Allergic contact dermatitis (ACD) may occur secondary to topical antifungals containing potential allergens in their vehicles. Variation of allergenic ingredients among commonly used antifungal creams (AFCs) has not been well characterized.
Objective
The study goal was to assess the frequency of allergenic ingredients in 4 commonly used topical AFCs.
Methods
Topical AFCs (clotrimazole, ketoconazole, miconazole, and terbinafine) were selected, and the ingredient lists for these products were obtained from the US Food and Drug Administration's Online Label Repository via a proprietary name search. A systematic literature review was performed using the ingredient name on MEDLINE (PubMed) database to identify reports of ACD confirmed by patch testing.
Results
Of the 20 ingredients analyzed, 6 had frequent allergenic potential. Propylene glycol was the most common cause of ACD identified in the literature and is an ingredient in ketoconazole 2% and miconazole nitrate 2%. Ketoconazole 2% and miconazole nitrate 2% creams contained the highest number of potential allergens (n = 3) among the 4 creams analyzed.
Conclusions
Of the 4 creams, terbinafine hydrochloride 1% and clotrimazole 1% contained the least number of potential allergenic ingredients. Awareness of the allergenic potential of commonly used AFCs may help health care providers when evaluating patients with ACD.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
GuptaAK, EinarsonTR, SummerbellRC, et al.An overview of topical antifungal therapy in dermatomycoses. A North American perspective. Drugs, 1998; 55(5):645–674.
2.
CrawfordF, HollisS. Topical treatments for fungal infections of the skin and nails of the foot. Cochrane Database Syst Rev, 2007; 3:CD001434.
3.
LiebelF, LyteP, GarayM, et al.Anti-inflammatory and anti-itch activity of sertaconazole nitrate. Arch Dermatol Res, 2006; 298(4):191–199.
4.
GilissenL, GoossensA. Frequency and trends of contact allergy to and iatrogenic contact dermatitis caused by topical drugs over a 25-year period. Contact Dermatitis, 2016; 75(5):290–302.
5.
GoossensRA. Allergic contact dermatitis from the vehicle components of topical pharmaceutical products. Immunol Allergy Clin North Am, 2014; 34(3):663–670, ix-x.
6.
del SavioB, SherertzEF. Is allergic contact dermatitis being overlooked?. Arch Fam Med, 1994; 3(6):537–543.
7.
ThyssenJP, LinnebergA, MenneT, et al.The epidemiology of contact allergy in the general population—prevalence and main findings. Contact Dermatitis, 2007; 57(5):287–299.
8.
FyhrquistN, LehtoE, LauermaA. New findings in allergic contact dermatitis. Curr Opin Allergy Clin Immunol, 2014; 14(5):430–435.
9.
MortzCG, AndersenKE. New aspects in allergic contact dermatitis. Curr Opin Allergy Clin Immunol, 2008; 8(5):428–432.
10.
SchnuchA, LessmannH, GeierJ, et al.Contact allergy to preservatives. Analysis of IVDK data 1996–2009. Br J Dermatol, 2011; 164(6):1316–1325.
11.
WarshawEM, MaibachHI, TaylorJS, et al.North American Contact Dermatitis Group patch test results: 2011–2012. Dermatitis, 2015; 26(1):49–59.
12.
WarshawEM, BelsitoDV, TaylorJS, et al.North American Contact Dermatitis Group patch test results: 2009 to 2010. Dermatitis, 2013; 24(2):50–59.
13.
FranswayAF, ZugKA, BelsitoDV, et al.North American Contact Dermatitis Group patch test results for 2007–2008. Dermatitis, 2013; 24(1):10–21.
14.
GoossensA, ClaesL, DriegheJ, et al.Antimicrobials: preservatives, antiseptics and disinfectants. Contact Dermatitis, 1998; 39(3):133–134.
15.
CurryEJ, WarshawEM. Benzyl alcohol allergy: importance of patch testing with personal products. Dermatitis, 2005; 16(4):203–208.
16.
Erfurt-BergeC, GeierJ, MahlerV. The current spectrum of contact sensitization in patients with chronic leg ulcers or stasis dermatitis—new data from the Information Network of Departments of Dermatology (IVDK). Contact Dermatitis, 2017; 77(3):151–158.
17.
TostiA, BardazziF, ValeriF, et al.Contact dermatitis from butylated hydroxyanisole. Contact Dermatitis, 1987; 17(4):257–258.
18.
