This analysis traces the evolution of ideas about one of the most important policies facing any state: taxation. The article will demonstrate that elite ideas about tax policy have changed dramatically over the past century and that these ideas have had enormous consequences for the development of the modern state. This article argues that there is an iterative, interdependent and dynamic relationship between policy makers' ideas, political institutions and public policy outcomes.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AaronH.GalperH. (1986) Assessing tax reform (Washington, DC: The Brookings Institution).
2.
AdamsT. S. (1928) ‘Ideals and Idealism in Taxation’, The American Economic Review, 18:1, 1–8.
3.
BarroR. (1991) ‘Economic Growth in a Cross Section of Countries’, The Quarterly Journal of Economics, 106:2, 407–444.
4.
BaumgartnerF. R.JonesB. D. (1993) Agendas and instability in American politics (Chicago: University of Chicago Press).
5.
BenhamF. (1942) ‘What is the Best Tax System’, Economica, 9:33–36, 115–126.
6.
BirdR. M. (1980) Tax Incentives for Investment: The State of the Art (Toronto: Canadian Tax Foundation).
7.
BirnbaumJ.MurrayA. (1987) Showdown at Gucci Gulch: law makers, lobbyists and the unlikely triumph of tax reform (New York: Random House).
8.
BjörklundA.PalmeM.SvenssonI. (1995) ‘Tax Reforms and Income Distribution: An Assessment Using Different Income Concepts’, Swedish Policy Review, 2, 229–266.
9.
BloughR.ShoupC. (1937) A Report on the Federal Revenue System: Consultants' report to Undersecretary of the Treasury. Box 63; Tax Reform Programs and Studies; Records of the Office of Tax Analysis/Division of Tax Research; General Records of the Department of the Treasury, Record Group 56 (College Park, MD: National Archives).
10.
BlythM. (2002) Great transformations: Economic ideas and institutional change in the twentieth century (New York: Cambridge University Press).
11.
BoskinM. J. (1990) ‘New directions in tax policy’, in BoskinM. J.McLureC. E.Jr (eds), World tax reform (San Francisco: ICS Press), 3–7.
12.
BoskinM. J.McLureC. E.Jr (eds) (1990) World tax reform (San Francisco: ICS Press).
13.
BuchananJ. M. (1987) Public finance in democratic process (Chapel Hill: The University of North Carolina Press).
14.
Confederation of British Industries (1965) Taxation in western Europe (London: Confederation of British Industries).
15.
ConlanT.WrightsonM.BeamD. (1990) Taxing Choices: The Politics of Tax Reform (Washington DC: CQ Press).
16.
DowdingK. (2000) ‘How not to use evolutionary theory in politics: a critique of Peter John’, British Journal of Politics and International Relations, 2:1, 72–80.
17.
EbersteinG. (1929) Om Skatt til Stat och Kommun (Stockholm: Norstedt and Sons).
18.
Economist (2001) ‘Is government disappearing?’, 27 September 2001, www.economist.com 11/19/2001.
GalbraithJ. K. (1978) The new industrial state (3rd edn) (Boston: Houghton Mifflin).
21.
GarrettG. (1995) ‘Capital mobility, trade and the domestic politics of economic policy’, International Organisation, 49:4, 657–687.
22.
GarrettG.LangeP. (1995) ‘Internationalisation, institutions and political change’, International Organisation, 49:4, 627–655.
23.
GenbergT. (1942) ‘Skatteutvecklingen sedan sekelskiftet’ (Taxation since the turn of the century), Meddelanden Fran Skattebetalarnas Forening, 76.
24.
GoldsteinJ.KeohaneR. (1993) ‘Ideas and Foreign Policy: An Analytic Framework’, in GoldsteinJ.KeohaneR. (eds), Ideas and Foreign Policy: Beliefs, Institutions and Political Change (Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press), 3–30.
25.
GravelleJ. (1992) ‘Equity Effects of the Tax Reform Act of 1986’, Journal of Economic Perspectives, 6:1, 27–44.
26.
