This paper addresses how New York City's workfare program has structured opportunities for collective action by welfare recipients. As workfare blurs the distinction between wage workers and welfare recipients, it calls into question accepted understandings of the rights and obligations of welfare recipients and fosters new claims on the state. The concept of “cultural opportunity structures” can help to explain the political mobilization of workfare participants if it is linked to a Durkheimian tradition of cultural analysis attentive to symbolic classification. The dramaturgic approach to culture exemplified in the work of Erving Goffman can usefully complement this structural approach if a narrow focus on frames and framing processes is broadened to include interaction rituals and ceremonial profanation.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AbramovitzMimi1996. Under Attack, Fighting Back: Women and Welfare in the United States.New York: Monthly Review Press.
2.
ACORN.1997a. “ACORN Workfare Organizing Project Update: September 1997.” Unpublished report.
3.
ACORN.1997b. “WEP Workers Organizing Committee, New York ACORN: YE/YB Report 1997.” Unpublished report.
The ACORN Report.1997. Newsletter from the National Office of the Association of Community Organizations for Reform Now (November).
7.
AlexanderJeffrey C.1988a. “Action and Its Environments.’ Chapter 10 in Action and Its Environments.New York: Columbia University Press.
8.
AlexanderJeffrey C.1988b. “Culture and Political Crisis: ‘Watergate’ and Durkheimian Sociology.’ Chapter 8 in Durkheimian Sociology: Cultural Studies.Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
9.
AlexanderJeffrey C.1988c. “Three Models of Culture and Society Relations: Toward an Analysis of Watergate.” In Action and Its Environments.New York: Columbia University Press.
10.
AlexanderJeffrey C.1989. “Durkheimian Sociology and Cultural Studies Today.’ Chapter 5 in Structure and Meaning.New York: Columbia University Press.
11.
AlexanderJeffrey C.1992. “Citizen and Enemy as Symbolic Classification: On the Polarizing Discourse of Civil Society.’ Chapter 12 in Cultivating Differences: Symbolic Boundaries and the Making of Inequality, edited by LamontMichèleFournierMarcel. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
12.
AlexanderJeffrey C.1995. “The Reality of Reduction: The Failed Synthesis of Pierre Bourdieu.’ Chapter 4 in Fin de Siècle Social Theory: Relativism, Reduction, and the Problem of Reason, edited by AlexanderJeffrey C.. New York: Verso.
13.
AlexanderJeffrey C.SmithPhilip1993. “The Discourse of American Civil Society: A New Proposal for Cultural Studies.”, Theory and Society22:151–207.
14.
BourdieuPierre1994. “Rethinking the State: Genesis and Structure of the Bureaucratic Field.”, Sociological Theory12:1–18.
15.
BourdieuPierreBoltanskiLuc1981. “The Educational System and the Economy: Titles and Jobs.” Pp. 141–51 in French Sociology: Rupture and Renewal since 1968, edited by LemertC. C.. New York: Columbia University Press.
16.
BriarScott1966. “Welfare from Below: Recipients’ Views of the Welfare System.” In The Law of the Poor, edited by TenBroek Jacobus. San Francisco: Chandler.
17.
City of New York 1990. Mayor's Management Report (September).New York: City of New York.
18.
City of New York 1991. Mayor's Management Report (September).New York: City of New York.
19.
City of New York 1992. Mayor's Management Report (September).New York: City of New York.
20.
City of New York 1993. Mayor's Management Report (September).New York: City of New York.
21.
City of New York 1994. Mayor's Management Report (September).New York: City of New York.
22.
City of New York 1995. Mayor's Management Report (September).New York: City of New York.
23.
City of New York 1996. Mayor's Management Report (February).New York: City of New York.
24.
City of New York 1997. Mayor's Management Report (September).New York: City of New York.
25.
City of New York 1998. Mayor's Management Report (Preliminary).New York: City of New York.
26.
CollinsRandall1988. “The Durkheimian Tradition in Conflict Sociology.’ Chapter 5 in Durkheimian Sociology: Cultural Studies, edited by AlexanderJeffrey C.. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
27.
DeParleJason1997. “White House Calls for Minimum Wage in Workfare Plan.”New York Times, May 16, p. A1.
28.
DouglasMary1966. Purity and Danger: An Analysis of the Concepts of Pollution and Taboo.New York: Routledge.
29.
DriverFelix1993. Power and Pauperism: The Workhouse System, 1834–1884.New York: Cambridge University Press.
30.
DurkheimEmile [1893] 1984. The Division of Labor in Society. Translated by HallsW. D.. New York: Free Press.
31.
DurkheimEmile [1897] 1951. Suicide: A Study in Sociology. Translated by SpauldingJohn A.SimpsonGeorgeSimpsonGeorge. New York: Free Press.
32.
