This article systematically reviews the effects of technology-based (TB) treatments on impaired social cognition (SC) in neurological and mental disorders.
Methods:
Strictly adhering to the PRISMA guidelines, a systematic search was carried out in PsycINFO, PubMed, and Web of Science (last search: April 22, 2021) to identify studies that, implementing a control group design, evaluated TB treatments targeting deficits in emotion recognition, Theory of Mind (ToM) and social behavior in adult patients with nondevelopmental and nonprogressive neurological or mental disorders. Risk of bias was assessed using the PEDro Scale, certainty assessment followed the GRADE approach.
Results:
Sixteen studies involving 857 patients, all focusing on psychotic disorders, were retrieved. The most pronounced effects were observed concerning emotion recognition with all studies revealing overall improvements. Regarding ToM and social behavior, results were mixed. However, the number of studies including outcome measures for these domains, is significantly lower compared to the domain of emotion recognition, limiting the validity of the results. Risk of bias and certainty assessment revealed further limitations of evidence.
Conclusion:
TB treatment achieves positive effects especially with regard to emotion recognition impairments, at least for patients with schizophrenia. Future research should expand the evaluation of TB training of other SC domains, ought to be carried out in more diverse patient populations, rely on different devices, and include follow-up measurements.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
FreemanD, ReeveS, RobinsonA, et al.Virtual reality in the assessment, understanding, and treatment of mental health disorders. Psychol Med, 2017; 47:2393–2400.
2.
GermineL, ReineckeK, ChaytorNS. Digital neuropsychology: Challenges and opportunities at the intersection of science and software. Clin Neuropsychol, 2019; 33:271–286.
3.
ScholtenMR, KeldersSM, van Gemert-PijnenJE. Self-guided web-based interventions: Scoping review on user needs and the potential of embodied conversational agents to address them. J Med Internet Res, 2017; 19:e383.
4.
RobertsonI. Does computerized cognitive rehabilitation work? A review. Aphasiology, 1990; 4:381–405.
NussbaumR, KellyC, QuinbyE, MacA, ParmantoB, DiciannoBE. Systematic review of mobile health applications in rehabilitation. Arch Phys Med Rehabil, 2019; 100:115–127.
7.
ChoiJH, KimJH, LeeJ, GreenMF. Social cognition training for individuals with schizophrenia: A review of targeted interventions. Clin Psychopharmacol Neurosci, 2009; 7:29–38.
8.
GrantN, LawrenceM, PretiA, WykesT, CellaM. Social cognition interventions for people with schizophrenia: A systematic review focussing on methodological quality and intervention modality. Clin Psychol Rev, 2017; 56:55–64.
9.
HoranWP, GreenMF. Treatment of social cognition in schizophrenia: Current status and future directions. Schizophr Res, 2019; 203:3–11.
10.
TanB-L, LeeS-A, LeeJ. Social cognitive interventions for people with schizophrenia: A systematic review. Asian J Psychiatr, 2018; 35:115–131.
11.
YamadaY, InagawaT, SueyoshiK, et al.Social cognition deficits as a target of early intervention for psychoses: A systematic review. Front Psychiatry, 2019; 10:333.
12.
CasselA, McDonaldS, KellyM, TogherL. Learning from the minds of others: A review of social cognition treatments and their relevance to traumatic brain injury. Neuropsychol Rehabil, 2019; 29:22–55.
13.
Vallat-AzouviC, AzouviP, Le-BornecG, Brunet-GouetE. Treatment of social cognition impairments in patients with traumatic brain injury: A critical review. Brain Inj, 2019; 33:87–93.
14.
ŻuromskiD, FedyniukA, MarekEM. Can new technologies make us more human? An inquiry on VR technologies in social cognition. Front Psychol, 2018; 9:705.
15.
RamdossS, MachalicekW, RispoliM, MulloyA, LangR, O'ReillyM. Computer-based interventions to improve social and emotional skills in individuals with autism spectrum disorders: A systematic review. Dev Neurorehabil, 2012; 15:119–135.
16.
TangJS, ChenNT, FalkmerM, BӧlteS, GirdlerS. A systematic review and meta-analysis of social emotional computer based interventions for autistic individuals using the serious game framework. Res Autism Spectr Disord, 2019; 66:101412.
