Entomological surveillance indices are used to estimate the risk of West Nile virus (WNV; family Flaviviridae, genus Flavivirus) transmission. To determine when and where to initiate mosquito control activities, integrated vector management programs establish action thresholds based on entomological surveillance indices. However, the application of entomological surveillance indices needs further investigation relative to the human risk of WNV infection. Herein, we examine the evidence from studies that investigated the quantitative relationship between entomological surveillance indices and human WNV cases using systematic review methods.
Results:
Across three databases, 5378 articles were identified. Using the selection criteria, 38 studies were included for study. Most articles explored entomological indices weekly and devised unique geographic scales to aggregate human and/or mosquito data. The most used models were logistic and negative binomial regression. Maximum likelihood estimates (MLEs) and vector index (VI) demonstrated the greatest ratio of number of positive results to number of times tested. Among all selected articles, 35 unique U.S. locations assessed MLE and/or VI. Human WNV infection had a significant association with MLE across 81.25% (13/16) of locations. VI showed successful performance across 80.00% (24/30) sites tested.
Conclusions:
This systematic review identifies methods for quantifying relationships between entomological and human WNV infection data. We found entomological surveillance indices applied to human WNV risk should include a measure of virus presence, such as MLE and VI. Model type and covariates were too variable to identify geographic or species-specific trends, though, when tested, including temperature, land cover, population density, and time improved the model. This study is meant to be informative and designed to assist public health agencies in seasonal WNV preparations but are not meant to be a panacea for all WNV surveillance challenges.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AndreadisTG, AndersonJF, VossbrinckCR, et al.Epidemiology of West Nile virus in Connecticut: A five-year analysis of mosquito data 1999–2003. Vector Borne Zoonotic Dis, 2004; 4(4):360–378; doi: 10.1089/vbz.2004.4.360
BollingBG, BarkerCM, MooreCG, et al.Seasonal patterns for entomological measures of risk for exposure to Culex vectors and West Nile virus in relation to human disease cases in Northeastern Colorado. J Med Entomol, 2009; 46(6):1519–1531; doi: 10.1603/033.046.0641
4.
BrownsteinJS, HolfordTR, FishD. Enhancing West Nile virus surveillance, United States. Emerg Infect Dis, 2004; 10(6):1129–1133; doi: 10.3201/eid1006.030457
5.
CDC. Mosquito Surveillance Software. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. 2024.
6.
ChakrabortyS, SmithRL. Error associated with estimates of minimum infection rate for endemic West Nile virus in areas of low mosquito trap density. Sci Rep, 2019; 9(1):19093; doi: 10.1038/s41598-019-55632-7
7.
ChungWM, BusemanCM, JoynerSN, et al.The 2012 West Nile encephalitis epidemic in Dallas, Texas. JAMA, 2013; 310(3):297–307; doi: 10.1001/jama.2013.8267
8.
ColbornJM, SmithKA, TownsendJ, et al.West Nile virus outbreak in Phoenix, Arizona—2010: Entomological observations and epidemiological correlations. J Am Mosq Control Assoc, 2013; 29(2):123–132; doi: 10.2987/13-6326r.1
9.
DanforthME, SnyderRE, LonstrupETN, et al.Evaluation of the effectiveness of the California mosquito-borne virus surveillance & response plan, 2009–2018. Rasgon JL. ed. PLoS Negl Trop Dis, 2022; 16(5):e0010375; doi: 10.1371/journal.pntd.0010375
10.
DavisJK, VincentG, HildrethMB, et al.Integrating environmental monitoring and mosquito surveillance to predict vector-borne disease: Prospective forecasts of a West Nile virus outbreak. PLoS Curr, 2017; 9; doi: 10.1371/currents.outbreaks.90e80717c4e67e1a830f17feeaaf85de
11.
DavisJK, VincentGP, HildrethMB, et al.Improving the prediction of arbovirus outbreaks: A comparison of climate-driven models for West Nile virus in an endemic region of the United States. Acta Trop, 2018; 185:242–250; doi: 10.1016/j.actatropica.2018.04.028
12.
DeFeliceNB, BirgerR, DeFeliceN, et al.Modeling and surveillance of reporting delays of mosquitoes and humans infected with West Nile virus and associations with accuracy of West Nile virus forecasts. JAMA Netw Open, 2019; 2(4):e193175; doi: 10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2019.3175
13.
DeFeliceNB, LittleE, CampbellSR, et al.Ensemble forecast of human West Nile virus cases and mosquito infection rates. Nat Commun, 2017; 8(1):14592; doi: 10.1038/ncomms14592
14.
DeFeliceNB, SchneiderZD, LittleE, et al.Use of temperature to improve West Nile virus forecasts. Lessler J. ed. PLoS Comput Biol, 2018; 14(3):e1006047; doi: 10.1371/journal.pcbi.1006047
15.