DurkheimEmile [1912] 1915. The Elementary Forms of the Religious Life. Translated by SwainJoseph Ward. New York: Free Press.
EmirbayerMustafaGoodwinJeff1996. “Symbols, Positions, Objects: Toward a New Theory of Revolutions and Collective Action.”, History and Theory35:358–74.
35.
Esping-AndersenGøsta1990. The Three Worlds of Welfare Capitalism. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
FinderAlan1998a. “Evidence Is Scant That Workfare Leads to Full-Time Jobs.”New York Times, April 12, p. A1.
38.
FinderAlan1998b. “Court Backs Giuliani's Way of Assigning Workfare Hours.”New York Times, September 19, p. B3.
39.
FirestoneDavid1996a. “New York Girding for Surge in Workfare Jobs.”New York Times, August 13, p. A1.
40.
FirestoneDavid1996b. “Labor Leader Drops Demand on Workfare.”New York Times, September 28, p. 25.
41.
FirestoneDavid1997. “Workfare Put in Question for 5,000.”New York Times, August 19, p. B1.
42.
FoucaultMichel1977. Discipline and Punish. Translated by SheridanAlan. New York: Vintage.
43.
FoucaultMichel1978. The History of Sexuality. Vol. 1: An Introduction. Translated by HurleyRobert. New York: Pantheon Books.
44.
FraserNancy1989. Unruly Practices: Power, Discourse, and Gender in Contemporary Social Theory. Minneapolis, MN: University of Minnesota Press.
45.
FraserNancyGordonLinda1994. “A Genealogy of Dependency: Tracing a Keyword of the U.S. Welfare State.”, Signs: Journal of Women in Culture and Society19:309–36.
46.
FuentesAnnette1996. “Slaves of New York.”In These Times, December 23, pp. 14–17.
47.
GamsonWilliam A.1985. “Goffman's Legacy to Political Sociology.”, Theory and Society14:605–22.
48.
GamsonWilliam A.1992. Talking Politics. New York: Cambridge University Press.
49.
GamsonWilliam A.MeyerDavid S.1996. “Framing Political Opportunity.’ Chapter 12 in Comparative Perspectives on Social Movements, edited by McAdamDougMcCarthyJohn D.ZaldMayer N.. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
50.
GarfinkelHarold1956. “Conditions of Successful Degradation Ceremonies.”, American Journal of Sociology61:420–24.
51.
GiddensAnthony1984. The Constitution of Society. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
52.
GiddensAnthony1990. The Consequences of Modernity. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.
53.
GiulianiRudolph W.1995. State of the City Address. New York City Council Chamber, January 11.
54.
GiulianiRudolph W.1996a. State of the City Address. New York City Council Chamber, January 11.
55.
GiulianiRudolph W.1996b. “Mayor Giuliani Praises Achievement of Work Experience Program Participants; Commends DC 37 Local 372 for Their Support of Workfare Initiative.”Press Release, December 14.
56.
GiulianiRudolph W.1997. “The Entrepreneurial City.”Speech at the Manhattan Institute, New York City, December 3.
57.
GoffmanErving1961. Asylums: Essays on the Social Situation of Mental Patients and Other Inmates. Chicago, IL: Aldine.
58.
GoffmanErving1963. Stigma: Notes on the Management of Spoiled Identity. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall.
59.
GoffmanErving1967. Interaction Ritual: Essays in Face-to-Face Behavior. Chicago, IL: Aldine.
60.
GonnermanJennifer1997. “Workfare's Casualties.”Village Voice, June 8, p. 48.
61.
GonzalezJuan1997. “Read These Ballots and WEP.”Daily News, October 21, n.p.
62.
GoodbanNancy1985. “The Psychological Impact of Being on Welfare.”Social Service Review59.
63.
GoodwinJeff1997. “The Libidinal Constitution of a High-Risk Social Movement: Affectual Ties and Solidarity in the Huk Rebellion.”, American Sociological Review62:53–69.
64.
GordonLinda1988. “What Does Welfare Regulate?”, Social Research55:609–30.
65.
GreenMark1997. “From Welfare to Work: Getting Lost along the Way.” Report by the Office of the Public Advocate for the City of New York (July).
66.
GreenhouseSteven1996a. “New York Union Leader Urges Halt to Broadening Workfare.”New York Times, September 23, p. A1.
67.
GreenhouseSteven1996b. “Union Head Is Assailed on Workfare Concessions.”New York Times, October 1, p. B3.
68.
GreenhouseSteven1996c. “Union Forum Is New Tool to Air Woes of Workers.”New York Times, November 2, p. B1.
69.
GreenhouseSteven1997a. “Labor Leaders Seek to Unionize Welfare Recipients Who Must Go to Work.”New York Times, February 19, p. A18.
70.
GreenhouseSteven1997b. “Nonprofit and Religious Groups Vow to Fight Workfare Program.”New York Times, July 24, p. A1.