17.
GainsfordK, FitzgibbonB, FitzgeraldPB, HoyKE. Transforming treatments for schizophrenia: Virtual reality, brain stimulation and social cognition. Psychiatry Res, 2020; 288:112974.
18.
Fernández-SotosP, Fernández-CaballeroA, Rodriguez-JimenezR. Virtual reality for psychosocial remediation in schizophrenia: A systematic review. Eur J Psychiatry, 2020; 34:1–10.
19.
AdolphsR. The neurobiology of social cognition. Curr Opin Neurobiol, 2001; 11:231–239.
20.
AdolphsR. Neural systems for recognizing emotion. Curr Opin Neurobiol, 2002; 12:169–177.
21.
CalvoMG, NummenmaaL. Perceptual and affective mechanisms in facial expression recognition: An integrative review. Cogn Emot, 2016; 30:1081–1106.
22.
GelderB de, BorstAW de, WatsonR. The perception of emotion in body expressions. Wiley Interdiscip Rev Cogn Sci, 2015; 6:149–158.
23.
SchererKR. Vocal communication of emotions: A review of research paradigms. Speech Commun, 2003; 40:227–256.
24.
PremackD, WoodruffG. Does the chimpanzee have a theory of mind?. Behav Brain Sci, 1978; 1:515–526.
25.
LeopoldA, KruegerF, dal MonteO, et al.Damage to the left ventromedial prefrontal cortex impacts affective theory of mind. Soc Cogn Affect Neurosci, 2012; 7:871–880.
26.
Shamay-TsoorySG, TomerR, BergerBD, GoldsherD, Aharon-PeretzJ. Impaired “affective theory of mind” is associated with right ventromedial prefrontal damage. Cogn Behav Neurol, 2005; 18:55–67.
27.
CaballoVE. Social Skills Assessment and Training Manual (in Portuguese). São Paulo: Santos, 2006.
28.
UzunianLG, VitalleMSdS. Social skills: A factor of protection against eating disorders in adolescentes. Cien Saude Colet, 2015; 20:3495–3508.
29.
KennedyDP, AdolphsR. The social brain in psychiatric and neurological disorders. Trends Cogn Sci (Regul Ed), 2012; 16:559–572.
30.
PinkhamAE. Social cognition in schizophrenia. J Clin Psychiatry, 2014; 75(Suppl 2):14–19.
31.
BoraE, BerkM. Theory of mind in major depressive disorder: A meta-analysis. J Affect Disord, 2016; 191:49–55.
32.
HoertnaglCM, HoferA. Social cognition in serious mental illness. Curr Opin Psychiatry, 2014; 27:197–202.
33.
VladM, Raucher-ChénéD, HenryA, KaladjianA. Functional outcome and social cognition in bipolar disorder: Is there a connection?. Eur Psychiatry, 2018; 52:116–125.
34.
WeightmanMJ, AirTM, BauneBT. A review of the role of social cognition in major depressive disorder. Front Psychiatry, 2014; 5:179.
35.
HaugerLE, SagoeD, VaskinnA, et al.Anabolic androgenic steroid dependence is associated with impaired emotion recognition. Psychopharmacology (Berl), 2019; 236:2667–2676.
36.
ThomaP, FriedmannC, SuchanB. Empathy and social problem solving in alcohol dependence, mood disorders and selected personality disorders. Neurosci Biobehav Rev, 2013; 37:448–470.
37.
DerntlB, HabelU. Deficits in social cognition: A marker for psychiatric disorders?. Eur Arch Psychiatry Clin Neurosci, 2011; 261(Suppl 2):S145–S149.
38.
WangK, XuM, JiY, et al.Altered social cognition and connectivity of default mode networks in the co-occurrence of autistic spectrum disorder and attention deficit hyperactivity disorder. Aust N Z J Psychiatry, 2019; 53:760–771.
39.
DesmaraisP, LanctôtKL, MasellisM, BlackSE, HerrmannN. Social inappropriateness in neurodegenerative disorders. Int Psychogeriatr, 2018; 30:197–207.
40.
PertzM, OkoniewskiA, SchlegelU, ThomaP. Impairment of sociocognitive functions in patients with brain tumours. Neurosci Biobehav Rev, 2020; 108:370–392.