DennettJA, BalaA, WuithiranyagoolT, et al.Associations between two mosquito populations and West Nile virus in Harris County, Texas, 2003–06. J Am Mosq Control Assoc, 2007; 23(3):264–275; doi: 10.2987/8756-971X(2007)23[264:ABTMPA]2.0.CO;2
16.
DunphyBM, KovachKB, GehrkeEJ, et al.Long-term surveillance defines spatial and temporal patterns implicating culex tarsalis as the primary vector of West Nile virus. Sci Rep, 2019; 9(1):6637; doi: 10.1038/s41598-019-43246-y
17.
FauverJR, PecherL, SchurichJA, et al.Temporal and spatial variability of entomological risk indices for West Nile virus infection in Northern Colorado: 2006–2013. J Med Entomol, 2016; 53(2):425–434; doi: 10.1093/jme/tjv234
18.
FranklinosLHV, JonesKE, ReddingDW, et al.The effect of global change on mosquito-borne disease. Lancet Infect Dis, 2019; 19(9):e302–e312; doi: 10.1016/S1473-3099(19)30161-6
19.
GhoshD, MansonSM, McMasterRB. Delineating West Nile virus transmission cycles at various scales: The nearest neighbor distance–time model. Cartogr Geogr Inf Sci, 2010; 37(2):149–163; doi: 10.1559/152304010791232208
20.
GuW, LampmanR, NovakRJ. Problems in estimating mosquito infection rates using minimum infection rate. J Med Entomol, 2003; 40(5):595–596; doi: 10.1603/0022-2585-40.5.595
21.
GuW, LampmanR, NovakRJ. Assessment of arbovirus vector infection rates using variable size pooling. Med Vet Entomol, 2004; 18(2):200–204; doi: 10.1111/j.0269-283X.2004.00482.x
22.
HamerGL, WalkerED, BrawnJD, et al.Rapid amplification of West Nile virus: The role of hatch-year birds. Vector Borne Zoonotic Dis, 2008; 8(1):57–67; doi: 10.1089/vbz.2007.0123
23.
HernandezE, TorresR, JoyceAL. Environmental and sociological factors associated with the incidence of West Nile virus cases in the Northern San Joaquin valley of California, 2011–2015. Vector Borne Zoonotic Dis, 2019; 19(11):851–858; doi: 10.1089/vbz.2019.2437
24.
HumphreysJM, YoungKI, CohnstaedtLW, et al.Vector surveillance, host species richness, and demographic factors as West Nile disease risk indicators. Viruses, 2021; 13(5):934; doi: 10.3390/v13050934
25.
KadingRC, CohnstaedtLW, FallK, et al.Emergence of arboviruses in the United States: The boom and bust of funding, innovation, and capacity. Trop Med Infect Dis, 2020; 5(2):96; doi: 10.3390/tropicalmed5020096
26.
KarkiS, BrownWM, UelmenJ, et al.The drivers of West Nile virus human illness in the Chicago, Illinois, USA area: Fine scale dynamic effects of weather, mosquito infection, social, and biological conditions. Papadopoulos NT. ed. PLoS One, 2020; 15(5):e0227160; doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0227160
27.
KarkiS, WestcottNE, MuturiEJ, et al.Assessing human risk of illness with West Nile virus mosquito surveillance data to improve public health preparedness. Zoonoses Public Health, 2018; 65(1):177–184; doi: 10.1111/zph.12386
28.
KeyelAC, Elison TimmO, BackensonPB, et al.Seasonal temperatures and hydrological conditions improve the prediction of West Nile virus infection rates in culex mosquitoes and human case counts in New York and Connecticut. Shaman J. ed. PLoS One, 2019; 14(6):e0217854; doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0217854
29.
KilpatrickAM, PapeWJ. Predicting human West Nile virus infections with mosquito surveillance data. Am J Epidemiol, 2013; 178(5):829–835; doi: 10.1093/aje/kwt046
30.
KilpatrickAM, KramerLD, JonesMJ, et al.West Nile virus epidemics in North America are driven by shifts in mosquito feeding behavior. Ostfeld R. ed. PLoS Biol, 2006; 4(4):e82; doi: 10.1371/journal.pbio.0040082
31.
KovachTJ, KilpatrickAM. Increased human incidence of West Nile virus disease near rice fields in California but not in Southern United States. Am J Trop Med Hyg, 2018; 99(1):222–228; doi: 10.4269/ajtmh.18-0120
32.
KwanJL, ParkBK, CarpenterTE, et al.Comparison of enzootic risk measures for predicting West Nile disease, Los Angeles, California, USA, 2004–2010. Emerg Infect Dis, 2012; 18(8):1298–1306; doi: 10.3201/eid1808.111558
33.