71.
GreenhouseSteven1997c. “Two Well-Known Churches Say No to Workfare Jobs.”New York Times, August 4, p. B3.
72.
GreenhouseSteven1997d. “Compromise with Unions on Workfare.”New York Times, August 8, p. B2.
73.
GreenhouseSteven1998. “Many Participants in Workfare Take the Place of City Workers.”New York Times, April 13, p. A1.
74.
HandlerJoel F.HollingsworthEllen Jane1969. “The Administration of Social Services and the Structure of Dependency: The Views of AFDC Recipients.”, Social Service Review43:406–20.
75.
HasenfeldYeheskelRaffertyJane A.ZaldMayer N.1987. “The Welfare State, Citizenship, and Bureaucratic Encounters.”, Annual Review of Sociology13:387–415.
76.
HaysSharon1994. “Structure and Agency and the Sticky Problem of Culture.”, Sociological Theory12:57–72.
77.
HegelGeorg Wilhelm Friedrich1977. Phenomenology of Spirit. Translated by MillerA. V.. Oxford, England: Clarendon Press.
78.
KaneAnne1991. “Cultural Analysis in Historical Sociology: The Analytic and Concrete Forms of the Autonomy of Culture.”, Sociological Theory9:53–69.
79.
KatzMichael B.1986. In the Shadow of the Poorhouse: A Social History of Welfare in America. New York: Basic Books.
80.
KatzMichael B.1989. The Undeserving Poor: From the War on Poverty to the War on Welfare. New York: Pantheon Books.
81.
KaufmanLeslie1997. “Welfare's Labor Pains.”Newsweek, March 31, p. 39.
82.
KennedyRandy1996. “Workfare Screening of Homeless Starts, Then Stops.”New York Times, August 21, p. B1.
83.
KrinskyJohn DavidReeseEllen N.d. “Class Acts: Political Economy and the Structuring of Workfare/Welfare Rights Activism 1995–2000.” Unpublished manuscript.
84.
LukesSteven1977. “Political Ritual and Social Integration.’ Chapter 3 in Essays in Social Theory. New York: Columbia University Press.
85.
MarshallT. H.1963. Class, Citizenship, and Social Development. Westport, CT: Greenwood Press.
86.
McAdamDoug1982. Political Process and the Development of Black Insurgency 1930–1970. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
87.
McAdamDoug1994. “Culture and Social Movements.’ Chapter 2 in New Social Movements: From Ideology to Identity, edited by LaranaEnriqueJohnstonHankGusfieldJoseph R.. Philadelphia, PA: Temple University Press.
88.
McAdamDoug1996a. Conceptual Origins, Current Problems, Future Directions.’ Chapter 1 in Comparative Perspectives on Social Movements, edited by McAdamDougMcCarthyJohn D.ZaldMayer N.. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
89.
McAdamDoug1996b. “The Framing Function of Movement Tactics: Strategic Dramaturgy in the American Civil Rights Movement.’ Chapter 15 in Comparative Perspectives on Social Movements, edited by McAdamDougMcCarthyJohn D.ZaldMayer N.. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
90.
McAdamDougMcCarthyJohn D.ZaldMayer N., eds. 1996. Comparative Perspectives on Social Movements. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
91.
MeadLawrence M.1986. Beyond Entitlement: The Social Obligations of Citizenship. New York: Free Press.
92.
MeadLawrence M.1992. The New Politics of Poverty: The Nonworking Poor in America. New York: Basic Books.
93.
MinkGwendolyn1998. Welfare's End. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
94.
MohrJohn W.1994. “Soldiers, Mothers, Tramps, and Others: Discourse Roles in the 1907 New York City Charity Directory.”, Poetics22:327–57.
95.
National Governors'Association, National Conference of State Legislatures, and American Public Welfare Association.1997. “Analysis of the Personal Responsibility and Work Opportunity Reconciliation Act of 1996.”http://www.crisny.org/not-for-profit/unions/h3734.htm. This page last updated: May 19, 1997.
96.
New York City Council Committee on General Welfare (CGW).1998. The Transcript of the Minutes of the Committee on General Welfare. Transcript of committee hearing held October 20. City Hall Council Chambers, New York City.
97.
New York City Council Committee on General Welfare and Committee on Higher Education (CGW/CHE).1998. The Transcript of the Minutes of the Committee on General Welfare (Held Jointly with) Committee on Higher Education. Transcript of joint committee hearing held October 14. City Hall Council Chambers, New York City.
98.
New York City Council Committee on Governmental Operations (CGO).1998. The Transcript of the Minutes of the Committee on Governmental Operations. Transcript of committee hearing held August 5. City Hall Council Chambers, New York City.
99.
New York State Department of Social Services.1995. Statistical Supplement to the Annual Report. Albany, NY: State of New York.