41.
AdamsAG, SchweitzerD, MolenberghsP, HenryJD. A meta-analytic review of social cognitive function following stroke. Neurosci Biobehav Rev, 2019; 102:400–416.
42.
MildersM. Relationship between social cognition and social behaviour following traumatic brain injury. Brain Inj, 2019; 33:62–68.
43.
WölwerW, CombsDR, FrommannN, PennDL. Treatment approaches with a special focus on social cognition: Overview and empirical results. In: MedaliaA, RoderV, eds. Neurocognition and social cognition in schizophrenia patients, Basic concepts and treatment. Basel Switzerland, New York: Karger, 2010:61–78.
44.
WykesT, ReederC, LandauS, et al.Cognitive remediation therapy in schizophrenia: Randomised controlled trial. Br J Psychiatry, 2007; 190:421–427.
45.
BornhofenC, McDonaldS. Comparing strategies for treating emotion perception deficits in traumatic brain injury. J Head Trauma Rehabil, 2008; 23:103–115.
46.
GuercioJM, Podolska-SchroederH, RehfeldtRA. Using stimulus equivalence technology to teach emotion recognition to adults with acquired brain injury. Brain Inj, 2004; 18:593–601.
47.
Rydin-OrwinT, DrakeJ, BrattA. The effects of training on emotion recognition skills for adults with an intellectual disability. J Appl Res Intellect Disabil, 1999; 12:253–262.
48.
BechiM, SpangaroM, BosiaM, et al.Theory of mind intervention for outpatients with schizophrenia. Neuropsychol Rehabil, 2013; 23:383–400.
49.
D'ZurillaTJ, GoldfriedMR. Problem solving and behavior modification. J Abnorm Psychol, 1971; 78:107–126.
50.
NezuAM, PerriMG. Social problem-solving therapy for unipolar depression: An initial dismantling investigation. J Consult Clin Psychol, 1989; 57:408–413.
51.
TomásP, FuentesI, RoderV, RuizJC. Cognitive rehabilitation programs in schizophrenia: Current status and perspectives. Int J Psychol Psychol, 2010; 10:19–204.
52.
WalendzikA, Rabe-MenssenC, LuxG, WasemJ, JahnR. The health-care situation in outpatient psychiatry—Results of a survey among members of the Germany Association of Psychotherapists (DPtV) [in German]. Gesundheitswesen, 2014; 76:135–146.
53.
PearsonOR, BusseME, van DeursenRWM, WilesCM. Quantification of walking mobility in neurological disorders. QJM, 2004; 97:463–475.
54.
AnderssonG, TitovN. Advantages and limitations of internet-based interventions for common mental disorders. World Psychiatry, 2014; 13:4–11.
55.
GreggL, TarrierN. Virtual reality in mental health: A review of the literature. Soc Psychiatry Psychiatr Epidemiol, 2007; 42:343–354.
56.
SusiT, JohannessonM, BacklundP. Serious games—An overview. Skövde: School of Humanities and Informatics, University of Skövde, 2007.
57.
BarakA, HenL, Boniel-NissimM, ShapiraN. A comprehensive review and a meta-analysis of the effectiveness of internet-based psychotherapeutic interventions. J Technol Hum Serv, 2008; 26:109–160.
58.
PageMJ, McKenzieJE, BossuytPM, et al.The PRISMA 2020 statement: An updated guideline for reporting systematic reviews. BMJ, 2021; 372:n71.
59.
SchardtC, AdamsMB, OwensT, KeitzS, FonteloP. Utilization of the PICO framework to improve searching PubMed for clinical questions. BMC Med Inform Decis Mak, 2007; 7:16.
60.
SherringtonC, HerbertRD, MaherCG, MoseleyAM. PEDro. A database of randomized trials and systematic reviews in physiotherapy. Man Ther, 2000; 5:223–226.
BalshemH, HelfandM, SchünemannHJ, et al.GRADE guidelines: 3. Rating the quality of evidence. J Clin Epidemiol, 2011; 64:401–406.
63.
RussellTA, GreenMJ, SimpsonI, ColtheartM. Remediation of facial emotion perception in schizophrenia: Concomitant changes in visual attention. Schizophr Res, 2008; 103:248–256.