LarsonSR, DeGrooteJP, BartholomayLC, et al.Ecological niche modeling of potential West Nile virus vector mosquito species in Iowa. J Insect Sci, 2010; 10:110–117; doi: 10.1673/031.010.11001
34.
LiaoZ, NguyenK, NewtonJ, et al.Developing a predictive risk model for West Nile virus activity based on mosquito breeding sources, environmental, and socioeconomic factors for Orange County, California. Proceedings of the Mosquito and Vector Control Association of California Conference, 2014; 82.
35.
LiuA, LeeV, GalushaD, et al.Risk factors for human infection with West Nile virus in Connecticut: A multi-year analysis. Int J Health Geogr, 2009; 8(1):67; doi: 10.1186/1476-072X-8-67
36.
LyimoIN, FergusonHM. Ecological and evolutionary determinants of host species choice in mosquito vectors. Trends Parasitol, 2009; 25(4):189–196; doi: 10.1016/j.pt.2009.01.005
37.
MessinaJP, BrownW, AmoreG, et al.West Nile virus in the greater Chicago area: A geographic examination of human illness and risk from 2002 to 2006. Urisa J, 2011; 23(1).
38.
MoriH, WuJ, IbarakiM, et al.Key factors influencing the incidence of West Nile virus in Burleigh County, North Dakota. Int J Environ Res Public Health, 2018; 15(9):1928; doi: 10.3390/ijerph15091928
39.
GublerDJ, CampbellGL, NasciR, et al.West Nile virus in the United States: guidelines for detection, prevention, and control. Viral Immunol, 2000; 13(4):469–475; doi: 10.1089/vim.2000.13.469, 11192293
40.
NasciRS, MutebiJ-P. Reducing West Nile virus risk through vector management. J Med Entomol, 2019; 56(6):1516–1521; doi: 10.1093/jme/tjz083.Reducing
41.
PaullSH, HortonDE, AshfaqM, et al.Drought and immunity determine the intensity of West Nile virus epidemics and climate change impacts. Proc R Soc B, 2017; 284(1848):20162078; doi: 10.1098/rspb.2016.2078
42.
ReisenWK, CarrollBD, TakahashiR, et al.Repeated West Nile virus epidemic transmission in Kern County, California, 2004–2007. J Med Entomol, 2009; 46(1):139–157; doi: 10.1603/033.046.0118
43.
RochlinI, TurbowD, GomezF, et al.Predictive mapping of human risk for West Nile virus (WNV) based on environmental and socioeconomic factors. Getz WM. ed. PLoS One, 2011; 6(8):e23280; doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0023280
44.
RudolphKE, LesslerJ, MoloneyRM, et al.Incubation periods of mosquito-borne viral infections: A systematic review. Am J Trop Med Hyg, 2014; 90(5):882–891; doi: 10.4269/ajtmh.13-0403
45.
SkaffNK, ChengQ, ClemeshaRES, et al.Thermal thresholds heighten sensitivity of West Nile virus transmission to changing temperatures in Coastal California. Proc Biol Sci, 2020; 287(1932):20201065; doi: 10.1098/rspb.2020.1065
UelmenJA, IrwinP, BartlettD, et al.Effects of scale on modeling West Nile virus disease risk. Am J Trop Med Hyg, 2021a;104(1):151–165; doi: 10.4269/ajtmh.20-0416
48.
UelmenJA, IrwinP, BrownWM, et al.Dynamics of data availability in disease modeling: An example evaluating the trade-offs of ultra-fine-scale factors applied to human West Nile virus disease models in the Chicago area, USA. Wen F. ed. PLoS One, 2021b;16(5):e0251517; doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0251517
49.
WalterSD, HildrethSW, BeatyBJ. Estimation of infection rates in populations of organisms using pools of variable size. Am J Epidemiol, 1980; 112(1):124–128; doi: 10.1093/oxfordjournals.aje.a112961
50.
WeberIB, LindseyNP, Bunko-PattersonAM, et al.Completeness of West Nile virus testing in patients with meningitis and encephalitis during an outbreak in Arizona, USA. Epidemiol Infect, 2012; 140(9):1632–1636; doi: 10.1017/S0950268811002494
51.
WimberlyMC, DavisJK, HildrethMB, et al.Integrated forecasts based on public health surveillance and meteorological data predict West Nile virus in a high-risk region of North America. Environ Health Perspect, 2022; 130(8):87006; doi: 10.1289/EHP10287
52.
WintersAM, BollingBG, BeatyBJ, et al.Combining mosquito vector and human disease data for improved assessment of spatial West Nile virus disease risk. Am J Trop Med Hyg, 2008; 78(4):654–665; doi: 10.4269/ajtmh.2008.78.654
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