100.
New York Times.1997. “Don't Unionize Workfare.” Editorial, February 21, p. A34.
101.
OrloffAnn1993. “Gender and the Social Rights of Citizenship: The Comparative Analysis of Gender Relations and Welfare States.”, American Sociological Review58:303–28.
102.
BanduraAlbert1996. “Gender in the Welfare State.”, Annual Review of Sociology22:51–78.
103.
Perez-PenaRichard1996a. “Transit Union Agrees to Allow Workfare Plan.”New York Times, September 19, p. A1.
104.
Perez-PenaRichard1996b. “A Union Chief Whose Life Led to His Workfare Deal.”New York Times, September 20, p. A1.
105.
Perez-PenaRichard1996c. “Objections aside, Transit Officials Predict Mayoral Support on Workfare.”New York Times, September 21, p. 23.
106.
Perez-PenaRichard1996d. “Transit Union Dissidents Feel Pressure.”New York Times, October 15, p. B3.
107.
Perez-PenaRichard1996e. “Transit Pact Is Approved by Workers.”New York Times, October 23, p. B1.
108.
PiersonPaul1994. Dismantling the Welfare State?New York: Cambridge University Press.
109.
PivenFrances Fox1981. “Deviant Behavior and the Remaking of the World.”, Social Problems28:489–508.
110.
PivenFrances FoxClowardRichard A. [1971] 1993. Regulating the Poor: The Functions of Public Welfare, rev. ed.New York: Vintage Books.
111.
PivenFrances FoxClowardRichard A.1977. Poor People's Movements: Why They Succeed, How They Fail.New York: Vintage Books.
112.
PivenFrances FoxClowardRichard A. [1982] 1985. The New Class War: Reagan's Attack on the Welfare State and Its Consequences.New York: Pantheon Books.
113.
PivenFrances FoxClowardRichard A.1988. “Welfare Doesn't Shore up Traditional Family Roles: A Reply to Linda Gordon.”, Social Research55:631–47.
114.
PopkinSusan1990. “Welfare: Views from the Bottom.”, Social Problems37(February).
115.
RamirezMargaret1997. “United Stance: Workfare Employees Vote Overwhelmingly to Unionize.”Newsday, October 24, n.p.
116.
ReeseEllenNewcombeGarnett N.d. “From Welfare Rights to Workers’ Rights: The Transformation of Welfare Rights Activism in the United States.” Unpublished manuscript.
117.
SchramSanford F.1993. “Postmodern Policy Analysis: Discourse and Identity in Welfare Policy.”, Policy Sciences26:249–70.
118.
SchramSanford F.1995. Words of Welfare: The Poverty of Social Science and the Social Science of Poverty.Minneapolis, MN: University of Minnesota Press.
119.
SchwartzMichael1976. Radical Protest and Social Structure.New York: Academic Press.
120.
SextonJoe1996. “Discontented Workfare Laborers Murmur ‘Union.’”New York Times, September 27, p. B1.
121.
SextonJoe1997. “Woman's Death Prompts Concerns over Workfare.”New York Times, June 24, p. B3.
122.
SkocpolTheda1980. “Political Response to Capitalist Crisis: Neo-Marxist Theories of the State and the Case of the New Deal.”Politics and Society10:155–201.
123.
SnowDavid A.RochfordBurke E.Jr.WordenStephen K.BenfordRobert D.1986. “Frame Alignment Processes, Micromobilization, and Movement Participation.”, American Sociological Review51:464–81.
124.
StackCarol B.1974. All Our Kin: Strategies for Survival in a Black Community.New York: Harper and Row.
125.
StoltzfusEmilie N.d. “We Are Contributors to Our Society: Productive Citizenship and the Post-World-War-II Call for Child Care as a Social Wage in California.” Unpublished manuscript.
126.
StoltzfusEmilie1999. “Citizen, Mother, Worker: Public Provision of Child Care, 1945–1965.” Ph.D. dissertation, Claremont Graduate University.
127.
TarrowSidney1994. Power in Movement: Social Movements, Collective Action, and Politics.New York: Cambridge University Press.
128.
TillyCharles1997. “Means and Ends of Comparison in Macrosociology”, Comparative Social Research16:47–57.
129.
TurnerVictor W.1969. The Ritual Process: Structure and Anti-Structure.Chicago, IL: Aldine.
130.
United States of ACORN1997a. Bimonthly publication of ACORN. Vol. 16, no. 2 (March/April).
Workers’ Rights Board (WRB).1997. Videotape of the Workers’ Rights Board hearing on workfare held March 11 at the Legislative Office Building in Albany, New York. The videotape was provided by Mr. Dominic Chan, the board's executive director, and transcribed by the author.
133.
WrightE. Assata1997. “Divided They Fall?”Village Voice, January 28, p. 21.