64.
FisherM, NahumM, HowardE, et al.Supplementing intensive targeted computerized cognitive training with social cognitive exercises for people with schizophrenia: An interim report. Psychiatr Rehabil J, 2017; 40:21–32.
65.
PopovaP, PopovTG, WienbruchC, CarolusAM, MillerGA, RockstrohBS. Changing facial affect recognition in schizophrenia: Effects of training on brain dynamics. Neuroimage Clin, 2014; 6:156–165.
66.
RussellTA, ChuE, PhillipsML. A pilot study to investigate the effectiveness of emotion recognition remediation in schizophrenia using the micro-expression training tool. Br J Clin Psychol, 2006; 45:579–583.
67.
Lado-CodesidoM, Méndez PérezC, MateosR, OlivaresJM, García CaballeroA. Improving emotion recognition in schizophrenia with ‘VOICES’: An on-line prosodic self-training. PLoS One, 2019; 14:e0210816.
68.
HookerCI, BruceL, FisherM, VeroskySC, MiyakawaA, VinogradovS. Neural activity during emotion recognition after combined cognitive plus social cognitive training in schizophrenia. Schizophr Res, 2012; 139:53–59.
69.
Vázquez-CampoM, MaroñoY, LaheraG, MateosR, García-CaballeroA. e-Motional Training®: Pilot study on a novel online training program on social cognition for patients with schizophrenia. Schizophr Res Cogn, 2016; 4:10–17.
70.
ZhangX, ChenL, ZhongZ, SuiH, ShenX. The effects of the micro-expression training on empathy in patients with schizophrenia. In: LongS, DhillonBS, eds. Man–machine–environment system engineering. Singapore: Springer Singapore, 2018:189–194.
71.
ByrneLK, PanL, McCABEM, MellorD, XuY. Assessment of a six-week computer-based remediation program for social cognition in chronic schizophrenia. Shanghai Arch Psychiatry, 2015; 27:296–306.
72.
GülkesenKH, IsleyenF, CinemreB, SamurMK, Sen KayaS, ZayimN. A web-based game for teaching facial expressions to schizophrenic patients. Appl Clin Inform, 2017; 8:719–730.
73.
DavisMH. Measuring individual differences in empathy: Evidence for a multidimensional approach. Pers Soc Psychol, 1983; 44:113–126.
74.
NuechterleinKH, GreenMF, KernRS, et al.The MATRICS consensus cognitive battery, part 1: Test selection, reliability, and validity. Am J Psychiatry, 2008; 165:203–213.
75.
EkmanP. Micro Expressions Training Tool and the subtle expressions training. Venice, CA: MOZGO Media, 2003.
76.
WongJ-J, ChoS-Y. A local experts organization model with application to face emotion recognition. Expert Syst Appl, 2009; 36:804–819.
77.
KaySR, FiszbeinA, OplerLA. The Positive and Negative Syndrome Scale (PANSS) for schizophrenia. Schizophr Bull, 1987; 13:261–276.
78.
KawataAK, RevickiDA. Psychometric properties of the Personal and Social Performance scale (PSP) among individuals with schizophrenia living in the community. Qual Life Res, 2008; 17:1247–1256.
79.
GolanO, Baron-CohenS, HillJJ, RutherfordMD. The ‘Reading the Mind in the Voice’ test-revised: A study of complex emotion recognition in adults with and without autism spectrum conditions. J Autism Dev Disord, 2007; 37:1096–1106.
80.
AndreasenNC. The Scale for the Assessment of Positive Symptoms (SAPS). Iowa City: University of Iowa, 1984.
81.
AndreasenNC. The Scale for the Assessment of Negative Symptoms (SANS): Conceptual and theoretical foundations. Br J Psychiatry Suppl, 1989; 155:49–58.
82.
HookerCI, BruceL, FisherM, et al.The influence of combined cognitive plus social-cognitive training on amygdala response during face emotion recognition in schizophrenia. Psychiatry Res, 2013; 213:99–107.
83.
LindenmayerJ-P, McGurkSR, KhanA, et al.Improving social cognition in schizophrenia: A pilot intervention combining computerized social cognition training with cognitive remediation. Schizophr Bull, 2013; 39:507–517.