TurnerTW. Dermatitis from butylated hydroxy anisole. Contact Dermatitis, 1977; 3(5):282.
19.
WhiteIR, LovellCR, CroninE. Antioxidants in cosmetics. Contact Dermatitis, 1984; 11(5):265–267.
MenenghiniCL, RantuccioF, LomutoM. Additives, vehicles and active drugs of topical medicaments as causes of delayed-type allergic dermatitis. Dermatologica, 1971; 143(3):137–147.
22.
AertsO, NaessensT, DandelooyJ, et al.Allergic contact dermatitis caused by wet wipes containing steareth-10: is stearyl alcohol to blame?. Contact Dermatitis, 2017; 77(2):117–119.
WilsonCL, CameronJ, PowellSM, et al.High incidence of contact dermatitis in leg-ulcer patients—implications for management. Clin Exp Dermatol, 1991; 16(4):250–253.
OisoN, FukaiK, IshiiM. Concomitant allergic reaction to cetyl alcohol and crotamiton. Contact Dermatitis, 2003; 49(5):261.
27.
Vanden BroeckeK, ZimersonE, BruzeM, et al.Severe allergic contact dermatitis caused by a rubber glove coated with a moisturizer. Contact Dermatitis, 2014; 71(2):117–119.
SogaF, KatohN, KishimotoS. Contact dermatitis due to lanoconazole, cetyl alcohol and diethyl sebacate in lanoconazole cream. Contact Dermatitis, 2004; 50(1):49–50.
30.
RodríguezE, ValbuenaMC, ReyM, et al.Causal agents of photoallergic contact dermatitis diagnosed in the National Institute of Dermatology of Colombia. Photodermatol Photoimmunol Photomed, 2006; 22(4):189–192.
31.
Kiec-SwierczynskaM, KreciszB, Swierczynska-MachuraD. Photoallergic and allergic reaction to 2-hydroxy-4-methoxybenzophenone (sunscreen) and allergy to cetyl alcohol in cosmetic cream. Contact Dermatitis, 2005; 53(3):170–171.
32.
KnijpJ, BruynzeelDP, RustemeyerT. Diagnosing lanolin contact allergy with lanolin alcohol and Amerchol L101. Contact Dermatitis, 2019; 80(5):298–303.
33.
KomamuraH, DoiT, InuiS, et al.A case of contact dermatitis due to impurities of cetyl alcohol. Contact Dermatitis, 1997; 36(1):44–46.
BurryJN. The value of patch testing: a review of 363 cases of allergic contact dermatitis. Med J Aust, 1969; 1(24):1226–1231.
43.
AndersenKE, HamannK. How sensitizing is chlorocresol? Allergy tests in guinea pigs versus the clinical experience. Contact Dermatitis, 1984; 11(1):11–20.
44.
BrittonJE, WilkinsonSM, EnglishJS, et al.The British Standard Series of contact dermatitis allergens: validation in clinical practice and value for clinical governance. Br J Dermatol, 2003; 148(2):259–264.
45.
Gomez de la FuenteE, Andreu-BarasoainM, Nuno-GonzalezA, et al.Allergic contact dermatitis due to chlorocresol in topical corticosteroids. Actas Dermosifiliogr, 2013; 104(1):90–92.
46.
Dooms-GoossensA, DegreefH, VanheeJ, et al.Chlorocresol and chloracetamide: allergens in medications, glues, and cosmetics. Contact Dermatitis, 1981; 7(1):51–52.
47.
AdaS, SeckinD. Patch testing in allergic contact dermatitis: is it useful to perform the cosmetic series in addition to the European standard series?. J Eur Acad Dermatol Venereol, 2010; 24(10):1192–1196.
48.
TongPL, ChowET. Isopropyl myristate contact allergy: could your moisturizer be the culprit?. Contact Dermatitis, 2017; 77(3):184–185.
49.
UterW, SchnuchA, GeierJ, et al.Isopropyl myristate recommended for aimed rather than routine patch testing. Contact Dermatitis, 2004; 50(4):242–244.
50.
BharatiA, KingCM. Allergic contact dermatitis from isohexadecane and isopropyl myristate. Contact Dermatitis, 2004; 50(4):256–257.
51.
SakakibaraS, KawabeY, MizunoN. Photoallergic contact dermatitis due to mineral oil. Contact Dermatitis, 1989; 20(4):291–294.
52.