HaasG. (1937) Tax Revision Studies: General Statement, revenue Estimates, Summaries, and Recommendations, Tax Reform Programs and Studies; Records of the Office of Tax Analysis/Division of Tax Research; General Records of the Department of the Treasury, Record Group 56 (College Park, MD: National Archives).
27.
HallP. (1993) ‘Policy paradigms, social learning and the state: The case of economic policy making in Britain, Comparative Politics, 25:3, 185–196.
28.
HallP.TaylorR. (1996) ‘Political science and the three new institutionalisms’, Political Studies, 44:4, 936–957.
29.
HansenB. (1969) Fiscal policies in seven countries (Paris: OECD).
30.
HayC. (2002) Political Analysis (London: Palgrave).
31.
HowardC. (1997) The hidden welfare state (Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press).
32.
IshiH. (1993) The Japanese tax system (2nd edn) (Oxford; New York: Clarendon Press).
33.
JohnP. (1999) ‘Ideas and interests; agendas and implementation: an evolutionary explanation of policy change in British local government finance, British Journal of Politics and International Relations, 1:1, 39–62.
34.
JohnP. (2000) ‘The uses and abuses of evolutionary theory in political science: A reply to Allan McConnell and Keith Dowding’, British Journal of Politics and International Relations2:1, 89–94.
35.
JonesC. (1996) ‘Mass-based income taxation: Creating a taxpaying culture, 1940–1952’, in BrownleeE. (ed), Funding the modern American state, 1941–1995: the rise and fall of the era of easy finance (New York: Cambridge University Press), 107–147.
36.
KerrP. (2002) ‘Saved from Extinction: Evolutionary Theorising, Politics and the State’, British Journal of Politics and International Relations, 4:2, 330–358.
37.
KeynesJ. M. (1933) ‘National self-sufficiency’, The Yale Review, 22.
38.
KeynesJ. M. (1936) The general theory of employment, interest and money (London: Macmillan).
39.
KingR. (1983) From redistributive to hegemonic logic: the transformation of American tax politics, Politics and Society, 12:1, 1–52.
40.
LeviM. (1988) Of rule and revenue (Berkeley, CA: University of California Press).
41.
LindbeckA. (1970) Den nya vänsterns ekonomiska teori (The new left's economic theory) (Stockholm).
42.
MartinC. J. (1989) Corporate taxation in pursuit of growth as cause and effect, Paper presented to the 1989 annual meeting of the American Political Science Association, Atlanta, Georgia.
43.
McDanielP.SurreyS. (1985) International aspects of tax expenditures: a comparative study (Deventer, Netherlands: Kluwer Publishing).
44.
McLureC. E. (1984) ‘The Evolution of Tax Advice and the Taxation of Capital Income in the USA’, Government and Policy, 2:3, 251–269.
45.
MellonJ. (1924) Taxation: the people's business (New York: The Macmillan Company).
46.
MinarikJ. (1990) Making America's Budget Policy From the 1980s to the 1990s (Armonk, NY: M.E. Sharpe, Inc).
47.
MusgraveR. (1990) ‘Comments’, in SlemrodJ. (ed), Do Taxes Matter? (Cambridge, MA: MIT Press).
48.
MusgraveR. A.MusgraveP. B. (1980) Public finance in theory and practice (New York: McGraw Hill).
49.
OECD (1991) Strategic industries in a global economy: Policy issues for the 1990s (Paris: OECD).
50.
PechmanJ. (1983) Federal tax policy (Washington, DC: Brookings Institution).
51.
PechmanJ. A. (ed) (1987) Comparative Tax Systems: Europe, Canada and Japan (Arlington, VA: Tax Analysts).
52.
PechmanJ.OknerB. (1974) Who bears the tax burden? (Washington, DC: Brookings Institute).
53.
PiersonP. (1993) ‘When effect becomes cause: Policy feedback and political change’, World Politics, 45:4, 595–628.
54.
PorterM. E. (1990) The Competitive Advantage of Nations (New York: The Free Press).
55.
RodriguezE. (1980) Offentlig inkomstexpansion: En analys av drivkrafterna bakom de offentliga inkomsternas utveckling i Sverige under 1900-talet (Public revenue growth: an analysis of the forces behind the expansion of public revenues in Sweden in the 1900s) (Uppsala: CWK Gleerup).