84.
NahumM, FisherM, LoewyR, et al.A novel, online social cognitive training program for young adults with schizophrenia: A pilot study. Schizophr Res Cogn, 2014; 1:e11–e19.
85.
LindenmayerJ-P, KhanA, McGurkSR, et al.Does social cognition training augment response to computer-assisted cognitive remediation for schizophrenia?. Schizophr Res, 2018; 201:180–186.
86.
Maroño SoutoY, Vázquez CampoM, Díaz LlenderrozasF, Rodríguez ÁlvarezM, MateosR, García CaballeroA. Randomized clinical trial with e-MotionalTraining® 1.0 for social cognition rehabilitation in schizophrenia. Front Psychiatry, 2018; 9:40.
87.
NahumM, LeeH, FisherM, et al.Online social cognition training in schizophrenia: A double-blind, randomized, controlled multi-site clinical trial. Schizophr Bull, 2021; 47:108–117.
88.
LucicL, RothmanB, KhanA, YavorskyC, OplerM. Preliminary findings of the Dynamic Social Cognition Battery (DSCB): A comprehensive toolkit for social cognition. Schizophr Bull, 2013; 39:239.
KohlerCG, TurnerTH, BilkerWB, et al.Facial emotion recognition in schizophrenia: Intensity effects and error pattern. Am J Psychiatry, 2003; 160:1768–1774.
91.
StoneVE, Baron-CohenS, KnightRT. Frontal lobe contributions to theory of mind. J Cogn Neurosci, 1998; 10:640–656.
92.
KerrSL, NealeJM. Emotion perception in schizophrenia: Specific deficit or further evidence of generalized poor performance?. J Abnorm Psychol, 1993; 102:312–318.
93.
AutherAM, SmithCW, CornblattB. Global functioning: Social scale (GF: Social). Glen Oaks, NY: Zucker Hillside Hospital, 2006.
94.
NiendamTA, BeardenCE, JohnsonJK, CannonTD. Global functioning: Role scale (GF: Role). Los Angeles: University of California, 2006.
95.
HappéFG. An advanced test of theory of mind: Understanding of story characters' thoughts and feelings by able autistic, mentally handicapped, and normal children and adults. J Autism Dev Disord, 1994; 24:129–154.
96.
DziobekI, FleckS, KalbeE, et al.Introducing MASC: A movie for the assessment of social cognition. J Autism Dev Disord, 2006; 36:623–636.
97.
MayerJD, SaloveyP, CarusoDR, SitareniosG. Measuring emotional intelligence with the MSCEIT V2.0. Emotion, 2003; 3:97–105.
98.
RussJ. Development of PROID, a computerized emotional prosody identification task. PennScience J, 2008; 6:14–20.
99.
BirchwoodM, SmithJ, CochraneR, WettonS, CopestakeS. The Social Functioning Scale. The development and validation of a new scale of social adjustment for use in family intervention programmes with schizophrenic patients. Br J Psychiatry, 1990; 157:853–859.
100.
McDonaldS, FlanaganS, RollinsJ, KinchJ. TASIT: A new clinical tool for assessing social perception after traumatic brain injury. J Head Trauma Rehabil, 2003; 18:219–238.
101.
KouoJL, EgelAL. The effectiveness of interventions in teaching emotion recognition to children with autism spectrum disorder. Rev J Autism Dev Disord, 2016; 3:254–265.
102.
LeeCSC, LamSHF, TsangSTK, YuenCMC, NgCKM. The effectiveness of technology-based intervention in improving emotion recognition through facial expression in people with autism spectrum disorder: A systematic review. Rev J Autism Dev Disord, 2018; 5:91–104.
103.
VassE, SimonV, FeketeZ, KisB, SimonL. Case report: Feasibility of a novel virtual reality-based intervention for patients with schizophrenia. Front Psychol, 2021; 12:642590.
104.
d'ArmaA, IserniaS, Di TellaS, et al.Social cognition training for enhancing affective and aognitive theory of mind in cchizophrenia: A systematic review and a meta-analysis. J Psychol, 2021; 155:26–58.
105.
SmithMJ, FlemingMF, WrightMA, et al.Brief report: Vocational outcomes for young adults with autism spectrum disorders at six months after virtual reality job interview training. J Autism Dev Disord, 2015; 45:3364–3369.