Gimenez-ArnauA, GilaberteM, CondeD, et al.Combined photocontact dermatitis to benzydamine hydrochloride and the emulsifiers, Span 60 and Tween 60 contained in Tantum cream. Contact Dermatitis, 2007; 57(1):61–62.
53.
MaibachH, ConantM. Contact urticaria to a corticosteroid cream: polysorbate 60. Contact Dermatitis, 1977; 3(6):350–351.
54.
Pasche-KooF, PilettaPA, HunzikerN, et al.High sensitization rate to emulsifiers in patients with chronic leg ulcers. Contact Dermatitis, 1994; 31(4):226–228.
55.
LucenteP, IorizzoM, PazzagliaM. Contact sensitivity to Tween 80 in a child. Contact Dermatitis, 2000; 43(3):172.
IsakssonM, JanssonL. Contact allergy to Tween 80 in an inhalation suspension. Contact Dermatitis, 2002; 47(5):312–313.
58.
GrimsRH, KrankeB, AbererW. Pitfalls in drug allergy skin testing: false-positive reactions due to (hidden) additives. Contact Dermatitis, 2006; 54(5):290–294.
CoorsEA, SeyboldH, MerkHF, et al.Polysorbate 80 in medical products and nonimmunologic anaphylactoid reactions. Ann Allergy Asthma Immunol, 2005; 95(6):593–599.
61.
SchwartzbergLS, NavariRM. Safety of polysorbate 80 in the oncology setting. Adv Ther, 2018; 35(6):754–767.
62.
McGowanMA, SchemanA, JacobSE. Propylene glycol in contact dermatitis: a systematic review. Dermatitis, 2018; 29(1):6–12.
DeKovenJG, WarshawEM, ZugKA, et al.North American Contact Dermatitis Group patch test results: 2015–2016. Dermatitis, 2018; 29(6):297–309.
65.
BlackH. Contact dermatitis from stearyl alcohol in Metosyn (fluocinonide) cream. Contact Dermatitis, 1975; 1(2):125.
66.
YesudianPD, KingCM. Allergic contact dermatitis from stearyl alcohol in Efudix cream. Contact Dermatitis, 2001; 45(5):313–314.
67.
ShoreRN, ShelleyWB. Contact dermatitis from stearyl alcohol and propylene glycol in fluocinonide cream. Arch Dermatol, 1974; 109(3):397–399.
68.
de BerkerD, MarrenP, PowellSM, et al.Contact sensitivity to the stearyl alcohol in Efudix cream (5-fluorouracil). Contact Dermatitis, 1992; 26(2):138.
69.
von der WerthJM, EnglishJS, DalzielKL. Loss of patch test positivity to cetylstearyl alcohol. Contact Dermatitis, 1998; 38(2):109–110.
70.
ThormannH, KollanderM, AndersenKE. Allergic contact dermatitis from dichlorobenzyl alcohol in a patient with multiple contact allergies. Contact Dermatitis, 2009; 60(5):295–296.
71.
Dooms-GoossensA, DegreefH. Contact allergy to petrolatums. (I). Sensitizing capacity of different brands of yellow and white petrolatums. Contact Dermatitis, 1983; 9(3):175–185.
72.
KangH, ChoiJ, LeeAY. Allergic contact dermatitis to white petrolatum. J Dermatol, 2004; 31(5):428–430.
73.
KunduRV, SchemanAJ, GutmanovichA, et al.Contact dermatitis to white petrolatum. Skinmed, 2004; 3(5):295–296.
FisherAA. Allergic paraben and benzyl alcohol hypersensitivity relationship of the “delayed” and “immediate” varieties. Contact Dermatitis, 1975; 1(5):281–284.
91.
LiuJ, WarshawEM. Allergic contact dermatitis from ketoconazole. Cutis, 2014; 94(3):112–114.
92.
LazzariniR, HafnerMFS, MiguelBAF, et al.Allergic contact dermatitis caused by topical ketoconazole: a relevant issue? Review of ketoconazole-positive patch tests. Contact Dermatitis, 2018; 78(3):234–236.
93.
Dooms-GoossensA, MaturaM, DriegheJ, et al.Contact allergy to imidazoles used as antimycotic agents. Contact Dermatitis, 1995; 33(2):73–77.
94.
SchemanA, SeversonD. American Contact Dermatitis Society Contact Allergy Management Program: an epidemiologic tool to quantify ingredient usage. Dermatitis, 2016; 27(1):11–13.
