ‘Bougainville: The Long Struggle for Freedom.’Paper presented to the UN International Conference on Indigenous Peoples: Environment and Development, available http://www.luc.wmin.ac.uk; Internet; (1998, 3 October).
12.
KymlickaW. (1998) ‘Is Federalism a Viable Alternative to Secession?’, in LehningP. B. (ed.), Theories of Secession. London; New York: Routledge, pp. 111–50.
13.
KymlickaW. (1995) Multicultural Citizenship. New York: Oxford University Press.
14.
MalikM. (1989) ‘Formula for peace: New guidelines for mining negotiations’, Far Eastern Economic Review, 145 (3 August), 22–3.
15.
MillerD. (1993) ‘In defense of nationality’, Journal of Applied Philosophy, 10 (1), 3–16.
MooreM. (1997) ‘On national self-determination’, Political Studies, 45 (5), 900–13.
18.
NozickR. (1974) Anarchy, State and Utopia. New York: Basic Books.
19.
O'CallaghanM. (1991) ‘Early test for peace’, Far Eastern Economic Review, 151 (7 February), 15.
20.
O'CallaghanM. (1990) ‘Retreat from violence’, Far Eastern Economic Review, 147 (22 March), 13.
21.
OganE. (1990) ‘Perspectives on a Crisis (5)’, in PolomkaP. (ed.), Bougainville: Perspectives on a Crisis. Canberra: Australian National University, pp. 35–41.
22.
PolomkaP. (1990) ‘Land as Life, Security and Impediment to Unity’, in PolomkaP. (ed.), Bougainville: Perspectives on a Crisis. Canberra: Australian National University, pp. 1–4.
23.
RawlsJ. (1971) A Theory of Justice. Cambridge MA: Harvard University Press.
24.
SpriggsM. (1992) ‘Bougainville Update: August 1990 to May 1991’, in SpriggsM.DenoonD. (eds), The Bougainville Crisis: 1991 Update. Bathurst: Crawford House Press, pp. 8–41.
25.
StandishBill (1993) ‘Papua New Guinea in 1992: Challenges for the state,’Asian Survey33 (2), 211–17.
26.
WaikoJ. D. (1993) A Short History of Papua New Guinea. Melbourne, Australia: Oxford University Press.
27.
WalzerM. (1983) Spheres of Justice: A Defense of Pluralism and Equality. New York: Basic Books.
28.
WanekA. (1996) The State and its Enemies in Papua New Guinea. Richmond: Curzon Press.
29.
Wesley-SmithT. (1991) ‘Papua New Guinea in 1990: A year of crisis,’Asian Survey, 31 (2), 188–95.