56.
RothsteinB.SteinmoS. (2002) ‘Restructuring politics: Institutional analysis and the challenges of modern welfare states’, in RothsteinB.SteinmoS. (eds), Restructuring the Welfare State: Political institutions and policy change (New York: Palgrave), 1–19.
57.
SabineB. E. V. (1966) A history of income tax (London: George Allen and Unwin).
58.
SandfordC. (1993) Successful Tax Reform: Lessons from an Analysis of Tax Reform in Six Countries (Bath: Fiscal Publications).
59.
ShirrasG. F.RostasL. (1942) The Burden of British Taxation (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press).
60.
SlemrodJ. (1995) ‘Professional Opinions About Tax Policy: 1994 and 1934’, National Tax Journal, 48:1, 121–147.
61.
SnowdenP. (1934) An autobiography (London: Nicholson and Watson).
62.
SOU (1936a) 1936 utredningar rorande det samlade skattetryket: Sverige och utlandet. Av inom finansdepartementet tillkallade sakkuniga (1936 commission concerning the total tax burden: Sweden and foreign lands. With the assistance of Finance department's experts) (Stockholm: SOU).
63.
SOU (1936b) Det Samlade Skattetrycket (The total tax burden) (Stockholm: SOU).
64.
SteinH. (1969) The fiscal revolution in America (Chicago: University of Chicago Press).
65.
SteinmoS. (1986) ‘So what's wrong with tax expenditures: a re-evaluation based on Swedish experience’, Journal of Public Budgeting and Finance, 6:2, 27–44.
66.
SteinmoS. (1993) Taxation and democracy: Swedish, British and American approaches to financing the modern state (New Haven: Yale University Press).
67.
StockmanD. (1986) ‘The triumph of politics’, Newsweek, 44, 50.
68.
StracheyJ. (1933) The coming struggle for power (New York: Covici-Friede Publishers).
69.
SurreyS. (1973) Pathways to tax reform (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press).
70.
SvallforsS. (1997) ‘Worlds of welfare and attitudes to redistribution: a comparison of eight western nations’, European Journal of Sociology, 13:3, 283–304.
71.
SwankD.SteinmoS. (2002) ‘The new political economy of taxation in advanced capitalist democracies, American Journal of Political Science, 46:3, 642–655.
72.
TanziV. (1969) The individual income tax and economic growth: an international comparison (Baltimore: John Hopkins Press).
73.
TanziV. (1987) ‘The Response of Other Industrial Countries to the U.S. Tax Reform Act’, National Tax Journal, 40:3, 339–355.
74.
TanziV. (1995) Taxation in an integrating world (Washington, DC: Brookings Institution).
75.
ThelenK.SteinmoS. (1992) ‘Historical institutionalism in comparative politics’, in SteinmoS.ThelenK.LongstrethF. (eds), Historical institutionalism in comparative politics: State, society, and economy (New York: Cambridge University Press).
76.
WaltmanJ. (1985) Political origins of the U.S. income tax (Jackson, Miss: University of Mississippi Press).
77.
WaltonV. (1928) Income tax, super-tax and sur-tax (London: Sir Isaac Pitman and Sons).
78.
WardH. (1997) ‘The possibility of an evolutionary explanation of the state's role in modes of regulation’, in StaynerJ.StokerG. (eds), Contemporary Political Studies (Nottingham: Political Studies Association).
79.
WeberC.WildavskyA. (1986) A History of Taxation and Expenditure in the Western World (New York: Simon and Schuster).
80.
WilliamsD. (1991) Trends in International Taxation (London: International Fiscal Association).
81.
WitteJ. (1983) ‘The distribution of federal tax expenditures’, Policy Studies Journal, 12:2, 131–146.
82.
WitteJ. (1985) The politics and development of the federal income tax (Madison: University of Wisconsin Press).
83.
YerginD.StanislawJ. (1998) The Commanding Heights (New York: Touchstone).
84.
YoungH. P. (1998) Individual strategy and social structure: an evolutionary theory of institutions (Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press).