106.
HummLB, OlsenD, BeM, FlemingM, SmithM. Simulated job interview improves skills for adults with serious mental illnesses. Stud Health Technol Inform, 2014; 199:50–54.
107.
Westerhof-EversHJ, Visser-KeizerAC, FasottiL, SpikmanJM. Social cognition and emotion regulation: A multifaceted treatment (T-ScEmo) for patients with traumatic brain injury. Clin Rehabil, 2019; 33:820–833.
108.
LongK, RagerB, AdamsG. Deficit awareness and cognitive performance in individuals with acquired brain injury. NeuroRehabilitation, 2014; 34:45–53.
109.
YlvisakerM, TurkstraLS, CoelhoC. Behavioral and social interventions for individuals with traumatic brain injury: A summary of the research with clinical implications. Semin Speech Lang, 2005; 26:256–267.
110.
ReayRE, LooiJC, KeightleyP. Telehealth mental health services during COVID-19: Summary of evidence and clinical practice. Australas Psychiatry, 2020; 28:514–516.
111.
CowanKE, McKeanAJ, GentryMT, HiltyDM. Barriers to use of telepsychiatry: Clinicians as gatekeepers. Mayo Clin Proc, 2019; 94:2510–2523.
112.
LopezA, SchwenkS, SchneckCD, GriffinRJ, MishkindMC. Technology-based mental health treatment and the impact on the therapeutic alliance. Curr Psychiatry Rep, 2019; 21:76.
113.
RochlenAB, ZackJS, SpeyerC. Online therapy: Review of relevant definitions, debates, and current empirical support. J Clin Psychol, 2004; 60:269–283.
114.
SchusterR, TopoocoN, KellerA, RadvoginE, LaireiterA-R. Advantages and disadvantages of online and blended therapy: Replication and extension of findings on psychotherapists' appraisals. Internet Interv, 2020; 21:100326.
115.
ChenP, HongW. Neural circuit mechanisms of social behavior. Neuron, 2018; 98:16–30.
116.
KandalaftMR, DidehbaniN, KrawczykDC, AllenTT, ChapmanSB. Virtual reality social cognition training for young adults with high-functioning autism. J Autism Dev Disord, 2013; 43:34–44.
117.
Sonnby-BorgströmM. Alexithymia as related to facial imitation, mentalization, empathy, and internal working models-of-self and -others. Neuropsychoanalysis, 2009; 11:111–128.
118.
XieX, Mulej BratecS, SchmidG, et al.How do you make me feel better? Social cognitive emotion regulation and the default mode network. Neuroimage, 2016; 134:270–280.
119.
SprengRN, MarRA. I remember you: A role for memory in social cognition and the functional neuroanatomy of their interaction. Brain Res, 2012; 1428:43–50.
120.
HopkinsIM, GowerMW, PerezTA, et al.Avatar assistant: Improving social skills in students with an ASD through a computer-based intervention. J Autism Dev Disord, 2011; 41:1543–1555.
121.
BölteS, GolanO, GoodwinMS, ZwaigenbaumL. What can innovative technologies do for autism spectrum disorders?. Autism, 2010; 14:155–159.
122.
VianinP. RECOS Program: Remediation and transfer of competences (in French). In: FranckN, ed. Cognitive remediation. Paris: Elsevier Masson, 2012:91–115.
123.
GaudelusB, VirgileJ, GeliotS, FranckN. Improving facial emotion recognition in schizophrenia: A controlled study comparing specific and attentional focused cognitive remediation. Front Psychiatry, 2016; 7:105.
124.
NorthMM, NorthSM, CobleJR. Virtual reality therapy: An effective treatment for psychological disorders. Stud Health Technol Inform, 1997; 44:59–70.
125.
YuenEK, GoetterEM, HerbertJD, FormanEM. Challenges and opportunities in internet-mediated telemental health. Prof Psychol Res Pr, 2012; 43:1–8.
126.
von BrachelR, HirschfeldG, BernerA, et al.Long-term effectiveness of cognitive behavioral therapy in routine outpatient care: A 5- to 20-Year follow-up study. Psychother Psychosom, 2019; 88:225–235.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
